Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you fight to get your DC into a school that didn't want them?

60 replies

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 19:13

Wondering if I should just give up. Been going on for over a year now! Totally drained and feel like I'm coming across as a bit like a dog with a bone and slightly unhinged!

DC has SEN and school is a specialist with life altering outcomes.

Alternative is a 'time wasting' provision (IMO) where outcome is probably going to be low levels if independence and lots of social care input.

WWYD?

OP posts:
secular39 · 01/02/2023 20:46

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 20:43

Just to make it clear - I had no idea of the cost of this college when I was researching it. Fees are not on their website (none of these colleges advertise their fees) as they are all Local Authority funded, plenty of other students get funding. I was horrified myself when I found out the cost from the Tribunal evidence.

I was just looking for a provision for my son and this is on the list of SEN colleges on the Department of Education website.

@CyberSpaceTraveller

Please! Don't ever feel like that! This is not a reflection on you at all. My own DC's attend an independent specialist school, well one does and the other an independent mainstream primary all funded by the LA.

You need to do what's best for your son. Costs are irrelevant. I do think special needs provision as a whole is ludicrously expensive (and a business for some) but that's another story.

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 20:43

Just to make it clear - I had no idea of the cost of this college when I was researching it. Fees are not on their website (none of these colleges advertise their fees) as they are all Local Authority funded, plenty of other students get funding. I was horrified myself when I found out the cost from the Tribunal evidence.

I was just looking for a provision for my son and this is on the list of SEN colleges on the Department of Education website.

OP posts:
ShoesIBoughtYouAsAPresent · 01/02/2023 20:38

x2boys · 01/02/2023 20:28

Yeah it would blow your mind what some placements costs ,not that this is relevant 🙄

I think it is relevant, as there isn't an infinite pot of tax money. Of course, if spending this much now means saving money later on (as the person concerned is able to be more independent and so forth) then it's worth it in the long term not just for the person concerned but for society as a whole.

JustKeepBuilding · 01/02/2023 20:34

Don’t give up now! After waiting all that time for a hearing.

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 20:33

The most crazy making thing is that this college said at first they had no concerns, invited us to visit, which we did, all very positive, talked about a 3 year programme they'd offer him where he could choose a course to study along with living skills etc.

They said to ask the Local Authority to formally consult with them and then they'd invite him for an assessment. I gave them all his paperwork when I initially contacted them detailing his self harming, learning disability everything. Same as Local Authority would have given them. Totally honest about previous placement breakdowns and his MH.

Then they said they couldn't met his needs in response to the Local Authority consultation. Totally shocked as thought I'd finally found the right place for him. Burst into tears actually which shocked me as well!

They did invite him for an assessment after a bit of wrangling but then said because he couldn't answer some academic questions (he hadn't been in education for over a year and had been a recluse with social anxiety for all that time) so again said they couldn't take him.

Tribunal judge has now ordered them to do another assessment but don't think it will be an unbiased opinion will it! Can't ask someone independent to over see it.

Tribunal has been adjourned until this has taken place.

So wondering if this is just a waste of time and should just give in.

OP posts:
secular39 · 01/02/2023 20:32

@x2boys I just don't understand why these schools are so expensive. I mean special needs in general and provisions is expensive but that is ALOT. To be fair, it's either that or adults being detained in mental hospitals or wrongly placed in prisons.

secular39 · 01/02/2023 20:30

If it's a section 41 school then I think it's worth admitting. Though it may be difficult for the LA to agree to fund if school saying that it can't meet needs. I've had the same issue before but I thought to myself I don't want to force for a school to admit my children but then again my DC's are younger and as you are away, the provisions for adults with SEN are scarce. So I'll say, do it! But brace yourself and look for an alternative school as a back up (I.e. the school may not tick all the boxes but the LA fund extra provisions if need be).

x2boys · 01/02/2023 20:28

secular39 · 01/02/2023 20:26

£250k a year college

Wow that is expensive....faints

Yeah it would blow your mind what some placements costs ,not that this is relevant 🙄

x2boys · 01/02/2023 20:27

I think it depends though if the school.itself is saying it can't meet the child's needs ?
my experience is only anecdotal but I know if some chlldren being placed in section41_schools and after a while the school itself says they can't meet the child's needs even though the LEA agreed to fund.

secular39 · 01/02/2023 20:26

£250k a year college

Wow that is expensive....faints

secular39 · 01/02/2023 20:24

OP, it's ridiculous. I think it comes down to that there's so many children with needs and very few specialist provisions hence why these places can afford to be picky with the pupils they admit. It's the system. They need more specialist provisions like this so that pupils don't have to go over two hours away to get the provision that they need.

ShoesIBoughtYouAsAPresent · 01/02/2023 20:23

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 20:03

Reasons are they can't meet his needs but their reasons IMHO don't make sense. An educational psychologist assessment has said the provision is exactly what he needs.but they don't agree. It's actually a college not a school btw. Thought I'd get more view points if I put school!

For example -

He has a mild learning disability, so they say he won't have a peer group at college but they have other students with learning disabilities.

He used to self harm (ASD) superficially only on his hands in his previous unsuitable mainstream college so he's classed as high risk. Evidence that he has not self harmed at all in almost 2 years from psychiatrist. College has a specific specialism in ASD and associated MH issues with on site psychologist which is the main reason I want him there! No violent behaviour ever.

His academic levels are too low despite proof he was working at college's required level 2 years ago.

I have posted about this before and got lots of grief about how much the college I want him to go to costs but he has an EHCP and spaces are available. It's Section 41 so they can be forced to admit.

I just want viewpoints on whether I'm mad to continue trying to flog a dead horse!

Local Authority obviously don't want to fund it (has to be residential due to distance) and are trying to paint me as a mad woman!

Had a Tribunal hearing this week and their barrister told blatant lies about how I wasn't engaging with them. I have a legal aid solicitor who has been useless and no help at all,

There are no other provisions like this (believe me I've l searched) and Local Authority want him to go to a mainstream college 20 miles away and segregate him with a 1:1 doing life skills when myself and Education Psychologist believe he shouldn't need a 1:1 in the right environment (never had one in mainstream primary and the mainstream secondary he left in Yr10) and is capable of doing an academic/vocational course and becoming largely independent, working etc.

He has ASD and psychologist believes his learning disability diagnosis is overstated due to lack of support to engage in his education previously which has always been my opinion. No EHCP until age 15, ASD not correctly diagnosed until he was 17. No qualifications from mainstream secondary as they didn't enter him for any or try to get him an EHCP.

This is his last chance to get an education due to his age.

I think I remember your original post. This is the £250k a year college, correct?

JustKeepBuilding · 01/02/2023 20:21

x2boys · 01/02/2023 20:15

A section 41_school.I believe is a private provision outside of of the LEA ?
if they are saying they can't meet his needs then unfortunately I think you might

have to
look elsewhe 're ? I I know it must be distressing several of my friends have been through this with their children ,are there any other section 41 schools / t colleges that might be suitable ?

Section 41 schools aren’t wholly independent so the LA can, and must, name the school if it is parental preference regardless of the school’s objections unless the LA can prove:
-The setting is unsuitable for the age, ability, aptitude or special educational needs (“SEN”) of the child or young person; or
-The attendance of the child or young person would be incompatible with the provision of efficient education for others; or
-The attendance of the child or young person would be incompatible with the efficient use of resources.

The bar do that is higher than many LAs care to admit.

QuantifiedSpecific · 01/02/2023 20:21

x2boys · 01/02/2023 20:15

A section 41_school.I believe is a private provision outside of of the LEA ?
if they are saying they can't meet his needs then unfortunately I think you might

have to
look elsewhe 're ? I I know it must be distressing several of my friends have been through this with their children ,are there any other section 41 schools / t colleges that might be suitable ?

I thought a s41 had to be treated the same as state maintained, ie the parental preference means the LA must place.

OP which judge did you have?

Ultimately your professional advice will trump the oppo barrister.

Hankunamatata · 01/02/2023 20:18

Do the tribunal has said no?

x2boys · 01/02/2023 20:15

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 20:03

Reasons are they can't meet his needs but their reasons IMHO don't make sense. An educational psychologist assessment has said the provision is exactly what he needs.but they don't agree. It's actually a college not a school btw. Thought I'd get more view points if I put school!

For example -

He has a mild learning disability, so they say he won't have a peer group at college but they have other students with learning disabilities.

He used to self harm (ASD) superficially only on his hands in his previous unsuitable mainstream college so he's classed as high risk. Evidence that he has not self harmed at all in almost 2 years from psychiatrist. College has a specific specialism in ASD and associated MH issues with on site psychologist which is the main reason I want him there! No violent behaviour ever.

His academic levels are too low despite proof he was working at college's required level 2 years ago.

I have posted about this before and got lots of grief about how much the college I want him to go to costs but he has an EHCP and spaces are available. It's Section 41 so they can be forced to admit.

I just want viewpoints on whether I'm mad to continue trying to flog a dead horse!

Local Authority obviously don't want to fund it (has to be residential due to distance) and are trying to paint me as a mad woman!

Had a Tribunal hearing this week and their barrister told blatant lies about how I wasn't engaging with them. I have a legal aid solicitor who has been useless and no help at all,

There are no other provisions like this (believe me I've l searched) and Local Authority want him to go to a mainstream college 20 miles away and segregate him with a 1:1 doing life skills when myself and Education Psychologist believe he shouldn't need a 1:1 in the right environment (never had one in mainstream primary and the mainstream secondary he left in Yr10) and is capable of doing an academic/vocational course and becoming largely independent, working etc.

He has ASD and psychologist believes his learning disability diagnosis is overstated due to lack of support to engage in his education previously which has always been my opinion. No EHCP until age 15, ASD not correctly diagnosed until he was 17. No qualifications from mainstream secondary as they didn't enter him for any or try to get him an EHCP.

This is his last chance to get an education due to his age.

A section 41_school.I believe is a private provision outside of of the LEA ?
if they are saying they can't meet his needs then unfortunately I think you might

have to
look elsewhe 're ? I I know it must be distressing several of my friends have been through this with their children ,are there any other section 41 schools / t colleges that might be suitable ?

JustKeepBuilding · 01/02/2023 20:09

Sadly many schools say they can’t meet DC’s needs without the LA being able to reach the high threshold that’s needed in order for the LA to refuse to name the setting. The majority of appeals are upheld.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 01/02/2023 20:04

Absolutely not!
My sons old school made up absolute bullshit to get him out asap after I insisted he went to a specific school.
Honestly my boy is nothing like the monster they made him out to be and I had support staff from there own school tell me it was all lies.

CyberSpaceTraveller · 01/02/2023 20:03

Reasons are they can't meet his needs but their reasons IMHO don't make sense. An educational psychologist assessment has said the provision is exactly what he needs.but they don't agree. It's actually a college not a school btw. Thought I'd get more view points if I put school!

For example -

He has a mild learning disability, so they say he won't have a peer group at college but they have other students with learning disabilities.

He used to self harm (ASD) superficially only on his hands in his previous unsuitable mainstream college so he's classed as high risk. Evidence that he has not self harmed at all in almost 2 years from psychiatrist. College has a specific specialism in ASD and associated MH issues with on site psychologist which is the main reason I want him there! No violent behaviour ever.

His academic levels are too low despite proof he was working at college's required level 2 years ago.

I have posted about this before and got lots of grief about how much the college I want him to go to costs but he has an EHCP and spaces are available. It's Section 41 so they can be forced to admit.

I just want viewpoints on whether I'm mad to continue trying to flog a dead horse!

Local Authority obviously don't want to fund it (has to be residential due to distance) and are trying to paint me as a mad woman!

Had a Tribunal hearing this week and their barrister told blatant lies about how I wasn't engaging with them. I have a legal aid solicitor who has been useless and no help at all,

There are no other provisions like this (believe me I've l searched) and Local Authority want him to go to a mainstream college 20 miles away and segregate him with a 1:1 doing life skills when myself and Education Psychologist believe he shouldn't need a 1:1 in the right environment (never had one in mainstream primary and the mainstream secondary he left in Yr10) and is capable of doing an academic/vocational course and becoming largely independent, working etc.

He has ASD and psychologist believes his learning disability diagnosis is overstated due to lack of support to engage in his education previously which has always been my opinion. No EHCP until age 15, ASD not correctly diagnosed until he was 17. No qualifications from mainstream secondary as they didn't enter him for any or try to get him an EHCP.

This is his last chance to get an education due to his age.

OP posts:
ChicCroissant · 01/02/2023 19:57

Are you on the waiting list for a place, or does he not meet the criteria in some way? It's hard to say from your post. Under what circumstances has he not gained a place.

Oblomov22 · 01/02/2023 19:41

Depends. Why do you want him there. Why don't they want him? What have they actually said? But my gut says no. Why go where you aren't wanted (in most areas of life this rule applies).

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 01/02/2023 19:40

It depends on why they don't want them.

If it's the actual school that actively doesn't want them, doesn't want the work load, then no. They won't get the best out of the child in that circumstances.

If the school are happy to take them, but it's a LA or funding issue then I'd absolutely fight. And keep fighting.

Ladyoftheprom · 01/02/2023 19:39

I think it's depends as to why the school are saying no, is it because they are saying they can't meet need or because they are oversubscribed and no places?
If they can't meet need then no I wouldn't fight, over subscribed/full yes I would

Good luck x

JustKeepBuilding · 01/02/2023 19:38

Depends on what type of school it is. If it is wholly independent then no, I wouldn’t because you need an offer of a place and the school is unlikely to change their mind. If it’s any other type of school, including s.41 independents, then I would because they can be forced to admit.

SpudleyLass · 01/02/2023 19:37

Hi Op,

I hope my experience might be relatable at all.

My 4yo DD is SEN - non verbal, genetic disorder, behavioural issues - still in nappies. We have just moved from a different LA to my birth county as there are more specialist schools here.It took such a long time to fight the previous LA to name specialist education on her EHCP - I'm now in the consultation stage with the new LA with three specialist schools in this area.

To answer your question, yes I would. I personally feel I have no choice as my DD cannot cope in mainstream. It took me telling the previous LA I was at the pointing of hurting myself before they took me seriously, despite all the evidence my DD had in regards to her SEN and her ASD Level 3 Diagnosis, before they finally relented.

This is one of those battles, I find, where you have to be a stick in the mud.