Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fall out between sister and husband

89 replies

poiuy · 01/02/2023 16:02

Fed up with this situation and hope for some advice! I’ve always been v close to my sister as mum died young. However, we are very different and she lives alone with no family and I have 3 older kids and all the chaos and busy days that family bring. To cut a long story short, she had a disagreement with my partner over something small in July 2021 whilst visiting . She told me afterwards that she was fuming but since then refuses to discuss it with any of us. I think she was over-sensitive but at any rate, forgive and forget and just move on and build bridges. She will no longer visit, even at Christmas/ for a few hours or meet if he is present. She expects me to meet her, usually in a restaurant or cafe. I am saddened that she won’t visit and cannot really keep affording this, especially if it involves bringing her nieces and nephews/our kids along. I think she is being really selfish and pathetic to be honest but if I broached the issues I think I would lose her, as she can be quite volatile. I feel sorry for my husband and loyal to his feelings. How can we move forward and should I just bow to her demands to meet just me (and maybe the kids) in some random place?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ComfortablyDazed · 01/02/2023 19:31

Cocobutt · 01/02/2023 19:00

Jesus I'd hate to be related to you. Do expect a full on apology if someone looks at you the wrong way?

@FuckNuggets

Ermm yeah of course.

Wouldn’t you?
Or do you let people walk all over you?

How do you get anything else done all day?

FuckNuggets · 01/02/2023 19:21

Cocobutt · 01/02/2023 19:00

Jesus I'd hate to be related to you. Do expect a full on apology if someone looks at you the wrong way?

@FuckNuggets

Ermm yeah of course.

Wouldn’t you?
Or do you let people walk all over you?

@Cocobutt

You expect an apology when someone looks at you funny, really? Bloody hell! You must be a nightmare to be around.

Cocobutt · 01/02/2023 19:00

Jesus I'd hate to be related to you. Do expect a full on apology if someone looks at you the wrong way?

@FuckNuggets

Ermm yeah of course.

Wouldn’t you?
Or do you let people walk all over you?

Kennykenkencat · 01/02/2023 18:48

ItsCalledAConversation · 01/02/2023 18:24

Betting on it, buying tickets, buying the kits/strips/decorations, watching the ads, buying the booze, etc etc. I would go on but it’s not worth the energy.

Just because I don’t like it doesn’t mean I don’t expect anyone else to. It’s fine if other people want to watch it. But these days TV can be paused, and it’s less important than a convo with a family member in real life, regardless of whether you like or loathe the game itself. I could have made the same argument (minus the being ripped off) about a cliffhanger episode of East Enders.

ItsCalledAConversation
Betting on it, buying tickets, buying the kits/strips/decorations, watching the ads, buying the booze, etc etc. I would go on but it’s not worth the energy

We are talking about watching England on tv

Yes I do bet on the football (I usually try and pay for the food shop with what I make) I have never bought a football strip, I don’t drink and I don’t even watch the matches. I have taken Ds to a few away games for his team.

Personally I have no real interest in Football as a sport but I will respect those that do watch it and want to concentrate on the tv.

You can’t pause a live match!

EasiTiger · 01/02/2023 18:32

It does seem quite trivial to react the way she has. Could it be less about what he said and more about the way he spoke to her? It reminds me a little of my sister and I years ago, she’s no longer with the father of her 3 children but when she was he would often speak to me incredibly disrespectfully and she would never challenge him. He would speak to my sister in the same fashion so I understand why she didn’t now because she couldn’t. He would always tell me I was sensitive and couldn’t take a joke. I did the same as your sister I stopped coming to the house I would meet her anywhere else. I decided I didn’t have to tolerate him any longer. Sorry if this is completely unrelated but she’s entitled to her feelings and she probably doesn’t want to discuss it because she knows you will dismiss her. I hope you can sort it out.

beetr00 · 01/02/2023 18:30

This wasn't just any match,

this was THE FINAL of the Euros (delayed from 2020), England v Italy.

1-1 full-time, went to penalties!!

ItsCalledAConversation · 01/02/2023 18:24

Betting on it, buying tickets, buying the kits/strips/decorations, watching the ads, buying the booze, etc etc. I would go on but it’s not worth the energy.

Just because I don’t like it doesn’t mean I don’t expect anyone else to. It’s fine if other people want to watch it. But these days TV can be paused, and it’s less important than a convo with a family member in real life, regardless of whether you like or loathe the game itself. I could have made the same argument (minus the being ripped off) about a cliffhanger episode of East Enders.

Kennykenkencat · 01/02/2023 18:17

ItsCalledAConversation · 01/02/2023 18:02

This is the kind of attitude I totally disagree with.

“If someone is watching something Especially England in the semi finals of the Euros then it goes without saying that you wouldn’t be talking.”

No, no it doesn’t. It doesn’t go without saying because football is not equally important for everyone. I couldn’t care less if it was a semi final (it’s laughable you think everyone should), I wouldn’t know they were playing or be able to tell the difference between England or a semi final or whatever cup it was. I would find any conversation about anything with family would be more important than this. Surely England literally never win anyway, it’s totally pointless and a mug’s game, ultimately you’re just being ripped off to line the pockets of whoever owns the clubs. It’s all totally pathetic in my opinion, and therefore irrelevant to my adult life. Presuming everyone feels the same as you do about football is insane, and results in these kind of upsets.

Then that is just rude.

Just because you don’t like something or don’t consider it important then you can treat a person who does like something with contempt and spoil their experience.

If you want to have a conversation then there are other rooms in the house to go and speak in without spoiling someone watching something they have been looking forward to.

The whole point is that England never do win anything so getting to the semis was huge.

How are people being ripped off and lining the pockets of whoever owns the clubs by watching England play.

That doesn’t make sense.

ItsCalledAConversation · 01/02/2023 18:02

Kennykenkencat · 01/02/2023 17:35

Your sister I think is so wrapped up in herself that anyone who makes a mistake or calls her out on her behaviour is met with over reaction
Probably why she is on her own as no one is going to be totally pleasant all of the time.

If someone is watching something Especially England in the semi finals of the Euros then it goes without saying that you wouldn’t be talking.

She has I think backed herself into a corner, a very lonely corner and has no way of getting out or back to the relationship you had.

I feel sorry for all of you that she has put up self imposed barriers that have come between her and those who love her.

This is the kind of attitude I totally disagree with.

“If someone is watching something Especially England in the semi finals of the Euros then it goes without saying that you wouldn’t be talking.”

No, no it doesn’t. It doesn’t go without saying because football is not equally important for everyone. I couldn’t care less if it was a semi final (it’s laughable you think everyone should), I wouldn’t know they were playing or be able to tell the difference between England or a semi final or whatever cup it was. I would find any conversation about anything with family would be more important than this. Surely England literally never win anyway, it’s totally pointless and a mug’s game, ultimately you’re just being ripped off to line the pockets of whoever owns the clubs. It’s all totally pathetic in my opinion, and therefore irrelevant to my adult life. Presuming everyone feels the same as you do about football is insane, and results in these kind of upsets.

Whatislove82 · 01/02/2023 17:46

CrazyLadie · 01/02/2023 17:32

Cause she always want to meet in restaurant etc and as OP still has 2 older kids at home she can't afford it.

Her “kids” are adults In their twenties

Kennykenkencat · 01/02/2023 17:40

WoolyMammoth55 · 01/02/2023 17:36

Hi OP, you said: "i think the world of her- that’s why I am so upset by it all"

If this is true, and your kids are grown, can't you visit her at her place sometimes?

I also think it's worth having a conversation about her putting you in an awkward position by refusing to see your husband - ask her what she would need to get past it, or if she intends to avoid him for the rest of their lives?

But ultimately if you love her then keep seeing her, just make it work, and don't make her do all the legwork.

(In your OP about the 3 kids and busy family life I was assuming you had 3 under 6! If they are grown then you're surely free to meet her on her terms sometimes? If you're refusing to do that then that might be part of her resentment...)

Wish you all the best getting this sorted.

I think the children what ever age they are want to see their aunt as well.

anya21 · 01/02/2023 17:39

I think your DH was really rude and your sister was understandable hurt.Saying ' it's water under the bridge' is NOT an apology.
I think your dh needs to make a genuine and heartfelt apology to your poor sister

WoolyMammoth55 · 01/02/2023 17:36

Hi OP, you said: "i think the world of her- that’s why I am so upset by it all"

If this is true, and your kids are grown, can't you visit her at her place sometimes?

I also think it's worth having a conversation about her putting you in an awkward position by refusing to see your husband - ask her what she would need to get past it, or if she intends to avoid him for the rest of their lives?

But ultimately if you love her then keep seeing her, just make it work, and don't make her do all the legwork.

(In your OP about the 3 kids and busy family life I was assuming you had 3 under 6! If they are grown then you're surely free to meet her on her terms sometimes? If you're refusing to do that then that might be part of her resentment...)

Wish you all the best getting this sorted.

Kennykenkencat · 01/02/2023 17:35

Your sister I think is so wrapped up in herself that anyone who makes a mistake or calls her out on her behaviour is met with over reaction
Probably why she is on her own as no one is going to be totally pleasant all of the time.

If someone is watching something Especially England in the semi finals of the Euros then it goes without saying that you wouldn’t be talking.

She has I think backed herself into a corner, a very lonely corner and has no way of getting out or back to the relationship you had.

I feel sorry for all of you that she has put up self imposed barriers that have come between her and those who love her.

Benjispruce4 · 01/02/2023 17:34

Sounds like an overreaction. Had they always got on before?

CrazyLadie · 01/02/2023 17:32

rothbury · 01/02/2023 17:31

I don’t understand why it’s a big deal to see your sister without your husband?

Cause she always want to meet in restaurant etc and as OP still has 2 older kids at home she can't afford it.

rothbury · 01/02/2023 17:31

I don’t understand why it’s a big deal to see your sister without your husband?

FuckNuggets · 01/02/2023 17:31

Cocobutt · 01/02/2023 16:36

Husband was watching massive football game - can’t remember - was it cup final or something at the time? He asked her to be quiet as he was trying to watch the game!
Husband said to her that he didn’t mean to upset and that ‘it’s water under the bridge’ and she is always welcome etc..but as time goes on and she wouldn’t visit at Christmas he is getting pretty fed up with the whole situation.

Why would she need to be quiet for a football match?
They usually show them in pubs where there’s loads of noise.

If it was such a big game that required people to be quiet then you shouldn’t have had visitors around.

I doubt it’s the fact he told her to be quiet which is what she’s upset about.
It’s the fact that your DH was a dick and then acted like it was no big deal and you are also acting like she over reacted.

He’s now getting fed of the situation - even though he was the one that caused it.

It’s the downplaying of it and the ‘water under the bridge’ that is the issue - he shouldn’t be the one even saying that!
He should be the one apologising and she gets to say whether it’s water under the bridge or not.
That fact that he said it just proves that she is not over reacting.

Why not just meet her at her house?

Jesus I'd hate to be related to you. Do expect a full on apology if someone looks at you the wrong way?

JudgeRudy · 01/02/2023 17:30

Whatislove82 · 01/02/2023 16:13

Perhaps it was straw that broke the camels back

Your OP certainly screams to me that you don’t hold her in the highest regard!

I didn't get that impression at all. I'd say she loves her sister and wants her old relationship back. The tone I got was one of frustration.

FuckNuggets · 01/02/2023 17:29

ColdHandsHotHead · 01/02/2023 16:15

actually if someone asked me to be quiet because they were watching football, I'd be annoyed. You don't need to hear it.

So annoyed you'd refuse to speak to them or visit their house for 18 months?

JudgeRudy · 01/02/2023 17:27

poiuy · 01/02/2023 16:11

Husband was watching massive football game - can’t remember - was it cup final or something at the time? He asked her to be quiet as he was trying to watch the game!
Husband said to her that he didn’t mean to upset and that ‘it’s water under the bridge’ and she is always welcome etc..but as time goes on and she wouldn’t visit at Christmas he is getting pretty fed up with the whole situation.

Well now you've given that information you're sister is totally unreasonable. I'd wonder if it's possible to ever reason with someone who came to such an extreme conclusion.
Continue to visit occasionally but let her know you would like it to be more but you're not willing to pander to this behaviour. Re iterate that she's welcome in your home when husband is or isn't in. If she chooses to refuse your invite that's on her. Would outside family members have any influence? What hapoens eg if you all met up for brothers 50th or attended a wedding. Is she seriously never going to speak to or be in the company of your husband?I don't think you can do much more. It has to come from her.

CrazyLadie · 01/02/2023 17:26

FrenchandSaunders · 01/02/2023 16:46

It was a HUGE match, it must have been the final of the Euros. If you are into football then that is big.

Your sister is being ridiculous, esp as he apologised afterwards.

I'm not a big footie fan but if it was world cup final or euro final I would have done the exact same thing 🤣🤣🤣

ItsCalledAConversation · 01/02/2023 17:25

Pleasebeafleabite · 01/02/2023 17:13

Are you OPs sister?

Wondering now how posters who make comments like this get through life without falling out for all time with everyone they come across

Lol, no but I do sympathise with the sister’s position.

The way I manage is by actively avoiding people who say they like football.

BadNomad · 01/02/2023 17:21

It doesn't matter that it was football - it is rude to talk when someone is watching TV. But she is within her rights to not tolerate being spoken to like shit by other people. The smart thing would have been for you and your sister to go somewhere else to natter if you knew your DH was going to be watching the game.

If visiting her is getting to be too much, then try to arrange for her to come to you if your husband will be willing. If they're not willing to do that then you'll just have to accept that you'll see each other less going forward.

Fladdermus · 01/02/2023 17:16

Is your husband often rude to your sister?

Swipe left for the next trending thread