Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You don’t have to satisfy cravings

86 replies

2023a · 01/02/2023 15:52

I’m getting a bit annoyed by people who go in about their ‘uncontrollable’ cravings. They are controllable.

Unless you’re pregnant (in which case, do what you need to do) or have a mental health condition, you don’t need to eat or drink everything you want to eat or drink. The fact that you want a litre of Diet Coke doesn’t mean you have to have a litre of Diet Coke.

This all seems very basic, but it seems some people don’t understand this. All this ‘how do I control my cravings?’ Just have the cravings? Not giving yourself said ‘treat’ won’t kill you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EthicalNonMahogany · 02/02/2023 06:56

There's dopamine levels which differ between us and which allow us greater or lesser control.

However sugar is also "the carer's addiction" - you can numb bad feelings but have no comedown that impacts your ability to work, have a relatively even mood, parent your children etc. Who are you to say, OP, that people are wrong for making decisions that work for them in the moment? Maybe their lives are intolerable otherwise.

Also there are systemic problems causing poverty linked obesity in this country, not just cravings.

FinallyHere · 02/02/2023 06:51

ResearchMakesMeCry · 02/02/2023 05:34

I understand there is a technique used in addiction recovery called 'urge surfing', wherein you notice the craving and ride it like a wave. It's related to mindfulness.

Wholeheartedly agree with this

The trick is to be mindful of how you will feel after giving in to the craving v if you allow that craving just to be.

Resisting the feeling, by giving in to it, causes it to persist, making it stronger. Allowing it to exist, causes its power to dissipate.

I wish I had understood this much, much earlier in my life. Glad to have got there at last.

FangsForTheMemory · 02/02/2023 06:47

I’m guessing the OP has only ever had cravings when she was pregnant which is why she’s allowing people who are pregnant to give in to them.

massivesalads · 02/02/2023 06:42

The OP is definitely sat eating a sharing pack of Maltesers as they read this thread

Woahtherehoney · 02/02/2023 06:39

Thanks for showing you completely misunderstand mental health, potential food addictions and the chemicals which affect ‘cravings’

WinterFoxes · 02/02/2023 06:37

OP you might as well say, other people are fools for having lower dopamine levels than me. Dopamine dictates whether you can control cravings.

Goatinthegarden · 02/02/2023 06:32

StarsSand · 02/02/2023 05:40

Yeah I think OP has accidentally stumbled on something legitimate within mindfulness. I think it is actually used to work with addicts.

You try and observe your feeling (or craving) without judging it or pushing it away. You just ride it out like a wave.

After a while you realise you can endure it, and it loses power over you.

I think it's about feeling your feelings rather than stuffing them down with an addictive behaviour to numb it.

So I don't think the OP is unreasonable, but there was probably a better way to approach the topic.

I agree with this. Cravings are surmountable but not as easy as OP makes out. Everyone has different challenges to overcome and food addictions can be huge for some people.

If I eat something I don’t actually need, I try to eat it mindfully, concentrating on how much I’m actually enjoying it and whether I’ve satisfied the craving by having it.

Sometimes the craving remains after I’ve finished it, meaning I shouldn’t have bothered in the first place. Sometimes, it wasn’t as good as I’d hoped. Sometimes, I’ll feel sluggish or lethargic later on as a result.

Now when I get a craving, I try to remember how I felt last time I had the food and most of the time, I decide it won’t be worth it. The less junk I eat, the less cravings I have for it.

I’m not perfect, I eat really well most of the time and hardly snack at all, but yesterday I thought ‘fuck it’, and ate a couple of biscuits, a large piece of chocolate, a packet of crisps and two drumstick lollies amongst all my usual healthy meals.

None of those things scratched the itch I was having and my bike ride home was hard work…so I’ll remember that today.

Foxywood · 02/02/2023 06:00

(One sweet now, Vs two sweets later experiment). Really really important to teach our kids delayed gratification if they don't work it out for themselves.

I think this is not considered good science nowadays as eg child might be from poor household, or a disruptive one, also adhd and autism can affect how dopamine is controlled.

I would definitely have taken the first sweet in case something happened some emergency, forgetful adult, older brother nicked it (most likely) etc which seems quite reasonable to me.

DietCroak · 02/02/2023 05:53

antipodeancanary · 01/02/2023 20:38

No they are not. Right from childhood children who are taught or self teach to delay gratification can be identified and that one piece of evidence is a really strong indicator for how well they succeed in life. This is particularly strong link with delayed gratification around food. (One sweet now, Vs two sweets later experiment). Really really important to teach our kids delayed gratification if they don't work it out for themselves.

anderson-review.ucla.edu/new-study-disavows-marshmallow-tests-predictive-powers/

Quite a lot of doubt about whether the marshmallow test actually predicts anything. (Obv that doesn’t make your broader point wrong.)

MistyRock · 02/02/2023 05:50

QuestionableMouse · 01/02/2023 16:47

I often crave weird stuff but I'm horribly anemic at the moment and it's linked. But thanks for dismissing a valid health issue.

Oh don't be so ridiculous!

StarsSand · 02/02/2023 05:40

ResearchMakesMeCry · 02/02/2023 05:34

I understand there is a technique used in addiction recovery called 'urge surfing', wherein you notice the craving and ride it like a wave. It's related to mindfulness.

Yeah I think OP has accidentally stumbled on something legitimate within mindfulness. I think it is actually used to work with addicts.

You try and observe your feeling (or craving) without judging it or pushing it away. You just ride it out like a wave.

After a while you realise you can endure it, and it loses power over you.

I think it's about feeling your feelings rather than stuffing them down with an addictive behaviour to numb it.

So I don't think the OP is unreasonable, but there was probably a better way to approach the topic.

ThreeblackCats · 02/02/2023 05:39

Well there you go folk! Remember where you were when you first saw this thread.

Op has single handed found the cure for obesity, smoking, heroin addiction, alcoholism and a host of other addictions.

just say no! Zammo had the answer but we all ignored him, thank science for op and her superior wisdom.

ResearchMakesMeCry · 02/02/2023 05:34

I understand there is a technique used in addiction recovery called 'urge surfing', wherein you notice the craving and ride it like a wave. It's related to mindfulness.

ouch321 · 02/02/2023 03:41

I think troll.

No one can be this dopey.

MissTrip82 · 02/02/2023 02:50

Hahahahahhahahaha if you’re performing your womanly function as a giver of life it’s fine to eat crap.

Otherwise you should be perfectly disciplined at all times.

Only pregnant women are a) affected by hormones and b) deserving of treats.

Makes sense.

PinkArt · 02/02/2023 02:35

Wowsers, thanks for this OP. Can't believe all it needed to solve the obesity crisis was a sanctimonious Mumsnet post.

CuntyMcBollocks · 02/02/2023 01:54

You appear to have a very limited view OP, of who is exempt from being judged. This thread has made me think of the time when I had an uncontrollable craving for something sweet. I wasn't suffering from a mental health condition, nor was I pregnant as I was only around 12 at the time, but I knew that my body NEEDED something sugary. I was shaking and feeling very faint, and it turns out that I actually had low blood sugar levels. So, no, things aren't just as simple as you seem to think. There are a myriad of reasons why some cravings really are uncontrollable.

Nicecow · 02/02/2023 01:22

DarkNurseries · 01/02/2023 15:54

Isn’t your annoyance at these people also controllable? As in, it’s ok to feel it, but no need to start a thread on an Internet forum about it?

Ha ha.

Perhaps give in to some of your cravings, might stop you from being such a misery guts OP😆

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 01:20

How on earth do you know what someone else's cravings feel like to them? By definition aren't cravings overpowering desires? You might as well say that about any pain, eg tooth ache, childbirth, bereavement, heartbreak, etc. A true craving is painful.
You do realise everyone feels things differently right? This all seems very basic, but it seems some people don’t understand this.
Why does it concern you enough to post about it?

Mynameisnotsteve · 02/02/2023 01:14

I scoffed some crisps right before bed and knew I’d be annoyed with myself. I also knew I got the craving because I’d stayed up too late as I was putting off doing something that I needed to do before going to bed so it was all part of a tangle of tiredness and procrastination and very little to do with actually wanting to eat crisps.

Busybutbored · 02/02/2023 01:07

You sound like you have a very sad and boring life OP. Have you not ever had an uncontrollable urge for something ... some chocolate, a quick shag, a delicious glass of wine? And oh how satisfying once the craving has been met.
Feel sorry for you Flowers

georgiegherkin · 02/02/2023 00:58

my primary school aged kid displays less simplistic thinking than you 😬

LadyJ2023 · 02/02/2023 00:19

The NHS do say junk food addiction can be even stronger than a cocaine addiction. And much as I don't particularly eat junk food or drink pips etc I wouldn't judge anyone who did and expect to know why they do it more than normal

PousseyNotMoira · 02/02/2023 00:15

PurpleWisteria1 · 01/02/2023 23:14

Gosh I find it hard. Almost everyone I know does. Only a couple of people I know who just get fuller quicker or don’t enjoy food as much and one who is extremely health conscious as processed food / sugar and alcohol makes her ill.
The majority of the country struggles with it daily and that’s why 67% of the population is currently overweight or obese!

People in (or from) the U.K. apparently struggle with it, yes. I’m not British, though. Obesity rates where I’m from are considerably lower. So, I suspect this is a cultural issue.

I wouldn’t say I was particularly health conscious, and I love food. I just don’t have the connection between liking a food and therefore having to have it or having to have it to excess in the way that’s described here. And it’s not an immense hardship or through some sort of force of will, that’s just not my relationship with food.

PurpleWisteria1 · 01/02/2023 23:14

PousseyNotMoira · 01/02/2023 22:51

To overcome that takes huge strength, will power, time and taking the hard route. Being conscious of that always, every day.
Most people just can’t do it for long if at all.

It’s hard work. A daily grind. Even for those who have had good eating / life habits growing up.

For quite a lot of people, it really isn’t/doesn’t. I’ve never found it to be and I genuinely love food. Ditto my entire family and most people I know.

This is an interesting thread.

Gosh I find it hard. Almost everyone I know does. Only a couple of people I know who just get fuller quicker or don’t enjoy food as much and one who is extremely health conscious as processed food / sugar and alcohol makes her ill.
The majority of the country struggles with it daily and that’s why 67% of the population is currently overweight or obese!