Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 16:36

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 16:29

No - if Labour had been in Government, we would probably have seen sound economic growth in the 2011 to 2020 period.

Then when the pandemic hit we would be entering it with:

(a) lower debt to GDP because of nine previous years of higher growth
(b) higher wages because of (i) less unnecessary austerity and (ii) stronger incentives for profits to be invested in private sector growth or wages rather than hoarded.

So a Labour Government wouldn't have avoided the economic hits of a pandemic and a war.

But they would have been able to weather those hits much more effectively, with much more fiscal headroom to get through them.

Hard to say how much the upswing just before a crash was Labour or just general global boom and bust that impacted us a lot in both directions.

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 16:36

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 16:35

Labour took over from the Conservatives when world economies were all on the up, inc. UK Plc. They had some great years, but then at the end of those golden years, there was nothing left, they blew the lot. Growth will never be the same again, particularly in evolved Western nations, regardless of what you do. We may get a small boost from the Green Revolution but what then, what's next? You never know what is coming along to bite you in the arse, regardless of who is in charge.

I think But Jeremy Corbyn is a more convincing argument.

TheGoogleMum · 01/02/2023 16:36

Here's a question for you OP
If the government don't fund any pay increases what will we do about the increasing staff shortages in public sector jobs? In areas like nursing staffing is already dangerously low in places. So if everyone leaves because the pay isn't worth it what will we do then?

I don't think they can afford not to increase pay

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 16:35

Labour took over from the Conservatives when world economies were all on the up, inc. UK Plc. They had some great years, but then at the end of those golden years, there was nothing left, they blew the lot. Growth will never be the same again, particularly in evolved Western nations, regardless of what you do. We may get a small boost from the Green Revolution but what then, what's next? You never know what is coming along to bite you in the arse, regardless of who is in charge.

2o23 · 01/02/2023 16:34

If they get pay rises then tax will have to go up. Then there'll be screaming and wailing again.

Aleaiactaest · 01/02/2023 16:34

The IMF are not that reliable in their predictions. Plenty of critique on numerous issues can be thrown their way.

Whatsshecalled · 01/02/2023 16:34

PeppermintChoc · 01/02/2023 16:10

Public servants have been underpaid for far too long (I am not nor have I ever been one by the way!)

i am a public servant and I don’t agree. I think a huge majority of public servants would have a huge shock if they went to the private sector. I honestly think if my colleagues when to the private sector for a year they’d never contemplate striking again. I am paid less than I was in the private sector. But there are many advantages and one is vastly different workload.

Well you're very lucky. I left the civil service last year after 10yrs, I left a team that had been reduced from 10 people to 4 people but where the workload had increased approx 3 fold, there was a requirement to staff a 24/7 rota all year round between just 4 people, no meaningful pay rise for 10yrs. They have a huge recruitment crisis and this was a familuar situation within many depts I worked with. Not all public/civil servants are as lucky as you but I'm glad your conditions are good.

ThisIsTrifficult · 01/02/2023 16:33

Look at the twitter or blog of Richard Murphy. He's really helped me to understand the finances of our country (not to the point where I can succinctly explain it!) and it's fascinating and frustrating.

Pyewhacket · 01/02/2023 16:31

GrumpyPanda · 01/02/2023 16:14

You're making a classical mistake, which is assuming that countries are like households. They're not. Balanced budgets at the risk of slipping into recession is precisely the wrong move in circumstances like the present.

Here's a thread that does an excellent job discussing the strikes and the present-dat British economy:

mobile.twitter.com/RichardJMurphy/status/1620701720132337665

Well, if its on Twitter it must be right.

fyn · 01/02/2023 16:31

I don’t know, increasing wages that much is just going to drive up inflation even more and I’m sure they’ll strike again so the cycle will begin again. We just need to ride it out, surely it’s a pretty basic economic principle. Before anyone starts, I am a civil servant on a low band currently and my DH is a soldier who earns half of what he could in the private sector. I think he’d be off to Colchester if he went on strike.

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 16:29

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 16:24

Labour were in on the upward swing just before a global crash. Other countries would have been experiencing the same upswing. Do you think if they were still in they would just have sailed through pandemic and war on same trajectory?

The IMF have kindly answered that question for you.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-64452995

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 16:29

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 16:24

Labour were in on the upward swing just before a global crash. Other countries would have been experiencing the same upswing. Do you think if they were still in they would just have sailed through pandemic and war on same trajectory?

No - if Labour had been in Government, we would probably have seen sound economic growth in the 2011 to 2020 period.

Then when the pandemic hit we would be entering it with:

(a) lower debt to GDP because of nine previous years of higher growth
(b) higher wages because of (i) less unnecessary austerity and (ii) stronger incentives for profits to be invested in private sector growth or wages rather than hoarded.

So a Labour Government wouldn't have avoided the economic hits of a pandemic and a war.

But they would have been able to weather those hits much more effectively, with much more fiscal headroom to get through them.

JassyRadlett · 01/02/2023 16:27

If the 'where's the money coming from' question is actually serious, I'd humbly suggest rejoining the customs union as a decent economic stimulus that would increase tax revenues.

Tessasanderson · 01/02/2023 16:27

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 16:15

The govenrment is trying to reduce the inflation by reducing peoples ability to spend. Ie raise interest rates. Make mortgages more expensive so they cant buy houses. In general just making things harder. Yes :-)

Most people who are asking for pay rises aren't rich. They are the ones who have been cutting back: no new shoes, holiday in UK (which is good for the economy, tbf) not buying new cars, etc etc etc.
They move from branded goods to supermarket own brand, or cheaper brands. Or cut down on the fun things.

Some are choosing between heating and eating, new coat or new shoes for their kids.

Imagine now if they have more disposable income. Will they stash in a tax-efficient offshore bank, or will they buy the coat AND the shoes? Heat AND eat. Maybe spend more on holiday, buy more treats.

That multiplies not only among the people with more disposable income, but to the shops and services they use. And that is how to get the economy moving by making money move around

Incidentally when interest rates are high those who can take their money out of the economy and save it. Savings aren't good for getting an economy moving.

This is a simple way of explaining the Keynsian multiplier. Which is something this government don't believe in, i think

Thanks for the reply.

I must say most of the teachers/firemen/nurses etc i know are on pretty decent wages. Can afford bigger houses, better cars, more holidays than the average person tbh. I dont begrudge them it, but they are definately not doing without compared to a LOT of other occupations. I know a couple where one is a teacher and the other a fireman living in Scotland. Their joint household income is way above £100k and they have huge house, nice cars and multiple holidays.

So if they and the others that are struggling in similar circumstances get a pay rise.....what will they spend it on. Well if the last 20 years has told us anything, they will spend it on houses. Bigger houses or second houses. I dont begrudge them but thats what extra money for them will mean.

As i said earlier.......they will stand still. Possibly improve. But what about the huge amount of other people working to get by, not on inflation busting benefits etc?

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 16:24

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 16:15

There's a few things you're missing.

First, those on benefits, including UC and Pensions, will have their benefits uprated in line with inflation. So they will be no better but no worse off in real terms.

But second, most economists say that providing decent pay rises for public sector workers would not fuel inflation. The inflation problem hasn't been caused by consumer spending, it's been caused by the war in Ukraine and higher production and trading costs brought on by both Covid and Brexit. Reducing consumer spending power of the several million public sector workers will not affect those prices significantly.

What is actually needed is growth. If the economy had grown under the Tories as it did under Labour, the economy would be about $1 trillion bigger than it is now. And that would mean the Government having about $440 billion (about £350 billion) extra for public spending.

Labour were in on the upward swing just before a global crash. Other countries would have been experiencing the same upswing. Do you think if they were still in they would just have sailed through pandemic and war on same trajectory?

jgw1 · 01/02/2023 16:23

BeautifulWar · 01/02/2023 15:37

It feels like no rash decisions are being made on anything economy related in the hope that Putin will either die or be removed from office and someone reasonable takes the reins in Russia. That would remove one of the stresses.

They don't seem to be making long-term decisions. Increasing wages beyond inflation would bite them in the arse if the rates become reasonable once again.

The Education Secretary this morning was quite clear that she had no way of explaining why teachers couldn't have a pay increase in line with inflation.
There is a massive difference to a pay increase that is in line with inflation and what the goverment is currently offering to many vital workers, who will be poorer this year and every subsequent year as a result.

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 16:16

PeppermintChoc · 01/02/2023 16:10

Public servants have been underpaid for far too long (I am not nor have I ever been one by the way!)

i am a public servant and I don’t agree. I think a huge majority of public servants would have a huge shock if they went to the private sector. I honestly think if my colleagues when to the private sector for a year they’d never contemplate striking again. I am paid less than I was in the private sector. But there are many advantages and one is vastly different workload.

So why is the public sector struggling so much to retain people?

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 16:15

Tessasanderson · 01/02/2023 16:05

I understand everyones comments about the government finding the money etc etc etc.

The thing i cant understand is what we are trying to achieve here. Stick with me as i am not the best at explaining things.

So we have big inflation at the moment because everything is expensive, all the materials are expensive and cost of living is just impossible. For decades people have borrowed money they cant really afford because borrowing was cheap. It hasnt taken much of a increase for it to hit a lot of people hard. Yes :-)

The govenrment is trying to reduce the inflation by reducing peoples ability to spend. Ie raise interest rates. Make mortgages more expensive so they cant buy houses. In general just making things harder. Yes :-)

So if we give nurses/teachers/blue light workers/everyone else that is due a wage rise an inflation busting wage rise.........WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?

From where i sit the teachers and the rest who get this big (Justified) pay rise end up in status quo. No worse off but essentially just treading water or possibly slightly better off. The economy gets a bigger boost because some rather large parts of society get a bit of security and start to move the economy on again, possibly back into increased inflation...........BUT what about the other HUGE chunk of the population who are left behind. The ones who didnt get that pay rise and have to deal with ever increasing inflation. The vast majority of our society who arent lucky enough to work for big institutions and havent got unions/rest of the public fighting their corner.

I can only forsee huge pain for those that havent got much to begin with. There is going to be even bigger gaps between the haves and the have nots.

Am i missing something?

There's a few things you're missing.

First, those on benefits, including UC and Pensions, will have their benefits uprated in line with inflation. So they will be no better but no worse off in real terms.

But second, most economists say that providing decent pay rises for public sector workers would not fuel inflation. The inflation problem hasn't been caused by consumer spending, it's been caused by the war in Ukraine and higher production and trading costs brought on by both Covid and Brexit. Reducing consumer spending power of the several million public sector workers will not affect those prices significantly.

What is actually needed is growth. If the economy had grown under the Tories as it did under Labour, the economy would be about $1 trillion bigger than it is now. And that would mean the Government having about $440 billion (about £350 billion) extra for public spending.

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 16:15

The govenrment is trying to reduce the inflation by reducing peoples ability to spend. Ie raise interest rates. Make mortgages more expensive so they cant buy houses. In general just making things harder. Yes :-)

Most people who are asking for pay rises aren't rich. They are the ones who have been cutting back: no new shoes, holiday in UK (which is good for the economy, tbf) not buying new cars, etc etc etc.
They move from branded goods to supermarket own brand, or cheaper brands. Or cut down on the fun things.

Some are choosing between heating and eating, new coat or new shoes for their kids.

Imagine now if they have more disposable income. Will they stash in a tax-efficient offshore bank, or will they buy the coat AND the shoes? Heat AND eat. Maybe spend more on holiday, buy more treats.

That multiplies not only among the people with more disposable income, but to the shops and services they use. And that is how to get the economy moving by making money move around

Incidentally when interest rates are high those who can take their money out of the economy and save it. Savings aren't good for getting an economy moving.

This is a simple way of explaining the Keynsian multiplier. Which is something this government don't believe in, i think

Bodybarnet · 01/02/2023 16:14

PeppermintChoc · 01/02/2023 16:10

Public servants have been underpaid for far too long (I am not nor have I ever been one by the way!)

i am a public servant and I don’t agree. I think a huge majority of public servants would have a huge shock if they went to the private sector. I honestly think if my colleagues when to the private sector for a year they’d never contemplate striking again. I am paid less than I was in the private sector. But there are many advantages and one is vastly different workload.

Your experience is not universal. My DH is private sector. His hours are more flexible, his pay is triple mine and he certainly does not have the emotional load of my job every day.

GrumpyPanda · 01/02/2023 16:14

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:30

exactly the gvt can only pay out, what they get coming in?

You're making a classical mistake, which is assuming that countries are like households. They're not. Balanced budgets at the risk of slipping into recession is precisely the wrong move in circumstances like the present.

Here's a thread that does an excellent job discussing the strikes and the present-dat British economy:

mobile.twitter.com/RichardJMurphy/status/1620701720132337665

Bodybarnet · 01/02/2023 16:11

Pyewhacket · 01/02/2023 16:01

We have vast public investment in transportation and infrastructure : Crossrail HS2 !!!!!. And healthcare is over 40% of all public sending and growing, with a £12b injection to cover backlog on top of an increase in NHS funding.

Sticking plasters to fix what is broken and vanity projects is not the same as meaningful investment.

Blankscreen · 01/02/2023 16:10

The money for the COVID measures was borrowed and still needs to be paid back.

They will no doubt raise income tax on higher paid people.

They don't tax wealth which is generally 'old' money.

Tax on private school fees will raise some money which needs to be offset against the additional costs resulting from the people pulling their kids out because they can no longer afford it.

The discontent will just shift up the payscales.

Someone up thread put it more elloquently but the NMW pay rise of 9% means it is hardly worth
the additional stress for hardly any more money.

Just listening to LBC and they are talking about pensions for public sector. Wow!!!!

PeppermintChoc · 01/02/2023 16:10

Public servants have been underpaid for far too long (I am not nor have I ever been one by the way!)

i am a public servant and I don’t agree. I think a huge majority of public servants would have a huge shock if they went to the private sector. I honestly think if my colleagues when to the private sector for a year they’d never contemplate striking again. I am paid less than I was in the private sector. But there are many advantages and one is vastly different workload.

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 16:08

Eleganz · 01/02/2023 16:01

They will have to improve offers in some way though. Some of the public sector have had pay freezes and 1% rises for most of the last 12 years. If the nurses and teachers get a better deal they will need to offer something to the civil service to get them back off strike.

They won’t budge to inflation matching, maybe hold out so inflation drops first then reduced offer. But will see

I don’t predict borrowing or taxes will increase more