Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
Diverging · 01/02/2023 17:48

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?

Or to put it another way where has all the money gone? Where is it? Why are so many of the resources owned by so few people?

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 17:44

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 16:35

Labour took over from the Conservatives when world economies were all on the up, inc. UK Plc. They had some great years, but then at the end of those golden years, there was nothing left, they blew the lot. Growth will never be the same again, particularly in evolved Western nations, regardless of what you do. We may get a small boost from the Green Revolution but what then, what's next? You never know what is coming along to bite you in the arse, regardless of who is in charge.

This is bollox sorry.

When Labour left office the economy was still about a third bigger in real terms than they found it in 1997. That is not ‘nothing left’.

By contrast the Tories have had the economy essentially flatlining over the last 13 years in real terms.

OchreDandelion · 01/02/2023 17:44

In addition to the many elements already covered, one simple way I had it explained to me was to imagine the life cycle of a pound.

It is not like an chocolate bar which, once eaten, is gone.

Money - which is paid to someone who will spend it - circulates.

Let's say, for example:

  • I am paid well enough to have an extra £100 at the end of the term, so I book my daughter into ballet lessons.
  • So the ballet school gets the £100 and that of other better paid people
  • The combined ballet fees mean the ballet teacher has an extra £100 at the end of the term, so she might go out to dinner.
  • More people going out to dinner means the restaurant buys more from the local butcher and hires an extra waiter.

That waiter can now come off benefits and all the people in the story pay more tax.

(Money doesn't circulate nearly so well in an off shore account though - which is why paying your workers can be a smart thing to do if you want vibrant local services).

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 17:39

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:38

@TeaKlaxon what do you mean?

The original claim was that public sector workers have it much better than private sector workers.

If that were true, workers would want to fill public sector roles before they look to the private sector. But that’s not happening.

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:39

I haven't said public sector jobs are easier...

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:38

@TeaKlaxon what do you mean?

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:36

I don’t think higher taxes are the answer, people are mobile and we have an economy that relies on being attractive wrt taxes

I think they are if you want good public services which I do.

They’re not low in any case but mid level and we should stick to that

And how do we fund the NHS & social care with an ageing population?

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 17:32

amylou8 · 01/02/2023 17:01

It will come from people like me who are self employed, struggling with the rising costs of doing business and getting absolutely no pay rise. It will come from my partner who works in the private sector and if getting 5% this year. We'll pay the public sectors cost of living demands with our increased taxes.

Do you think public sector workers don’t pay taxes?

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 17:29

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 16:52

So why is the public sector struggling so much to retain peo

It's not just the public sector it's across many industries. We don't have enough workers

But by the logic that public service jobs are easier they should be the first to be filled in an economy with a worker shortage.

jcyclops · 01/02/2023 17:27

The idea that public sector pay can be funded by cutting MPs wages and expenses is as imbecilic as suggesting people wouldn't struggle if they cancelled Netflix or stopped buying a coffee each day.

Public sector pay costs around £235bn/year - central gov £165bn, local gov £70bn. The NHS wage bill alone is around £60bn. A 10% pay rise across the sector would cost £23.5bn, and as the government would recover approx 32% through income tax and NI, the extra cost would be around £16bn every year.

Labour want to eliminate all non-dom tax rules - and estimates this would provide up to £3bn/year (other sources estimates are lower) so that isn't going to pay for it. Their other big idea is to massively increase the energy windfall tax, but this would be spent on energy subsidies for consumers and industry, and would disappear if and when energy prices come down, so that isn't going to fund the pay rises either.

That leaves the old favourites of a massive rise in taxes (income tax, NI and VAT account for two thirds of all taxes) and/or big cuts in spending and/or a big increase in borrowing - adding to the £50bn/year interest bill already forecast for the next few years, and that's £50bn/year we will be spending for which we get sweet FA irrespective of which party forms the next government.

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 17:27

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:10

@MarshaBradyo

I would have it more in line with European countries. However as I said I wouldn't do this without overhauling benefits. We pay higher tax as a family & I don't feel I get "enough back". If I got child benefit or a % of my salary when unemployed I would.

I would also bring CGT in line with income.

What do you think the solution is?

I’m just guessing at 55% to 60%? Not sure what it is exactly

I don’t think higher taxes are the answer, people are mobile and we have an economy that relies on being attractive wrt taxes

They’re not low in any case but mid level and we should stick to that

re solutions other than taxing people highly I would have liked a party to run on CU or SM but that’s out. Even Labour don’t want to rock the Brexit vote.

Other than that become more attractive via taxes, don’t try to cut what we do well by adding more tax, but use high GDP sectors to grow others. Bit hard without information but I do think there’s a way through this that’s not just higher tax based.

orangegato · 01/02/2023 17:22

Controversial but I’m a public servant (office role) and would take a pay cut to WFH. Maybe that’d save the govt a few hundred million if all that could opted for a pay cut to do so. Then pay nurses teachers etc what this brings in.

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:21

Tax unearned income at the same rate as earned income - that would more than cover it!

People won't vote for that though!

WinnieFosterReads · 01/02/2023 17:18

I think your lack of understanding of economics might mean that you're not going to understand the answers on here.

But perhaps you could think of it in terms of where did the government find the money from for:
failed PPE contracts (worth billions);
failed track and trace (worth billions);
MPs' expenses scandal (hundreds of thousands);
failed PM press briefing room similar to US President (almost £3million)

Aishah231 · 01/02/2023 17:17

Tax unearned income at the same rate as earned income - that would more than cover it!

Abra1t · 01/02/2023 17:14

One solution would be to take some of the often generous pension benefits and pay it now. So some of the current employee contributions could come as pay instead. Of course, there would be an issue of future pension funds not being as large if you did this, but you could argue that a public servant with a young family needs the money now.

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:13

Thank god my parents were immigrants so my dc have an easier time of moving abroad. It's depressing but i'm not sure how they will fix things.

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:10

@MarshaBradyo

I would have it more in line with European countries. However as I said I wouldn't do this without overhauling benefits. We pay higher tax as a family & I don't feel I get "enough back". If I got child benefit or a % of my salary when unemployed I would.

I would also bring CGT in line with income.

What do you think the solution is?

2bazookas · 01/02/2023 17:08

well, we can make a start by forcing millionaire politicians to pay their taxes in UK.

PeppermintChoc · 01/02/2023 17:07

Mellymoon · 01/02/2023 17:05

They pay agency nurses way more than nhs nurses- if they can afford to do that then why not just pay nurses better and encourage retention?
also the government could actually make companies and their mates who avoid tax pay what they should and it would pay for the entire NHS.

It wouldn’t actually help with the staff shortages though. So you’d have a more expensive workforce and still have the issue of too few workers. So still need to pay agency staff who would still expected to be compensated over and above the baseline wage for their job in return for lack of security.

Mellymoon · 01/02/2023 17:05

They pay agency nurses way more than nhs nurses- if they can afford to do that then why not just pay nurses better and encourage retention?
also the government could actually make companies and their mates who avoid tax pay what they should and it would pay for the entire NHS.

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:03

@Neededanewuserhandle people have more options now. I won't do that care job, I'll take the supermarket job that pays more. I'll take the IT job in Europe. I take the doctor job in Oz.

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:01

This gov hasn't invested in young people or the economy & now that cheap money run has come to an end, the shit has hit the fan. But many people looked the other way cause their house went up by X amount.

amylou8 · 01/02/2023 17:01

It will come from people like me who are self employed, struggling with the rising costs of doing business and getting absolutely no pay rise. It will come from my partner who works in the private sector and if getting 5% this year. We'll pay the public sectors cost of living demands with our increased taxes.

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 17:00

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 16:52

So why is the public sector struggling so much to retain peo

It's not just the public sector it's across many industries. We don't have enough workers

You mean we don't have enough cheap workers.