Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 19:22

What happens if they don't get the pay rise also?

OP posts:
Winterday1991 · 01/02/2023 19:21

It's a very valid point, such large pay rises for teachers would cost billions. However, there is a severe shortage of teachers for some disciplines, so I don't know what the answer is.

JassyRadlett · 01/02/2023 19:20

Nothing about school funding etc.

I'm not in the education system but even I know that the 'fully funded' bit of a fully funded pay rise is all about school funding.

A pay rise that's not fully funded means schools have to fund it from existing budgets. Which means cuts to other things.

On top of existing cuts and pay erosion for 2010, where do you think the money will come from for pay rises if it's not cutting non-teaching staff and other things that schools need to pay for?

popopop · 01/02/2023 19:16

@PartyHelp have you ever worked in a school?

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 19:08

Teachers are not striking for more money, they are asking for better working conditions, respect (as in for their profession to be treated with respect) and for pay comensurate with their expertise/at a deserved rate.

Sorry but this isn't true. They are only looking for more money. The NEU is demanding a fully-funded, above-inflation pay rise, while NASUWT has asked for a 12 per cent rise. The NAHT is seeking a fully-funded pay award at the rate of inflation last September, when it was 10.1 per cent, plus 5 per cent.

Nothing about school funding etc. and of course they are perfectly entitled to strike for more pay, good luck to them if they haven't had proper payrises in years they are entitled to it but I'm really sick of reading the 'well they are just trying to fix the schools BS on MN, all schools are underfunded etc.' as if they are just being altruistic by striking!

People in this country don't know they are born when it comes to schools and the amount of resources they have and the fact you have to pay for basically nothing except for school uniform.

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 19:08

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 18:51

When we look at reasons for low growth, yes I think there will be higher growth under a Labour Government.

I think there will be more incentives for companies to reinvest profits rather than providing record breaking dividends for shareholders, for example. I think there will be less slavish devotion to the market and ideological pursuit of austerity even where that market is not functioning. I think there will be more targeted investment in, for example, green energy and infrastructure and skills. I think there will be fewer economically illiterate and ideologically driven insistence that economies are like household budgets.

So yes, I do think a Labour Government will likely create more growth.

That sounds like faith in something happening

I’m not seeing much so far that suggests Labour are going to do much that is very good.

Have you heard their specific policies so far - which stand out as being good?

It’s always a matter of perspective but any party that starts using ‘tax the rich’ narrative for votes sounds on a losing path- people can go.

It does gain votes but not much more. Blair at least had the sense not to do this. Imo Labour won’t look at the difficult stuff that could make a difference (Brexit) but will throw everything they’ve heard might poll well regardless because 13 years is a very long time to be out and they don’t want to risk another Ed Miliband.

That approach makes me feel less positive, but we’ll see I guess.

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 18:51

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 18:12

Do you think we’ll go back to 90s growth when Labour get in or it’ll be closer to the economic reality of today?

People look to the comparative short stints of Labour and I get the impression it’s not the global upswing they see - how many other countries had similar boom before the bust?, plus spending we’re paying for now, but some idea that Labour will do the same just because it’s Starmer.

The 70s just before Thatcher got in aren’t mentioned though.

When we look at reasons for low growth, yes I think there will be higher growth under a Labour Government.

I think there will be more incentives for companies to reinvest profits rather than providing record breaking dividends for shareholders, for example. I think there will be less slavish devotion to the market and ideological pursuit of austerity even where that market is not functioning. I think there will be more targeted investment in, for example, green energy and infrastructure and skills. I think there will be fewer economically illiterate and ideologically driven insistence that economies are like household budgets.

So yes, I do think a Labour Government will likely create more growth.

theworldhas · 01/02/2023 18:41

This government is about as certain of defeat at the next election in less than two years time as any government can be: Lagging about 25 points in the poll. The majority in the country would be hard pushed to name a single achievement of their ten plus years in office.

What they are trying to do right now, IMO, is make this country as impoverished and ungovernable as possible so that they can try to get back in again before the end of the decade. In the meantime they will decimate public services - so that, when they do get in again, full on privatisation of the NHS will (they hope) be an historically easy sell. Moreover they know that letting poverty spiral and inequality rise will actually be less a problem for them than Labour, as nobody expects Tories to safeguard the lives of the poor.

theworldhas · 01/02/2023 18:29

@GrumpyPanda

excellent link. This sums it up nicely:

No wonder we are the only economy heading for a recession. Other governments are managing the fallout of war. We’re seeing that war used as an excuse for an economic war on the people and institutions of this country

Honper · 01/02/2023 18:19

It's going to come from my fucking fanny.

Happysalley · 01/02/2023 18:18

Well they can start by clawing some of it back from greedy entitled mps claiming tens of thousands to redecorate their offices or heat their stables. What world do we live in when mps are quaffing expensive wine and gourmet foods in parliament, all heavily subsidised, and nurses are surviving on microwaved pasta for a 12 hour shift? Then there's the ppe backhanders, eat out to help out shite, badly handled covid payments, etc. There is money available, but it's not earmarked for the plebs.

strongallowed · 01/02/2023 18:16

ginnybag · 01/02/2023 15:32

Because more in wages ultimately = more tax.

The jump in the NMW in April will increase Tax revenue, as more people will find themselves over the thresholds, and start paying it, and those already paying it will pay more. The same raise will cut the benefits bill by meaning more people earn more of their income rather than claiming it.

Beyond that, VAT, PAYE, NI Contributions, (and pensions contributions but they don't help balance the books now, just eventually) Corp tax etc etc are all percentage taxes.

This means that more in wages means more in contributions from businesses. In turn, they put up prices, increasing VAT and (possibly) Corporation Tax takes.

People with more money in their pockets spend it in shops and restaurants and service businesses, putting money into the economy to keep it buoyant. Of course, that's also more tax running through the government coffers and keeping the country liquid. They buy property - stamp duty and eventual inheritance tax. They invest - capital gains tax.

There's also the issue that, in some cases, they really have no choice. You can't hike the NMW by 9.7% this year, on top of around 7% last year, on top of, on top of etc and not eventually expect the middle bracket to kick off and demand they're paid their value of their skills.

From April, the NMW balances out for a full time worker to around £20k a year before tax. That's any adult, doing any job for 37.5 hours a week.

Want people to spend years at college and then Uni training, at their own expense, and then do stressful, demanding, absolutely essential jobs? Pay them.

Want them to take on roles where they're responsible for the safety of others, sometimes putting their own lives on the line, and certainly seeing things which shock and upset them? Pay them.

Want them to work utterly unfriendly, exhausting patterns with no work/life balance? Pay them.

Because if we don't - then people won't. We need people to want to do these jobs, and we need a lot of them, so we have to make it worthwhile. The universally understood way of making something 'worth it' is the reward at the end. For a job, that's your paycheck.

It's obviously very far from as simple as this, of course, but it's also really not as simple as 'where's it coming from?'

It isn't great for inflation, though, you're right about that.

Exactly.
If you want people to do the jobs, you have to make them attractive. Literally everyone on here says they never want to be a teacher or nurse or carer. So what happens then 🤷‍♀️

bakewellbride · 01/02/2023 18:14

Ffs there is PLENTY of money - it's just unfairly distributed!!

Bankers, politicians and many others could all be paid much, much less. Ridiculous amounts of money are spent of things unnecessarily. I wonder how much the queen's funeral cost. The money is there, it's just tied up unfairly with those at the top.

Barbie222 · 01/02/2023 18:14

JassyRadlett · 01/02/2023 16:27

If the 'where's the money coming from' question is actually serious, I'd humbly suggest rejoining the customs union as a decent economic stimulus that would increase tax revenues.

👏 👏👏

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 18:12

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 18:07

It did - but overall across thirteen years it rose in real terms. The rise would have been higher if the crash hadn’t happened but even with the crash the overall impact of 13 years of Labour was an economy that was about 33% bigger.

That meant increases in tax revenue without having to put tax rates up. It meant spending could increase without higher borrowing. That’s what we’ve lost out on under the Tories.

Do you think we’ll go back to 90s growth when Labour get in or it’ll be closer to the economic reality of today?

People look to the comparative short stints of Labour and I get the impression it’s not the global upswing they see - how many other countries had similar boom before the bust?, plus spending we’re paying for now, but some idea that Labour will do the same just because it’s Starmer.

The 70s just before Thatcher got in aren’t mentioned though.

Wibblewibble1 · 01/02/2023 18:10

“There isn’t a magic money tree!” Said ex prime minister Theresa May, before finding a magic money tree to join forces with the DUP….

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 18:07

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 17:51

Did it decrease in real terms with the crash?

It did - but overall across thirteen years it rose in real terms. The rise would have been higher if the crash hadn’t happened but even with the crash the overall impact of 13 years of Labour was an economy that was about 33% bigger.

That meant increases in tax revenue without having to put tax rates up. It meant spending could increase without higher borrowing. That’s what we’ve lost out on under the Tories.

Oysterbabe · 01/02/2023 18:02

I think the government just need to make their best and final then hold firm. The railway and Royal Mail are destroying themselves, no one would rely on them now, support for the rest will wither and die the longer it goes on and they'll settle eventually.

Tinytigertail · 01/02/2023 18:01

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:30

exactly the gvt can only pay out, what they get coming in?

That's right, but if people earn a decent living wage, they will have more money to spend, which pumps more money into the economy which in turn generates more tax and revenue for the government. They apply this logic to the superwealthy, but never seem as keen to apply it to public sector workers. Go figure...

safeplanet · 01/02/2023 17:59

Well the global elite aren't going to fix our problems.

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 17:53

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 17:48

@WinnieFosterReads The examples you gave were one-off responses to the pandemic. They are not paid annually, and won't recur in future years.

I think MN tends to underestimate the mobility of the ultra rich. They might like London for the country estates, legal and education systems, but they'd probably choose US healthcare, Milan or Strasbourg for culture, Switzerland for banking/finance. They can and do flit between these places, using private jets. Tell them their global wealth is subject to UK tax, and watch them leave.

Labour seem very out of touch with how they’ll use all this extra wealth to fund major gaps.

This group is the most mobile and other countries are keen

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 17:51

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 17:44

This is bollox sorry.

When Labour left office the economy was still about a third bigger in real terms than they found it in 1997. That is not ‘nothing left’.

By contrast the Tories have had the economy essentially flatlining over the last 13 years in real terms.

Did it decrease in real terms with the crash?

PeppermintChoc · 01/02/2023 17:50

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 17:29

But by the logic that public service jobs are easier they should be the first to be filled in an economy with a worker shortage.

Who says there aren’t more applicants for public sector jobs than private sector? It still doesn’t deal with a skill shortage.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 17:48

@WinnieFosterReads The examples you gave were one-off responses to the pandemic. They are not paid annually, and won't recur in future years.

I think MN tends to underestimate the mobility of the ultra rich. They might like London for the country estates, legal and education systems, but they'd probably choose US healthcare, Milan or Strasbourg for culture, Switzerland for banking/finance. They can and do flit between these places, using private jets. Tell them their global wealth is subject to UK tax, and watch them leave.

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 17:48

If anyone's interested, the IFS have produced a number of charts showing actual wage growth/decline in real terms for striking workers. Interesting read. Poor old University lecturers are the worst off, at 19%, but you sadly never hear about them, as it's only those in HE who suffer. Train drivers are well ahead, and surprisingly paramedics are slightly ahead too. The rest are around 10% behind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread