Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 21:44

Still waiting for your response @Thebestwaytoscareatory . How many families are depending on your decision-making to keep a roof over their heads and food on the table? The 8 families depending on our business to keep paying their wages are not at foodbanks, or claiming UC. Because contrary to your malevolent spin, we do take our responsibilities as employers very seriously. Yes, we make a profit. And all our taxes are paid. You could go through it with a forensic accountant and there's nothing to find. Your anti-commerce attitude does a lot of damage.

Whammyyammy · 01/02/2023 21:31

Increase in public sector wages comes from:

  1. Increase in taxes
And/or
  1. Decrease in other public services

Not difficult

Eleganz · 01/02/2023 21:27

Stackss · 01/02/2023 20:47

There is no bottomless pit of money. Inflation would also go through the roof of the unions got their way. The government have offered a 5% increase, with more for the lowest paid, which was affordable and reasonable.

I would personally have offered 7.5% to those who worked through the pandemic like nurses and firefighters, with a 4% offer for those who were at home like teachers and civil servants.

Labour have been very clear that they could not fund the pay rises demanded. Inflation is on the way down so I would now be saying to the unions, r “you’ve had your chance, pay freeze it is.”

And you would have a general strike.

You do realise that civil servants have been offered just 2%? That's after a pay freeze the year before and 1% or pay freezes for most of the decade before that.

Turnover in many of the public sector professions is horrendous, in the civil service it is at over 13% of the total workforce. The government spent 3 years and over £100,000 trying to recruit a chief of digital because the pay was so far below the market rate that potential candidates we literally laughing at their search consultancy and that is for a very senior role.

Teachers and nurses have been offered more but their pay has decline in real terms very badly too. My view is that they get a bit more because they have pay review bodies and are more in the public eye. Civil and public servants though, they can just go fuck themselves.

As for the pandemic, I am absolutely fucking furious with liars like you claiming that public sector workers were sat at home doing fuck all. It was private sector workers sat at home on 80% tax funded pay twiddling their thumbs.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 21:14

@Thebestwaytoscareatory I look forward to your response here, because I am calling you out for all the rubbish you post about business and enterprise greed. How many people do you have on YOUR payroll? When you answer that I might take your opinion seriously.

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 21:10

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 20:55

People don't pay corporation tax, corporations/businesses do. Sure, some of those using the above loophole may be company owners responsible for paying tax on the profit of their company, but even then they're still paying less than someone on PAYE. Equally, some who use the loophole will be the top 1%-10% whose only income is from investments (and you can be 100% sure those types will make use of every other trick in the book to avoid paying tax, while making use of all the benefits of a developed society).

Let's not pretend that there's not lots of other little loopholes available to a business owner that allows them to reduce their tax liabilities that the average Joe doesn't get access too.

Also, what does corporation tax max out at? 25%. What does income tax top out at? 45%. As with all things tory, the richer you are the more you benefit from the system.

Don't worry I agree with most of the things you put forward that the rich can get away with. There is no reason why the tax system is so complicated. What's up with one rate that is charged to everyone above the tax free allowance.

Someone mentioned above about builders doing cash in hand, I would make it tax evasion to also offer cash with the sole purpose of getting the job cheaper knowing that the tradesman is doing evasion.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 21:10

@Thebestwaytoscareatory but most of the economy is SMEs, which employ about 60% of the workforce, and most are similar to my DHs, and have NOTHING in common with Amazon or Google. We are an 8 person engineering business in SW UK. We don't deal with retail customers, at all. We work in power generation, marine and industrial heat transfer. We don't have a marketing department, there's one admin person who does bills, purchasing and payroll, and six engineers. That's the entire business. We started it, we run it, we pay well, and if business is quiet for a bit (which happens) WE stop getting paid. We take all the risk of investment.

What do you do ToryScarer? How many people are on your payroll?

Springisspringingagain · 01/02/2023 21:08

It is always argued it seems by the Tories that public sector workers should put up with low pay that doesn’t keep pace with inflation and gets devalued for the sake if the economy. Why is it that these workers have to sacrifice basic living standards to keep the economy going rather than the wealthy? Why is it that MPs always award themselves pay rises and mock those who can’t manage on way less?

I actually feel heartened that union membership is massively rising and so many us of the silent majority are getting pretty angry with the massive unjust gap between the haves and have nots in our society. Even if you are lucky enough to be comfortably off, it is miserable to be part of such an uncaring selfish society. We have the ability as one if the wealthier nations to create a society that includes fairness and a decent level of health, education and care for all.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 01/02/2023 21:05

Person B who is getting paid this way would probably own the company so would have paid corporation tax on the 40000 figure so that would take the outcome much closer

The company person A works for will also have paid corporation tax.

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 21:01

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 20:44

Person B owns a ltd company, they take a small wage and decides to take the rest in dividends.

The dividends are drawn from post tax profits so have had corporation tax off.

Overall how much tax would person B have paid on the 50000 he had in his Ltd company.

I know that since the dividend tax was put at 7.5% the perk of being paid via dividends is minimal and certainly not as the example shown

Yes, I understand how it works.

You are not being charged corporation tax, the business is. I might as well say that my salary would be higher if my employer didn’t have to pay corporation tax.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 20:55

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 20:21

Person B who is getting paid this way would probably own the company so would have paid corporation tax on the 40000 figure so that would take the outcome much closer

People don't pay corporation tax, corporations/businesses do. Sure, some of those using the above loophole may be company owners responsible for paying tax on the profit of their company, but even then they're still paying less than someone on PAYE. Equally, some who use the loophole will be the top 1%-10% whose only income is from investments (and you can be 100% sure those types will make use of every other trick in the book to avoid paying tax, while making use of all the benefits of a developed society).

Let's not pretend that there's not lots of other little loopholes available to a business owner that allows them to reduce their tax liabilities that the average Joe doesn't get access too.

Also, what does corporation tax max out at? 25%. What does income tax top out at? 45%. As with all things tory, the richer you are the more you benefit from the system.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 20:54

Being a little bit persnickety @LiquoriceAllsort2 , I want the name of your accountant if you pay 7.5% on dividends from your limited company. We pay closer to 20%, after corporation tax.

And before everyone gets het up about how much is paid out to shareholders, do please remember that the largest shareholdings of all are those owned by your and my pension fund. UK pension funds own something like 80+% of all UK public company shares --- so they are looking into the future when you expect to retire. This is not as simple as greedy hedgies zipping up the uninformed. This is very long term financial planning at population level.

OchreDandelion · 01/02/2023 20:53

allowing schools to ask for donations (monthly standing order)

They can do this, if they are careful, and many do. It massively favours schools with an affluent parent base though.

OchreDandelion · 01/02/2023 20:49

Stackss · 01/02/2023 20:47

There is no bottomless pit of money. Inflation would also go through the roof of the unions got their way. The government have offered a 5% increase, with more for the lowest paid, which was affordable and reasonable.

I would personally have offered 7.5% to those who worked through the pandemic like nurses and firefighters, with a 4% offer for those who were at home like teachers and civil servants.

Labour have been very clear that they could not fund the pay rises demanded. Inflation is on the way down so I would now be saying to the unions, r “you’ve had your chance, pay freeze it is.”

Which teachers were at home? I was in school every day of the pandemic!

Fearforfriend · 01/02/2023 20:47

As others have said -

Close tax law loopholes while allow large scale tax avoidance schemes

Actively investigate and prosecute tax evasion

Reverse the recent tax breaks for high income banks and bankers

Revisit their own expenses which are massively out of step with any other profession

Hmmmm I wonder why they won’t do any of these thing????

Stackss · 01/02/2023 20:47

There is no bottomless pit of money. Inflation would also go through the roof of the unions got their way. The government have offered a 5% increase, with more for the lowest paid, which was affordable and reasonable.

I would personally have offered 7.5% to those who worked through the pandemic like nurses and firefighters, with a 4% offer for those who were at home like teachers and civil servants.

Labour have been very clear that they could not fund the pay rises demanded. Inflation is on the way down so I would now be saying to the unions, r “you’ve had your chance, pay freeze it is.”

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 20:44

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 20:35

You don’t appear to understand the difference between corporation and income tax.

Person B is not being personally taxed on the profits of the company. The corporate entity is being taxed. Entirely different.

Person B owns a ltd company, they take a small wage and decides to take the rest in dividends.

The dividends are drawn from post tax profits so have had corporation tax off.

Overall how much tax would person B have paid on the 50000 he had in his Ltd company.

I know that since the dividend tax was put at 7.5% the perk of being paid via dividends is minimal and certainly not as the example shown

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 20:38

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 20:35

You don’t appear to understand the difference between corporation and income tax.

Person B is not being personally taxed on the profits of the company. The corporate entity is being taxed. Entirely different.

I think I understand, I own a limited company 🤣🤣

Forgooodnesssakenow · 01/02/2023 20:36

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:12

what do you mean not this again, ive never asked it before.

Where does it end and are the government really a bottomless pit of money all the time.

They seem to find the money somehow to give big tax breaks to their pals with big businesses... Maybe they should look in that pocket first

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 20:35

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 20:21

Person B who is getting paid this way would probably own the company so would have paid corporation tax on the 40000 figure so that would take the outcome much closer

You don’t appear to understand the difference between corporation and income tax.

Person B is not being personally taxed on the profits of the company. The corporate entity is being taxed. Entirely different.

Aleaiactaest · 01/02/2023 20:34

Personally I think they should pay key public sector workers much more but get rid of the overly generous and atypical pensions. So the salaries become more comparable to the private sector.

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 20:28

Pyewhacket · 01/02/2023 16:01

We have vast public investment in transportation and infrastructure : Crossrail HS2 !!!!!. And healthcare is over 40% of all public sending and growing, with a £12b injection to cover backlog on top of an increase in NHS funding.

We are way below the European average.

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 01/02/2023 20:21

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 20:13

Not a bottomless pit no, but there are plenty of ways the government could increase revenue without cutting serviceds or increasing tax for the average person, they just have no desire to do so.

For example, the government could change the way they tax dividends so that it is more aligned to other forms of tax (I can't remember the exact figure, I want to say £20-30b, but doing this would raise several billion extra a year at least. However, that would primarily impact tory voters so they'll never touch it.

But to illustrate just how fucked this situation is here's a comparison of two people earn £50,000 p/a (we're going to assume neither pay anything into a pension).

Person A is salaried and pays tax via PAYE. Their tax/take home breakdown is as follows.

Gross: £50,000
NI: £4,491.60
Income tax: £7,486.00
Take home: £38,022.40

Person B earns a salary of £9,100 and receives dividends of £40,900. Their tax / take-home breakdown is as follows.

Gross:£50,000
NI: £0
Income tax: £0
Dividend tax: £3,100.13
Take home: £46,899.87

Despite person b paying no NI they will still qualify for state pension, sickness benefits and other benefits, the burden for paying for which is pushed onto those who are PAYE.

That's just one of the ways the government have set up to fuck over the average person in favour of the elite.

Person B who is getting paid this way would probably own the company so would have paid corporation tax on the 40000 figure so that would take the outcome much closer

Grumpybutfunny · 01/02/2023 20:20

I would like to see them redraw the budget so income - essential expenses (like 1,2,3) = benefits (including pension rises) plus discretionary spending

1.education
2.health
3.security/essential services (armed forces, police, fire etc)

  1. Some council spending but instead of town council do it as one national contract.

Things like £20 to see a GP, allowing schools to ask for donations (monthly standing order) could also be used to increase income.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 20:13

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:26

never said that but where does the money come from?
Are the gvt a bottomless pit of money all the time?

Not a bottomless pit no, but there are plenty of ways the government could increase revenue without cutting serviceds or increasing tax for the average person, they just have no desire to do so.

For example, the government could change the way they tax dividends so that it is more aligned to other forms of tax (I can't remember the exact figure, I want to say £20-30b, but doing this would raise several billion extra a year at least. However, that would primarily impact tory voters so they'll never touch it.

But to illustrate just how fucked this situation is here's a comparison of two people earn £50,000 p/a (we're going to assume neither pay anything into a pension).

Person A is salaried and pays tax via PAYE. Their tax/take home breakdown is as follows.

Gross: £50,000
NI: £4,491.60
Income tax: £7,486.00
Take home: £38,022.40

Person B earns a salary of £9,100 and receives dividends of £40,900. Their tax / take-home breakdown is as follows.

Gross:£50,000
NI: £0
Income tax: £0
Dividend tax: £3,100.13
Take home: £46,899.87

Despite person b paying no NI they will still qualify for state pension, sickness benefits and other benefits, the burden for paying for which is pushed onto those who are PAYE.

That's just one of the ways the government have set up to fuck over the average person in favour of the elite.

Cracklingfire1 · 01/02/2023 20:11

@SleeplessInEngland this is why this is a great thread, so people can explain it simply to us dullards. I find mumsnet to be a great educator. Why would you be against someone trying to understand? It's commendable.