Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
malificent7 · 02/02/2023 06:57

The government don't give a shit about these type of caring jobs ( I'm an ex teacher..now nhs ahp) as they do not generate cash. We voted for a staunch capitalist government who see poverty as a moral failing. They have no time for sick people or poor kids in a state school. They only have time for the rich.
They see people working for the public sector as 2nd class citizens and not deserving of a decent wage. No coincidence, like others have said, that these are jobs mostly done by women.

Alexandra2001 · 02/02/2023 06:54

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:26

Also, what does corporation tax max out at? 25%. What does income tax top out at? 45%. As with all things tory, the richer you are the more you benefit from the system

Yep they should definitely increase the CT rate and then we can all watch the economy for completely!

We had low CT rates from 2016, it did nothing to increase inward investment... or home grown productivity or RnD.
Germany has a business tax rate of just under 30%, yet seems to have a strong economy.

We don't tax investment income as we do earned income, in deed it can be reduced to 0% by using ISA's.... Capital gains has many loopholes to reduce liability.. then there is council tax reform, someone like Sunak will pay around double for his main residence and swimming pool over an average priced house, despite being worth many times more....

We could change the universal energy support scheme, why are multi nationals and millionaires getting support?????

But what the OP and others are ignoring is that without significant increases in pay, we will continue to have sub standard health and education.. neither will help boost the economy, provide the skilled workforce we need or increase inward investment.

What people who are say we cannot afford it (inc Government) need to come up with is an alternative to keep staff?

Nellodee · 02/02/2023 06:51

Tax wealth, not just income.

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 06:46
  • • increase in taxes.

Should those earning a million pounds a year pay the same proportion of tax as someone earning £20,000?*

Of course not but they don't. Assuming you aren't referring to tax avoidance the someone earning £20k has an effective tax rate of 12.5% whereas someone with a million pounds of income has an effective rate of 46%.
Of course that only refers to income tax and both parties will pay VAT on certain thing they purchase but I find it hard to believe that would make the rates much closer!

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 06:43

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 06:41

@JassyRadlett we are just going round in circles and I'm pretty sure you know what I mean but for clarity - if the government give teachers are payrise this will increase school funding but it will then be paid on to teachers so the school does not have any extra money to pay for any other resources.

@jgw1 that's a fair point but ultimately how do you know anyone's motivation. No-one is going to say I'm just striking cos I want more money! It suits the narrative and to make it all about the evil Tory's versus saintly teachers and nurses. If they haven't had proper payrises for years then of course they should try and get them however they can but I personally draw the line at thanking the teachers in my kid's school for going on strike and the kids missing school when they have already missed months and months of school in their short educational life.

I know the motivation of the teachers doctors and nurses I have discussed it with and have no reason to think they are not representative, all be it they are a small sample.

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 06:41

@JassyRadlett we are just going round in circles and I'm pretty sure you know what I mean but for clarity - if the government give teachers are payrise this will increase school funding but it will then be paid on to teachers so the school does not have any extra money to pay for any other resources.

@jgw1 that's a fair point but ultimately how do you know anyone's motivation. No-one is going to say I'm just striking cos I want more money! It suits the narrative and to make it all about the evil Tory's versus saintly teachers and nurses. If they haven't had proper payrises for years then of course they should try and get them however they can but I personally draw the line at thanking the teachers in my kid's school for going on strike and the kids missing school when they have already missed months and months of school in their short educational life.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 06:37

Whammyyammy · 01/02/2023 21:31

Increase in public sector wages comes from:

  1. Increase in taxes
And/or
  1. Decrease in other public services

Not difficult

Other options are available.

But lets examine

  1. increase in taxes.

Should those earning a million pounds a year pay the same proportion of tax as someone earning £20,000?

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 06:32

And I obviously can't stop you misquoting me but it's disingenuous, weakens your own arguements and by doing so it exposes you as a manipulative person.

Jesus Christ get a grip, it's a forum on mumsnet not a trail at The Hague! I am not misquoting anything - it is exactly what you said. Maybe you should look-up the definition of misquoting.
Maybe if your own trite close all the loopholes arguments had any substance you wouldn't have to make character assassinations of other posters.

Elvira2000 · 02/02/2023 06:23

I just listened to this podcast. He explains really well (from 38/39 mins) that if you increase the salary of a low-earning worker most will work it's way back in tax eventually to the government.

pca.st/episode/f9f756e8-d48c-404b-9b50-37f089d7700f

NI and tax from the worker, then they spend (every penny), on which is VAT. The person who receives that money will then pay income tax and business taxs and pay for their own goods, services and bills, and so on.

Thinking about it though. I see one drawback with this theory: that a large proportion of a worker's wages is now going to utilities (heating) which has a very low revenue for the government. What with subsidies and all being privately owned.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 05:19

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:23

But that's not what I said is it.
I said it is only about payrises for the teachers and not other funding for schools!
Clearly any agreed pay rise will increase funding to a school but only to be paid directly to teachers so will have no impact on other funding for schools.
I'm sick of reading on here and elsewhere about all these saintly teachers who are really just striking to benefit our kids and how we should we grateful (even though they will likely miss several days of school because of the strikes).
They are striking to increase their pay, nothing else. As I already said good luck to them but I don't want to hear how they are doing us all a favour.

That is because the law does not permit strikes for other reasons. The motivation behind many teachers, doctors and nurses going on strike is not pay, but that is the only lawful reason they can strike.

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 02/02/2023 05:09

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 23:42

I wasn't comparing the two though, I didnt even mention CT in my first post, another poster brought that into it because, apparently, we now have to include the tax our employers pay in CT when discussing IT loopholes, or is that only allowed if you're a business owner (which I also didn't mention in that first post btw)?

The fact is there are loopholes that are exploited by certain sections of society that means they can avoid paying tax in a way not open to the average person. Apparently that's a very touchy subject for some on here.

And I obviously can't stop you misquoting me but it's disingenuous, weakens your own arguements and by doing so it exposes you as a manipulative person.

I brought up the corporation tax as you quoted some figures that I feel were disingenuous about the taxes paid.

Ltd companies are available to all sections of society. You could set one up in half an hour.

It's like the evil gas and electric shareholders debate that is used to suggest some people are raking it in from the poor, but what is always missed out that most workers with a company pension are one of the evil shareholders.

Most of the people vilified for evading taxes are just normal business owners going about their daily business.

JassyRadlett · 01/02/2023 23:55

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:23

But that's not what I said is it.
I said it is only about payrises for the teachers and not other funding for schools!
Clearly any agreed pay rise will increase funding to a school but only to be paid directly to teachers so will have no impact on other funding for schools.
I'm sick of reading on here and elsewhere about all these saintly teachers who are really just striking to benefit our kids and how we should we grateful (even though they will likely miss several days of school because of the strikes).
They are striking to increase their pay, nothing else. As I already said good luck to them but I don't want to hear how they are doing us all a favour.

But that's exactly what they're striking over.

You say that 'clearly' any pay rise will increase funding to a school. Which is, unfortunately, not the case.

The current pay settlement from the government isn't fully funded. So the increase to teachers has to come out of existing budgets.

So by calling for a fully funded increase, teachers are very much looking at overall school budgets, not just their own pay. Because the current offer would see teacher pay increase at the cost of the rest of the school budget.

So if they achieve a fully funded pay rise, they would restore to school budgets a de facto school funding cut that is implicit in the current pay offer.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 23:42

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:57

@Thebestwaytoscareatory I'll quote what I like thanks.
CT is not comparable to IT because the business owner does not just have access to the profits unless they take it out in the form of a salary or dividends, both of which are taxable. So comparing the rate of CT with IT as if to say business owners pay tax at a lower rate is nonsensical.

I wasn't comparing the two though, I didnt even mention CT in my first post, another poster brought that into it because, apparently, we now have to include the tax our employers pay in CT when discussing IT loopholes, or is that only allowed if you're a business owner (which I also didn't mention in that first post btw)?

The fact is there are loopholes that are exploited by certain sections of society that means they can avoid paying tax in a way not open to the average person. Apparently that's a very touchy subject for some on here.

And I obviously can't stop you misquoting me but it's disingenuous, weakens your own arguements and by doing so it exposes you as a manipulative person.

007DoubleOSeven · 01/02/2023 23:00

@girlfriend44

Not read full thread but You might find this interesting

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:57

@Thebestwaytoscareatory I'll quote what I like thanks.
CT is not comparable to IT because the business owner does not just have access to the profits unless they take it out in the form of a salary or dividends, both of which are taxable. So comparing the rate of CT with IT as if to say business owners pay tax at a lower rate is nonsensical.

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:53

popopop · 01/02/2023 22:38

@PartyHelp did I say that?

I was intrigued by your notion that schools are well resourced. Absolutely not the case.

Also, if you read up on how the previous pay rise has been funded, you will soon learn that it comes directly from the school budget, therefore impacting drastically on other areas within the school. The gov have not funded these pay rises hence the ' fully funded' demand.

But my point is still the same - they are only looking for funded payrises not funding for anything else.

In terms of the education provided and what people have to pay directly for (not through tax) the UK has a far better system to ireland for example where the vast majority of schools expect a monthly donation so much do there is a voluntary and non-voluntary portion and that has been the case for many years. All books are paid for by parents.
So again I think parents in this country don't know how lucky they are.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 22:50

Oh and @EffortlessDesmond as I now know I've to keep you posted of my whereabouts, I'm going away to do something else for a bit and might not be back on tonight.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 22:49

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:26

Also, what does corporation tax max out at? 25%. What does income tax top out at? 45%. As with all things tory, the richer you are the more you benefit from the system

Yep they should definitely increase the CT rate and then we can all watch the economy for completely!

Please don't part quote me in an attempt to put words in my mouth.

That bit you've quoted was from a longer post and was in response to someone who said that because business pay corporation tax, business owners pay much the same as someone on PAYE. At no point did I suggest raising corporation tax.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/02/2023 22:42

Sorry @EffortlessDesmond I do do other things with my time than sit on here waiting for randoms to reply.

I'm not actually sure what your point is to be honest? That because you employ a few people you're entitled to something extra?

You're actually a very good example of why we find ourselves in this situation. You're a small fish (not meaning that in a derogatory way), but you'll fight tooth and nail to protect the big fish because you mistakenly think that I, as a monstrous socialist, want to take more from you to give to the "feckless".

I don't by the way, I want the gap to between top and bottom to close, I want the 1% that own 25% of all wealth to, well not own 25% of all wealth. There can still be rich and poor, just in my ideal world the rich won't be obscenely rich and the poor will be able to afford a nice life with warm homes, full bellys and comfortable retirements regardless of career choice.
The fact you get so defensive about things suggests to me you see alot of yourself in what I post about and don't like being confronted by it.

And to answer your question I'm employed in a sustainability consultancy role now, so no-one directly depends on me. However, we've saved our clients millions in O&M expenses and work with them to implement measures, policies, strategies, etc, that aim to improve their employee's satisfaction, retention, development, health and wellbeing as part of our core services. Prior to that I ran our family business (nessessity rather than desire), which employed 5 others. That's now being run by one of those 5 and they're all still chugging along nicely AFAIK.

popopop · 01/02/2023 22:38

@PartyHelp did I say that?

I was intrigued by your notion that schools are well resourced. Absolutely not the case.

Also, if you read up on how the previous pay rise has been funded, you will soon learn that it comes directly from the school budget, therefore impacting drastically on other areas within the school. The gov have not funded these pay rises hence the ' fully funded' demand.

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:26

Also, what does corporation tax max out at? 25%. What does income tax top out at? 45%. As with all things tory, the richer you are the more you benefit from the system

Yep they should definitely increase the CT rate and then we can all watch the economy for completely!

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:23

JassyRadlett · 01/02/2023 19:20

Nothing about school funding etc.

I'm not in the education system but even I know that the 'fully funded' bit of a fully funded pay rise is all about school funding.

A pay rise that's not fully funded means schools have to fund it from existing budgets. Which means cuts to other things.

On top of existing cuts and pay erosion for 2010, where do you think the money will come from for pay rises if it's not cutting non-teaching staff and other things that schools need to pay for?

But that's not what I said is it.
I said it is only about payrises for the teachers and not other funding for schools!
Clearly any agreed pay rise will increase funding to a school but only to be paid directly to teachers so will have no impact on other funding for schools.
I'm sick of reading on here and elsewhere about all these saintly teachers who are really just striking to benefit our kids and how we should we grateful (even though they will likely miss several days of school because of the strikes).
They are striking to increase their pay, nothing else. As I already said good luck to them but I don't want to hear how they are doing us all a favour.

PartyHelp · 01/02/2023 22:16

popopop · 01/02/2023 19:16

@PartyHelp have you ever worked in a school?

Why are you only allowed comment if you work in a school?
No I haven't worked in a school but I know how a school works.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 22:07

Sorry 20 minutes...

EffortlessDesmond · 01/02/2023 22:06

40 minutes and no reply from @Thebestwaytoscareatory .