Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 02/02/2023 09:32

PrincessConstance · 02/02/2023 08:48

The main issue is if the people working in the NHS for instance are given a pay rise, that won't make the service miraculously great again. It means we'll be paying more for a service that isn't fit for purpose.

I asked my DD when does your ward/dept ever run properly? she replied "Only when we have a full team in..." she added which rarely happens.

If staff are leaving, then whatever reforms you or anyone else does... will not work... NHS like education is a people business.

NHS needs investment in staff, equipment and buildings plus reform too but the none of these can be done in isolation.

Crumpetdisappointment · 02/02/2023 09:28

no but a better pay for workers will encourage more applicants

Neededanewuserhandle · 02/02/2023 09:21

PrincessConstance · 02/02/2023 08:48

The main issue is if the people working in the NHS for instance are given a pay rise, that won't make the service miraculously great again. It means we'll be paying more for a service that isn't fit for purpose.

You're right, it's just one part of improvements needed to the NHS. It is needed though.

KnittedCardi · 02/02/2023 09:19

JassyRadlett · 02/02/2023 08:52

The tax burden is still mostly taken by top centiles but figures on what changes people want to tax rates would be simpler

That's quite an indictment of the huge income inequality in this country though.

Our income tax system is a bit of a mess - Very broad bands with very steep increases at each. More tax bands with more graduation through the system would be a better option.

Plus sorting out dividend tax, as someone else said.

The interesting thing is that the high wealth inequality only exists between the very top and bottom 5%'s. The 90% of people floating around "the middle" are all pretty equal.

User98866 · 02/02/2023 09:13

They need to tax wealth hoarders to get money circulating again. It’s not as hard to do as they tell us.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 09:10

Many less unequal countries have a land or property tax. That might be a good place to start.

Crumpetdisappointment · 02/02/2023 08:53

the teachers shown on the news are saying they need to have second jobs, due to money

JassyRadlett · 02/02/2023 08:52

The tax burden is still mostly taken by top centiles but figures on what changes people want to tax rates would be simpler

That's quite an indictment of the huge income inequality in this country though.

Our income tax system is a bit of a mess - Very broad bands with very steep increases at each. More tax bands with more graduation through the system would be a better option.

Plus sorting out dividend tax, as someone else said.

PrincessConstance · 02/02/2023 08:48

The main issue is if the people working in the NHS for instance are given a pay rise, that won't make the service miraculously great again. It means we'll be paying more for a service that isn't fit for purpose.

StripyHorse · 02/02/2023 07:57

Persuadable · 01/02/2023 15:50

Focussing on just the money is misisng the point.

Teachers are not striking for more money, they are asking for better working conditions, respect (as in for their profession to be treated with respect) and for pay comensurate with their expertise/at a deserved rate.

If you sat down with any working teacher and said, hey, we have no more money, but what can be done is to make sure you have adequate resources (to support evey child in their learing and make sure all children have what they need (food, paper, pens, IT - so you dont have to supply this stuff yourself), make sure you never work over your core hours, make sure we cut the administrative burden and streamline pointless testing systems, as well as speaking about and celebrating your prefession more then many of them would be somewhat happy.

The pay increase they are asking for is in many cases driven by the oppostie of these things - regular overtime, no support, massive admin burden and having to constantly put their hand in their own posckt to support children they work with.

Lots of poeple get paid what teachers do - and consider it an ok salary - but this is because it is representative of their working conditions and their professionsal status - this is not the case for teachers right now. Thats why teachers are (rightly) mad and striking.

All of this. Plus....

...the other point of the teachers' strike which is for a FULLY FUNDED pay rise.

It's all very well and good for the government to agree a 5% pay increase, but if school budgets don't also increase, combined with costs being higher (heating, resources etc) it means cuts elsewhere. Either essentials aren't available, or maintenance is delayed, or the heating is turned down, or staff numbers are cut. All this leads to a lower standard of education for children.

Alexandra2001 · 02/02/2023 07:54

@FlippyFloppyShoe That guy started in the police force over 20 years ago, those pensions aren't available to new starters in the police/public services now plus employees pay in around double what someone in private sector would.

So far no one is coming forward on how to stop staff leaving and keep them motivated....... if they won't give them an inflation matching pay rise.

MarshaBradyo · 02/02/2023 07:52

SocksAndTheCity · 02/02/2023 07:46

It's a few years old but the Equality Trust study summarised here www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/lowest-earners-more-tax-richest-office-national-statistics-inequality-council-tax-vat-equality-trust-a7704331.html showed that the poorest households do indeed spend a far higher proportion of their income on tax, mainly VAT and council tax.

Given the current state of affairs some six years later I would be amazed if the figure hasn't got worse.

What are you suggesting as an alternative?

How high would the top tax rate be and how much lower VAT and council tax - if the latter changes

The tax burden is still mostly taken by top centiles but figures on what changes people want to tax rates would be simpler

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 07:51

SocksAndTheCity · 02/02/2023 07:46

It's a few years old but the Equality Trust study summarised here www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/lowest-earners-more-tax-richest-office-national-statistics-inequality-council-tax-vat-equality-trust-a7704331.html showed that the poorest households do indeed spend a far higher proportion of their income on tax, mainly VAT and council tax.

Given the current state of affairs some six years later I would be amazed if the figure hasn't got worse.

It is a little hard to do that analysis for the covid years as many people at different incomes levels recieved significant government protection.

But certainly the government have done nothing to deliberately address this.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 07:49

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 07:35

@jgw1 - well if it's true surely you can provide some evidence other than you saying it is true. It's not really about what either of us think. I have given you the income tax numbers where is is clear a significantly higher percentage is paid by higher earners so maybe you could provide some back-up for your assertions.

Its not hard to find the ONS data that shows that the poorest 5th of our population paid 23% of their income in indirect taxes whilst the richest 5th paid 9%, and once one gets to an income level of a million pounds the difference is more extreme.

FlippyFloppyShoe · 02/02/2023 07:49

I'm happy for pay rises in public sector as long as defined benefit pension burden is removed.
I read one of the serving policemen that got done for rape was going to get a pension of 20k a year after coming out of prison...whilst I don't think his pension should be removed, I do think people need to appreciate that for someone that has no higher education (so no barriers to anyone) and to go into public service and get a guaranteed index linked pension is a massive benefit that is probably only available to those in public services these days and if you want the financial reward now in terms of wages, then it should be separate to getting an increased guaranteed reward at retirement.
Do I think people in public service work harder than people in private sector? No and i think it is an insulting to claim that.

JassyRadlett · 02/02/2023 07:47

@PartyHelp You are still missing the point that the current offer isn't fully funded. So it represents a cut to non-teacher-salary school budgets.

Saying that 'if the government give teachers are payrise this will increase school funding but it will then be paid on to teachers so the school does not have any extra money to pay for any other resources' is flat out wrong - it would reverse the current situation.

If the sole outcome of the strikes was to get the current offer fully funded, it would reverse that cut and put money directly back into non-teacher-salary pay. Saying

You are treating all this like there's no offer currently on the table - ie that the Union demands exist in a vacuum. They don't. The current government pay settlement offer represents a funding cut to schools, because they have to cut spending elsewhere to pay for it.

SocksAndTheCity · 02/02/2023 07:46

It's a few years old but the Equality Trust study summarised here www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/lowest-earners-more-tax-richest-office-national-statistics-inequality-council-tax-vat-equality-trust-a7704331.html showed that the poorest households do indeed spend a far higher proportion of their income on tax, mainly VAT and council tax.

Given the current state of affairs some six years later I would be amazed if the figure hasn't got worse.

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 07:35

@jgw1 - well if it's true surely you can provide some evidence other than you saying it is true. It's not really about what either of us think. I have given you the income tax numbers where is is clear a significantly higher percentage is paid by higher earners so maybe you could provide some back-up for your assertions.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 07:26

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 07:23

@jgw1 I would be interested in any proof you have that someone paying tax on £20k pays the same proportion of their income tax as someone who pays tax on £1m. I don't believe that to be correct.

Whether you believe it or not, doesn't change that it is the current state of affairs.

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 07:23

@jgw1 I would be interested in any proof you have that someone paying tax on £20k pays the same proportion of their income tax as someone who pays tax on £1m. I don't believe that to be correct.

Aishah231 · 02/02/2023 07:21

Tax unearned income - shares from dividends etc at the same rate as earned income and our spending problems would be solved. Plus as others have pointed out low paid or middle income workers spend almost everything they earn and are taxed on their income plus their spending. The government gets back on average 1.6 pounds for every pound it spends in this way.

Teachers were also striking about funding as the current pay offer is not funded and therefore comes directly out of school budgets. They are striking for 10% which is slightly below inflation and therefore is not only a pay cut but also can't be inflationary.

Public sector spending is also not inflationary in the way private wage rates are as they don't affect prices.

Basically the government wants a fight with the unions and is deliberately offering pay awards it knows can't be accepted. There's no good economic reason for any of this - despite media spin to the contrary

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 07:16

Alexandra2001 · 02/02/2023 07:04

This is very true... a independent report into social care and support for children following the brutal murders of 2 children, recommended £1.2bn in extra funding, the Govt is going to fund £200m, same with education, £11bn recommended, Govt came up with £2bn.

But when it comes to installing key meters in the poorest households, they don't stop that... been going on for years but until a journalist, nothing was done, Schapps horrified? yes he was, Horrified private industry wont be able to punish the poor... though after a suitable delay, it will continue....

As far as I understood the Education Secretary on the radio yesterday the extra 2 billion that was promised for education in the autumn exists (not yet in schools) so that the Prime Minister can say that spending on schools has increased since 2010 and for no other reason.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 07:14

malificent7 · 02/02/2023 06:57

The government don't give a shit about these type of caring jobs ( I'm an ex teacher..now nhs ahp) as they do not generate cash. We voted for a staunch capitalist government who see poverty as a moral failing. They have no time for sick people or poor kids in a state school. They only have time for the rich.
They see people working for the public sector as 2nd class citizens and not deserving of a decent wage. No coincidence, like others have said, that these are jobs mostly done by women.

Are they capitalists?
I thought and I may be wrong that capitalists were of the view that markets should be allowed to determine the value of everything. So if there is a shortage the price should be allowed to increase.
There is a shortage of doctors, teachers and nurses surely in that situation a capitalist would see straightaway that the solution was to increase their wages until there was no longer a shortage?

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 07:09

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 06:46

  • • increase in taxes.

Should those earning a million pounds a year pay the same proportion of tax as someone earning £20,000?*

Of course not but they don't. Assuming you aren't referring to tax avoidance the someone earning £20k has an effective tax rate of 12.5% whereas someone with a million pounds of income has an effective rate of 46%.
Of course that only refers to income tax and both parties will pay VAT on certain thing they purchase but I find it hard to believe that would make the rates much closer!

It would be nice if it were true that higher earners pay a higher proprotion of their income as tax than lower earners but it is not the case.
Lower earners pay a higher proportion of their income in all forms of taxes than higher earners do.
Would you agree that is an absurd situation and ought to be addressed?

Alexandra2001 · 02/02/2023 07:04

malificent7 · 02/02/2023 06:57

The government don't give a shit about these type of caring jobs ( I'm an ex teacher..now nhs ahp) as they do not generate cash. We voted for a staunch capitalist government who see poverty as a moral failing. They have no time for sick people or poor kids in a state school. They only have time for the rich.
They see people working for the public sector as 2nd class citizens and not deserving of a decent wage. No coincidence, like others have said, that these are jobs mostly done by women.

This is very true... a independent report into social care and support for children following the brutal murders of 2 children, recommended £1.2bn in extra funding, the Govt is going to fund £200m, same with education, £11bn recommended, Govt came up with £2bn.

But when it comes to installing key meters in the poorest households, they don't stop that... been going on for years but until a journalist, nothing was done, Schapps horrified? yes he was, Horrified private industry wont be able to punish the poor... though after a suitable delay, it will continue....

Swipe left for the next trending thread