Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
JemimaTiggywinkles · 01/02/2023 16:06

Teacher's pay (like most of the public sector) has not increased in line with inflation, nor with average private sector pay, for over a decade. This is coming to a head now because everyone has a breaking point. As a PP said, this has been caused by mismanagement of the economy under successive Tory governments, and the only way to change things is to properly grow the whole economy.

I think the government should agree to actually fund the pay rises they have already offered teachers for this year, and agree a medium-term (3-5 year) strategy to bring education funding (including teacher salaries) back up to where they would have been if they had kept pace with private sector wages.

Tessasanderson · 01/02/2023 16:05

I understand everyones comments about the government finding the money etc etc etc.

The thing i cant understand is what we are trying to achieve here. Stick with me as i am not the best at explaining things.

So we have big inflation at the moment because everything is expensive, all the materials are expensive and cost of living is just impossible. For decades people have borrowed money they cant really afford because borrowing was cheap. It hasnt taken much of a increase for it to hit a lot of people hard. Yes :-)

The govenrment is trying to reduce the inflation by reducing peoples ability to spend. Ie raise interest rates. Make mortgages more expensive so they cant buy houses. In general just making things harder. Yes :-)

So if we give nurses/teachers/blue light workers/everyone else that is due a wage rise an inflation busting wage rise.........WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?

From where i sit the teachers and the rest who get this big (Justified) pay rise end up in status quo. No worse off but essentially just treading water or possibly slightly better off. The economy gets a bigger boost because some rather large parts of society get a bit of security and start to move the economy on again, possibly back into increased inflation...........BUT what about the other HUGE chunk of the population who are left behind. The ones who didnt get that pay rise and have to deal with ever increasing inflation. The vast majority of our society who arent lucky enough to work for big institutions and havent got unions/rest of the public fighting their corner.

I can only forsee huge pain for those that havent got much to begin with. There is going to be even bigger gaps between the haves and the have nots.

Am i missing something?

Indigoshift · 01/02/2023 16:02

There are probably loads of situations where money could be redirected that we don't know of; aren't privy too.

One example is the Tax break on private schools. I am sure some people don't agree with it. I do.

There are probably many other ways it could be found. That you may or may nit agree with?
The bar in the house of commons?

amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/12/keir-starmer-private-school-tax-breaks-charitable-labour-education

Eleganz · 01/02/2023 16:01

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 15:54

It’s not and servicing debt costs tax payers a lot too.

A fair chunk is for energy support atm, another hit after pandemic

I don’t think there will be inflation matching rises even with strikes

They will have to improve offers in some way though. Some of the public sector have had pay freezes and 1% rises for most of the last 12 years. If the nurses and teachers get a better deal they will need to offer something to the civil service to get them back off strike.

Pyewhacket · 01/02/2023 16:01

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 15:57

The only way you could do that would be from an increase in productivity in the private sector, and we have low productivity.

And we have low productivity because we have low public investment in aresa such as education, health and transport. The answer is not cuts, it's investment.

We have vast public investment in transportation and infrastructure : Crossrail HS2 !!!!!. And healthcare is over 40% of all public sending and growing, with a £12b injection to cover backlog on top of an increase in NHS funding.

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 16:01

Pyewhacket · 01/02/2023 15:53

Yep, that's the reality of it.

All government borrowing ( the national debt is currently greater now than it was at the end of the war ) has to be paid back, with interest, out of taxation. So you either pay for further public sector funding out of taxation now or you pay to service the debt out of taxation - to simply print more money just stokes inflation. The comment that we can fund the increase in spending from the increase in taxation revenue is total nonsense ( borrowing is greater than the increase in tax revenue !!! ). The only way you could do that would be from an increase in productivity in the private sector, and we have low productivity.

So, the only way to pay for all this public sector pay demand is to increase taxation or take it from somewhere else, or both - either way, we, as a country, cannot afford it. Going on strike will not alter that.

It's not correct that the only way to fund additional spending is through increased taxes, or reduced spending, or increased borrowing. At least not in the longer term which is the right way to view public finances.

The best way to fund increased spending on, e.g. pay (or anything else) is for the economy to grow faster than borrowing, so that debt as a proportion of GDP is falling even if it is growing in raw numbers.

If the Tories had grown the economy like the last Labour Government did, there would be far more fiscal headroom to fund pay increases. And actually, a Labour Government probably wouldn't have let pay become so bad in the first place, so workers would be more willing to ride out a couple of tough years to get over an inflation spike. But after thirteen years or needless austerity, public sector workers just can't take another real terms pay cut.

Eleganz · 01/02/2023 15:59

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 15:50

But if the PP's answer is "just switch jobs" the private NHS will still have to offer higher pay to get people to "switch" to work in it.

Private healthcare is a whole different ball game. They can pay big bucks because there will be big bills and lots of nice state contracts too.

You have to understand that these people don't believe in public services free at the point of use. The just want rich people to get richer and if that means the rest of us live in penuary so be it.

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 15:57

The only way you could do that would be from an increase in productivity in the private sector, and we have low productivity.

And we have low productivity because we have low public investment in aresa such as education, health and transport. The answer is not cuts, it's investment.

MrWhippersnapper · 01/02/2023 15:56

DarkDarkNight · 01/02/2023 15:53

They could ask Michelle Mone and the rest of them to pay back the money they took through dodgy PPE contracts. The amount of money Tory cronies have stripped from this country is disgusting.

Led by Donkeys have just stuck a sign on her yacht ‘Pandemic Profiteer’

RudsyFarmer · 01/02/2023 15:55

Quarantine easing. Just print more money. It’s fine.

MasterBeth · 01/02/2023 15:55

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:26

never said that but where does the money come from?
Are the gvt a bottomless pit of money all the time?

To some extent, yes, they are.

Government finances don't work like those of households. Governments can print money, move money, and borrow money over ridiculously long time frames.

It's not the way to finance revenue spending like public service wages, but it is a way to finance public investment on infrastructure and capital projects that will power our economy to drive more tax revenue to pay for revenue spending like public service wages.

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 15:54

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:12

what do you mean not this again, ive never asked it before.

Where does it end and are the government really a bottomless pit of money all the time.

It’s not and servicing debt costs tax payers a lot too.

A fair chunk is for energy support atm, another hit after pandemic

I don’t think there will be inflation matching rises even with strikes

Evvyjb · 01/02/2023 15:53

Persuadable · 01/02/2023 15:50

Focussing on just the money is misisng the point.

Teachers are not striking for more money, they are asking for better working conditions, respect (as in for their profession to be treated with respect) and for pay comensurate with their expertise/at a deserved rate.

If you sat down with any working teacher and said, hey, we have no more money, but what can be done is to make sure you have adequate resources (to support evey child in their learing and make sure all children have what they need (food, paper, pens, IT - so you dont have to supply this stuff yourself), make sure you never work over your core hours, make sure we cut the administrative burden and streamline pointless testing systems, as well as speaking about and celebrating your prefession more then many of them would be somewhat happy.

The pay increase they are asking for is in many cases driven by the oppostie of these things - regular overtime, no support, massive admin burden and having to constantly put their hand in their own posckt to support children they work with.

Lots of poeple get paid what teachers do - and consider it an ok salary - but this is because it is representative of their working conditions and their professionsal status - this is not the case for teachers right now. Thats why teachers are (rightly) mad and striking.

@Persuadable excellent and thoughtful words. For me, absolutely true.

Pyewhacket · 01/02/2023 15:53

Oysterbabe · 01/02/2023 15:19

Tax and cuts to services.

Yep, that's the reality of it.

All government borrowing ( the national debt is currently greater now than it was at the end of the war ) has to be paid back, with interest, out of taxation. So you either pay for further public sector funding out of taxation now or you pay to service the debt out of taxation - to simply print more money just stokes inflation. The comment that we can fund the increase in spending from the increase in taxation revenue is total nonsense ( borrowing is greater than the increase in tax revenue !!! ). The only way you could do that would be from an increase in productivity in the private sector, and we have low productivity.

So, the only way to pay for all this public sector pay demand is to increase taxation or take it from somewhere else, or both - either way, we, as a country, cannot afford it. Going on strike will not alter that.

TeaKlaxon · 01/02/2023 15:53

The big problem here is the Tories 13 years of economic stewardship has been a total disaster. Many of us were shielded enough not to feel it acutely, but those with the least have been feeling it for a decade or more.

At its core, the Tories have not done enough to spur sound economic growth.

Under the last Labour Government, from 1997 to 2010, the economy grew by 60% (and that's after you account for the financial crash in 2008-09). About 4.6% a year. Under the Tories from 2010 to 2021, it grew by just 25% or 2.3% a year.

But it gets much worse. In real terms - i.e. after accounting for inflation - the economy grew by 33% under Labour (2.5% a year) but under the Tories, the real growth has been 0.7% in 11 years - that's 0.06% a year.

Why is that relevant to what sort of wages can be afforded? Well, if the economy had grown under the Tories at the same rate as under Labour, UK GDP in 2023 would be worth about $1 trillion more than it actually is.

What does that mean? It means (with the right policies at least) more money for higher wages in the private sector, more tax revenue, less dependence on benefits, particularly in work benefits like tax credits.

There is a difficult fiscal position now - but it is entirely of the Tories making because the economy has essentially flatlined for the last thirteen years.

DarkDarkNight · 01/02/2023 15:53

They could ask Michelle Mone and the rest of them to pay back the money they took through dodgy PPE contracts. The amount of money Tory cronies have stripped from this country is disgusting.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 15:52

Chowtime · 01/02/2023 15:27

Well the money for the nurses payrise could come out of the money they are currently paying agency nurses (about double) - once that money is redirected to the regular nurses they'll attract more stafff and not need agency. Further, earning more will mean they need less tax credits so the government will save money there and finally if they earn more they will pay more tax, more NI and spend more in the shops and pay more VAT.

First sensible answer

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 15:50

Eleganz · 01/02/2023 15:47

The private sector, this is the plan.

But if the PP's answer is "just switch jobs" the private NHS will still have to offer higher pay to get people to "switch" to work in it.

Persuadable · 01/02/2023 15:50

Focussing on just the money is misisng the point.

Teachers are not striking for more money, they are asking for better working conditions, respect (as in for their profession to be treated with respect) and for pay comensurate with their expertise/at a deserved rate.

If you sat down with any working teacher and said, hey, we have no more money, but what can be done is to make sure you have adequate resources (to support evey child in their learing and make sure all children have what they need (food, paper, pens, IT - so you dont have to supply this stuff yourself), make sure you never work over your core hours, make sure we cut the administrative burden and streamline pointless testing systems, as well as speaking about and celebrating your prefession more then many of them would be somewhat happy.

The pay increase they are asking for is in many cases driven by the oppostie of these things - regular overtime, no support, massive admin burden and having to constantly put their hand in their own posckt to support children they work with.

Lots of poeple get paid what teachers do - and consider it an ok salary - but this is because it is representative of their working conditions and their professionsal status - this is not the case for teachers right now. Thats why teachers are (rightly) mad and striking.

Eleganz · 01/02/2023 15:47

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 15:43

Who will run the NHS and Education when everyone has switched out of those jobs?

The private sector, this is the plan.

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 15:47

roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 15:39

The "they've wasted it on other things so they should spend billions on double digit % public sector wage increases" argument isn't great.

That's a fair point, but that argument is just an illustration that money can always be found for things the government regards as worthwhile.
Their refusal to remunerate public sector employees properly or fund public services adequately is because of their dislike of any enterprise not motivated by greed.

Namechangeforthis6 · 01/02/2023 15:45

We could cut down on mp's expenses for a start

PrincessConstance · 01/02/2023 15:45

www.officialdata.org/uk/inflation/2000?amount=25000

Here's an interesting link.
Wages have NOT kept up with inflation.
Pay scales across all sectors are lagging.

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 15:43

SummerWinds · 01/02/2023 15:42

Strikes won't work, the government don't care, plus if they give in everybody else will be striking. supermarket workers and carers, earn a pittance in comparison, yet still an important job. Government will not back down, it's all a huge waste of time. People are better off switching jobs.

Who will run the NHS and Education when everyone has switched out of those jobs?

Neededanewuserhandle · 01/02/2023 15:42

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:30

exactly the gvt can only pay out, what they get coming in?

That's overly simplistic and incorrect - although it is the ridiculous line that Thatcher always parroted. It wasn't true then (as she well knew) and it isn't true now. It's way more complicated - some good more detailed explanations have appeared on this thread.