Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where all the money is going to come from to increase wages?

285 replies

girlfriend44 · 01/02/2023 15:05

Genuine question. Re people who are striking for more money.

Where do they think the extra money is going to come from to increase all their wages and how will this keep inflation down?
Can the government really afford to pay everyone more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TeaKlaxon · 03/02/2023 09:06

Stackss · 02/02/2023 20:19

@Alexandra2001

One of the biggest contributors to inflation is wage rises. If the unions got their way with 19% rises, it would be through the roof.

This is just not true.

Wages have not been a significant factor in current inflation levels.

FlippyFloppyShoe · 03/02/2023 00:35

@strongallowed I get the impression that most teachers are not leaving because of the money, but because of all the crap that has been lumped on them (rightly or wrongly). So now there is a huge emphasis on social care aspect, levelling up, coping with a much more diverse ability within classes, more compulsory things to cover as part of the curriculum and fewer people to fill these roles which exacerbates the issue. I've spent many years living with teachers and have considered (and even applied) to do it myself, but it is all the requirements outside of teaching the actual subject that put me off.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 21:07

JassyRadlett · 02/02/2023 20:53

Yes, it's vitally important that pay for public sector workers like nurses and teachers are kept not only well below inflation but also below private sector wage growth. They are of course more useful as an inflationary tool than for the specific skills and vital societal roles they have been hired to do.

It's almost like the government lobbed a giant inflationary labour-restraining firecracker into a box of gunpowder, and then when it unsurprisingly exploded refused to pay the firefighters...

Firefighting is a vocation and so those that do it don't need to be paid.

JassyRadlett · 02/02/2023 20:53

Stackss · 02/02/2023 20:19

@Alexandra2001

One of the biggest contributors to inflation is wage rises. If the unions got their way with 19% rises, it would be through the roof.

Yes, it's vitally important that pay for public sector workers like nurses and teachers are kept not only well below inflation but also below private sector wage growth. They are of course more useful as an inflationary tool than for the specific skills and vital societal roles they have been hired to do.

It's almost like the government lobbed a giant inflationary labour-restraining firecracker into a box of gunpowder, and then when it unsurprisingly exploded refused to pay the firefighters...

Justcallmebebes · 02/02/2023 20:42

Power ballads even

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 20:39

Stackss · 02/02/2023 20:19

@Alexandra2001

One of the biggest contributors to inflation is wage rises. If the unions got their way with 19% rises, it would be through the roof.

You are joking right?

strongallowed · 02/02/2023 20:20

PrincessConstance · 02/02/2023 08:48

The main issue is if the people working in the NHS for instance are given a pay rise, that won't make the service miraculously great again. It means we'll be paying more for a service that isn't fit for purpose.

Any change to the NHS (privatisation, pay rises, change fee structure - whatever) will take decades to pull the service back up. Nothing will immediately unlock extra services / staff / infrastructure. Those days are long gone. So yes, any change, whatever it is, will see people paying more for exactly the same shit service. But you have to think of the future and for our children I guess.

Stackss · 02/02/2023 20:19

@Alexandra2001

One of the biggest contributors to inflation is wage rises. If the unions got their way with 19% rises, it would be through the roof.

strongallowed · 02/02/2023 20:18

FlippyFloppyShoe · 02/02/2023 07:49

I'm happy for pay rises in public sector as long as defined benefit pension burden is removed.
I read one of the serving policemen that got done for rape was going to get a pension of 20k a year after coming out of prison...whilst I don't think his pension should be removed, I do think people need to appreciate that for someone that has no higher education (so no barriers to anyone) and to go into public service and get a guaranteed index linked pension is a massive benefit that is probably only available to those in public services these days and if you want the financial reward now in terms of wages, then it should be separate to getting an increased guaranteed reward at retirement.
Do I think people in public service work harder than people in private sector? No and i think it is an insulting to claim that.

All of this is irrelevant though. It matters not what people think in terms of how much you should get paid or how hard you work etc. it just has to be appealing enough for people to want to do it. Currently there's no appetite for people to do these jobs. Without them, there are no essential services. So something has to change.

Alexandra2001 · 02/02/2023 19:21

Stackss · 02/02/2023 17:54

In any event, it looks like the government are going to withdraw the offers currently on the table for the NHS and teachers. Given inflation is about to start falling rapidly, I suspect the unions have shit themselves in the foot by refusing to accept and they will end up with a pay freeze after all.

Do you know how inflation works?

If inflation drops to 5%, the 11% increase we ve seen in prices, esp food (17%), are not going to fall, they are baked in, all that has happened is the rate of increase is less ... .... unless we get deflation, which is not desirable.

also, inflation in the UK is not yet falling, 0.2% drop, unlike in the EU which saw a 2% drop... it is by no means certain inflation will in the next 3 to 6 months.

Energy is going up approx 40% in April too.

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 18:42

Stackss · 02/02/2023 17:54

In any event, it looks like the government are going to withdraw the offers currently on the table for the NHS and teachers. Given inflation is about to start falling rapidly, I suspect the unions have shit themselves in the foot by refusing to accept and they will end up with a pay freeze after all.

A pay freeze would be nice. The government are proposing a pay cut.

Stackss · 02/02/2023 17:54

In any event, it looks like the government are going to withdraw the offers currently on the table for the NHS and teachers. Given inflation is about to start falling rapidly, I suspect the unions have shit themselves in the foot by refusing to accept and they will end up with a pay freeze after all.

EsmeSusanOgg · 02/02/2023 13:28

Ultimately, tax. But where that burden falls and whether efficiency savings and business boosts are considered too is a matter for policy experts and politicians (the latter, being the owns who decide whether to follow advice or not).

jgw1 · 02/02/2023 13:25

IheartNiles · 02/02/2023 11:25

In this country there are far too much money in the hands of too few. These few hoard a vast amount of wealth. The government can choose to redistribute this using a variety of means, they just don’t want to and this is the consequence of the corruption that infiltrates politics. It’s obscene and morally wrong that billionaires even exist.

So true.

LauraNicolaides · 02/02/2023 11:39

If inflation is running at 10% then (all other things being equal) the government's income goes up by 10%, because things like the amount of income tax raised will go up. So the government can afford to pay more in wages.

(All other things are not equal, and in fact tax revenue is falling, partly due to brexit as the economy shrinks, but we would have had to deal with that anyway (by cutting spending and/or raising borrowing).)

IheartNiles · 02/02/2023 11:25

In this country there are far too much money in the hands of too few. These few hoard a vast amount of wealth. The government can choose to redistribute this using a variety of means, they just don’t want to and this is the consequence of the corruption that infiltrates politics. It’s obscene and morally wrong that billionaires even exist.

Neededanewuserhandle · 02/02/2023 10:51

IR35 was the way the government has sort[sic] to correct this. It says that if you work solely for one person or company you should be employed not self employed.
That isn't what IR35 says - it is way more complex than that and working solely for one employer isn't relevant.

Neededanewuserhandle · 02/02/2023 10:49

When talking about saving NI one of the main ways of avoiding it is via umbrella companies that a lot in the media use
This is incorrect.
You don't know what an umbrella company is or how it works.

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 02/02/2023 10:46

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/02/2023 10:01

It wasn't meant to be disingenuous, it was meant to be an example of how the tax system is set up to benefit the wealthy, I wasn't even thinking about SME owners at the time.

In retrospect, I shouldn't have mentioned a salary of £9100 as apparently that acts as a trigger for SME owners, and I only did so to illustrate that someone can effectively pay no NI for their entire working lives, while earning a good wage, and still qualify for state pension, whereas most of us wouldn't.

I'm not sure why you think being a "normal business owner" should mean you're free to evade tax without people being angry about it? Can I also ask why you count the tax a business pays on profit as a personal tax when speaking about a business owner but not an employee? As it seems to me the only reason to do this is to try and justify the continuation of an unfair tax system.

Let's say you own a business that will make 50000 a year. You can either be self employed and be pretty much taxed as a PAYE person or you can set up a LTD company and be paid via dividends.
Since you would be the sole owner you would work out what tax you are paying so corporation tax would feature in the working out. Also. not forgetting you would be paying a lot more for you accountant for the LTD company.

I have a limited company that employs people, we work in the gas industry, the only reason I have a limited company is nothing to do with saving tax but is the liability our family would have if one of our employees makes a mistake.

When talking about saving NI one of the main ways of avoiding it is via umbrella companies that a lot in the media use. IR35 was the way the government has sort to correct this. It says that if you work solely for one person or company you should be employed not self employed.

Funny how the presenters on LBC are suddenly against IR35 when it means them paying more tax.

EffortlessDesmond · 02/02/2023 10:28

Apology accepted @Thebestwaytoscareatory !

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/02/2023 10:22

EffortlessDesmond · 02/02/2023 09:34

I'm not actually sure what your point is to be honest? That because you employ a few people you're entitled to something extra?
You're actually a very good example of why we find ourselves in this situation. You're a small fish (not meaning that in a derogatory way), but you'll fight tooth and nail to protect the big fish because you mistakenly think that I, as a monstrous socialist, want to take more from you to give to the "feckless".
I don't by the way, I want the gap to between top and bottom to close, I want the 1% that own 25% of all wealth to, well not own 25% of all wealth. There can still be rich and poor, just in my ideal world the rich won't be obscenely rich and the poor will be able to afford a nice life with warm homes, full bellys and comfortable retirements regardless of career choice.
The fact you get so defensive about things suggests to me you see alot of yourself in what I post about and don't like being confronted by it.

I totally agree that our SME is very small fry! But because it's very small, it has to be honest. The pay differential between DH and staff is known to everyone who works there, and I'm fairly certain it's not resented because he created the business and took the risk of failure, and in a downturn we take nothing out, while staff continue on salary.

DH is trying to retire, but to do so without folding the company. It has already taken three years and is still not settled. Trade sale? Possibly. Employee ownership? We've asked and most are unwilling to take the risk. Which goes a long way to explaining the sad statistic that fewer than 25% of entrepreneurs' businesses survive the death or retirement of the founders. Even if we eventually succeed, I promise we shan't be obscenely rich in the sense I surmise you understand the term.

And if making the case for business is being defensive, then my view is that it needs making here from time to time. Very easy to shift blame to "them".

And I won't cross the street to defend the rapacious utilities that harass and hound the elderly poor or the foolish and feckless onto pre-payment meters via thuggish debt collectors, and charge them premium rates for essentials. See this morning's Times if you want the correctness of your derision confirmed, and the wave of revulsion from ToL commentators.

It's great that your business is transparent, treats it's employees well and considers them in it's decision making. That's exactly what we need more of in business. I'd also like to apologies for the defensive comments, I have misinterpreted your posts and unfairly jumped to a wrong conclusion.

I appreciate I don't always make myself clear when talking about "them" but my ire isn't aimed at people earning good money from running a good business. I genuinely don't take issue with someone earning £100k, £250k, even £1m pa from a business they've built and taken risks for providing they do so in an ethical and fair way (to my standards of course).

My problem is with people earning good or obscene money from a business that exploits others and cheats the society they benefit from and with any business or business owner who opposes reform that would allow us start addressing the issue.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/02/2023 10:01

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 02/02/2023 05:09

I brought up the corporation tax as you quoted some figures that I feel were disingenuous about the taxes paid.

Ltd companies are available to all sections of society. You could set one up in half an hour.

It's like the evil gas and electric shareholders debate that is used to suggest some people are raking it in from the poor, but what is always missed out that most workers with a company pension are one of the evil shareholders.

Most of the people vilified for evading taxes are just normal business owners going about their daily business.

It wasn't meant to be disingenuous, it was meant to be an example of how the tax system is set up to benefit the wealthy, I wasn't even thinking about SME owners at the time.

In retrospect, I shouldn't have mentioned a salary of £9100 as apparently that acts as a trigger for SME owners, and I only did so to illustrate that someone can effectively pay no NI for their entire working lives, while earning a good wage, and still qualify for state pension, whereas most of us wouldn't.

I'm not sure why you think being a "normal business owner" should mean you're free to evade tax without people being angry about it? Can I also ask why you count the tax a business pays on profit as a personal tax when speaking about a business owner but not an employee? As it seems to me the only reason to do this is to try and justify the continuation of an unfair tax system.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/02/2023 09:45

PartyHelp · 02/02/2023 06:32

And I obviously can't stop you misquoting me but it's disingenuous, weakens your own arguements and by doing so it exposes you as a manipulative person.

Jesus Christ get a grip, it's a forum on mumsnet not a trail at The Hague! I am not misquoting anything - it is exactly what you said. Maybe you should look-up the definition of misquoting.
Maybe if your own trite close all the loopholes arguments had any substance you wouldn't have to make character assassinations of other posters.

I'll character assassinate anyone I want, thank you. This is mumsnet not The Hague!

You're right on one point however, I should have called you out for contextomy not mimisquoting. Will you ever forgive me??

And the point's only trite because there's a refusal in government to act, so we're stuck making the same wider points.

This might surprise you, but I don't actually have any influence in amending the UK's tax legislation, beyond writing to my MP. I also wasn't aware you were interested in discussing the details of what a new tax system could look like as so far all you've done is take things I say out of context to make an unrelated point and moan when I respond.

MarshaBradyo · 02/02/2023 09:42

EffortlessDesmond · 02/02/2023 09:34

I'm not actually sure what your point is to be honest? That because you employ a few people you're entitled to something extra?
You're actually a very good example of why we find ourselves in this situation. You're a small fish (not meaning that in a derogatory way), but you'll fight tooth and nail to protect the big fish because you mistakenly think that I, as a monstrous socialist, want to take more from you to give to the "feckless".
I don't by the way, I want the gap to between top and bottom to close, I want the 1% that own 25% of all wealth to, well not own 25% of all wealth. There can still be rich and poor, just in my ideal world the rich won't be obscenely rich and the poor will be able to afford a nice life with warm homes, full bellys and comfortable retirements regardless of career choice.
The fact you get so defensive about things suggests to me you see alot of yourself in what I post about and don't like being confronted by it.

I totally agree that our SME is very small fry! But because it's very small, it has to be honest. The pay differential between DH and staff is known to everyone who works there, and I'm fairly certain it's not resented because he created the business and took the risk of failure, and in a downturn we take nothing out, while staff continue on salary.

DH is trying to retire, but to do so without folding the company. It has already taken three years and is still not settled. Trade sale? Possibly. Employee ownership? We've asked and most are unwilling to take the risk. Which goes a long way to explaining the sad statistic that fewer than 25% of entrepreneurs' businesses survive the death or retirement of the founders. Even if we eventually succeed, I promise we shan't be obscenely rich in the sense I surmise you understand the term.

And if making the case for business is being defensive, then my view is that it needs making here from time to time. Very easy to shift blame to "them".

And I won't cross the street to defend the rapacious utilities that harass and hound the elderly poor or the foolish and feckless onto pre-payment meters via thuggish debt collectors, and charge them premium rates for essentials. See this morning's Times if you want the correctness of your derision confirmed, and the wave of revulsion from ToL commentators.

You make good points generally - also re perspectives from SMEs often lacking on here and who carries the risk.

EffortlessDesmond · 02/02/2023 09:34

I'm not actually sure what your point is to be honest? That because you employ a few people you're entitled to something extra?
You're actually a very good example of why we find ourselves in this situation. You're a small fish (not meaning that in a derogatory way), but you'll fight tooth and nail to protect the big fish because you mistakenly think that I, as a monstrous socialist, want to take more from you to give to the "feckless".
I don't by the way, I want the gap to between top and bottom to close, I want the 1% that own 25% of all wealth to, well not own 25% of all wealth. There can still be rich and poor, just in my ideal world the rich won't be obscenely rich and the poor will be able to afford a nice life with warm homes, full bellys and comfortable retirements regardless of career choice.
The fact you get so defensive about things suggests to me you see alot of yourself in what I post about and don't like being confronted by it.

I totally agree that our SME is very small fry! But because it's very small, it has to be honest. The pay differential between DH and staff is known to everyone who works there, and I'm fairly certain it's not resented because he created the business and took the risk of failure, and in a downturn we take nothing out, while staff continue on salary.

DH is trying to retire, but to do so without folding the company. It has already taken three years and is still not settled. Trade sale? Possibly. Employee ownership? We've asked and most are unwilling to take the risk. Which goes a long way to explaining the sad statistic that fewer than 25% of entrepreneurs' businesses survive the death or retirement of the founders. Even if we eventually succeed, I promise we shan't be obscenely rich in the sense I surmise you understand the term.

And if making the case for business is being defensive, then my view is that it needs making here from time to time. Very easy to shift blame to "them".

And I won't cross the street to defend the rapacious utilities that harass and hound the elderly poor or the foolish and feckless onto pre-payment meters via thuggish debt collectors, and charge them premium rates for essentials. See this morning's Times if you want the correctness of your derision confirmed, and the wave of revulsion from ToL commentators.