Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think we, Joe Public, have a responsibility to support strike action

89 replies

OverSharon · 01/02/2023 12:25

listening to teachers say that better teacher funding will mean better quality education over time has made me ‘realise’ (shower thought epiphany) that’s true of everything.

if we support strike action, we support people being happier at work, instead of the public sector feeling like they are required to work for us whether they like it or not.

…my opinion: it’s actually all of us that are bearing the brunt of the cost of keeping inflation down. The physical and emotional cost. If we begrudge strike action, we continue to allow the government not to think of other ways to tackle inflation. If they can’t raise wages, lower our cost of living.

OP posts:
OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:44

I think the clever people right now are withholding their rage. There’s absolutely no point fighting as it will just delay the answer being found, and I believe the point is that there is currently no answer. The government isn’t saying no, they’re saying we don’t know. Things seem too complicated right now to know exactly what to be angry at. ‘Experts’ can’t agree across any field. Something has to give?

OP posts:
Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 01/02/2023 13:43

OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:37

At this stage I don’t support any particular fix because I don’t understand the options. So I can say categorically that I do not support an above inflation pay rise! I can see why you may have thought so though. I guess people supporting strikers will be seen to be supporting ‘unreasonable’ fixes, but that’s certainly not what I’m after.

That makes sense. I did assume you agreed with the pay rise. I have no idea what the solution is either, but there must surely be some bright people out there that can come up with something well thought out and sustainable.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 13:40

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 13:34

I think things like this are trickier in difficult times. Right now EVERYONE is up against it. Even the "big" private sector earners. So they are looking at strikes thinking why on earth should I pay more taxes, for less public services, when I can barely pay my bills and the government is warning my private sector employer not to increase wages due to inflation, so that teachers can have a 12% pay rise. People will feel defensive and protective of their own interests. Couple this with the stress of covid lockdowns which school closures make feel all too close. It creates this defensive race to the bottom.

So yes, we should all support worker's rights, and the right to strike. For public sector as well and private. But I do understand why some people find it difficult to support in their particular circumstances.

(I say this as someone who supports striking in general, as well as this specific one.)

I think this is insightful

WitchQueenofDarkness · 01/02/2023 13:39

I do not support the strikes

DomesticShortHair · 01/02/2023 13:39

WinnieFosterReads · 01/02/2023 13:30

The full yougov survery shows support for unions is rising.
There's also a poll covered in the Guardian that shows increasing support for nurses and ambulance workers striking.
Redfield & Wilton's poll shows twice as many people support strikes as the number that oppose them.
Another poll says support is high for workers who earn less than £50k.
Plus there was a survey covered in numerous places showing the majority supported striking by education and teaching staff.
46% blamed the government for NHS strike action. Only 17% blamed NHS staff.
44% blamed the government for the teachers' strike action. Only 23% blamed the unions.
The National Parent Forum of Scotland showed 87% of parents supported teacher's striking.

There are more. Lots more. But that's just a brief overview. As I said you need to consider who has commissioned the survey and where its published. That's why I've given quite a wide overview. The Tories made it quite clear they use polls to try to influence public opinion not to gauge it so the polls they commission are always slanted towards a particular outcome. Yougov often uses a self-selecting group of respondents which makes it less representative and arguably easier to skew. Not all surveys are equal - which is the point I made in my earlier post.

Increasing support for and saying who is to blame for the strikes, is very different to how many actually support the strikes. As per that Sky news article, support for went from 34-37%, still a considerable minority.

OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:37

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 01/02/2023 13:35

YANBU to support striking for better pay an conditions
YABU to support an above inflation pay rise

At this stage I don’t support any particular fix because I don’t understand the options. So I can say categorically that I do not support an above inflation pay rise! I can see why you may have thought so though. I guess people supporting strikers will be seen to be supporting ‘unreasonable’ fixes, but that’s certainly not what I’m after.

OP posts:
GinClassHeroes · 01/02/2023 13:37

DomesticShortHair · 01/02/2023 13:30

Why are they striking for better pay for a job they are all quitting?

I can’t believe I’m really having to answer this, but:

Teachers went into teaching because they wanted to be teachers, the pay reflected the level of education/training/working hours/working conditions.

Then, wages stagnated and workload increased to the point they were working 10h/day instead of 6. And the working conditions got worse as budgets got cut, cut, cut.

Then people started leaving, which made those who stayed work more and more, with less and less resources. All while getting no more pay.

Those that are left are there because they have the same ideals they did when they went into teaching - to make a difference and all that jazz. Except they can’t. Because they don’t have time, or resources.

They have three choices:

  1. stay and put up with it
  2. leave
  3. stay and campaign for change
if they do 1, then nothing changes, and over time more teachers quit, they are replaced by some poor bright eyed and bushy tailed newbie who will tolerate it for so long before becoming disillusioned. If they do 2, they are actively damaging the kids they want to help. So they do 3. And then parents are up in arms about that too - so we circle back round to choice 1 or 2.

What do you think they should do?

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 01/02/2023 13:35

YANBU to support striking for better pay an conditions
YABU to support an above inflation pay rise

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 13:34

I think things like this are trickier in difficult times. Right now EVERYONE is up against it. Even the "big" private sector earners. So they are looking at strikes thinking why on earth should I pay more taxes, for less public services, when I can barely pay my bills and the government is warning my private sector employer not to increase wages due to inflation, so that teachers can have a 12% pay rise. People will feel defensive and protective of their own interests. Couple this with the stress of covid lockdowns which school closures make feel all too close. It creates this defensive race to the bottom.

So yes, we should all support worker's rights, and the right to strike. For public sector as well and private. But I do understand why some people find it difficult to support in their particular circumstances.

(I say this as someone who supports striking in general, as well as this specific one.)

OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:34

roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 13:24

@OverSharon thing is, we're in an economic downturn for many reasons. Not all related to the government. The private sector isn't receiving inflation busting pay rises. Why should the public sector be immune? It's hard to be that sympathetic when unions are asking for double digits max

Forgive me... I think my understanding falls short here. See this is exactly the kind of thing I was hoping to find. I was under the impression that the private sector is responsible for itself, and the public sector for itself and so on. Now retail is something I have worked on and off for the past many years. And a couple of times, I was better off than my mum on a 40hr week. I was helping her with her planning! Working in the private sector made me feel valued. I would NEVER become a teacher. Or a nurse. I’d sooner wear a kick me sign shopping the way people treat workers these days.

OP posts:
anaconda1831 · 01/02/2023 13:32

A lot of economists totally reject the governments argument that pay rises will stoke inflation.

We need a wealth tax and to invest revenue gained into our public services through pay rises.

Crunchymum · 01/02/2023 13:31

Surely Joe Bloggs have absolutely zero say or sway in strike action?

It's a personal choice as to whether you support it or not. You can't tell people how to feel.

(I 100% support strike action, for transparency)

WinnieFosterReads · 01/02/2023 13:30

DomesticShortHair · 01/02/2023 12:57

What surveys are you basing that on? YouGove says overall that they’re not, and Sky News recently had an article saying only 37% support the unions.

yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2023/01/31/what-affects-support-strikes

It varies from sector to sector (nurses striking is more popular than train drivers, for example). But I’m curious to see the evidence of your assertion that every survey shows the public supports the strikes.

The full yougov survery shows support for unions is rising.
There's also a poll covered in the Guardian that shows increasing support for nurses and ambulance workers striking.
Redfield & Wilton's poll shows twice as many people support strikes as the number that oppose them.
Another poll says support is high for workers who earn less than £50k.
Plus there was a survey covered in numerous places showing the majority supported striking by education and teaching staff.
46% blamed the government for NHS strike action. Only 17% blamed NHS staff.
44% blamed the government for the teachers' strike action. Only 23% blamed the unions.
The National Parent Forum of Scotland showed 87% of parents supported teacher's striking.

There are more. Lots more. But that's just a brief overview. As I said you need to consider who has commissioned the survey and where its published. That's why I've given quite a wide overview. The Tories made it quite clear they use polls to try to influence public opinion not to gauge it so the polls they commission are always slanted towards a particular outcome. Yougov often uses a self-selecting group of respondents which makes it less representative and arguably easier to skew. Not all surveys are equal - which is the point I made in my earlier post.

DomesticShortHair · 01/02/2023 13:30

GinClassHeroes · 01/02/2023 13:20

Then why are they all quitting/why is nobody signing up?

Why are they striking for better pay for a job they are all quitting?

OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:28

BlusteryLake · 01/02/2023 13:26

Not all strike action is the same, though. I support the teachers but not the rail workers, because the rail workers have already been made a pretty reasonable offer but have ridiculous expectations so keep turning them down.

I think in this particular scenario, ‘strike action’ as a whole is actually representative of our collective disgust at having to live on a shoestring for as long as we’ve had a Tory government. Or at least that’s how it feels to someone who has never been a Tory supporter.

OP posts:
OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:26

roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 13:24

@OverSharon thing is, we're in an economic downturn for many reasons. Not all related to the government. The private sector isn't receiving inflation busting pay rises. Why should the public sector be immune? It's hard to be that sympathetic when unions are asking for double digits max

But don’t you see they’re asking for that because that’s how bad off we all are… things are so bad with our government, the government can’t even be bothered to pay its own workers properly. If Rishi Sunak was Jeff Bezos, Amazon would be in administration.

OP posts:
BlusteryLake · 01/02/2023 13:26

Not all strike action is the same, though. I support the teachers but not the rail workers, because the rail workers have already been made a pretty reasonable offer but have ridiculous expectations so keep turning them down.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 13:24

@PatientZorro well said

OverSharon · 01/02/2023 13:24

Viviennemary · 01/02/2023 13:13

I don't support the strikes either. These people have far better terms and conditions re sick pay and pensions than a lot of people in other jobs. And their pay is reasonable too.

I can see why you may think that, but this hasn’t been true in over 15 years. Speaking as the daughter of a woman who retired from teaching last year, and is not even retirement age. She would just rather live on nothing than go back to that environment.

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 01/02/2023 13:24

@OverSharon thing is, we're in an economic downturn for many reasons. Not all related to the government. The private sector isn't receiving inflation busting pay rises. Why should the public sector be immune? It's hard to be that sympathetic when unions are asking for double digits max

Highhi · 01/02/2023 13:22

I will point this out over and over.
Unless you decide to spend your whole pay rise on a foreign holiday booked with a foreign company, most of the pay rise increase will end up back with the government anyway.

GinClassHeroes · 01/02/2023 13:20

Viviennemary · 01/02/2023 13:13

I don't support the strikes either. These people have far better terms and conditions re sick pay and pensions than a lot of people in other jobs. And their pay is reasonable too.

Then why are they all quitting/why is nobody signing up?

GinClassHeroes · 01/02/2023 13:20

There seems to be a bit of an agenda to get everyone fighting amongst themselves. Strike action is going to intensify - here in Scotland we had a single day, then another union had a single day, then the unions coordinated a day. We now have 16 days of strikes where each school will be closed for two non consecutive day. Next round is 20 days of strikes with two consecutive days.

This is going to escalate in England too, so you all better prepare childcare or lobby your MPs to agree to the pay deal. Or suck it up.

Useit · 01/02/2023 13:19

I don't support the strikes

Viviennemary · 01/02/2023 13:13

I don't support the strikes either. These people have far better terms and conditions re sick pay and pensions than a lot of people in other jobs. And their pay is reasonable too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread