Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

List of striking teachers

190 replies

Motherland2624 · 01/02/2023 10:27

Hi
one of my sons is in the upper sixth of the local grammar school
the headmistress has just sent a list of striking teachers (for our information)
to get a idea of what our child’s day is going to look like
do you think this is a power move by the head trying to name and shame the teachers
I think it’s totally unnecessary its a legal right to strike
strike or not I support all teachers in their choice
just wondering on peoples opinions ?

OP posts:
catsandkid · 01/02/2023 16:38

Head's response is not OK in my opinion. Head seems to be sorry for sharing non striking teacher names, but sees absolutely no problem with sharing striking teachers names. From a GDPR standpoint the striking teachers will be NEU, and their NEU membership is a Special Category data that can only be processed or disclosed with informed consent.

As PP says, whilst some teachers may have communicated to students directly that they were striking, those same teachers are unlikely to have given the head/school consent to share such information to others (parents). So it still rings of a GDPR failure to me.

saraclara · 01/02/2023 16:34

clarrylove · 01/02/2023 16:26

Her last point is valid. If staff have given permission for it to be shared, it's not a GDPR breach. I think you have gone in very heavy handed here.

It's not. She doesn't know which of the staff on that list have told their classes. And those who did, chose their audiences. They didn't give permission for all the parents of all the pupils to be told.

clarrylove · 01/02/2023 16:26

Her last point is valid. If staff have given permission for it to be shared, it's not a GDPR breach. I think you have gone in very heavy handed here.

Motherland2624 · 01/02/2023 16:14

I got a reply from the head
I don’t think her last point was valid as there had been continuous communication about the plans for today everyone was aware

List of striking teachers
OP posts:
PartyTips · 01/02/2023 13:20

PeekAtYou · 01/02/2023 12:59

My ds is in a comprehensive Sixth Form and he was sent a list of teachers who are in today so he knew whether or not to turn up to lessons. His school is open for year 11 and for some year 12/13 classes.
The list of who is in today could be used to work out who is not hence who is striking but I think that's fair enough.

It would be a list of:

  • teachers striking
  • teachers with childcare issues meaning they can’t attend work
  • teachers who are unwell
  • teachers who are on courses
  • teachers on short-term leave (like paternity)
  • teachers off for ad hoc reasons (like moving house, an important funeral or compassionate grounds etc)

People might think they know from that list who is striking but they’d be wrong. In OP’s case, they’d be correct.

tigger1001 · 01/02/2023 13:14

GreaterStickle · 01/02/2023 11:41

I don’t see a problem with it. If they’re not ashamed to be striking (and they should be) then what’s the issue?

GDPR my arse 🙄

What other gdpr rules would you be ok with the school breaking?

ilovesooty · 01/02/2023 13:10

Motherland2624 · 01/02/2023 11:06

I’ve just quoted this in my email to the head I hope that’s ok

Good. The headteacher has behaved appallingly. I'd consider a complaint to the governors citing a potential data breach.

Can2022getanyworse · 01/02/2023 13:05

AlisonDonut · 01/02/2023 11:15

I'd forward that straight to the Union rep or to one of the teachers.

This is outrageous.

Holy fuck that's appalling behaviour from the head.

Of course its OK to say which classes are closing - my school is closed to ALL y7-y10 but there will be a good number of teachers not striking whose classes aren't in school.

I'd be sending that on to the teachers and the governors, really bad.

PeekAtYou · 01/02/2023 12:59

My ds is in a comprehensive Sixth Form and he was sent a list of teachers who are in today so he knew whether or not to turn up to lessons. His school is open for year 11 and for some year 12/13 classes.
The list of who is in today could be used to work out who is not hence who is striking but I think that's fair enough.

Motherland2624 · 01/02/2023 12:56

I have emailed the head of year and she asked if she could foward to headmistress
also put it on twitter tagging school and union in

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 01/02/2023 12:52

Something similar happened a few years ago in a university I used to work in.

Is such behaviour even legal? I doubt it.

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 01/02/2023 12:49

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 12:19

this is great! I guess they are scared to being political, but union activity, whether you agree or not, is a huge part of society and history. It's right the children should learn about it, and be helped to understand why they have the day off.

The conversation was triggered by another mum telling her DD and my DD that "Miss X wants a day off" 🙄

Far from the HT sending emails with striking teachers names to shame them, she had a boombox in the playground 😂proper microphone set-up!

I forget the exact figures, but the strike was about high school teachers getting a 3% payrise and primary teachers getting 1% - so the curriculum was switched around for my son's class to focus on the number 3 that week. There was a project 'What has 3?' - triangles, Goldilocks & 3 Bears, football hattrick, high school teachers!

They really talked to the (older) kids about it; about not accepting less than you deserve, unfair treatment between 2 parties etc.

It wasn't at all about funding or improving the school as there's no probelms there - plenty books, resources etc., it was purely teacher salaries and the support was massive. So beneficial for the kids to do it this way.

MrWhippersnapper · 01/02/2023 12:42

Totally illegal and they’ll have the union on their backs

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:40

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:34

I agree that the information absolutely shouldn't have been shared with parents, or with pupils for that matter. But the son is in Upper Sixth, so it's completely normal to say 'come in for p2 and p5, but p3 and p4 are cancelled.' These are kids who are 17 and 18. I suspect the Head was being lazy and didn't want to send a personalised timetable around so just sent this list instead. They'll regret that when it comes back to bite them, hopefully.

Clearly for younger pupils, you couldn't have them backwards and forwards all day, but you could easily have a later than normal start or an earlier than normal finish, e.g. 'Year 10, your first lesson of the day will be P2, you should arrive at school for 9.45am and register directly with your P2 teacher. The library will be available for private study for any pupils wishing to arrive earlier.'

PhillySub · 01/02/2023 12:39

Doesn't that fall under the heading of misguidedly breaking data protection laws? If you were of a mind to cause mischief you could very well cause her problems.

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:35

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:34

I agree that the information absolutely shouldn't have been shared with parents, or with pupils for that matter. But the son is in Upper Sixth, so it's completely normal to say 'come in for p2 and p5, but p3 and p4 are cancelled.' These are kids who are 17 and 18. I suspect the Head was being lazy and didn't want to send a personalised timetable around so just sent this list instead. They'll regret that when it comes back to bite them, hopefully.

Obviously normal rules would apply about signing in and out of the school if the pupils are going off site.

CPL593H · 01/02/2023 12:35

I would be notifying the union and making sure that as many teachers as possible know that their names are on the list.

There is no earthly reason why the parents of young people who will be at university in a few months, some who may be legal adults, need to know this for any kind of reasonable purpose.

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:34

MrsAvocet · 01/02/2023 12:25

Ok, but I can't believe any schools will be saying to their kids "Mr Brown is in for physics period 2 so go to that lesson but then we dont want to see you until Mrs Green's french lesson in period 5". So parents knowing which lessons are on or off is not necessary. You need to know if your child is in school or not, not exactly what they are doing during the time.
And from the OP's description it sounds like her DS is in school for the day and the list of striking teachers has been sent after the school day has begun. So it's not information that is remotely useful to the parent. It's an invasion of the teachers'privacy dressed up as "oh we thought you might like to know what your child is doing today".

I agree that the information absolutely shouldn't have been shared with parents, or with pupils for that matter. But the son is in Upper Sixth, so it's completely normal to say 'come in for p2 and p5, but p3 and p4 are cancelled.' These are kids who are 17 and 18. I suspect the Head was being lazy and didn't want to send a personalised timetable around so just sent this list instead. They'll regret that when it comes back to bite them, hopefully.

MrsAvocet · 01/02/2023 12:25

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:16

Not every school decided this in advance. They will have made plans based on different scenarios of how many staff will be striking, but without knowing until the day how many will actually be off, they wouldn't have known which of those plans to implement. Some schools assumed the maximum number would be off (the numbers of NEU members who are being called to strike, not names, are provided to the school in advance, but the school won't know how many will choose to actually strike, unless they foolishly told the school voluntarily) and so gave advance warning that they would implement X plan. Other schools waited to see how many staff they had in.

Ok, but I can't believe any schools will be saying to their kids "Mr Brown is in for physics period 2 so go to that lesson but then we dont want to see you until Mrs Green's french lesson in period 5". So parents knowing which lessons are on or off is not necessary. You need to know if your child is in school or not, not exactly what they are doing during the time.
And from the OP's description it sounds like her DS is in school for the day and the list of striking teachers has been sent after the school day has begun. So it's not information that is remotely useful to the parent. It's an invasion of the teachers'privacy dressed up as "oh we thought you might like to know what your child is doing today".

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 12:19

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 01/02/2023 12:13

I'm in another country, but when primary school teachers went on strike here they spent the week leading up to it doing related art & crafts projects - the kids were making signs and placards and learning all about unions and strike actions. My son was 4 and was painting big banners made by the older kids. We knew all teachers would be on strike, they sent out an invitation to all parents to join them in the playground, put the party tables out and families brought food / drinks / placards and joined the strike. Parents who couldn't make it because of work etc sent donations in. Just a very different atmosphere and way of garnering support - was fantastic! They should change the approach in the UK from maximum disruption to maximum support!

this is great! I guess they are scared to being political, but union activity, whether you agree or not, is a huge part of society and history. It's right the children should learn about it, and be helped to understand why they have the day off.

The conversation was triggered by another mum telling her DD and my DD that "Miss X wants a day off" 🙄

Fink · 01/02/2023 12:16

MrsAvocet · 01/02/2023 12:10

No. Still completely unnecessary. Children are not wandering in and out of school to just attend lessons which are running as normal. No sane headteacher would sanction that as it would be a logistical nightmare and a huge Safeguarding risk.
Every school in our area - and I assume nationally - had decided in advance which pupils will be in and which not. At my children's school it's years 11, 13 and vulnerable pupils/emergency workers' children only who are in school which seems to be a fairly standard approach round here at least. And if they are in, they are in for the whole day. Appropriate supervision will be provided for the day. There is absolutely no need for parents to be informed about the minutiae of their child's school day today any more than any other day - they can ask their child after school if they want that the detail.

Not every school decided this in advance. They will have made plans based on different scenarios of how many staff will be striking, but without knowing until the day how many will actually be off, they wouldn't have known which of those plans to implement. Some schools assumed the maximum number would be off (the numbers of NEU members who are being called to strike, not names, are provided to the school in advance, but the school won't know how many will choose to actually strike, unless they foolishly told the school voluntarily) and so gave advance warning that they would implement X plan. Other schools waited to see how many staff they had in.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 01/02/2023 12:15

The head is on dodgy ground here, even without releasing this to the parents (!). I should think the NEU (not to mention other unions) would take a very dim view of this indeed.

MrsKeats · 01/02/2023 12:15

That's disgusting and probably illegal.
I would say so in no uncertain terms,
You see why teachers are striking?

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 01/02/2023 12:13

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 12:08

I am inclined to think though that teachers should be upfront about striking and why they are doing it. Presumably it's something they believe in strongly and are taking a stand for. While I can see that this seems slightly hung out to dry (although I am just not sure that was the motivation - I mean it could have been, but it could also just be lazy communication), I think I would just own it.

Both my kids' teachers were striking. DD knew and asked me why her teacher was striking, we talked a little about it and I encouraged her to ask her teacher about her personal motivation for it, which she did and they had a little chat about it. DS is younger and his teacher told they class they would be off today as she was striking. I feel quite happy that they were open and honest about it, and prepared to answer questions. Exercising the right to strike is something that kids should be aware of.

I'm in another country, but when primary school teachers went on strike here they spent the week leading up to it doing related art & crafts projects - the kids were making signs and placards and learning all about unions and strike actions. My son was 4 and was painting big banners made by the older kids. We knew all teachers would be on strike, they sent out an invitation to all parents to join them in the playground, put the party tables out and families brought food / drinks / placards and joined the strike. Parents who couldn't make it because of work etc sent donations in. Just a very different atmosphere and way of garnering support - was fantastic! They should change the approach in the UK from maximum disruption to maximum support!

MrsAvocet · 01/02/2023 12:10

electricmoccasins · 01/02/2023 11:56

Perhaps it would have been better for the Head to indicate which classes are happening e.g Mr Brown’s physics class etc.

Obviously, by process of elimination, you can still work out who’s striking, but it isn’t an obvious list of those who are.

No. Still completely unnecessary. Children are not wandering in and out of school to just attend lessons which are running as normal. No sane headteacher would sanction that as it would be a logistical nightmare and a huge Safeguarding risk.
Every school in our area - and I assume nationally - had decided in advance which pupils will be in and which not. At my children's school it's years 11, 13 and vulnerable pupils/emergency workers' children only who are in school which seems to be a fairly standard approach round here at least. And if they are in, they are in for the whole day. Appropriate supervision will be provided for the day. There is absolutely no need for parents to be informed about the minutiae of their child's school day today any more than any other day - they can ask their child after school if they want that the detail.