Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private sector - unions

65 replies

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 09:42

If you are in the private sector, do you wish you had a union? If effective unions were available for private sector workers would you join (and pay into) one? Would you strike if asked to?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 01/02/2023 12:36

don't be daft though. If you are doing the same job as someone else, and you have been there the same amount of time and have the same qualifications you should be paid the same.

But then i am also a republican who thinks that the massive inequality in the UK could be solved with their own October Revolution instead of the meek and, frankly, daft acceptance of the massive-inequality status quo

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 12:34

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 12:32

What I am saying is that I don't think everyone doing the SAME job, should necessarily be on the SAME salary.

what like men could be paid more than women? that sounds like fantastic business practice

Or, take a deep breath, perhaps the woman could be paid more than the man. Just imagine 😉

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 12:32

What I am saying is that I don't think everyone doing the SAME job, should necessarily be on the SAME salary.

what like men could be paid more than women? that sounds like fantastic business practice

Thriwit · 01/02/2023 12:32

I work in the private sector, in an industry that’s always been private, and am a union member. Our union is currently engaged in pay talks with the company. We even striked a few years ago.
For many people it’s not as easy as “just get a new job” when you’re not in an urban area and you have other responsibilities

Felixishandsome · 01/02/2023 12:31

There is a big difference between being in a union, and being in a private company that recognises a union.

With the first they can support you as an individual during a dispute etc, but unless the second is true they have no 'power' as such within the organisation and won't have reps in the company, or be able to engage about policies

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 12:18

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 12:01

No, because I don't believe in collective bargaining. Salary should be paid on merit and performance. I personally think it is terrible to all be paid the same regardless of educational attainment and performance.

that's not how collective bargaining works. Unions are very keen on pay differentials so (at least the ones I've been involved in are). So they will negotiate, say, a baseline salary, and then increments for promotions, length of service etc etc.

You don't honestly believe they go in and say to a firm "right, you have to pay everyone in the union 30k a year and 30 days hoiday" and the senior managers and junior employees get the same?

Of course I don't. What I am saying is that I don't think everyone doing the SAME job, should necessarily be on the SAME salary.

pigsinoodies · 01/02/2023 12:15

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 11:58

Those are all sectors that used to be public. I wonder if that's why there is still a culture of unions there. I would guess the answer is yes.

It's also much more likely to be in blue collar sectors than white collar.

I used those companies as examples because they make up a large part of the current headline disputes. They are former public sector companies but they're also large-scale businesses which have existed since the heyday of the union movement in the 70s, albeit under different ownership structures.

Union organisation doesn't tend to happen in businesses with a small workforce where the management are in daily contact with the workforce. And union membership is 'discouraged' by many of the big name, 'one man at the helm' businesses which have grown up since union membership started to fall in the early 80s.

GoodChat · 01/02/2023 12:15

Union members have more sway in private companies. I work in the private sector and our union fought and won and extra 3% on top of the company's original offer.

DomesticShortHair · 01/02/2023 12:13

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 11:48

Why do you think that an employer should owe you any more?

i expect an employer to stay within employment law. Which mine didn't. They made me an out of court offer just before we went to tribunal.

Why on earth would you think i would put up with being shafted by a lawbreaker?

Yeah, they probably deserved that result for how they’d gone about it. It’s not hard to manage someone out of a job and stay within the law, so a claim against them was fair enough and well deserved, to teach them a lesson for being a bit rubbish. I’m fairly sure they’ve learned how to approach it differently next time.

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 12:01

No, because I don't believe in collective bargaining. Salary should be paid on merit and performance. I personally think it is terrible to all be paid the same regardless of educational attainment and performance.

that's not how collective bargaining works. Unions are very keen on pay differentials so (at least the ones I've been involved in are). So they will negotiate, say, a baseline salary, and then increments for promotions, length of service etc etc.

You don't honestly believe they go in and say to a firm "right, you have to pay everyone in the union 30k a year and 30 days hoiday" and the senior managers and junior employees get the same?

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 11:58

pigsinoodies · 01/02/2023 11:56

Royal Mail, BT and the rail companies are all private sector and all largely unionised.

Union membership is more predominant (and certainly more high profile) in larger and longer-established companies.

Those are all sectors that used to be public. I wonder if that's why there is still a culture of unions there. I would guess the answer is yes.

It's also much more likely to be in blue collar sectors than white collar.

OP posts:
pigsinoodies · 01/02/2023 11:56

Royal Mail, BT and the rail companies are all private sector and all largely unionised.

Union membership is more predominant (and certainly more high profile) in larger and longer-established companies.

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 11:54

Also, as I am on a role, I don't believe it is right for 15% of the working population (mostly public sector), to hold 85% of the working population to ransom. Actually, why don't the private sector all just down tools, and see what occurs. No gas, electric, water, telecoms, food.

We always get the line of greedy private sector making all those profits. Where do you think your lovely pensions are invested in. No profits, no pension growth.

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 11:50

No, because I don't believe in collective bargaining. Salary should be paid on merit and performance. I personally think it is terrible to all be paid the same regardless of educational attainment and performance. Also, pay should be driven by local employment and costs of living. Paying the same rate to someone living in the North East v. someone living in the South East is a nonsense.

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 11:48

Why do you think that an employer should owe you any more?

i expect an employer to stay within employment law. Which mine didn't. They made me an out of court offer just before we went to tribunal.

Why on earth would you think i would put up with being shafted by a lawbreaker?

DomesticShortHair · 01/02/2023 11:46

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 11:40

Maybe a union would be useful to me if there was ever a dispute or something - I haven't really considered it to be honest.

this is all fine, the "well i'd just leave and get a new job". You don't need a union for that. But when you have given 10 years of good work and are considered too expensive and your company give you redundancy notice and recruit someone to do your exact job at half the salary? Too bloody right you do. And a nice surprise it was for them when i took a union rep to a meeting i called with the MD and HR. it's like insurance, you don't need them until you do.

And my colleagues? i have always told people to join a union, they said "don't need one, if i want more money I'll find a new job". And then? Kicked out at 50, no redundancy money. It wasn'T fun for some of them.

I have no problem with that. The only thing work owes me is the money at the end of the month, in exchange for the work that I do. It’s all laid out in the contract, and they can get rid of me, or I can leave, at any time (notice period accepted). I don’t expect an employer to do any more than that, it’s purely a transactional relationship. Why do you think that an employer should owe you any more?

Reugny · 01/02/2023 11:45

GreaterStickle · 01/02/2023 11:36

I’m in the private sector but not in a union.

I don’t agree with striking. If I wasn’t happy with my pay or working conditions I would just get a job elsewhere.

Try that when you are aged 50+

Unless you work in a sector where there are lots of freelance workers who can earn a good living, you will find you won't get another job.

Reugny · 01/02/2023 11:41

When I worked permanently I was in a union even thought the union never represented the entire workforce. The union sorted out an employment dispute with one employer. Then a few years later I worked for an employer who got taken over. Instead of making legit redundancies the employer did all sort of tricks to get rid of people, however when they found out I was in a union they made a reasonable offer to pay me off.

One of my brothers' then joined the same union. The union needed as many members in his company to join as they managed to negotiate a solution with his company so him and his colleagues jobs were not off-shored.

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 11:40

Maybe a union would be useful to me if there was ever a dispute or something - I haven't really considered it to be honest.

this is all fine, the "well i'd just leave and get a new job". You don't need a union for that. But when you have given 10 years of good work and are considered too expensive and your company give you redundancy notice and recruit someone to do your exact job at half the salary? Too bloody right you do. And a nice surprise it was for them when i took a union rep to a meeting i called with the MD and HR. it's like insurance, you don't need them until you do.

And my colleagues? i have always told people to join a union, they said "don't need one, if i want more money I'll find a new job". And then? Kicked out at 50, no redundancy money. It wasn'T fun for some of them.

GreaterStickle · 01/02/2023 11:36

I’m in the private sector but not in a union.

I don’t agree with striking. If I wasn’t happy with my pay or working conditions I would just get a job elsewhere.

Hakunamatata91 · 01/02/2023 11:34

As PPs have said, union membership is available to private sector workers. However the UK does have much lower rates of union membership than some other countries- in the 20s% I believe. Given that includes public sector workers who are more likely to be in a union that means private sector workers who are in a union are very much the minority. In my experience certain sectors with private sector tend to have high rates of unionisation- eg oil and gas workers in the north sea are very unionised and have had industrial action in recent history.

I'm no longer in the private sector but when I was i wasn't a member of a union. I didn't work in a sector where having a union was common. I've dealt with union reps and they vary massively from brilliant, to some who are needlessly obstructive/confrontational and who actually wind up causing more issues for the members they are representing. I am pretty up to speed on employment law and would have no issues holding an employer to account on that front myself, so didn't see much benefit to me personally. I could see that for someone who would like the advice/representation side of it membership would be worth it if you got a good rep.

fanonney · 01/02/2023 11:20

I work in the private sector, I am not in a union.

In all honesty, I'm not very interested in collective bargaining. I work in a sector with healthy competition between companies, my pay is determined by how difficult it is to find people to do the job I do, and by how well I do it, and by how well the company as a whole does. If they don't pay me accordingly, I will leave and go elsewhere. In particular, I am not interested in working somewhere with a standardised payscale you progress through with experience - I find that incredibly unmotivating!

Maybe a union would be useful to me if there was ever a dispute or something - I haven't really considered it to be honest.

KrisAkabusi · 01/02/2023 11:16

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 10:53

Because we never hear about any action that thery taking? I've also never come across a person IRL who is member of a union and private sector.

In my home country it's really common, I was surprised there wasn't a union to join when I started working here. Are you memebr of a union @KrisAkabusi

I'm in the public sector now, so yes. But back when I worked in factories, I was also a union member. I was signed up by the shop steward my first week in the job. I encourage everyone to join. It's not just about taking action, its about collective negotiation, right for individuals. If a factory isn't on strike, there's an argument that the union are doing their job properly! Striking is a last resort, a lot can be achieved before resorting to that. It may be that a private company is better able to increase pay than the government is.

noblegiraffe · 01/02/2023 11:11

Because we never hear about any action that thery taking?

Did you Google? BT, Stagecoach and Fox’s biscuits all took industrial action before Xmas and secured better pay deals as a result.

Brefugee · 01/02/2023 11:07

Thing is that whilst you can join a union, even in the smallest of employers, the union won't engage with negotiations etc for small numbers of people. Yes, they'll "support" you in, say, an unfair dismissal case, but they're not going to spend time talking to your employer about routine stuff like pay rises etc.

but for a small employer it is easier to negotiate your own. And as pp said if you don't like your conditions move. And if you can't negotiate? Learn how. But. If, as i was, your employer tries something on? Union helped me draft a letter, then attended a meeting with me, and then got a lawyer involved. I won but others in a similar position didn't. (i won in terms of getting a pay out, not keeping my job). It was an attempt at hire-refire and calling it redundancy.