Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private sector - unions

65 replies

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 09:42

If you are in the private sector, do you wish you had a union? If effective unions were available for private sector workers would you join (and pay into) one? Would you strike if asked to?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rothbury · 03/02/2023 15:14

Millions of people in private sector are union members.

Here is a link to how to find out which trade union is the right one for you.
www.tuc.org.uk/join-a-union

Some roles may have more than one option of course.

ilovesooty · 03/02/2023 15:10

I worked for 15 years in the voluntary sector for a company that didn't recognise unions. I was still a union member despite not actually needing them. It was a happy place to work but things can change. Given my previous experience I wasn't taking any chances.

I'm now self employed - and still a union member. I'm actually in two unions.

bingoitsadingo · 03/02/2023 14:57

Eh? What's with the graduate premium then? Why do gradutes earn more money than non-grads. If that were the case, why bother with HE at all.

This is such a non-sequitur.
People do degrees to gain certain skill and knowledge. These are valuable (or perceived to be) to employers. However, some people gain those skills and knowledge without a degree, or they get a degree but their grade doesn't reflect how good the skills relevant to the job in question are.
So you might have one person doing a job with a degree, and one person who self-taught the same skills, and they can be equally as good at their jobs. The fact that other people without degrees get paid less (on average) is irrelevant to comparing the pay of people within a particular role.

Badbadbunny · 02/02/2023 10:39

KnittedCardi · 02/02/2023 09:23

The idea that educational attainment is a measure of someone's monetary worth is also half baked

Eh? What's with the graduate premium then? Why do gradutes earn more money than non-grads. If that were the case, why bother with HE at all.

Plenty of jobs/trades pay more than graduate wages.

Also, a lot of "graduate" jobs don't actually "need" graduates - lots of jobs never used to be degree jobs. They're tending to be higher paid jobs, and simply "weeding out" applicants by requiring a degree. So it's kind of the opposite really, that some higher paid jobs/professions are higher paid anyway, but self-select graduates just to reduce the number of applicants.

KnittedCardi · 02/02/2023 09:23

The idea that educational attainment is a measure of someone's monetary worth is also half baked

Eh? What's with the graduate premium then? Why do gradutes earn more money than non-grads. If that were the case, why bother with HE at all.

christmaspudding43 · 01/02/2023 15:34

KnittedCardi · 01/02/2023 11:50

No, because I don't believe in collective bargaining. Salary should be paid on merit and performance. I personally think it is terrible to all be paid the same regardless of educational attainment and performance. Also, pay should be driven by local employment and costs of living. Paying the same rate to someone living in the North East v. someone living in the South East is a nonsense.

Paying more to someone in the south east to allow them to buy a property that is worth more and generally appreciates more along with allowing them to accrue a more valuable pension would have to be subject to forcing that person to remain in the south east when they retire and/or downsize which is patently nonsensical. I'm not completely against some recognition of cost of living via a payment but it's not a simple approach, particularly in these times of increased wfh and huge disparity in generational wealth, along with differences in funding of various services including but not limited to public transport.

The idea that educational attainment is a measure of someone's monetary worth is also half baked.

Reugny · 01/02/2023 15:23

Elsatellsa · 01/02/2023 13:55

People choosing not to join a union isn't the same as them not existing or not being able to. The reality is that most people aren't bothered by strikes unless it immediately effects them, many strikes wouldn't so they wouldn't be effective.

My brother who is in a union that is recognised by his employers has never called for a strike in his workplace. Simply as it isn't effective. Their main role is keeping the workforce in jobs and sorting out workplace disputes for individual members.

Likewise my DP, who is a union rep, only role is sorting out workplace disputes for individuals/groups or preventing a couple of his shit managers causing them in the first place. In his workplace there are lots of different unions and if his union called for a strike it wouldn't be effective, there as if one of the others did it could be.

Useit · 01/02/2023 15:16

I worked in quality control in a warehouse setting for a private company and joined a union but more for help if there was a dispute, disciplinary or unfair dismissal, stuff like that rather than striking. It wasn't anything to do with the company though, it was probably Unite, I can't remember

Lulu1919 · 01/02/2023 15:07

I work in an Independent/private school ...in a union

MarshaBradyo · 01/02/2023 15:06

Private sector and unions are not of interest to me. I wouldn’t pay fees

Elsatellsa · 01/02/2023 15:04

EBearhug · 01/02/2023 14:24

People choosing not to join a union isn't the same as them not existing or not being able to.

That is true, but many people don't realise that if there is no recognised union, they can still join one, so it is not always an informed choice.

Many people don't understand how unions work. A colleague in his 40s only recently learnt that you don't get paid if you're on strike. Many unions will offer an allowance from a strike fund, but your employer won't pay you.

I mean peoples ignorance isn't anyone elses fault really.

EBearhug · 01/02/2023 14:24

People choosing not to join a union isn't the same as them not existing or not being able to.

That is true, but many people don't realise that if there is no recognised union, they can still join one, so it is not always an informed choice.

Many people don't understand how unions work. A colleague in his 40s only recently learnt that you don't get paid if you're on strike. Many unions will offer an allowance from a strike fund, but your employer won't pay you.

Elsatellsa · 01/02/2023 13:55

People choosing not to join a union isn't the same as them not existing or not being able to. The reality is that most people aren't bothered by strikes unless it immediately effects them, many strikes wouldn't so they wouldn't be effective.

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 13:53

EBearhug · 01/02/2023 13:51

There is always a union to join, even if there's no recognised one. The TUC website has a union finder tool, so you can search by sector.

Yes, there are unions. But I guess I wonder what the point is to them givenmost people don't join them (EXCEPT in certain sectors). If it's mainly just legal assistance in a dispute then I guess, like pp said, it's a kind of insurance.

OP posts:
EBearhug · 01/02/2023 13:51

There is always a union to join, even if there's no recognised one. The TUC website has a union finder tool, so you can search by sector.

EBearhug · 01/02/2023 13:42

I'm in the private sector. (Well, I was. As of today, I am economically inactive.) I've been in a union for most of my working life. There aren't enough members for it to be a recognised union, (you need 30% of staff for an employer to have to recognise it, but they can choose to do so with fewer members,) so they're not involved in pay negotiations etc, and can't call for a strike.

But they have a large library of knowledge, and were absolutely invaluable when I had to go through a disciplinary (I was innocent,) and through recent redundancy - they just removed a whole level of stress from me about having to find a lawyer to review the agreement and so on.

It's like insurance - might seem waste of money most of the time, but the moment you need them, it's worth every penny. I have been very grateful for my membership when I've needed it.

fanonney · 01/02/2023 13:19

They got in a recent graduate who floundered, cost them money because they couldn't do the job properly, and later recruited someone i'd trained, at nearly my salary to dig them out of a hugely expensive hole.
They paid for my expertise and knowledge of the company. When they didn't want to do that? they lost

So they weren't doing the same job you did, were they? the recent grad did a far inferior job and the company lost out as a result.
A competitive job market sorts out shit like that, because companies who pull stunts like that lose out to ones who don't.

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 13:15

Quveas · 01/02/2023 12:58

You maybe aren't listening then if you've never heard of industrial action in the private sector? There's been plenty of it. There are millions of UK private sector workers in unions, and many unions covering all sorts of jobs. So yes, UABU, because you haven't tried very hard to find a union if you think private sector workers don't have unions in the UK.

And strike action is not the only form of industrial action either.

You are right, there has been some highly publicised ones for specific sectors - rail, aviation, postal. I’ve learnt from this thread quite a few factories and warehouses gave them too. I guess I was more thinking office works, people who don’t work for huge companies etc

im ever so sorry for trying to learn a bit more 🙄

OP posts:
Brefugee · 01/02/2023 13:02

If they can find someone to do the exact same job at half the salary, I'm probably being overpaid - in which case, how nice for me to have had that for ten years.

nope. I call bullshit
They got in a recent graduate who floundered, cost them money because they couldn't do the job properly, and later recruited someone i'd trained, at nearly my salary to dig them out of a hugely expensive hole.
They paid for my expertise and knowledge of the company. When they didn't want to do that? they lost

but you keep doig yourself down, i am perfectly happy with my terms and conditions and am well able to negotiate for myself. Others not so much. And when you need help, the unions know what they're doing.

Quveas · 01/02/2023 12:58

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 10:53

Because we never hear about any action that thery taking? I've also never come across a person IRL who is member of a union and private sector.

In my home country it's really common, I was surprised there wasn't a union to join when I started working here. Are you memebr of a union @KrisAkabusi

You maybe aren't listening then if you've never heard of industrial action in the private sector? There's been plenty of it. There are millions of UK private sector workers in unions, and many unions covering all sorts of jobs. So yes, UABU, because you haven't tried very hard to find a union if you think private sector workers don't have unions in the UK.

And strike action is not the only form of industrial action either.

DelurkingAJ · 01/02/2023 12:51

Lots of professionals have trade bodies that aren’t unions but provide some of the same benefits (eg legal assistance). So, my accountancy body (to whom I pay hefty annual fees…although my employer then covers those) would do the aid in legal situation but not pay negotiations. For a start my job isn’t standardised (and nobody else in my organisation does my role, nor would anyone elsewhere have an identical role…) so I’m not quite sure where they’d start!

fanonney · 01/02/2023 12:47

when you have given 10 years of good work and are considered too expensive and your company give you redundancy notice and recruit someone to do your exact job at half the salary?

If they can find someone to do the exact same job at half the salary, I'm probably being overpaid - in which case, how nice for me to have had that for ten years. If they're taking a hit on performance to do that - well, the market and their competitors will determine whether my work is actually worth the rate I'm being paid.

Unions are very keen on pay differentials so (at least the ones I've been involved in are). So they will negotiate, say, a baseline salary, and then increments for promotions, length of service etc etc.

I don't like length of service payments, I think they encourage stagnant mediocrity. I've worked in places where you get annual increments by default and then very occasionally you might get a second increment in one year, or a promotion. But you definitely can't have that year on year if you perform significantly better than average (and of course there is variation). So why would anyone bother trying to be really valuable? IME a promotion either involves company politics or a change of job role and so that doesn't leave any scope for just rewarding people who are doing a really good job of what they're doing.

What I am saying is that I don't think everyone doing the SAME job, should necessarily be on the SAME salary.

Exactly. Not everyone doing the "same job" does the same amount of work to the same standard. Why should that not be reflected in peoples pay.

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 12:47

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 01/02/2023 12:46

I read unions as unicorns so this thread is very disappointing!

😂Yes, in that context it certainly is. Private sector unicorns would be much more fun.

OP posts:
StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 01/02/2023 12:46

I read unions as unicorns so this thread is very disappointing!

AccidentallyRunToWindsor · 01/02/2023 12:43

Trust me, I am private sector and unions are very much a thing in my company.