Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today we strike

209 replies

Perfect28 · 01/02/2023 07:56

Aibu to ask you to support all striking workers today? Please do, however you can.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
noblegiraffe · 01/02/2023 10:47

Oh right, so those of us in the private sector just have to suck it up, but public sector employees can all have pay rises because they won't impact inflation as much?

The private sector doesn’t seem to be ‘sucking it up’ as much as the public sector.

If you are in the private sector and do not recognise that graph, then unionise like the Amazon workers are doing.

Threaten strike action like BT workers did, or Stagecoach drivers, or Fox’s Biscuits factory workers did before Christmas, all accepting a better pay deal.

Today we strike
mrshoho · 01/02/2023 10:40

Solidarity 👍.

ChristmasKraken · 01/02/2023 10:38

Perfect28 · 01/02/2023 09:43

The reason pay rises in the private sector is an inflationary pressure is because companies often fund wage rises through price increases of product or service (and rarely out of profits). Things get more expensive as a result (inflation).

This is not true in the public sector, where the services provided aren't directly paid for by the user (and are instead funded by taxation).

Oh right, so those of us in the private sector just have to suck it up, but public sector employees can all have pay rises because they won't impact inflation as much?
I don't support the strikes. Any of them. I've never agreed with it for any sector. Its the equivalent of a child stamping its feet and refusing to put its coat on because you've said they can't have another snack.

I do think education should be better funded, and that's on all of us to write to our MPs/vote differently to make that change happen. Further disrupting children's education, putting people's lives at risk etc. is not the answer.

workinmums · 01/02/2023 10:37

I've always been in support of all strikes but just in my head really. I've read a few replies on here on how to actually help. Thanks

evtheria · 01/02/2023 10:35

Stormyseasallround · 01/02/2023 09:57

Why are so many private sector workers on here so determined that we all have a race to the bottom?? If you have had stagnating wages, miserable conditions etc etc then I feel sorry for you. I can both empathise with you AND fight for better conditions for myself.

Public sector wage rises leading to higher inflation has been repeatedly disproven by economists. It’s simply a lie trotted out by the rich, and swallowed by the stupid. If it was such a massive crisis, why haven’t MPs turned down their wage rises year after year after year, in order to avoid tanking the economy??

And please let’s remember that a lot of the rights and privileges enjoyed by us all (private and public sector) only exist because of unions. Holiday pay, maternity pay, sick pay… do you think the rich of the past handed these things over to the poor workers willingly?? Of course not. Unions fought for and secured them, and we all reap the benefits.

So many valid points here.

noblegiraffe · 01/02/2023 10:19

My Y11 asked about the strikes and I asked them if they were happy about the state of the school and their teachers and they started talking about how the school was falling apart, how they hadn’t had a proper English teacher since September, loads of supply teachers in other subjects etc etc.

They can see what’s happening to education because they’re living it.

TheColourofspring · 01/02/2023 10:10

I’m on strike too. Solidarity ✊🏻

Today we strike
MrWhippersnapper · 01/02/2023 10:08

BookwormButNoTime · 01/02/2023 09:57

Conversation with my 15 year old niece who came to ours this morning as her school is closed and wanted company went something like this. She only found out her school was closed at 8am this morning as teachers refused to tell the head as to whether they were striking or not.

(Obviously not word for word…)

I really don’t understand why teachers are messing me around when my GCSEs are coming up in a few months. I feel like we only just got back to school properly again after covid. My education is a joke to these selfish people. I get that everyone is struggling for money and they would all like a pay rise, but if you have told us you were striking then we could have had a plan as to what I am going to study today. They just don’t care about us. (She then burst into tears).

This is the impact on the children. Whilst I support the strikes, she really does have a point. Teaching is a specialised profession. You wouldn’t have lawyers or accountants just ditching their clients for a day without some sort of handover or notice.

I know strikes are meant to be disruptive, but the futures of these children are being impacted when they really don’t need it. I’m not talking about protecting the future of teaching (funding and working conditions are shocking), but what about the right here right now kids being used as pawns?

Covid was not the fault of the teachers, lockdown was not the fault of the teachers, if she’s year 11 she can do revision

Stormyseasallround · 01/02/2023 10:00

If your 15 year old niece lacks the independence to be able to do a bit of self-supported revision today, then she needs to have some serious conversations with herself. My Year 11 child has heaps of stuff she’s happily revising today.

Stormyseasallround · 01/02/2023 09:57

Why are so many private sector workers on here so determined that we all have a race to the bottom?? If you have had stagnating wages, miserable conditions etc etc then I feel sorry for you. I can both empathise with you AND fight for better conditions for myself.

Public sector wage rises leading to higher inflation has been repeatedly disproven by economists. It’s simply a lie trotted out by the rich, and swallowed by the stupid. If it was such a massive crisis, why haven’t MPs turned down their wage rises year after year after year, in order to avoid tanking the economy??

And please let’s remember that a lot of the rights and privileges enjoyed by us all (private and public sector) only exist because of unions. Holiday pay, maternity pay, sick pay… do you think the rich of the past handed these things over to the poor workers willingly?? Of course not. Unions fought for and secured them, and we all reap the benefits.

BookwormButNoTime · 01/02/2023 09:57

Conversation with my 15 year old niece who came to ours this morning as her school is closed and wanted company went something like this. She only found out her school was closed at 8am this morning as teachers refused to tell the head as to whether they were striking or not.

(Obviously not word for word…)

I really don’t understand why teachers are messing me around when my GCSEs are coming up in a few months. I feel like we only just got back to school properly again after covid. My education is a joke to these selfish people. I get that everyone is struggling for money and they would all like a pay rise, but if you have told us you were striking then we could have had a plan as to what I am going to study today. They just don’t care about us. (She then burst into tears).

This is the impact on the children. Whilst I support the strikes, she really does have a point. Teaching is a specialised profession. You wouldn’t have lawyers or accountants just ditching their clients for a day without some sort of handover or notice.

I know strikes are meant to be disruptive, but the futures of these children are being impacted when they really don’t need it. I’m not talking about protecting the future of teaching (funding and working conditions are shocking), but what about the right here right now kids being used as pawns?

Perfect28 · 01/02/2023 09:54

@rrumship do you have anything valuable, helpful or meaningful to add? Any potential solutions?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/02/2023 09:52

I support them but still miffed with the disruption, because I’m angry at the govt for causing the situation

Pandaphonium · 01/02/2023 09:51

I think lots of attractions offering free entry for children today has undermined the strikes a bit to be honest. Lots of my friends and other school parents are delighted that they have been able to justify taking the day off and having a nice day out.

evtheria · 01/02/2023 09:50

I fully support educators' striking.

Colourinsidethelines · 01/02/2023 09:49

I fully support everyone striking today. I’m an ex teacher so biased but I know first hand how hard teachers work and how dedicated they are the government and media just repeatedly take the piss out them. Solidarity!

OchreDandelion · 01/02/2023 09:47

rumship · 01/02/2023 09:43

Id rather have teachers who are in it because they want to teach not fill their pockets.

Pay me more I`ll well a quit, well bye bye. 🖐

You may prefer that, but the current situation proves there are not enough people who can afford to be that generous with their time.

Caring about other people's children does not pay the ever-increasing bills that teachers - like everyone else - have to pay.

A teacher who started work in 2010 and made expected progress up the pay scales has lost £64,000 in real terms since then as salaries have fallen behind inflation. As inflation rises and pay does not, this will only get worse.

rumship · 01/02/2023 09:47

Perfect28 · 01/02/2023 09:44

Rumship your reply is so illegible you are barely communicating your point. Just goes to show how important education is I guess...

Well to say I have a very well paid job and hold a first class degree, despite having dyslexia I can say, your point is 😂

Moopsi · 01/02/2023 09:46

Cockerdileteeth · 01/02/2023 09:18

If I'm a private sector employer, pay rises will likely get passed to my customers, by putting prices up.
Public sector pay rises don't have the same direct feedback loop to market prices.

So prices will go up for everyone? That's exactly what inflation is!

Andformynexttrick · 01/02/2023 09:46

So you are saying that teachers do work more than their overall contracted hours - which are in any case much longer during term time to get the work done?

MrWhippersnapper · 01/02/2023 09:45

rumship · 01/02/2023 09:43

Id rather have teachers who are in it because they want to teach not fill their pockets.

Pay me more I`ll well a quit, well bye bye. 🖐

There is a massive recruitment and retention crisis, that is the reality.

Belladonna208 · 01/02/2023 09:45

If the sector I'm in had had the pay increases we should have had since 2010, even the lowest paid would be on about 10k more annually.

Those of you in the private sector who have had low or no pay increases, what base are you starting from? One per cent of a hundred grand is rather different from the same percentage of 12k, say.

Besides, it isn't just pay that people are striking about, it's terms and conditions and patient or pupil or passenger safety often due to chronic understaffing and lack of investment combined with the impact of Brexit, COVID and the Ukraine situation. I truly despair of how many folk on here and elsewhere whinge about so many services yet seem incapable of joining up the dots for the reasons why.

And yes I'm in a Union though where I currently live the union is so toothless the only way I could contribute personally was by taking the day off.

Which is bitterly ironic if you know anything about the industrial history of the area (north west).

Perfect28 · 01/02/2023 09:44

Rumship your reply is so illegible you are barely communicating your point. Just goes to show how important education is I guess...

OP posts:
rumship · 01/02/2023 09:43

MrWhippersnapper · 01/02/2023 09:41

Which is exactly what's happening, but who cares if there’s no one to teach your kids eh ?

Id rather have teachers who are in it because they want to teach not fill their pockets.

Pay me more I`ll well a quit, well bye bye. 🖐

Perfect28 · 01/02/2023 09:43

The reason pay rises in the private sector is an inflationary pressure is because companies often fund wage rises through price increases of product or service (and rarely out of profits). Things get more expensive as a result (inflation).

This is not true in the public sector, where the services provided aren't directly paid for by the user (and are instead funded by taxation).

OP posts: