Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should some songs never be sung again?

363 replies

Atethehalloweenchocs · 31/01/2023 21:57

I was at a social event where there was various songs which we were singing along to. One of which was Delilah. Obviously the content is abhorrent, but its a banger of a tune, and something that loads of people know. The day after, found an old playlist with a bunch of Michael Jackson stuff on. AIBU to think it is ok to sing along to a song with a good tune even if the content or artist is problematic?

OP posts:
DemiColon · 01/02/2023 10:14

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 09:16

That's an interesting point. I mean Bill Wyman and Mandy Smith was a big story but there wasn't any paedophile abuse that I remember (to be fair I was working and had two babies in that period so I might have missed it) but yes Polanski had to go on the run (I know there is a consent issue but then Mandy Smith wasn't old enough to consent was she.)

With the racism issue do you think Polanski being Jewish plays a part in that? I do think the change from him being the tragic figure with the murder of his wife and baby changing to him being evil played a part, almost like people felt he hadn't deserved their sympathy.

Very complicated things to figure out with it all.

Part of it was just that in Polanski's case he was charged with a crime.

There was a lot of bad thinking at the dawn of the sexual revolution about teenagers sex lives. Teenagers, no matter how immature they are, are often really interested in sex and having sex and having sex with rock stars. The people arguing for total sexual freedom seemed to take the view that anyone who is keen for sex should be able to do it, and hang-ups about that are people being repressed, because after all sex is natural and there isn't anything wrong with it. The music scene in particular with groupie culture was almost an experiment in that perspective - one where adults standing against it were seen as squares and behind the times.

I'd say that some of the rock gods of the period were part of that scene in a more idiotic, passive way, just like they were involved with drugs in an idiotic, unthinking way. It was around them, people thought it was great, they didn' think about it much. Someone like Bowie was fairly young himself and clearly changed his views on it as he got older.

Polanski is a different kettle of fish, if you read the stuff he wrote, he really was obsessed with teen girls in particular, and continually and into his old age seems to have been ok with what were pretty exploitative scenarios. The difference in capacity between himself and the young women seems to have been part of the attraction for him.

stayathomer · 01/02/2023 10:14

Sorry that was because of the sleazy way he sings in the song it makes me want it banned!!!

stayathomer · 01/02/2023 10:14

Baby it's Cold Outside - but I love the Ryan Kelly version
I actually heard that that was written by a husband and wife team and wasn’t what we all thought it was the base of the sleazy way he things anyway makes me want it band!!

Somebody said don’t stand so close to me-I always feel a bit weird listening to that to be honest-I don’t know how I feel about it! And as for every breath you take sting said he was at a horrendous place in his life and he regrets the song as it does what it says on the tin- it’s about him not being able to let his ex go

billycat321 · 01/02/2023 10:13

Bobby's Girl. 'If I were Bobby's girl what a faithful thankful girl I'd be. Doormat, more like. As for rap lyrics- can't make out a word they are 'singing'; terrible diction

Hellsmovie · 01/02/2023 10:11

OneEnchantedEvening · 31/01/2023 22:50

I would ban all gansta rap or whatever name the shite is known by. With its appalling references to women, killing and guns-it should never be heard, plus it's not music it's just shit.

It would be boring of we were all the same wouldnt it.

It's just music, dont like it ,dont listen

Simples

Banditrules · 01/02/2023 10:08

Howaboutthisonehenry · 01/02/2023 08:42

‘young girl, get out of my mind’ was the one I was thinking about!

Think awful lyrics don’t deserve to be listened to, but kind of pointless banning these- they’ll die off with the 69’s generation.

I love ‘Billie Jean’ and ‘Thriller’ so as much as I detest Michael Jackson and his actions, I won’t drop from my playlist!!

Because where do you draw the line? So many artists/ composers had dodgy views and behaviours that weren’t right even in their day, but a good tune is a good tune!

The chorus from a Plan B song samples the lyrics from Young Girl so it may not die out as quickly as you think!

Talia99 · 01/02/2023 10:07

Ludo19 · 01/02/2023 08:04

"Every breath you take" has a stalker element too

I thought it was meant to be about a stalker and the band was completely boggled by it being taken up as a romantic anthem

LydiaBin · 01/02/2023 10:04

I feel as if we're entering a very literal age, where everything is judged at absolute face value, regardless of context. You're not meant to admire the narrator of Delilah, or Don't Stand So Close to Me - they're songs about people caught in terrible situations.

Kanaloa · 01/02/2023 10:02

Scooopsahoy · 01/02/2023 09:20

It’s a really interesting dilemma. There’s a lot of posters here saying they could never listen to lostprophets again as the lead singer is a convicted paedophile. Which is obviously understandable.

But would it be different if it was the bassist who had been convinced? Or the lead sound engineer or producer? Or the record label owner? These will all be making money/ royalties from the music. Should we never listen to anything producer by Phil Spector?

I think there’s some emotional connection when we listen to a vocalist that means we hold them to certain standards we don do with other musicians or people in the music business more generally.

This is what I meant but said much better! Yes, there is a weird sort of connection with a lead singer that people don’t seem to feel quite the same for other artists.

Kanaloa · 01/02/2023 10:00

Chouetted · 01/02/2023 07:18

I've never quite recovered from going to see Titus Andronicus as a teenager Confused

I think there is a difference in people’s perceptions of like a Shakespeare play and a song by a paedophile though. In TA, Shakespeare is specifically leaving a warning for those who seek out revenge journeys. Same with Othello - he is pointing out the dangers of jealousy and how it can make it easy to be manipulated. So the audience knows this isn’t the author/playwright’s true views being presented - it’s fictional and often showing the dangers of certain behaviours. But when it’s a musician I think people often see them as speaking directly through the song. So then they feel ‘tricked’ or something because they’ve sung along to a song by someone who turned out to be a rapist or similar. It’s weird, maybe it’s because there’s a more personal connection between a singer and the listener.

I mean for me I’ll listen to almost anything anyway. The only song I don’t listen to is PIMP. I like the tune but I find the lyrics absolutely horrible, and so gleeful.

DemiColon · 01/02/2023 10:00

Ludo19 · 01/02/2023 08:04

"Every breath you take" has a stalker element too

But so what?

It describes a pretty common human experience of obsessional love. Something that both men and women do sometimes. Even people who don't go that far in their behaviour often have the experience of their having to pull themselves up when their emotions try and push them in that direction.

Do people really think artistic output should only be about people behaving impeccably, or that if it shows morally problematic things, the bad people need to be shown to be punished?

Helenahandkart · 01/02/2023 10:00

MrsGhandi · 01/02/2023 01:25

How about?

You're so hot, teasing me
So, you're blue, but I can't take a chance on a chick like you
That's something I couldn't do
There's that look in your eyes
I can read in your face that your feelings are driving you wild
Ah, but girl, you're only a child
Well, I can dance with you, honey, if you think it's funny
Does your mother know that you're out?
And I can chat with you, baby, flirt a little maybe
Does your mother know that you're out?
Take it easy (take it easy)
Better slow down, girl
That's no way to go
Does your mother know?

Being sung every night at the Abba Arena.

That song is very clearly about underage girls trying to get it on with the ABBA men, and the ABBA men turning them down because they’re too young.
It’s the exact opposite of sleazy men getting it on with 13 year olds.
It literally tells them to stop and go home to their mums.

LydiaBin · 01/02/2023 09:51

My DM was always baffled about the modern outrage over Baby It's Cold Outside: at the time, she claimed, it was assumed that the woman wanted to stay just as much as the man did, but had to find a 'reason' because of judgemental parents/brothers/aunts, etc. Yes, it's sad that women had to resort to coy excuses to avoid judgement, but she wasn't clawing at the door to avoid Dean Martin's rohypnol.

Diverging · 01/02/2023 09:44

Kate Bush even replaced Rolf's contributions with those of her son on one of the re-releases of her albums (Aerial?).

I’m really conflicted about this one because the original version with Rolf’s voice is so much better. His voice just suits the music. The newer version with her son’s voice just doesn’t work and I find it unlistenable. So I always go back to the original and then of course the Rolf issue intrudes into the music.
She should have replaced him with someone who had a more suitable, aged characterful voice similar to the original imo.

Dotjones · 01/02/2023 09:42

I think provided there are no royalties being paid to an artist who is a convicted paedophile or similar lowlife there's no harm in songs being played. Just because something seems inappropriate now doesn't mean it has no merit.

To argue that no Michael Jackson songs should be played on the radio is like arguing we shouldn't be wearing seatbelts because Jimmy Savile starred in "clunk click every trip" adverts telling us to do so. Yes he was a disgusting paedophile who abused countless victims but you have to separate the art and the artist's message from their crimes.

Put another way, I'd prefer someone to survive a car crash because they had worn a seatbelt despite Jimmy Savile's offences than them die because they hadn't.

CockSpadget · 01/02/2023 09:41

Elderflower14 · 01/02/2023 08:37

Oliver's Army... Uses the n....r word!

There are thousands of tracks that use that word.

WinterFoxes · 01/02/2023 09:38

@SecretPeston - how is Come On Eileen vile rapey lyrics? He says she's grown up now and he really fancies her in that dress. It's not rapey to lust after someone and want them to take their clothes off.

SecretPeston · 01/02/2023 09:35

Come on Eileen and Tonight's the Night - both vile, underage rapey lyrics. Should be banned.

Diverging · 01/02/2023 09:34

It’s when I catch myself muttering what’s a matter you, hey, gotta no respect. Whadaya think you do hey. That I realise my life has gone very wrong somewhere.

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 09:33

LoveMyPiano · 31/01/2023 23:56

Not singing as such in this case: I learnt the piano many many years ago, and my g/mother would often buy me the sheet music for popular pieces of the day. I was going trough all my music recently and found the music for "Two Little Boys" by RH. Fortunately, my piano shares the office space, and there is a shredder right alongside.....

Also (even though I was late to the getting my own record player party), my first 45rpm single was "Angel Face" by The Glitter Band.
The shame.

My taste in music has improved somewhat, Thank God.

Rolf Harris didn't write the music or lyrics though did he? I can remember when he was first singing it and he said it was an old American piece.

BellePeppa · 01/02/2023 09:32

WinterFoxes · 01/02/2023 09:20

I've never understood this either. Bowie is still revered but others are villified. Why? What makes one manipulative rock star a filthy paedophile/hebephile and another absolutely unimpeachable? Is it just that no one wants to stop listening to Bowie and the Stones whereas ditching Gary Glitter and Michael Jackson is an easier decision?

I think the main difference is the groupies culture back then. There were a lot of very eager groupies in those days and age was probably never mentioned. Not defending that of course but I don’t think Bowie was ever a danger on the street to girls. I would imagine looking back he was could have been appalled at the lack of his own boundaries in the 1970s rock culture. I can listen to Bowie but I can’t listen to Glitter.

vera99 · 01/02/2023 09:30

StoneofDestiny · 31/01/2023 22:52

God save the King/Queen shouldn't be sung. A whole lot of nonsense that encourages subservience of citizens and reinforces the ridiculous role of royals

Cross forum bleed I love 💘 it. None the anthem its a terrible dirge of a tune.

Brokenmiata · 01/02/2023 09:28

Music is music. If you didn't listen to it because the artist was questionable at some point, you'd have no one to listen to.

CousinKrispy · 01/02/2023 09:28

That's a good question about Polanski and whether racism plays a part in how he's been treated, but I'm very uncomfortable with this line of thought. My understanding is that he was convicted in a court of law of plying a 13 year old with quaaludes and alcohol and anally raping her while she resisted. I'm perfectly comfortable with audiences or colleagues turning their backs on him. I guess the issue is why isn't that done with other figures. Ugh.

That said I am a big believer in separating the art from the artist, and understanding that art can be used to depict bad things, because art is for depicting the whole range of human life, not just the pretty parts. The example of opera made above is a good one.

Branleuse · 01/02/2023 09:27

WinterFoxes · 01/02/2023 09:20

I've never understood this either. Bowie is still revered but others are villified. Why? What makes one manipulative rock star a filthy paedophile/hebephile and another absolutely unimpeachable? Is it just that no one wants to stop listening to Bowie and the Stones whereas ditching Gary Glitter and Michael Jackson is an easier decision?

I think the groupie scene was clearly exploitative, but are you really saying its comparable to Gary Glitter hiring trafficked young children to rape in third world countries, or Ian Watkins raping babies?