Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should some songs never be sung again?

363 replies

Atethehalloweenchocs · 31/01/2023 21:57

I was at a social event where there was various songs which we were singing along to. One of which was Delilah. Obviously the content is abhorrent, but its a banger of a tune, and something that loads of people know. The day after, found an old playlist with a bunch of Michael Jackson stuff on. AIBU to think it is ok to sing along to a song with a good tune even if the content or artist is problematic?

OP posts:
SinisterBumFacedCat · 01/02/2023 13:59

Delilah always reminds me of Carmen. It feels a bit hypocritical to cancel songs about murder whilst crime fiction, true crime podcasts and tv shows are having a massive boom in popularity, especially amongst women.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 01/02/2023 13:55

Her Daddy

Should some songs never be sung again?
Copper80 · 01/02/2023 13:54

Delilah is based on the bible story! Read it.

Kanaloa · 01/02/2023 13:49

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/02/2023 13:26

I always thought it was 'her daddy' at the time.

I mean even if it was ‘your daddy’ it’s still not the best message ever, is it? That rich men will treat you nicely and make an effort, and poor men will just try it on with you!

I don’t think I’ve ever thought about lyrics so carefully 😂

Copper80 · 01/02/2023 13:47

Sorry but bowie did not go with 13 year olds.

HectorPlasm · 01/02/2023 13:39

MargotMoon · 31/01/2023 22:34

Whenever I see the band name 'Showaddywaddy' written down I say it in my head in Jimmy Savile's voice and find it funny. I can't help it but I know it's wrong

Ooops - me too!

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/02/2023 13:26

NewspaperTaxis · 01/02/2023 11:17

I feel a bit defensive about this top tune, it comes up on these kind of threads a lot for the reason you give, but isn't the lyric 'If YOUR Daddy's rich... If YOUR Daddy's poor' as in, if you can afford to take her out for a meal, if you're from a. wealthy family, fine do that but otherwise just hang loose. Instead it gets interpreted as, if she's wealthy you may as well spend money on her, otherwise don't bother and see what you can get away with sexually as she can't afford a lawyer to sue you!

I always thought it was 'her daddy' at the time.

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/02/2023 13:24

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 12:08

I don't know if there was much talk about Bowie and underage girls in the 70s, I think the accusations came later but again I can't swear to it as I wasn't taking much notice of what was said about him.

I didn't think there were allegations as much as boasts.

LoveMyPiano · 01/02/2023 13:21

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 09:33

Rolf Harris didn't write the music or lyrics though did he? I can remember when he was first singing it and he said it was an old American piece.

No he didn't - but is isn't music I would reach for nowadays anyway. His association with it though, is what doomed it to the shredder. Also, rare for me, as I would never actually dispose of sheet music - I have a copy of The Londonderry Air from my Great-grandmother's childhood!
(Wracks brain wondering of the writer, composer or lyrics to that are offensive....)

Steviebrown · 01/02/2023 12:56

I typed up a long post that for some reason MN decided to withhold for review. Goodness knows why. I pointed out that Oliver's Army was written in 1978 as a scathing political comment on the situation in Northern Ireland. The phrase "one less white n**r" reflected the anger behind the song.

If we're going to censor the Police song about a stalker, or Tom Jones for singing a song about a man who murdered his two-timing partner - what about fictional novels? The writers of books and poetry aren't recommending or endorsing murder, nor are they saying they would commit murder - they are writing about a situation that they imagined. Sometimes they write based on their feelings about a real life situation. That's what song writers do.
How far do we want to erase art and imagination? Control what people imagine or choose to think about?
I live with a musician who is retired from performing but still writing songs for other artists. He's constantly wandering about thinking of situations he's heard about, or imagined, or speculated about and pondering turning them into words and music. He's not a jealous man, but he writes about jealousy. He's not a young man out looking for a hot woman (any more) but he can write about it. 😂

Aprilx · 01/02/2023 12:49

WestOfWestminster · 31/01/2023 22:25

Are we ruling out anything by Rolf Harris? No real loss there.

My sister bought a painting by Rolf Harris, before his crimes were revealed. It made my skin crawl that she kept this painting up afterwards though.

cstaff · 01/02/2023 12:47

My dad's party piece used to be "You're 16, you're beautiful and your mine....". About 10 years ago or more my mam started to make comments about it being inappropriate but she never said anything to him - just me afaik. Not sure where I stood on it tbh - until now when this thread started.

Woo
You come on like a dream
Peaches and cream
Lips like strawberry wine
You're sixteen, you're beautiful and you're mine (ooh, mine all mine)
You're all ribbons and curls (ooh)
Ooh, what a girl (ooh)
Eyes that sparkle and shine (ooh)
You're sixteen, you're beautiful and you're mine (ooh)
Mine all mine, mine, mine, mine

You're my baby, you're my pet (ooh wah, wah)
We fell in love on the night we met (ooh wah, wah, wah)
You touched my hand, my heart went pop (ooh)
Ooh, when we kissed I could not stop (ooh)
You walked out of my dreams, and into my arms (ahh)
Now you're my angel divine (ahh)
You're sixteen, you're beautiful and you're mine (ooh wah, wah, wah)
You're my baby, you're my pet (ooh wah, wah, wah)
We fell in love on the night we met (ooh, we fell in love)
You touched my hand, my heart went pop (ooh what a night, ooh what a night)
Ooh, when we kissed I could not stop (ooh-ooh)
You walked out of my dreams, and into my car (ahh)
Now you're my angel divine
You're sixteen, you're beautiful, and you're mine (ooh wah, wah, wah)
You're sixteen, you're beautiful, and you're mine (ooh wah, wah, wah)
You're sixteen, so beautiful, and you're mine (ooh wah, wah, wah)
All mine, all mine, all mine (ooh wah, wah, wah)
All mine, all mine, all mine (ooh wah, wah, wah)

gogohmm · 01/02/2023 12:18

@PortiasBiscuit

Actually a lot of opera has dubious storylines- great music though

MrsHughesPinny · 01/02/2023 12:14

I grew up with a couple of the lads from Lostprophets (not the one who needs to be shot out of a large cannon directly into the sun) and I do feel bad for them. Their careers ruined, their music can never be listened to again and they’re marred forever by association with that monster.

gogohmm · 01/02/2023 12:09

I remember mick jagger saying in an interview, girls were throwing themselves at them each night, sneaking into their hotel rooms - if asked they would claim to be over 26 but they never checked their passports for their ages. He said he wasn't proud of their behaviour with such young girls but they were young themselves and couldn't believe their luck, plus drunk and stoned.

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 12:08

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/02/2023 11:51

I'm not aware of any complaints about Bowie though. I know there is the issue of consent but I was 15 in 1970 and maybe see some of these things differently. Gary Glitter, Rolf Harris etc were completely different.

I don't know if there was much talk about Bowie and underage girls in the 70s, I think the accusations came later but again I can't swear to it as I wasn't taking much notice of what was said about him.

Rosscameasdoody · 01/02/2023 12:02

Dis626 · 01/02/2023 10:52

This!

And no meaningful society left. Just generations isolated, brainwashed, and afraid to speak their minds or strive for the truth in case they are labelled racist, sexist, misogynist or multi phobic. Makes George Orwell seem optimistic !!

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 12:00

TheMarzipanDildo · 01/02/2023 11:04

I really like the book/film Georgy Girl. Clothes are the least of her issues really.

Was that the film with Lynn Redgrave? I can't remember much of it, saw it over 50 years ago, but I do remember I liked it at the time. It was about quite complicated relationships if I remember rightly with Georgy ending up with a husband and baby, the baby not really being hers.

sentientpuddle · 01/02/2023 11:58

I don't understand the problem with Delilah. I can understand having a problem with Tom Jones being the singer though.
It's a story, a work of fiction, based on a dark mind and dark act that someone is capable of. It doesn't mean it's the sentiment or desires of the author, like any work of fiction. I don't imagine you would read a murder mystery book and think that it shouldn't be read or that the author was abhorrent, for having the imagination to put those thoughts and words on paper.
Think of traditional murder ballads, like Down in the Willow Garden by The Everly Brothers .
Many people seem to think that art should be separated from the artist but surely the two things cannot be mutually exclusive. I love how Nick Cave talks about this.

A fictional act may well be reflective of what’s in the mind of the author, and lyrics are a way to safely express that, an acceptable outlet, or they may be pure fiction, but I think ‘so I poisoned that dear little girl’ is not the same as ‘you’re such a good girl, you know you want it’ which, to my mind, is abhorrent. I listen to a radio station in the car that plays Rod Stewart’s ‘Tonight’s the Night’ now & again. I have to change the station. It’s fucking sick. I’ve never known Rod to be questioned on it.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 01/02/2023 11:51

Cuppasoupmonster · 31/01/2023 22:24

You can’t help an ear worm but I wouldn’t play it if it was lostprophets for example…

I feel really sorry for the other members of the band but you just can't listen to their music without thinking of that evil bastard.

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/02/2023 11:51

BellePeppa · 01/02/2023 09:32

I think the main difference is the groupies culture back then. There were a lot of very eager groupies in those days and age was probably never mentioned. Not defending that of course but I don’t think Bowie was ever a danger on the street to girls. I would imagine looking back he was could have been appalled at the lack of his own boundaries in the 1970s rock culture. I can listen to Bowie but I can’t listen to Glitter.

I'm not aware of any complaints about Bowie though. I know there is the issue of consent but I was 15 in 1970 and maybe see some of these things differently. Gary Glitter, Rolf Harris etc were completely different.

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 11:50

NewspaperTaxis · 01/02/2023 11:31

I have a theory about this - some are part of the New Establishment. If so, their public disgrace incriminates and reflects poorly on the general public - it makes them look foolish and whole swathes of their upbringing have to be deleted. History has to be rewritten, almost. The State will want to avoid that.

It's easy enough to eliminate Jimmy Savile because he fronted some TV shows, he didn't create anything, no records or movies. Ditto Rolf Harris really.
Ironically, the likes of Sir Cliff Richard, Freddie Starr and Paul Gambaccuni got it in the neck because they are Old Establishment. They hadn't done anything wrong, nor Leon Britton or Field Marshall Lord Bramall, but the police went after them - in my opinion as a misdirection tactic to distract from the number of grooming gangs, rings really in various local authorities, almost certainly overseen by them and the police. Okay, the police might have found something - they were on a fishing expedition - but really they could be thrown under a bus. Sir Cliff's records weren't being played much, he hadn't done much to keep himself relevant, he avoids interviews with the music press. If he's really been part of a paedophile ring with extensive links I'd never expect the Met to go after him - they had no form on this. They'd cover it up, more likely. Dame Cressida Dick sat on a file linking serial killer Levi Bellfield to care homes, and Lambeth paedophile activity in its care homes was suppressed for decades. Again, links between Prince Andrew and Epstein were coming to light around this time, so they may have been into misdirection.

Anyway, the surviving Beatles, Stones, Who, Bowie - they were never likely to go after them, whether the allegations are fictional or not. Others in the bracket will be Take That, Duran Duran, Spandau Ballet. Ironically these are the New Establishment - you don't take them down. They enjoy the privileges that used to be afforded MPs, Royals, the upper classes and so on. While some members of the Royal Family like Prince Andrew, they're Old Establishment and generally seen as fair game.

Wow, lot to take in there. I think I'll need to read it again.

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 01/02/2023 11:50

I volunteered with the Rotary club including at Christmas when we visited local areas with Santa and his sleigh. I'd take my DC, (collecting funds for local children's charities) and when they got tired they'd jump on the sleigh. Christmas songs would play from speakers.

I have a video of DC happily riding along waving. This was around ten years ago. It was only recently I played it for DC and noticed Gary Glitter singing. I think the title is 'Rock and roll Christmas.' The video was taken years after he was outed.

pigsinoodies · 01/02/2023 11:43

LoveMyPiano · 01/02/2023 01:22

But I am aware that Two Little Boys is the story of the lives of two boys and their paths through life, and death in the case of one of them. I always would learn the words as I played, and I was at an age when they became ingrained.
I still don't want to play it any more though.
I recently started to play "Childhood" by Michael Jackson, which of course, is his own plea for understanding.

I was listening to a programme about Beethoven the other day, who was a brilliant but troubled human being. And everyone loves a bit of Beethoven!

Not the point of the thread at all but I don't think anyone dies in Two Little Boys? Jack rescues Joe - he doesn't leave him dying.

CousinKrispy · 01/02/2023 11:40

ScribblingPixie · 01/02/2023 11:07

Hey there, Georgy girl
Swinging down the street so fancy-free
Nobody you meet could ever see the loneliness there inside you
Hey there, Georgy girl
Why do all the boys just pass you by?

Jim Dale from the Carry On films wrote the lyrics!

Oh I didn't know this, thank you!

Urgh now it's stuck in my head again ... but Judith Durham had such an effortless voice.