Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should some songs never be sung again?

363 replies

Atethehalloweenchocs · 31/01/2023 21:57

I was at a social event where there was various songs which we were singing along to. One of which was Delilah. Obviously the content is abhorrent, but its a banger of a tune, and something that loads of people know. The day after, found an old playlist with a bunch of Michael Jackson stuff on. AIBU to think it is ok to sing along to a song with a good tune even if the content or artist is problematic?

OP posts:
piggypoole · 01/02/2023 22:18

DontTouchMePlease · 31/01/2023 22:17

Gary Glitter -Leader of the gang.
sometimes it pops into my head and I find myself singing
”Come on, come on, come on, come on, come on, come on..”
Then I remember he’s a filthy paedophile and his foot stomping tune from the 70’s, played at our primary school discos, isn’t one I should be singing.

He signs I'm the one who put the bang in gang ugh

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2023 22:17

ancientgran · 01/02/2023 10:43

I haven't read anything by Polanski so didn't know that.

I also wonder what the parents were thinking, I remember Mandy Smith's mother seemed quite happy with the relationship, with the Polanski case I vaguely remember the 13 year old was at his home for him to take photos, she was unhappy as previous session had involved topless or nude photos and yet she was there without a chaperone. It doesn't excuse Wyman or the Polanski but it does seem odd to say the least.

Sorry bit off topic.

Mandy Smith's mother married Bill Wyman's son...

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2023 22:15

stayathomer · 01/02/2023 10:23

Did many people know about the Delilah song? How did it get so popular? (And how was the melody used in a weetabix ad?!)

Well, one thing you can say about Tom Jones and his songs is that you can generally hear every word.

But I just don't think that people thought too much about what the song was saying

Kanaloa · 01/02/2023 22:14

FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 22:00

But isn't the whole point of this song to make you initially think it's a romantic song until you realise Clair is little girl? It's whole intention is to play with the listener!

It was a big trend at the time. Songs like Save All Your Kisses or Memphis, Tennessee etc build up a ‘romantic’ storyline then reveal at some point they are actually talking about a daughter/child. So in Memphis, Tennessee he’s singing about a girl calling him and he missed the call, and how he was torn apart from his special girl because her ‘mom didn’t agree’ then it’s revealed Marie is his 6yo daughter.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/02/2023 22:12

Honper · 01/02/2023 00:09

You'd have to go a long way to find an artiste/group that didn't do a single objectionable thing or sing a single objectionable line, really.

From cousin-fucking to teen grooming, to mafia lording, to turf shootings, the tunes you listen to and films you watch are made by flawed people living lives of excess. This is why parents didn't want their daughters seeing Elvis on telly 70 years ago. It's rock and roll and celebrity and it's never been known for clean living.

If you want that, go and listen to a nice bit of Gregorian chant. Although, the church hardly has lily white hands ...

Neither did the composers - OK, it's Renaissance polyphony rather than Gregorian chant, but Gesualdo definitely counts as an arsehole, for a start.

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2023 22:11

CockSpadget · 01/02/2023 09:41

There are thousands of tracks that use that word.

There was a Checkpoint Charlie
He didn't crack a smile
But it's no laughing party
When you've been on the murder mile
Only takes one itchy trigger
One more widow one less white n*r
Oliver's Army is here to stay
Oliver's Army are on their way
And I would rather be anywhere else
than here today

About NI and the British troops

ScribblingPixie · 01/02/2023 22:08

Claire was written by Gilbert O'Sullivan as a gift to her parents, about the nightmare of babysitting her (together with her brothers and sisters; she was the little naughty one) yet how adorable she was. They're still in touch.

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2023 22:07

CousinKrispy · 01/02/2023 09:23

That is so amazingly crap!! Thank you for sharing, it's given me a laugh.

Reminds me a bit of The Seekers' song:
Hey there, Georgy girl
Swinging down the street so fancy-free
Nobody you meet could ever see the loneliness there inside you
Hey there, Georgy girl
Why do all the boys just pass you by?
Could it be you just don't try or is it the clothes you wear?
You're always window shopping but never stopping to buy
So shed those dowdy feathers and fly a little bit

I find the lyrics so cringey but it's a really compelling tune!

And was the theme to a very famous film of the time

FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 22:00

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:49

Look up the lyrics

But isn't the whole point of this song to make you initially think it's a romantic song until you realise Clair is little girl? It's whole intention is to play with the listener!

ScribblingPixie · 01/02/2023 21:59

Like Jimi Hendrix' Voodoo Chile/Child. It doesn't literally mean child.

ReneBumsWombats · 01/02/2023 21:54

SecretPeston · 01/02/2023 19:50

"Don't say a word, my virgin child" kind of suggests that he is referring to a young person.

Read the lyrics again.

I didn't really spot that. "Child" is often used in song lyrics in the same way as "baby".

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:49

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:29

Clare by Gilbert O'Sullivan Ugh

Look up the lyrics

notacooldad · 01/02/2023 21:45

Once we have exhausted the songs we shouldn't be listening to and artists that have a questionable moral compass should we stop using inventions by brilliant but flawed inventors?

Butteredtoast55 · 01/02/2023 21:34

MargotMoon · 31/01/2023 22:34

Whenever I see the band name 'Showaddywaddy' written down I say it in my head in Jimmy Savile's voice and find it funny. I can't help it but I know it's wrong

This really made me laugh and that's probably even wronger! 😂

notacooldad · 01/02/2023 21:33

I've always been a bit uncomfortable with the "come on Eileen" lyrics
Why? I never thought it was sung ( character wise) by an older creepy bloke but by a peer of 'Eileen'

lollipoprainbow · 01/02/2023 21:31

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:29

Clare by Gilbert O'Sullivan Ugh

Urgh why ?? So predictable

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:31

Don't hear under my thumb anymore

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:29

Clare by Gilbert O'Sullivan Ugh

Atethehalloweenchocs · 01/02/2023 21:28

Had to step away from the computer after I posted so just getting back to it now - thanks for all the interesting comments. For the record, I dont believe in censorship and understand attitudes change over time so lyrics and stories in older songs may not reflect current values. I only used Tom Jones and Delilah as an example as it was sung at an event I went to, and I enjoyed it- but of course there has been a lot of news recently about violence towards women which made me reflect on the lyrics in a way I had not before (btw it is not clear that it is his partner - he says she was his woman but could have just decided that, and it is pretty clear he feels justified in killing her. Also clear how many people have never really thought about the lyrics before, which is where I was). And MJ came up on a play list the next day when I was thinking about this. I agree that if we hold the past to the attitudes of the current we would eliminate so much art. Better to understand it with thoughtful commentary about why this is out of date. Makes me think about pulling down statues too, but I think that is a whole other debate. And for the person who called me a puritan, er, ok, not sure how you got there but whatever.

OP posts:
FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 19:58

You do all know 16 year olds have sex, and it's perfectly legal!

FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 19:57

Songs aren't written as a mantra to live your life by!

Tom Jones (and whoever wrote Delilah) wasn't suggesting that killing your girlfriend if she cheats on you is the right thing to do! It's just a story told from the perspective of the killer, that's all. It's a great tune, with a dramatic story line which is why it's so popular.

Likewise, 'Living Doll' isn't suggesting that it's ok to lock girls in trunks, it's an acknowledgement that dolls are kept in trunks (toy chests) and he's likening his girlfriend to a doll as she's so beautiful. And at the end of the day it's only a fun song and trunk rhymes with hunk. Best version ever was the comic relief version with Cliff andThe Young Ones. 😁

SecretPeston · 01/02/2023 19:50

ReneBumsWombats · 01/02/2023 17:13

I just looked up the lyrics and I don't see the problem? He's saying she's a virgin but no suggestion that she's a child or unconsenting?

"Don't say a word, my virgin child" kind of suggests that he is referring to a young person.

Read the lyrics again.

FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 19:44

LydiaBin · 01/02/2023 09:51

My DM was always baffled about the modern outrage over Baby It's Cold Outside: at the time, she claimed, it was assumed that the woman wanted to stay just as much as the man did, but had to find a 'reason' because of judgemental parents/brothers/aunts, etc. Yes, it's sad that women had to resort to coy excuses to avoid judgement, but she wasn't clawing at the door to avoid Dean Martin's rohypnol.

Exactly this!

FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 19:42

Marigoldandivy · 01/02/2023 08:21

Living Doll, Cliff Richard. ‘Gonna lock her up in a trunk….’ Ick.

Ha ha ha, if you're taking this song seriously enough to be upset about it then we do not live on the same planet!

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/02/2023 19:10

fortheloveofflowers · 01/02/2023 19:02

@KimberleyClark well the tune is quite a happy tune but he is talking about stabbing her. I've never paid that much attention to the words before that's all.

I never heard it as a happy tune. It's supposed to be anguished, desperate. I agree with people who consider it in the same way as any other work of fiction like a novel or a poem. It's not advocating murder.