Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should some songs never be sung again?

363 replies

Atethehalloweenchocs · 31/01/2023 21:57

I was at a social event where there was various songs which we were singing along to. One of which was Delilah. Obviously the content is abhorrent, but its a banger of a tune, and something that loads of people know. The day after, found an old playlist with a bunch of Michael Jackson stuff on. AIBU to think it is ok to sing along to a song with a good tune even if the content or artist is problematic?

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 02/02/2023 10:58

PortiasBiscuit · 02/02/2023 10:20

As to “Clare” I think he’s meant to be her Dad or her uncle or something. It’s a bit sick that people think otherwise. You might as well get offended by “ Save all your kisses for me” by Brotherhood of Man.

“Clare” was his manager’s daughter that he used to babysit.

Neither his manager nor “Clare” ever had any issues with the song.

PortiasBiscuit · 02/02/2023 10:20

As to “Clare” I think he’s meant to be her Dad or her uncle or something. It’s a bit sick that people think otherwise. You might as well get offended by “ Save all your kisses for me” by Brotherhood of Man.

IdidntshagHarry · 02/02/2023 10:14

Gary Glitter songs, Rolf Harris, other various men that have then gone on to commit crimes against children there are a few I don't recall the names.

pam290358 · 02/02/2023 08:27

Welsh rugby have banned fans from singing Delilah at matches. Don’t know how they’re going to enforce that one.

pam290358 · 02/02/2023 08:26

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 05:32

So was OJ Simpson found Not Guilty. You honestly think OJ didn't kill his ex? Child sexual abuse cases are notoriously difficult to prosecute when it's strangers, let alone rich and famous people. Men especially don't lie about things like this, they don't even want to admit it to themselves (speaking as the daughter of a man abused by a priest).

If someone is found guilty in a court of law, you have to abide by it, otherwise what’s the point of the justice system. Whether or not you think Jackson, or OJ were guilty is of no consequence because the jury had access to all the facts when they made their decision. The general public didn’t.

ancientgran · 02/02/2023 08:18

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 08:13

I'm aware of that but there there is a difference between that, and a girl being violently anally raped. A big difference. What Polanski did when he violently attacked that girl was traumatic.

We don't know how the other girls felt, pressured? Drugged? Drunk? We don't know how it affected them afterwards when they realised how they had been used and abused. Doesn't lessen what Polanski did but it shouldn't mean we give the others a pass. Laws are there for a reason.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 08:13

ancientgran · 02/02/2023 08:00

A 13 year old can't give consent, they were also raped.

I'm aware of that but there there is a difference between that, and a girl being violently anally raped. A big difference. What Polanski did when he violently attacked that girl was traumatic.

CaptainMyCaptain · 02/02/2023 08:04

FancyFanny · 01/02/2023 22:00

But isn't the whole point of this song to make you initially think it's a romantic song until you realise Clair is little girl? It's whole intention is to play with the listener!

I've never liked Gilbert O'Sullivan or his lyrics but this song is quite innocent. A Woman's Place is in the Home is much worse.

ancientgran · 02/02/2023 08:00

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 06:26

You're missing the point though. Jagger's and Bowie's girls may have wanted it but Polanski's girl sure did not. She was RAPED. It wasn't consentual.

A 13 year old can't give consent, they were also raped.

CaptainMyCaptain · 02/02/2023 07:18

notacooldad · 01/02/2023 21:33

I've always been a bit uncomfortable with the "come on Eileen" lyrics
Why? I never thought it was sung ( character wise) by an older creepy bloke but by a peer of 'Eileen'

Me too. I loved it when it came out. I didn't find it at all creepy.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 06:26

Ponoka7 · 01/02/2023 14:33

Mike Jagger and Bowie both confessed to having sex with 13 year old groupies. Chrissie Hynde defended it because she claims it was what the girls wanted. There was drinking and drug taking. Both were given to the girls. When you consider how Polanski was pursued (I'm not saying that is wrong) yet so many others ignored, the stuff around it being because he is Jewish does ring true.

You're missing the point though. Jagger's and Bowie's girls may have wanted it but Polanski's girl sure did not. She was RAPED. It wasn't consentual.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 05:59

Clawdy · 01/02/2023 08:51

On a lighter note, a Bacharach song by Jack Jones, big hit in the sixties, "Wives And Lovers" :
"Hey, little girl, comb your hair, fix your makeup
Soon he will open the door
Don't think because there's a ring on your finger
You needn't try any more
For wives should always be lovers too
Run to his arms the moment he comes home to you
Dim all the lights, pour the wine, start the music
Time to get ready for love."

I always think of the movie The 1st Wives Club when I read/hear those lyrics.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 02/02/2023 05:32

JustWantedACat · 01/02/2023 08:12

Michael Jackson was found not guilty, Jimmy Saville was never arrested or charged as his crimes only came to public light after his death. If you think Jackson was guilty that's your opinion not a fact because the fact was he was found not guilty in a court of law.

So was OJ Simpson found Not Guilty. You honestly think OJ didn't kill his ex? Child sexual abuse cases are notoriously difficult to prosecute when it's strangers, let alone rich and famous people. Men especially don't lie about things like this, they don't even want to admit it to themselves (speaking as the daughter of a man abused by a priest).

Chouetted · 02/02/2023 04:42

Zebedee55 · 02/02/2023 04:40

Wales RFU have now banned Delilah from being sung at the Six Nations tournament, or future events.

Good luck with that idea - fans generally sing what they want to. 🙄

news.sky.com/story/welsh-rugby-union-bans-delilah-being-sung-at-principality-stadium-12800771

From the link you posted - "While "Delilah" has been banned from the WRU's official playlists there hasn't been any restrictions on fans singing the song."

Zebedee55 · 02/02/2023 04:40

Wales RFU have now banned Delilah from being sung at the Six Nations tournament, or future events.

Good luck with that idea - fans generally sing what they want to. 🙄

news.sky.com/story/welsh-rugby-union-bans-delilah-being-sung-at-principality-stadium-12800771

Chouetted · 02/02/2023 04:02

Atethehalloweenchocs · 01/02/2023 21:28

Had to step away from the computer after I posted so just getting back to it now - thanks for all the interesting comments. For the record, I dont believe in censorship and understand attitudes change over time so lyrics and stories in older songs may not reflect current values. I only used Tom Jones and Delilah as an example as it was sung at an event I went to, and I enjoyed it- but of course there has been a lot of news recently about violence towards women which made me reflect on the lyrics in a way I had not before (btw it is not clear that it is his partner - he says she was his woman but could have just decided that, and it is pretty clear he feels justified in killing her. Also clear how many people have never really thought about the lyrics before, which is where I was). And MJ came up on a play list the next day when I was thinking about this. I agree that if we hold the past to the attitudes of the current we would eliminate so much art. Better to understand it with thoughtful commentary about why this is out of date. Makes me think about pulling down statues too, but I think that is a whole other debate. And for the person who called me a puritan, er, ok, not sure how you got there but whatever.

See, I don't why you think it is out of date.

Delilah will be out of date when women are no longer killed, not before.

I still feel the narrator is very conflicted. He paints a picture of a deceptive woman out to snare him and betray him (like the biblical Delilah - choice of name no coincidence), but then after the murder he begs for forgiveness. That's just not what people who feel justified do.

After all, he's singing "Why? Why? Why?", not "Die! Die! Die!". The way some people talk about it, you'd think it was the latter.

To be honest, the song really makes me reflect on my own capabilities for passion, jealousy and anger. I may never have killed anyone, but I've certainly thought thoughts I'm not proud of. Humans are gonna human.

Saschka · 02/02/2023 01:42

Deathbyfluffy · 31/01/2023 23:02

We’re talking about not singing songs etc for reasons that have merit - not one person’s crackpot views.

There’s a reason we only sing one verse these days:

Lord, grant that Marshal Wade
May by thy mighty aid
Victory bring;
May he sedition hush,
and like a torrent rush
Rebellious Scots to crush!
God save the King!

DemiColon · 02/02/2023 01:27

Arg - should say above, they thought the Righteous Brothers were black.

That's what I get for trying to make my sentence clearer.

DemiColon · 02/02/2023 01:26

Clawdy · 01/02/2023 22:53

So many songs about teenage girls are actually supposed to be about their teenage boy friends. So many people now seem to assume they're about older guys. Most of them aren't.

Yeah, this is true, and it doesn't necessarily relate to the actual age of the singer. For a long time rock and pop were really seen as a teen thing, and many singers tried to look and talk and dress like teens way past the time they were that age, because that was kind of the job. They needed to sing their teen songs for teens to listen to. It wasn't meant to be some kind of heartfelt Nirvanaesque self-revelation.

There were no videos, not so much tv, so it was quite possible to maintain that illusion. of youth It was mostly stuff people heard on the radio. There were lots of people who thought The Righteous Brothers were white for years, and my father once described seeing Neil Sedaka in a parade, and being surprised he was a short plump little guy who looked like someone's uncle.

ChellyT · 01/02/2023 23:47

Cuppasoupmonster · 31/01/2023 22:24

You can’t help an ear worm but I wouldn’t play it if it was lostprophets for example…

I literally came here to say this too!

Blackfleece · 01/02/2023 23:26

I like the way these threads wizz on with all the outraged people completely ignoring the posters who suggest that writing a song is like writing any other work of fiction. I guess singing the songs could be compared to acting in a play or movie as well. Oh, let's get outraged about the words of Delilah because a jealous man kills his cheating wife. But no problem with, hmm let's think, an actor playing a deranged serial killer in You.

Blackfleece · 01/02/2023 23:21

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:29

Clare by Gilbert O'Sullivan Ugh

You really should Google and find out the actual story about Clare and Gilbert.

WinterFoxes · 01/02/2023 22:57

BellePeppa · 01/02/2023 09:32

I think the main difference is the groupies culture back then. There were a lot of very eager groupies in those days and age was probably never mentioned. Not defending that of course but I don’t think Bowie was ever a danger on the street to girls. I would imagine looking back he was could have been appalled at the lack of his own boundaries in the 1970s rock culture. I can listen to Bowie but I can’t listen to Glitter.

That's a good point. I know someone underage who slept with Bowie. She was fifteen, so old enoygh to know that he turned her on. Probably too young to deal with the emotional realisation it was a ONS. But she was pretty happy about it and as an adult had no hang ups about it. It was just an adventure in her youth.

Clawdy · 01/02/2023 22:53

So many songs about teenage girls are actually supposed to be about their teenage boy friends. So many people now seem to assume they're about older guys. Most of them aren't.

Nanny0gg · 01/02/2023 22:29

piggypoole · 01/02/2023 21:29

Clare by Gilbert O'Sullivan Ugh

It was a song about his niece! Nothing sleazy there at all