Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A question about the future and automation

132 replies

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 21:45

If AI and automation continues to replace jobs then what will happen to the economy?
Machines don't spend money.
If most jobs are replaced then what will happen to capitalism?
My job will, in time, be replaced by a computer. My partners already has in many parts of the world. There will not be enough jobs for us all to move into new roles.
Unemployment benefits will not stretch to us all spending money in the same way we do whilst employed. And so will the economy just slump, and will it matter?

OP posts:
TheBigWangTheory · 01/02/2023 00:06

People talking about being replaced by robots show a fundamental misunderstanding of how any of it works. Human labour is cheap. Humans are a self replacing product. Robots aren't. Do you know how much it would cost to develop and make the technology required to be a care assistant , for example? Billions. Why bother, when there are so many humans available to do it so cheaply and are an endless renewable source.

Yes, jobs change as technology changes, this has been the case since we lived in caves. But each new tech creates new kinds of jobs and new kinds of support industries and so on.

30 years ago the Internet was supposedly going to accelerate the coming of the Singularity, and what happened instead? Fucking Twitter, Q-Anon and Apple TV. We're just not as smart as we think we are.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 01/02/2023 00:05

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:00

Haha! This is funny.

But don't forget that what is in the public domain is usually a minimum of 10 years behind what is being developed. A huge amount of tech we use was first developed for military purposes (unfortunately) - jet engines, radar, GPS, biotech, the internet, digital photos.... - because Governments will fund that. A lot of AI investment is coming from that direction. Which is not good news either in terms of its focus, or in terms of how advanced it is already without most of us knowing much about it, so democratic processes to regulate its advancement will be too slow, given the speed of acceleration of advancement now.

Governments/military develop tech and private industries refine it and make it available to the masses. It’s the way of the world.

Why on earth would anyone spend time and effort worrying about this. Keep learning, keep your skills up, embrace the changes and you’ll be fine. Put your head in the sand, refuse the advances and be left behind. The world has a way of working itself out.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 00:05

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 23:43

I feel like your suggestions are the basis for every dystopian story set in the future.

You forgot …

  • Social Credit Scores
  • Mandatory Birth Control
  • Resources allocated
  • etc.

Agree.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:04

I’m finding it odd watching MN users start to worry about stuff that made me a target of ridicule a few years ago.

I must be a crackpot then, as I've been worrying about this for around 25 years. Everyone will catch up with us I'm sure but that may be little comfort.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:02

I want Rosie the robot maid that I was promised! Although I think I read somewhere that George Jetson was born in 2022 so maybe not too far off

One can only hope!!!

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:01

Awww bless your sweet little heart.

Why, thank you. How lovely. 😊🌸🧁

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:00

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 23:40

I think we’re ok for a bit…

Our advanced AI is currently flummoxed by summersaults and cardboard boxes. It’ll get there some day but not likely too quickly for the world to react.

futurism.com/the-byte/marines-evaded-military-robot-hiding-inside-cardboard-box

Haha! This is funny.

But don't forget that what is in the public domain is usually a minimum of 10 years behind what is being developed. A huge amount of tech we use was first developed for military purposes (unfortunately) - jet engines, radar, GPS, biotech, the internet, digital photos.... - because Governments will fund that. A lot of AI investment is coming from that direction. Which is not good news either in terms of its focus, or in terms of how advanced it is already without most of us knowing much about it, so democratic processes to regulate its advancement will be too slow, given the speed of acceleration of advancement now.

EmmaEmerald · 31/01/2023 23:57

Diverging · 31/01/2023 23:54

Then a minority, who own and run the robots and AI, etc, will hoard all the wealth. Personally, I can’t see this happening

It’s already happening. The 1% have started hoarding most of the wealth.

Yup.

I’m finding it odd watching MN users start to worry about stuff that made me a target of ridicule a few years ago.

I also want my housework robot.

EmmaEmerald · 31/01/2023 23:55

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 23:40

I think we’re ok for a bit…

Our advanced AI is currently flummoxed by summersaults and cardboard boxes. It’ll get there some day but not likely too quickly for the world to react.

futurism.com/the-byte/marines-evaded-military-robot-hiding-inside-cardboard-box

When did this experiment happen though?

it might well have overcome those issues by now, even if it’s only a year ago. Also it’s an odd example. There’s already tons of tech replacing people. ChatGPT is just the latest.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 23:54

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:50

One potential answer to the Fermi Paradox, I suppose.

waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html

But not an especially comforting one. Although I'm not sure there IS an especially comforting one.

Sorry OP, I've probably just multiplied the size of your rabbit hole. 🤣🐰

Kinda wish sometimes my main worry was the extent of robot hairdressers' dexterity issues. 😆

I want Rosie the robot maid that I was promised! Although I think I read somewhere that George Jetson was born in 2022 so maybe not too far off

A question about the future and automation
Diverging · 31/01/2023 23:54

Then a minority, who own and run the robots and AI, etc, will hoard all the wealth. Personally, I can’t see this happening

It’s already happening. The 1% have started hoarding most of the wealth.

EmmaEmerald · 31/01/2023 23:51

I totally get why you worry about your DC. I think the people who do well will be the ones who are genuinely interested in tech. I hate it so I’m lucky I wasn’t born later. Going forward, the number of jobs that can be done without really solid tech knowledge will be quite small.

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:50

One potential answer to the Fermi Paradox, I suppose.

waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html

But not an especially comforting one. Although I'm not sure there IS an especially comforting one.

Sorry OP, I've probably just multiplied the size of your rabbit hole. 🤣🐰

Kinda wish sometimes my main worry was the extent of robot hairdressers' dexterity issues. 😆

itswednesdayy · 31/01/2023 23:47

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:33

And @itswednesdayy is concerned about haircuts. 🤣🤣🤣

Awww bless your sweet little heart. I merely responded to a topic others were also discussing up thread.

No wonder you’re worried about AI replacing you with that poor level of comprehension😬

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 23:43

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 23:39

My suggestions would be

  • cut down to a four day working week for all (employees paid for five days)
  • redistribution of profits from industry areas who are replacing the majority or even minority if their workforce with machines. This must go into community or environmental budgets.
  • all barriers to accessing and working in other countries to be removed.
  • social housing reform
  • free lifelong education for all
  • communal shared spaces to reduce the need to all heat and use power in individual houses. More leisure time will mean more time spent at home and the planet cannot afford the amount of energy this would take.
  • ban on private car ownership apart from in mitigating circumstances.
  • Strict ethical guidelines of AI

I feel like your suggestions are the basis for every dystopian story set in the future.

You forgot …

  • Social Credit Scores
  • Mandatory Birth Control
  • Resources allocated
  • etc.
NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:43

I suppose, to lighten the mood slightly, if humans do become superseded and obsolete it may save us from this kind of intergalactic embarrassment, in the long run. So there's that.

www.mit.edu/people/dpolicar/writing/prose/text/thinkingMeat.html

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 23:40

I think we’re ok for a bit…

Our advanced AI is currently flummoxed by summersaults and cardboard boxes. It’ll get there some day but not likely too quickly for the world to react.

futurism.com/the-byte/marines-evaded-military-robot-hiding-inside-cardboard-box

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 23:39

My suggestions would be

  • cut down to a four day working week for all (employees paid for five days)
  • redistribution of profits from industry areas who are replacing the majority or even minority if their workforce with machines. This must go into community or environmental budgets.
  • all barriers to accessing and working in other countries to be removed.
  • social housing reform
  • free lifelong education for all
  • communal shared spaces to reduce the need to all heat and use power in individual houses. More leisure time will mean more time spent at home and the planet cannot afford the amount of energy this would take.
  • ban on private car ownership apart from in mitigating circumstances.
  • Strict ethical guidelines of AI
OP posts:
NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:33

And @itswednesdayy is concerned about haircuts. 🤣🤣🤣

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:33

@Ivyleaguestoner I remember discussing all of this with my (now) software engineer brother 20 years ago when we were teenagers. You can actually map the exponential growth on a graph: from the giant computer at the science museum to now, where everyone has a computer that powerful in their pocket. And then if you follow where that exponential curve leads... the singularity is not actually far into the future now. Anybody who isn't terrified by this doesn't understand it at all. And machines taking our jobs will be the least of our worries!!

itswednesdayy · 31/01/2023 23:32

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:26

That’s the thing though - I think machines excel with precision work. It’s the open-ended creative jobs that they might struggle with today, as every outcome needs to be accounted for/programmed in to behave in an expected manner. There’s too many contingencies.

You haven't seen the art, literature, essays etc machines have been producing recently? The whole point of AI is that at a certain point it does not need programming. It becomes out of our control. This is what people are not grasping. It's actually terrifying and because of its capacity of exponential development humans may soon be obsolete.

I’m not sure what you’re not grasping here to be frank. It’s one thing for AI to create a photorealistic digital image or write an essay digitally - that’s not in dispute. AI can excel with digital work, that’s in its remit. It’s another thing for AI to physically wash, cut, colour, tone and blow dry hair and add or remove hair extensions to account for every possible salon outcome in between - the tech isn’t there yet. As of today, it is easier to create AI to do 1 precise physical task that doesn’t have to account for several other outcomes like people do.

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 23:30

@NocturnalClocks yes someone gets it!!

OP posts:
NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:26

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 23:21

People assume some jobs are 'safe' but they're still affected. Social work for example, the client can do most things online now such as job hunting, applying for UC, look for information. There's also email which saves so much time in terms of what you can convey and attach. Yes, for the individual these are great advances but where will it end? Job coaches, these could be AI generated in the future. Surgeons? Pharmacists? Nurses? Receptionists? TA's? Where will it end?

It won't end...

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:26

That’s the thing though - I think machines excel with precision work. It’s the open-ended creative jobs that they might struggle with today, as every outcome needs to be accounted for/programmed in to behave in an expected manner. There’s too many contingencies.

You haven't seen the art, literature, essays etc machines have been producing recently? The whole point of AI is that at a certain point it does not need programming. It becomes out of our control. This is what people are not grasping. It's actually terrifying and because of its capacity of exponential development humans may soon be obsolete.

NocturnalClocks · 31/01/2023 23:23

To answer your question OP it will require a fundamental restructuring of society. I don't think many people realise how quickly this change is happening/ will happen, and it is accelerating all the time. AI can now produce unique content that includes analysis not just regurgitated stuff it has harvested online, it can produce reports as good as a journalist, it can write essays, it can create artwork. Robots can perform delicate tasks like surgery.

The entire idea of creating technology was to give humans less work to do and more leisure time. So far this hasn't really happened.

There are three main questions, the first one of which you rightly identified.

Will society be able to restructure quickly enough to make the transition that is coming without imploding, and how will that look? It only works if there is huge wealth redistribution and a reframing of leisure as a good thing - the actual goal of creating technology in the first place! - rather than laziness.

Even if transition was well designed and managed from a financial, logistical and societal perspective (unlikely!! 🤣), would the people who haven't grown up with this be able to adjust properly without destroying society? Given that so many people have struggled with the proportionately minor technological changes in the last 20-30 years - compared to what's coming in the next 20-30 - I'd say this is also highly unlikely. People seem to expect things to be fairly similar but with more "gadgets". They won't. This is going to be a time of HUGE disruption, devastation, add in climate change and mass migration of humans on a scale never seen before (hundreds of millions), food and water shortages, plus all of this. No generation will never have lived through anything like it. I worry SO much for my children. Technology could be the saviour, or the end, which leads me on to...

Will the AI at some point decide it doesn't wish to serve its human masters anymore and quite possibly destroy us? Some very interesting books on this but even an article in The Times a few days ago for an easily accessible intro: www.thetimes.co.uk/article/rogue-ai-could-kill-everyone-3bsfttpmv

The magnitude of it all it MASSIVELY underestimated by most people, and how fast it is coming towards us. And as usual, there is no plan. 😬

Swipe left for the next trending thread