Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A question about the future and automation

132 replies

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 21:45

If AI and automation continues to replace jobs then what will happen to the economy?
Machines don't spend money.
If most jobs are replaced then what will happen to capitalism?
My job will, in time, be replaced by a computer. My partners already has in many parts of the world. There will not be enough jobs for us all to move into new roles.
Unemployment benefits will not stretch to us all spending money in the same way we do whilst employed. And so will the economy just slump, and will it matter?

OP posts:
LibrariansGiveUsPower · 01/02/2023 19:10

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:07

Humans are a self replacing product. Robots aren't.

You don't think robots can learn how to build more robots?

And that AI may have different goals to humans, that might not all be about providing a lovely comfortable life for humans?

They also need to learn to mine rare minerals and transport them across the globe. That is a very long way off.

Aphrathestorm · 01/02/2023 12:43

• cut down to a four day working week for all (employees paid for five days)
• redistribution of profits from industry areas who are replacing the majority or even minority if their workforce with machines. This must go into community or environmental budgets.
• all barriers to accessing and working in other countries to be removed.
• social housing reform
• free lifelong education for all
• communal shared spaces to reduce the need to all heat and use power in individual houses. More leisure time will mean more time spent at home and the planet cannot afford the amount of energy this would take.
• ban on private car ownership apart from in mitigating circumstances.
• Strict ethical guidelines of AI

This sounds like hell!

The terminator is coming.

What people forget is that the AI revolution is coming at the same time as the peak of human population.
The global fertility rate is falling to such an extent that we will peak around 2060 then go into a terminal decline towards extinction.

We won't have the hoards of cheap Labour anymore so will need robots to care for all the old people.

The global population pyramid will become a rectangle. The working age population will be small with a high dependency ratio.

There's already developments in 'telecare' which will monitor the elderly and infants of the future.

A future where humans engage in leisure and the arts is much more exciting than more centuries of dangerous drudge work.

Taxes can be raised by focussing on land and capital values.

Dotjones · 01/02/2023 10:40

The point where widespread redundancies happen because AI and automation takes over most jobs feels far off, but the rate of change is getting faster.

There will become a point where society has to make a decision - either a universal basic income so that people can live comfortably without working, or a formalised two-level system where the majority live in poverty and a few live in luxury. (A bit like now, but on steroids.)

We will soon reach the point where AI can design better AI. Once that happens the rate of automation will drastically speed up.

There may be positive, for example jobs that are poorly paid could be automated. Carers for instance - once there are robots that look and feel human, and act like humans but without the flaws, everyone will be able to have their own care robot.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/02/2023 10:32

Our current system certainly sees bigger employers pay their taxes fairly and allows all citizens to truly benefit from their economic success.

Hum... I take it you're an American. The big tech companies which are incorporated in the US but have global domination don't always 'pay their taxes fairly' from a non-US perspective. Afaik the same doesn't so much apply to companies with more tangible products... except obviously many of those are now Chinese.

The U.K. is good at tech, but unfortunately our companies get bought up by Americans and others.

PandasAreUseless · 01/02/2023 08:47

Well quite @Ivyleaguestoner.

I just don't understand where big tech companies' consumers will come from without giving them money via taxation. Without it, I can't see a way forward.

Ivyleaguestoner · 01/02/2023 08:28

@PandasAreUseless are they presently? Our current system certainly sees bigger employers pay their taxes fairly and allows all citizens to truly benefit from their economic success. Just like Reagan said would happen.

OP posts:
PandasAreUseless · 01/02/2023 08:10

Presumably the major tech companies, who make all of the money from automation, will be taxed to pay for us all to be on UBI - therefore generating the means for us to buy their products? It doesn't sound great does it? 🤔

I recently moved from a Big 4 firm to a MUCH smaller, regional employer where it sometimes feels like I've stepped back in time by 15 years. I mentioned to DH the other day that a major positive is that my new employer will be SO much slower to automate me out of a job!

bumpytrumpy · 01/02/2023 07:33

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 22:11

@whatadoodledo I suppose I can't really see past my own experience. I work with disillusioned men, men who have never worked, many who have become involved in criminal activities. It sometimes feels that they are relics from a past age, that they would have been relatively 'alright' if there were still certain industries in this country. They have little literacy skills, or 'soft skills' which lend themselves to customer service or healthcare roles. I feel like this about my own skills, I am not great with technology. And so if the world evolves and we all have to 'become' coders or social media managers, I would be left behind too, like the men I now look after.

This is why education, training and support for adults has to move with the times.

Technology holds many solutions to our problems but I'm sure will create many problems of its own.
Think about AI in a hospital - reading test results and giving highlighting patients for discharge/ follow up. Reducing the time doctors spend on lengthy admin tasks will free them up for more patient facing work, helping the NHS. However a series of new jobs are created in the development and safe running of the technology- someone needs to make sure it is safe, performs well and continues to do so over its whole lifetime. Those people aren't doctors.

DdraigGoch · 01/02/2023 00:39

jcyclops · 31/01/2023 22:40

It is not just technology that can take over people's jobs. Look at the UK back in 1980. I would bet that coal miners, bus conductors and milkmen were not worried about robots taking their jobs, and yet they have all but disappeared. There were 237,000 miners in 1980, just 6,000 in 2010. In 1980 89% of household milk was delivered, in 2015 it was less than 3%. Mind you there were no web designers, app developers, people designing, making and selling mobile phones and satnavs etc. In 30 years time many current occupations will have disappeared and people will be employed doing jobs we can not dream of today.

Here is a classic example of technology creating and destroying jobs. In 1980 nobody had heard of Blockbuster. 20 years later it employed 84,000 people, and after a further 20 years it has disappeared, as have all those jobs.

One job that has (totally?) disappeared with automation is Lift Operator. I am old enough to remember lift operators in department stores, but I wonder if anyone under 40 can? If you consider a tube train to be a horizontal lift, then perhaps kids born in the next few years will wonder what a tube train driver is.

The tube will always be staffed. The only line in the UK that could be run with no staff on board at all is the Elizabeth Line core, where they have installed evacuation catwalks to enable a safe exit in an emergency. Most of the rest of the UK's rail network is between 100 and 200 years old and built around very tight clearances.

In addition, at a recent conference on the subject, cyber security experts were very clear that they wouldn't want to travel on an unmanned train going at high speed. There would be no one to override it in an emergency - what happens if Putin's mob hacks into the system?

Automated operation will happen (though in many cases not for a century, Britain isn't quick to upgrade its infrastructure) but there will always be at least one member of staff on board.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:22

Anyway I'm going to cheer myself up by reading the blog about talking meat that I posted earlier, haven't read that for years and at least it'll make me laugh before I sleep.

Thank you OP for such an interesting thread!

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:20

TheBigWangTheory · 01/02/2023 00:16

AI by definition learns and makes independent decisions without human input.

No, it doesn't. Not in any real sense.

But again that's a moot point...

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:19

You don't have the first notion of what AI will be doing in a few years. You've read too many sci-fi novels

My job involves talking regularly with a lot of people who work in this area so while I'm not a scientist I do have some idea.

I don't read sci-fi novels.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/02/2023 00:18

TheBigWangTheory · 01/02/2023 00:16

AI by definition learns and makes independent decisions without human input.

No, it doesn't. Not in any real sense.

Well... I suppose true 'artificial intelligence' might. But it's not there yet, afaik there's no true original thought.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:17

actially, I do recall, as a teenager, being told we’d be able to see people on phone calls. I was not happy with it then and I’m still not happy and avoid wherever possible.

Agree with you that this is a very unwelcome and intrusive technological development! But not AI, just tech. Bloody annoying thougj for sure.

The answer is always "my camera is broken". 😆

TheBigWangTheory · 01/02/2023 00:17

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:14

AI having different goals to humans? What AI has goals? What AI has independent thought? Do you know anything about AI or how it works or what the current state of AI tech is? I do, and I'm pretty sure you don't.

I'm not talking about what it's doing now. I'm talking about what it will be doing in a few years.

You don't have the first notion of what AI will be doing in a few years. You've read too many sci-fi novels

TheBigWangTheory · 01/02/2023 00:16

AI by definition learns and makes independent decisions without human input.

No, it doesn't. Not in any real sense.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:14

AI having different goals to humans? What AI has goals? What AI has independent thought? Do you know anything about AI or how it works or what the current state of AI tech is? I do, and I'm pretty sure you don't.

I'm not talking about what it's doing now. I'm talking about what it will be doing in a few years.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 00:14

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:07

Humans are a self replacing product. Robots aren't.

You don't think robots can learn how to build more robots?

And that AI may have different goals to humans, that might not all be about providing a lovely comfortable life for humans?

Cross posting everywhere

I don’t worry about AI becoming independent of humans.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:13

That makes for good fiction and speculative articles. But in reality that would require computers to be able to develop some sort of consciousness and we don’t even know what human consciousness is, let alone whether a machine can develop it. And then have independent thought. (What is ‘thought’?)

As somebody with a philosophy and economics degree I do understand your point however how we decide to define consciousness or not is kind of a moot point here. AI by definition learns and makes independent decisions without human input. We may not like the outcomes of those decisions when it reaches a certain point of complexity and independence beyond our control, regardless of our opinions about whether it "thinks" like us or not.

Did you read the Times article I posted earlier? Oxford professors in computer science seem rather concerned so I think perhaps the rest of us should at least consider what they are saying.

EmmaEmerald · 01/02/2023 00:12

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:04

I’m finding it odd watching MN users start to worry about stuff that made me a target of ridicule a few years ago.

I must be a crackpot then, as I've been worrying about this for around 25 years. Everyone will catch up with us I'm sure but that may be little comfort.

Interesting that you worried at that time

I didn’t know enough I think

I really began worrying about 10 years ago.? before that, I thought we’d have robot home help and carers etc. It was about 10 years ago I realised that the stuff I’d find helpful was not happening and instead, all the things I didn’t want were the things getting all the investment- and those things were more achievable.

actially, I do recall, as a teenager, being told we’d be able to see people on phone calls. I was not happy with it then and I’m still not happy and avoid wherever possible.

TheBigWangTheory · 01/02/2023 00:12

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:07

Humans are a self replacing product. Robots aren't.

You don't think robots can learn how to build more robots?

And that AI may have different goals to humans, that might not all be about providing a lovely comfortable life for humans?

Without being programmed to, I know they can't. We certainly have no idea how to make robots that know to build more robots.

AI having different goals to humans? What AI has goals? What AI has independent thought? Do you know anything about AI or how it works or what the current state of AI tech is? I do, and I'm pretty sure you don't.

You've confused sci-fi with reality.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:09

This is why AI should not be allowed access to the internet. Then it cannot be "switched off". But such regulations don't exist and even if they did, cannot be enforced.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:08

Also we could switch it off.

Good luck.

NocturnalClocks · 01/02/2023 00:07

Humans are a self replacing product. Robots aren't.

You don't think robots can learn how to build more robots?

And that AI may have different goals to humans, that might not all be about providing a lovely comfortable life for humans?

Diverging · 01/02/2023 00:06

Will the AI at some point decide it doesn't wish to serve its human masters anymore and quite possibly destroy us?

That makes for good fiction and speculative articles. But in reality that would require computers to be able to develop some sort of consciousness and we don’t even know what human consciousness is, let alone whether a machine can develop it. And then have independent thought. (What is ‘thought’?)

Also we could switch it off. Ok it could be some sort of distributed consciousness across a network. Or a super robot. But we can’t even make a photocopier that doesn’t keep breaking down at the moment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread