Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MIL being an inconsiderate guest?

139 replies

Newbiehelp · 31/01/2023 18:25

Hi,

New on here so please be kind!

I moved away for a job with husband and child. We have lived away for a year and MIL has come to visit. It’s been 5 days which have been bearable. We went food shopping and she came with us. I though more to see what the shops are like where we are live. Instead she started to add food we would never buy to my trolly. Initially, I thought it was as I had a trolly that has a few bits so made sense to have them all in my trolly. When we got to the checkout, I put my stuff down and she put hers down, moved the divider and when I said the we don’t eat something so to put it back, she said “oh, I’ll eat that”.

I get as a host I should accommodate her. And we’ve provided her with the spare room (which we usually use as an office) so I’m working from the bedroom, not ideal. Also I have cooked extra with each meal so she can eat. But I personally would not have put anything extra in her trolly, especially expensive food just for me, if I went to the shops with her.

I’m I completely unreasonable in not expecting to pay for things just for her benefit? She left her PJs and toiletries so I’ve loaned her mine. Again not great as last time she stayed (before we moved) she ended up taking my PJs, when I asked for them she said “you gave them to me”!

We went out to a beauty spot on Sunday (unplanned) I took a small handbag and didn’t take my purse and hubby left his (he has been in an odd mood and snappy for the last week or so, apparently stressed with work). I said we would go back to get my purse as we were only 5 mins down the road and she said “don’t worry, I’ve got my card” so she paid for lunch, which turned out more than expected as hubby and her both had a few extra drink. But I don’t see why she should be expecting me to pay for special shopping which cost me 1/4 more than I was buying. She knows that we are not made of money, she on the other hand has plenty of money as only flies business class and doesn’t have a mortgage, I also saw her bank statement left on the dining table and it had more money than most people earn a year. I just don’t think I would expect my child when she grown up to pay for my expensive exclusive food when I am staying with her. I’m saving her a fortune by letting her stay with me as the cheapest hotel locally is £230 a night. She can afford to pay for a hotel but has decided as she travelled alone wants to spend time with us (more hubby and the child).

I get some of you might think 1/4 more is nothing but when she knows we only have a car between us, and we watch what we spend money on in a time of the cost of living crisis. I think at best it is insensitive that she expects me to pay for her special food. I have to go shopping again and am not sure how to deal with this, she insists on coming with us anytime we go out.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 31/01/2023 20:02

I think people are fixating on where you said you were cooking extra and not actually reading your posts OP.

You need to have a stern word with your husband to sort his moods out or you'll be taking off elsewhere for a bit and he can deal with his mother and tell her that you can't afford to pay for her shopping next time you go so she'll have to pay separate.

Lennybenny · 31/01/2023 20:01

@Newbiehelp not sure why you're getting some odd replies.
Next time split the food up and assume she'll pay for the extra things she's added.

You are letting her stay...how long for?

Perhaps dh is getting annoyed she's still there and is wanting some peace and quiet.

Why are people having a go about her paying for lunch...she's having everything her own way and not forking out. Buying lunch is nothing compared to what you're doing for her.

Politely find out when she's leaving.

AndNowIKnowWhatHappened · 31/01/2023 19:57

Does she think your husband earns most of the household money? My MIL wouldn't pay for anything when she visits and I wouldn't expect her to. It's a bit cultural for her. Males usually pay for things. It's not because she is mean it's more just how she was raised.

Has she given you or your husband any big gifts in the past? Did she support him through university or help with your wedding or similar?

TheFretfulPorpentine · 31/01/2023 19:57

I'm sure it is not normal for an adult to go out for the day without any money or means of payment.

hellobethyname · 31/01/2023 19:55

She must feel pretty unwelcome at your attitudes .

You let her pay for lunch but act like cooking an extra meal is a big deal .
Maybe she wanted to do
Some nice things and outings while she's there with you - it sounds like you view her as an inconvenience and she knows it .

Just say no in future . And hope she is still as generous with that big bank account when she dies because a) you shouldn't be boating at her private bank statement and b) you all sound like you really can't be arsed with her staying unless she's paying .

Horrible .

Liorae · 31/01/2023 19:55

Do you resent cooking an extra portion for your own mother when she visits?

Goldie2021 · 31/01/2023 19:53

This sounds like normal practice when my in-laws, or any family come to stay. We might pick up the tab here, they will pick
up the tab there. No big deal it all
works out fairly evenly in the end. Same situation if we go visiting.

Grimchmas · 31/01/2023 19:52

Has she got room to actually host you when you go to visit? If not then the fact that she stays with you/ you stay in a hotel is irrelevant.

Your H is being an arse, stop cleaning if he's not willing to contribute.

How much longer is she staying? If you have to do another shop, could you quietly do an online shop and don't tell her so she can't add stuff? Or if you have to take her, just say breezily up front "MIL we're on a tight budget so if you want to buy yourself any extra bits please do grab yourself a basket and buy any nice extras you'd like for yourself"

If she complains or your H is a dick about it, direct then to have it out with each other not you.

EyesOnThePies · 31/01/2023 19:51

Why do you stay in a hotel when you go to her?

Cnidarian · 31/01/2023 19:51

What you're doing is bare minimum, she paid for lunch (it's weird not to take your phone and purse out btw) and a few things she likes to eat is hardly a big imposition. A good host would've asked if there was anything their guest likes and would have it in for them before they arrive, this would be normal in my family.

Overgrowngrasslady · 31/01/2023 19:51

You and your husband are Behaving like petulant children. It’s awful there is a child involved in this

why are you not telling your husband to fucking behave, or he can fuck off out of it.

he’s been horrible since she arrived, and causing an atmospher and you’re resenting everything about her being there. But you both indulged in a lunch out she paid for and he got his fill of free drinks

what an example you both set to your kid, it’s so utterly dysfunctional and unpleasant.

Maray1967 · 31/01/2023 19:50

roarfeckingroarr · 31/01/2023 19:36

@Newbiehelp so tell me - what am I missing? What's so bad about adding a few items to shopping?

Op says it was pricey stuff - added 25 per cent to the bill. You don’t go shopping when you’re staying at someone’s house, even family, add stuff to their trolley for you to eat and expect them to pay for it. You certainly don’t do it when it’s your son and DIL who you know are having to watch their finances.

whiteroseredrose · 31/01/2023 19:48

The question is, did you invite her or did she invite herself?

I also would prefer to stay in an Airbnb when visiting anyone, including family. And I'd rather they did the same. Each to our own.

I certainly wouldn't expect a guest to just assume I'll buy stuff. My DM would put hers separately and then I'd insist on paying. Same with MIL.

EyesOnThePies · 31/01/2023 19:47

Presumably she pays for the two of you when you visit her? In terms of groceries.

It is perfectly normal for ILs to stay, I have never expected my family to stay in a hotel, so don’t see it as ‘saving them’ £230 a night.

You moved away. She now has to pay travel in order to see her closest family.

As a guest I would not put any shopping I fancied in someone else’s trolley, but if a guest relative did it I wouldn’t think twice.

Worry more about why your DH is being a dick, in a mood.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 31/01/2023 19:45

I can't believe you bring up cooking extra amounts for her.
Have you just landed on planet Earth?
That is what people do. It's the bare minimum.

FurAndFeathers · 31/01/2023 19:44

So if you don’t want her to stay and have an exam why didn’t you use your words @Newbiehelp ?

”Sorry MIL, DH is super busy with work and I have an exam that week so need the study, we can’t accommodate you that week but why don’t you visit on xx dates?”

surely that would be better than the resentful passive aggressive interaction you seem to be engaged in

superdupernova · 31/01/2023 19:41

Sorry OP but even with the updates, you are being unreasonable and tight. Instead of spending time justifying yourself, try reading all of the replies.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 31/01/2023 19:40

you are as bad as each other.

either be generous or draw clear lines of expectations. you both sound stingy

IheardYouButDontWantToAnswer · 31/01/2023 19:38

She's only been with you for 5 days and you're fed-up already..... How long is she expected to stay? She's your husband's mum, so of course you should be cooking enough food for her to be able to have some. You paid for the few extras she put in your trolley? So what - she paid when you all went out, so that would make it even, wouldn't it? I wouldn't want to stay with people who seem to resent me being there.

roarfeckingroarr · 31/01/2023 19:36

@Newbiehelp so tell me - what am I missing? What's so bad about adding a few items to shopping?

DontTouchMePlease · 31/01/2023 19:35

I’m hoping she’s leaves whats in her bank account to the cats home.

I can’t believe you have made an issue out of cooking an extra meal for her and buying her a coffee.

Overgrowngrasslady · 31/01/2023 19:31

For goodness sake. What a dysfunctional as fuck family. Op you’re posting like it’s a race to the bottom. Who can be the shitiest host. Not sure there is much in it.

Newbiehelp · 31/01/2023 19:30

@roarfeckingroarr you don’t get it. That’s fine.

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 31/01/2023 19:29

You are sounding very mean to me. Your MIL has travelled to visit and you resent her a few food items? And think it's worth mentioning that you bought her a coffee?

Unless she chucked a couple of lobsters and some gold door knobs in your trolley, I don't get it.

DulcetTones · 31/01/2023 19:23

Cross-posted...

Well, in that case, all bets are off. If she doesn't actually host you in her own home (and not through lack of room or ability), I would resent having to host her when you haven't even invited her to visit.

I'd still approach your husband. He's already in a bad mood, apparently, so what do you have to lose?