Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MIL being an inconsiderate guest?

139 replies

Newbiehelp · 31/01/2023 18:25

Hi,

New on here so please be kind!

I moved away for a job with husband and child. We have lived away for a year and MIL has come to visit. It’s been 5 days which have been bearable. We went food shopping and she came with us. I though more to see what the shops are like where we are live. Instead she started to add food we would never buy to my trolly. Initially, I thought it was as I had a trolly that has a few bits so made sense to have them all in my trolly. When we got to the checkout, I put my stuff down and she put hers down, moved the divider and when I said the we don’t eat something so to put it back, she said “oh, I’ll eat that”.

I get as a host I should accommodate her. And we’ve provided her with the spare room (which we usually use as an office) so I’m working from the bedroom, not ideal. Also I have cooked extra with each meal so she can eat. But I personally would not have put anything extra in her trolly, especially expensive food just for me, if I went to the shops with her.

I’m I completely unreasonable in not expecting to pay for things just for her benefit? She left her PJs and toiletries so I’ve loaned her mine. Again not great as last time she stayed (before we moved) she ended up taking my PJs, when I asked for them she said “you gave them to me”!

We went out to a beauty spot on Sunday (unplanned) I took a small handbag and didn’t take my purse and hubby left his (he has been in an odd mood and snappy for the last week or so, apparently stressed with work). I said we would go back to get my purse as we were only 5 mins down the road and she said “don’t worry, I’ve got my card” so she paid for lunch, which turned out more than expected as hubby and her both had a few extra drink. But I don’t see why she should be expecting me to pay for special shopping which cost me 1/4 more than I was buying. She knows that we are not made of money, she on the other hand has plenty of money as only flies business class and doesn’t have a mortgage, I also saw her bank statement left on the dining table and it had more money than most people earn a year. I just don’t think I would expect my child when she grown up to pay for my expensive exclusive food when I am staying with her. I’m saving her a fortune by letting her stay with me as the cheapest hotel locally is £230 a night. She can afford to pay for a hotel but has decided as she travelled alone wants to spend time with us (more hubby and the child).

I get some of you might think 1/4 more is nothing but when she knows we only have a car between us, and we watch what we spend money on in a time of the cost of living crisis. I think at best it is insensitive that she expects me to pay for her special food. I have to go shopping again and am not sure how to deal with this, she insists on coming with us anytime we go out.

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 01/02/2023 05:20

Now that your mil has set a precedent of staying at your home, I suggest you invite yourselves to stay with her. This will save you way more than the money spent on food and the pjs. If she complains about you not visiting frequently enough, that is your ‘in’ for starters.

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/02/2023 05:17

Maray1967 · 31/01/2023 19:50

Op says it was pricey stuff - added 25 per cent to the bill. You don’t go shopping when you’re staying at someone’s house, even family, add stuff to their trolley for you to eat and expect them to pay for it. You certainly don’t do it when it’s your son and DIL who you know are having to watch their finances.

This. I think some people on mn have forgotten what it is like to be on a budget. It is really rude to add stuff regardless without being prompted. The meal out is a moot point, firstly, because it is totally normal to take your hosts out for a meal on visiting and secondly, because op and her dh only went out as her mil was there.

If anything, your mil should be happy to help out and look after your lo so that you can study. As for the pjs, can you not just ask for them back?

lifeinthehills · 01/02/2023 05:10

I voted YABU - because it was in your hand to say, "Sorry, MIL, I can't afford that," when she put extra in the trolley. You didn't and are choosing to complain about it when you could have said no. Most people wouldn't do it but she did and you could have said no.

She did pay for lunch, so that's something. It doesn't sound like she's a great host when you visit either, but I suppose you both get to set the terms of your hosting. Decide what is okay for you and do that. Don't do things you resent afterwards.

Your DH needs to step up and be present for his mother and managing the visit more.

Lolabear38 · 01/02/2023 04:36

I think I have a very different attitude and approach to hosting than you do @Newbiehelp .

When people - especially family - travel to see us (and we live far, far away from them) I welcome them into my home and love that they’ve gone out of their way to come and spend time with us and our dc. It wouldn’t even occur to me to think I’m saving them money on a hotel - presumably your MIL has come more to see you than see where you live?

I don’t cook extra food so they have something to eat. I happily include them in our meal times and expect to provide the majority of the food they’ll be eating. I know it’ll cost me extra money so I try and be careful about the meals I make and plan ahead accordingly. While they’re here they will often treat us to a meal which I don’t expect but I’m really grateful for. I also know that my hospitality will usually be reciprocated when we go to visit them - but sometimes it’s not and that’s ok too.

When we go shopping if there’s something they want I’ll try my best to get it for them. I don’t know your financial situation but the only thing I would say is that if you can’t afford the things she added to the trolley then that’s a conversation you need to have with her, or your DH does at the very least. It could well be that it hasn’t really occurred to her the cost implications 🤷🏻‍♀️ especially if she doesn’t have any money worries like you say she doesn’t. That’s a relatively simple fix.

Honestly I don’t really understand your issue here, you seem to be complaining about having to do the things any decent host would expect to do anyway. Did you think she would be staying with you and providing her own meals for herself?

pollyglot · 01/02/2023 04:04

When I stay with my children and their families, I always pay for the supermarket shops. It was always expected. I can't imagine putting my preferences on their shopping bill. They are young, have young kids and are stretched financially, and I have no real demands on my pension/savings. I do the cooking too, to give them a break. Your MIL is mean-spirited, but I also think that perhaps you are a little obsessed with the situation.

deeperthanallroses · 01/02/2023 03:42

If my dp was being a grumpy shit while his mum was staying, wearing my pyjamas using my work space, and I was shopping and cooking everyone dinner every night, I’d move out for a few days.
‘hey Dh, i don’t know what’s up with you but next time you want to be a grumpy shit who’s miserable to live with for days don’t do it while we are hosting your mum. By we I mean I becasue you’re doing fuck all. Up till now, as I’ve booked myself a place for a few days, told your mum I just desperately need study time, but she should enjoy catching up with you and dc and I’ll go stay somewhere else. If there’s not an ENORMOUS apology waiting for me this is not the end of this discussion either. Bye.

Ihadenough22 · 01/02/2023 03:21

I think that your unhappy due the following:
Your mil invited herself to stay in your house. Yet you have to stay in a hotel when you visit her. Meanwhile she has a house being far bigger than yours.
Because of this it costs you more to visit her.

You had to give up your office as she has her stuff their and it the room she is sleeping in.
Then you have an exam coming up soon and you can't use your office.

Your husband is busy in work so your left minding his mother and despite this when he is at home he is in bad mood. Did you tell your husband that you had exam coming up and to explain to his mother to come at another time?

Then you found her bank statement and what in that account. Was your MIl decent in the past re money or time? I know people who got to their retirement years after saving for years or getting a good pension and they resent spending their money. Did your mil claim in the past that she hant to he money to help you and now you find out she has plenty of money?

I think at this stage you need to find out when your mil is leaving. I would tell your husband that you like if he got his mother away from your house for a day to let you study. I would also say to him that it not fair to leave you to do all the work during his mother visit. You noticed he is not happy as the moment but he can't be taking it out on the he rest of you being in a bad mood ect.
Going forward I would discuss with your husband if and when his mother comes to stay that he has to take some time off when she is their because your not having another visit like this.

Fraaahnces · 01/02/2023 02:48

I think you need to send DH a text message to see why he's being a miserable git and leaving all the MIL sitting to you and why she is costing YOU so much money in extras.... He needs to pull his finger out as she is HIS mother, and not yours.

gloriawasright · 01/02/2023 01:45

What a weird thread .
You sound very petty,quite unpleasant really.
You are keeping score. Coffee,ice creams some extra bits at the supermarket .
If MIL has any sense ,she will not be back.
You 'saw' a bank statement how convenient for you.
I am still trying to get my head round the

uncomfortablydumb53 · 31/01/2023 23:37

Neither you or your MiL understand the word host!
She doesn't provide accommodation or food when you see her, and you think it's a hassle cooking her an extra portion of food
Your DH isn't exactly making an effort either

Rosei · 31/01/2023 23:24

Shes family, you're treating her like a business. You sound mean.

Kisskiss · 31/01/2023 23:12

I was on your side, until you said she volunteered to pay for lunch….

FrangipaniBlue · 31/01/2023 23:01

@Newbiehelp Google "ask culture" Vs "guess culture".

I'm willing to wager money your MIL is an asker and you are a guesser.

Neither of you are in the wrong or being unreasonable but it might explain how you are interacting with each other!

rothbury · 31/01/2023 22:26

This is a reverse surely?

I think you jumped the shark with the “cooking extra so she can eat” OP

Justcallmebebes · 31/01/2023 22:21

Kangarude · 31/01/2023 18:56

She's your MIL. It's not unusual that you would cook for her and provide her with a bed whilst she is staying with you!
In relation to the extra items at the shop, just explain that you're on a tight budget, rather get your DH to tell her

This. She's your MIL, not some random and you seem to begrudge everything about her

Johnnysgirl · 31/01/2023 22:12

She covered an expensive lunch, then put a few bits and pieces in your trolley 🤷🏻‍♀️

This is quite odd - Also I have cooked extra with each meal so she can eat
Did you really expect a house guest to cater for themselves?

Swiftswatch · 31/01/2023 22:08

expensive exclusive food

Its a bloody supermarket, how ‘exclusive’ can the bits she added be?! 😂

You honestly sounds like you hate everything about her, I mean even listing that you cooked an extra portion for her to eat with you as though it’s some huge favour? Should she have cooled and eaten separately?

She took you out to lunch and you’re moaning about a few items added to the grocery shop?
Are you this unwelcoming around your own friends and family or just your husband’s?

Confusednewmum1 · 31/01/2023 22:07

I think it’s normal, mean what did it come to £25??? She bought lunch the other day.

I would let it slide and treat her more like family than a lodger.

reallypuzzledoverthis · 31/01/2023 22:02

I pity your MIL having such an unwelcoming and petty DIL and seemingly useless son

HappinessDragon · 31/01/2023 21:55

I think maybe you haven't phrased your original post too well. Comments like I've cooked extra so she can eat sound awful and I honestly don't think you would cook just for yourselves and leave her without.
Maybe you need to revisit this in your head - She may have invited herself, but surely thats because she wanted to see you all? And yes, very likely she wanted to see your husband more than she wanted to see you, but it's not surprising really - he is her son!
You might not add stuff to someone else's trolley - I wouldn't - but maybe she feels comfortable enough to do so to you? My adult son wouldn't/doesn't think twice about loading me up and I don't generally mind, but on the odd occasion when I thinks its too much, I tell him to get his wallet out. You CAN say no!
As for your office, if you already knew about the exam etc before she arranged to stay, you should have said it wasn't convenient. If you found out after it was arranged, you should have asked her to reschedule - your job is important.
And something is biting your husband - maybe there's an atmosphere between you and MIL, maybe he's having work issues, maybe he doesn't like his hair, I have no idea, but it really sounds like this is a lot of self made drama that you can reframe if you try.
Tell DH you are no longer the weeks entertainments manager and he needs to stick a smile on his face and shape up.
Forget about the extra trolley items, enjoy a free lunch, accept what you can't change, ask for your PJ's back before she leaves and make sure that you are prepared for next time with a yes, its fine, no its not convenient, let me get you a basket for your shopping etc. Good luck!

Cadburysucks · 31/01/2023 21:32

Old People do get selfish as they age, I think you have to suck it up.

Liorae · 31/01/2023 21:25

SoosanCarter · 31/01/2023 21:16

If she’s staying with you for a holiday, why would she have her bank statement with her, and if she did, why leave it on the table?
Something not adding up here.

You don’t sound very welcoming or hospitable.

Because daughters in law on Mumsnet always have remarkably comprehensive knowledge of their in laws financial situation.

SoosanCarter · 31/01/2023 21:16

If she’s staying with you for a holiday, why would she have her bank statement with her, and if she did, why leave it on the table?
Something not adding up here.

You don’t sound very welcoming or hospitable.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 31/01/2023 21:03

yup

BHRK · 31/01/2023 21:03

Gosh you sound so mean. Terrible hosting… giving her a bed begrudgingly and being annoyed you have to make an extra portion of food… is well, shocking. This is your husband’s mother. No wonder she put some things on the conveyor belt to eat.. what’s wrong with her fancying something a bit different anyway?