Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL visiting with cats?

118 replies

Lollipalooza · 31/01/2023 15:34

Not sure if IBU to worry about SIL visiting with cats? Opinions please!

SIL is coming Friday for the weekend to visit our newborn DD (3 weeks old). First baby in the family on DH's side.

We're not close at all, but she's making a big effort to drive up to visit so excited for her to meet DD.

The only thing is, she's planning to bring her two cats along for the weekend.

I have no experience with cats whatsoever and not sure if bringing them around a new baby would be a disaster? All the information online is about preparing your own cats for the arrival of baby and getting them used to the idea/smell/sounds, but these cats won't have time to adjust at all. I worry they could respond badly to crying and go for her (I know, unlikely we'll take our eyes off her!).

DH not worried at all when I asked him about it.

WIBU to ask her not to bring them? I worry this will mean she can't come at all. For context, we recently moved cross-country to be closer to my family and away from DH's, and he's been feeling sad that they are missing out on seeing DD so I don't want to prevent this visit or upset DH/SIL, and I could be worrying over nothing.

OP posts:
Catingle · 31/01/2023 18:31

One of my cats hides when people visit my house, let alone taking them to visit someone else's!

I’ve had cats that hide just because the postman has rung the doorbell, and I’ve had cats who love company and will be in the middle of the action during all the carnage of a kid’s birthday party.

GreaterStickle · 31/01/2023 18:30

Lol nope. SIL and no cats or neither at all.

LookItsMeAgain · 31/01/2023 18:30

It's a no from me too.

Tell them while you're really looking forward to seeing them, their cats are not invited and they'll have to find someone to look after their cats while they visit.

Seriously, start as you mean to go on.

Viviennemary · 31/01/2023 18:30

No. She absolutely can't bring her cats to your house. Crazy woman.

Fleabigg · 31/01/2023 18:29

The baby will be absolutely fine, I’d be more worried about the cats who will absolutely fucking hate the situation.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 31/01/2023 18:26

I have traveled with cats under a very unique set of circumstances… mine was used to travel and staying in new houses because I got him while at uni and he traveled home with me on breaks. I then got a job a couple of years after uni, that had me on the road 100%, so he lived with me in hotels (I’d be stationary in a city for ~2 mo) so he was totally used to it.

No way would I attempt that with random not acclimated to travel and new places cats.

@Lollipalooza All that being said, it’s most likely that they’ll spend all of their time under a bed or in a closet. If you allow them at all. (I wouldn’t).

Desertbarncat · 31/01/2023 18:25

Most likely the cats will pee in your house, stress and being territorial animals they like to mark their territory. You will never get the smell of cat pee out of your floors or furniture.

UWhatNow · 31/01/2023 18:23

I personally wouldn’t want shedding pet hair, fecal matter, claws, smelly pet food and everything else that goes along with cats around my house, let alone my beautiful new baby. I would tell her that if she insists on bringing them she would have to leave them in the car because they’re not coming into the house.

minipie · 31/01/2023 18:11

What everyone else said. This is bonkers. The cats will be totally fine with an automatic cat feeder and a litter tray. Far happier than being stuffed in a cat carrier and taken somewhere unfamiliar. And even if I’m wrong and they will miss SIL dreadfully Hmm you are still perfectly entitled to say you don’t want pets in your home.

daisy46 · 31/01/2023 18:06

I'd ask her to contain the cats to the bedroom that she will be sleeping in and have their litterbox/food/etc all in one place (also so you don't have to worry about them getting out/running away). I would imagine they would hide under the bed all weekend. That's what my cat would do!

AtomicRitual · 31/01/2023 17:58

One of my cats hides when people visit my house, let alone taking them to visit someone else's!

She's bonkers OP. Unless the cats are used to travelling I would not be happy with this.

As PPs have said, she'd have to keep them in one room (so what's the point in bringing them) and it will be full of smells they don't know, so there's a very good chance they'll pee or poo on something!

I do know people that take their cats on holiday with them, but it's their own second/holiday home, so familiar smells, etc.

Ragwort · 31/01/2023 17:48

I love the idea of a PP's cat enjoying the 'enrichment' of going visiting 😹

Imenti · 31/01/2023 17:46

YANBU. Absolutely not - cats like warm snuggly places...like babies moses baskets which introduces a risk of them suffocating the baby so you will need to keep watch 24/7 and make sure they are never left alone with the baby. Not to mention cat hair and whatever they might bring in from outside all over your cat free house. In your shoes I'd want to scrub the house from head to toe after they left and you are definitely not going to feel like doing anything like that!!

SleeplessInEngland · 31/01/2023 17:40

Unless they’re unusually aggressive I’d have no concerns over the baby. Still really precious of the SiL to bring them for an overnight stay though. They’ll survive 48 hours alone!

Catingle · 31/01/2023 17:29

Lollipalooza · 31/01/2023 17:10

Thanks all for your comments!

I'm reassured there would be no physical danger to DD - not thrilled by the thought of her stuff (or our new house furniture) getting jumped on, scratched, peed on or left covered in hair by two hysterical cats though!

I don't know anything about the cats - whether they travel well, or what they'll be travelling with, or where they will sleep/eat/litter etc. Will ask DH again if he has considered any of this - I did ask when it was first suggested and just got "it will be fine!" back, which is not good enough frankly! He's not particularly practical though and probably just thought I was worried about baby's safety - I was, but I was also worried about the logistics.

OP I would get your DH to check whether the cats have experience travelling like this - that’s the main thing.

If they do come, I’d suggest they stay largely confined to the room that SIL is sleeping in - it’s not cruel to the cats to keep them in one room for a couple of days (better for them in fact) and it minimises any worry for you. A couple of old towels you can use to put under a litter tray and food bowls might be helpful to protect the carpets, and don’t put you best duvet cover on the bed.

If the cats have never travelled before I think it’s fine to say you don’t want to be the testing ground. But if they’re experienced travellers and you want to be accommodating you’re unlikely to have any major issues.

Cherrysoup · 31/01/2023 17:23

I think the cats will be very stressed. What a mad idea to bring them. I'd tell her absolutely no way.

chupachump · 31/01/2023 17:22

This would be a flat no from me, even without the newborn. Cats aren't like dogs in that they just want their home, their neighbourhood whereas dogs are generally happy as long as they're with their people.

My cats would have freaked out, probably puked and pissed everywhere. It's not fair on anyone.

Fladdermus · 31/01/2023 17:22

I have cats. Baby safety, a complete non issue. But I wouldn't do with my cats. Cats hate travelling and they hate being in new houses. I think this is a pretty cruel thing to do to them.

titchy · 31/01/2023 17:21

Bloody hell - the entire point of cats is that you don't have to take them with you! Has she got confused with dogs?

Dashel · 31/01/2023 17:20

My cat has moved house three times and she has never had an accident and is not destructive at all, so I think accidents and damage would be dependent on the individual cats.

If she is definitely going to bring the cats I would get a large plastic sheet to put litter trays on and ask her what she is bringing for them.

I love cats and there is no way I would drag my cat on a road trip and to a strange house for her sake, she would hate it and be terrified. Depending on how brave the cats are they might spend the entire time hiding. Your dc will be fine but the poor cats.

Masterofcats · 31/01/2023 17:18

Poor cats. most cats would hate to go visiting like that. I assume they will stay in the spare room ( probably cowering under a bed). I doubt they will be any harm to your baby but honestly don't see the point of her bringing them. cat sitter, cattery or even electronic feeder if only for a couple of nights all seem a better and kinder option to both cats and you.

PortiasBiscuit · 31/01/2023 17:16

Lock the cats in one room with their food and a litter tray. There is no question of them rampaging through the house or coming anywhere near the baby.
However it is a very odd way to behave, we have 5 cats and I can’t see any one of them being accepting of being ferried about like this.. except maybe our Ragdoll, he is very laid back.
She should leave them at home and hire a cat sitter.

marshmallowcakes · 31/01/2023 17:14

Where are they going to do their business?

GracieLouFreeebush · 31/01/2023 17:12

When I moved house my cat pissed everywhere. I’ve changed all of the carpets and still get the odd whiff of it.

Lollipalooza · 31/01/2023 17:10

Thanks all for your comments!

I'm reassured there would be no physical danger to DD - not thrilled by the thought of her stuff (or our new house furniture) getting jumped on, scratched, peed on or left covered in hair by two hysterical cats though!

I don't know anything about the cats - whether they travel well, or what they'll be travelling with, or where they will sleep/eat/litter etc. Will ask DH again if he has considered any of this - I did ask when it was first suggested and just got "it will be fine!" back, which is not good enough frankly! He's not particularly practical though and probably just thought I was worried about baby's safety - I was, but I was also worried about the logistics.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread