Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Supporting nhs consultant doctors industrial action

453 replies

Lapland123 · 31/01/2023 13:54

I hope this has public support. Consultants have seen the largest pay erosion in public services- now 35 % pay erosion since 2010.

Add the pension debacle, where we are asked for real money now for a theoretical glitch in how pensions are calculated. The ‘real money ‘ bill now can be 6+ months of your take home pay annually. Yes, really.

Vacancies exist in multiple specialties and the day to day job is more and more difficult in the context of vacancies throughout the nhs

I hope we have support for industrial action due to this government’s disgraceful erosion of our pay though we are working harder than ever

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ShoddyCustomerCare · 01/02/2023 08:40

I absolutely support their strike action. We need everyone to step up and support. We need these highly trained, chronically undervalued professionals to run our services, which we depend on. Unless everyone has thousands sitting about which they could use for private health care? Not me, certainly.

Those pissed off that they already have what, on the cover, looks like a high salary need to give their heads a shake. They have worked and worked for that salary and it is being stripped from them in various ways mentioned upthread. No wonder they are leaving for other countries where they receive a salary reflective of their contribution to society.

You want 115k? Go put in the fucking work, then I bet you would be complaining about being robbed of it when you are in their positions. The grass isn't always greener and we need empathy to support and retain our highly skilled professionals, not indignant and often ignorant jealousy.

Same goes with all sectors striking. Solidarity. ✌️

FixTheBone · 01/02/2023 08:34

edwinbear · 31/01/2023 23:10

I guess anyone on a final salary pension scheme has a vested interest in getting the salary on which it’s based as high as possible.

Final salary scheme ended years ago.... some consultants still have some of their pension in that scheme.

Battlecat98 · 01/02/2023 08:34

AdelaideRo · 31/01/2023 20:31

@edwinbear I would accept a lower pay rise this year if virtually every year for the last 20 years the government hadn't rejected the advice from an independent body about my pay to give me a much smaller pay rise.

Cumulatively this has resulted in a 35% drop in pay over the past 15 years.

I'm fed up. Everything in the hospital is basically left to the consultants. No junior doctors because they are hacked off with working for free/ very little - the consultants will do it.
No admin support (too expensive) to type letters. Never mind the consultants can type their own. But they can't have any additional paid admin time. No money for that.
No porter to take urgent specimens to the lab - never mind the consultant will do it as they know that if they don't the specimen might not have the urgent tests done on it look for cancer .

The good will is ending. I"m done.

I'm going to start cancelling any operation that is going to run beyond my planned end of day. No more staying late because the family have travelled to the hospital/ made arrangements etc.

And I'm actively planning my route out of the NHS. For the money I get paid I'm sure I can do something a whole lot less stressful that doesn't leave me waking up in the middle of the night scared for my patients.

I and the majority of my teaching hospital colleagues do no private practice.

I work more than full time but I also only work 4 days a week. Because my regular working day is 11 hours long (and I often finish late).

As a NHS nurse I completely agree with you. The workings of the NHS now is impossible, we to, have to pick up everything that cannot be done by anyone else. But, we regularly get castigated because something went wrong and that is our fault.

The stress is unmanageable, always late off of work, it's now expected if we didn't stay patients would be even more unsafe. I support all strikers. This government has deliberately caused all of this devaluing of public services.
I agree with you regarding not staying late and not doing extra surgery, we need to try to work to rule. If we did this the NHS would have bigger problems. The good will of the staff is gone. The experienced staff are leaving. I have just returned from 2 months off due to burn out. Of course on return nothing has changed, the stress is off the scale. I am looking to leave. The NHS will loose a highly experienced nurse and I know more will follow.

noworklifebalance · 01/02/2023 08:30

Blagdoon · 01/02/2023 08:16

Lots of employees don’t get paid enough for the hours, responsibility and stress. Teachers, carers and social workers come to mind. And they’re paid a hell of a lot less than consultants. But they still do their jobs because they care about people. They aren’t whinging “I’m not doing it because you can’t afford to pay me”. Teachers especially work a ridiculous amount of unpaid hours. And we would equally be in a pickle if these people quit their jobs and went abroad. Sorry but all of those people are in line for a public sector pay rise long before consultants.

They ARE striking and they ARE quitting and there are massive vacancies in their sectors, because they cannot recruit or retain.
And we are already in a pickle.

FixTheBone · 01/02/2023 08:28

Jazz12 · 31/01/2023 22:31

NHS salary of a newly qualified entry level brain consultant. Do you know how much they make through private practice? Tax payer trained them for it through heavily subsidised tuition.

Sick of this BS. To say that taxes pay for training is a really lazy statement that doesn't go even halfway to understanding how medical education works in the UK.

I learned while working and providing a service, at a lower rate of pay than a consultant, but, often, particularly in senior years doing a similar level of work. By providing this service, especially out of hours cover overnight and weekends, I freed up consultant hours for them to do the work that I couldn't. During that time, I paid for my own exams, courses and training, and studied in my own time, often several hours per night while not being payed for it at all.

If there wasn't trainees , then there would be virtually no work done in the NHS.

nolongersurprised · 01/02/2023 08:18

Joshitai · 01/02/2023 07:53

You can’t claim that they “devote everything to saving lives” when they’re literally letting people die so they can protest about their £100k+ salary being too low.

It’s the action of striking for money in the full knowledge that people will die because of your strike that is morally deficient.

Theres no image of consultants playing golf, we all know that they work hard in a stressful job as do many other professions. It’s just that other professions don’t have convenient hostages whose lives they can sacrifice for more pay.

the problem with the current conditions though, is that the doctors who remain are working in untenable conditions. The conditions are terrible for a number of reasons but accentuated by doctors leaving and by unfilled staff positions.

Doctors who are overworked, overtired, seeing patients in corridors, covering more than one job, working without a break for the toilet or food - they will be the ones who are struck off when the inevitable mistakes happen.

Blagdoon · 01/02/2023 08:16

Coffeewinecake · 31/01/2023 23:24

£100k is a lot of money and I can see why to someone outside the profession will say it’s a high wage, because in pure monetary terms it is when compared with a lot of other jobs.
But it’s not enough for the hours, responsibility, the consequences of each and every decision, stress and the length of time it take to get to that wage.

No 18 year old choosing the career can appreciate this - plus the nature of the job, the complexities of diseases, treatments, the wages, pensions etc have all changed incredibly since the UCAS application forms went at age 17.

Lots of employees don’t get paid enough for the hours, responsibility and stress. Teachers, carers and social workers come to mind. And they’re paid a hell of a lot less than consultants. But they still do their jobs because they care about people. They aren’t whinging “I’m not doing it because you can’t afford to pay me”. Teachers especially work a ridiculous amount of unpaid hours. And we would equally be in a pickle if these people quit their jobs and went abroad. Sorry but all of those people are in line for a public sector pay rise long before consultants.

Joshitai · 01/02/2023 07:58

Changechangychange · 01/02/2023 07:52

There is nothing stopping you from training as a doctor, and in 20 years’ time becoming a consultant yourself, if you think the pay and conditions are amazing.

The actual people doing it currently don’t think the pay or conditions are amazing, and are leaving. So we need to improve one or the other to retain staff.

Frankly, I’d rather reassign a consultant to work as a binman for a month on binman wages, then they’d realise how great their pay and conditions actually are and be begging to come back. The expectation that pay and conditions must be “amazing” is entitlement.

Endlesssummer2022 · 01/02/2023 07:58

Tory HQ klaxon has clearly gone off. Back to stoking politics of envy to persuade the gullible to vote against their interests, which they will in 2024. Thank fuck I have dual citizenship and can quit this place when the shit really hits the fan. Let the Tory bots and fans sit in A&E waiting room for 2 days with their head half hanging off.

They’ll soon be singing ‘Feed the world (‘do they know it’s 2023?)’ in Ethiopia to raise money for the UK.

Joshitai · 01/02/2023 07:53

SpideyCraw · 01/02/2023 07:48

I’m astounded such a comment could be made about people who devote everything to saving lives. This image of consultancy’s fucking off to the golf course at 3pm is rubbish - they work horrendous hours in impossibly stressful conditions, going way above and beyond what they are contractually obliged to do, because they want to keep patients safe in a deficient system. Agree with the strikes or don’t, but to accuse them of “morally deficient disregard for human lives” is abhorrent.

You can’t claim that they “devote everything to saving lives” when they’re literally letting people die so they can protest about their £100k+ salary being too low.

It’s the action of striking for money in the full knowledge that people will die because of your strike that is morally deficient.

Theres no image of consultants playing golf, we all know that they work hard in a stressful job as do many other professions. It’s just that other professions don’t have convenient hostages whose lives they can sacrifice for more pay.

Changechangychange · 01/02/2023 07:52

edwinbear · 01/02/2023 07:50

Just own it OP. What you want and think you deserve, is for the 90% of the working population who earn less than you, to receive even less in their pay packets each month, so you can have more in yours. Shameful.

There is nothing stopping you from training as a doctor, and in 20 years’ time becoming a consultant yourself, if you think the pay and conditions are amazing.

The actual people doing it currently don’t think the pay or conditions are amazing, and are leaving. So we need to improve one or the other to retain staff.

edwinbear · 01/02/2023 07:50

Just own it OP. What you want and think you deserve, is for the 90% of the working population who earn less than you, to receive even less in their pay packets each month, so you can have more in yours. Shameful.

SpideyCraw · 01/02/2023 07:48

Joshitai · 01/02/2023 07:42

God the morally deficient disregard for human lives

I’m astounded such a comment could be made about people who devote everything to saving lives. This image of consultancy’s fucking off to the golf course at 3pm is rubbish - they work horrendous hours in impossibly stressful conditions, going way above and beyond what they are contractually obliged to do, because they want to keep patients safe in a deficient system. Agree with the strikes or don’t, but to accuse them of “morally deficient disregard for human lives” is abhorrent.

Changechangychange · 01/02/2023 07:47

Sorry, my actual pension pot had doubled from £120k to £200k, and so my projected pension was something ridiculous on the assumption my pension would continue to double each year. Which obviously it hasn’t.

Changechangychange · 01/02/2023 07:44

YankeeDad · 31/01/2023 21:07

@lookluv, I am the first to support fairer pension taxation for NHS consultants (see my previous long missive) but I suspect that you might be giving selective information here. You said that your NHS take home pay is £63k, but if your pension tax charge is 32k then I strongly suspect you have substantial additional income from other sources, such as private practice or perhaps investment income.

A pension tax charge of 32k would require pension capital value growth of at least £71k in excess of the annual allowance, and your annual allowance does not get tapered below £40k unless you have threshhold income above £200k. With an untapered annual allowance, pension capital value growth would therefore have to be £111k in order to generate that level of pension tax charge, and I don’t think a person on £130k or even £150k pensionable salary would be getting £111k in pension capital value growth.

I’m happy to be corrected in case I am getting it wrong.

Nope, the change from SpR payscale (only base salary pensionable) to consultant payscale (entire salary pensionable) will do that too. And don’t forget the pension projection is based on your FT final salary, even if you are PT.

I went from full time ST9 (salary about £65k) to part time consultant (salary £53k) and got a £160k tax bill. Because my projected pension pot had doubled (from £120k to about £200k, nowhere near £1m). Thankfully that was in 2019-20, and there was a covid mitigation scheme in place, or we would literally have lost our house.

I know several other colleagues stung by this in their first consultant year.

Joshitai · 01/02/2023 07:42

Orangepolentacake · 01/02/2023 07:18

God the ignorance

God the morally deficient disregard for human lives

MushMonster · 01/02/2023 07:32

Yes, keeping up with inflation is very reasonable indeed.
This year and last we have exceptional circumstances. To be honest, I think we would have to ask an economist how much the UK can afford to pay (to all of us) and go from there. I cannot give you a figure, because economy is not my speciality. If I have to guess, I bet we can stretch to 5% for medium to high pay range and 8% or so for lower wages (I support higher increase on the lower wages due to the hike in price o basic goods). We could all get double the pay tomorrow, but by doing so the price of everything goes up 3 times. We need experts in economy to figure the reasonable numbers. Now, the government is meant to do this, but this one is busy trying to figure out who is to seat on the PM seat next.
I think companies should be severely reducing their margins during this, as to keep a hold on prices. There is no point on business struggling to pay the fuel bill when BP is making record profits, in my opinion.
The issue with pensions and the associated tax does not sound fair to me at all, for example.
I think the NHS structure needs addressing. The recuiting, work load, work conditions, paperwork and so on.

But I do not think the patients are the issue, at all.

Orangepolentacake · 01/02/2023 07:25

Lapland123 · 01/02/2023 07:11

A few hear with fixed incorrect ideas, bees in bonnets and chips on shoulders.

Consultants are not worth 35% less than they were 12 years ago.

Enough nonsense about gold plated pensions when the actual details of that have been explained repeatedly and clearly to you. The great pension theft has many consultants needing to reduce hours, leave nhs and move across to private. Because they CANNOT AFFORD A YEARLY TAX BILL OF 6 MONTHS NET PAY

If that doesn’t get it into your head, nothing ever will. You will only feel this when you need medical care and the consultants have left the building.

Some people just don’t want to know. But when it’s their knee replacement, their 15h wait in a&e, their child waiting years for a SEN/ND assessment, their 3 week wait for a GP appointment or 18 months wait for secondary care, they’re outraged. Meanwhile, some people in finance or tech raking it in and no one seems to think that society is not rewarding properly those who keep us alive.
no interest in connecting the dots. Will watch the Kardashians instead of thinking for 5 minutes

Orangepolentacake · 01/02/2023 07:18

Onnabugeisha · 31/01/2023 18:01

Sorry, no I cannot support any strikes by essential personnel where striking literally means excess & entirely preventable deaths. Doesn’t matter how high up the food chain you are, if ‘industrial action’ aka striking is what you want support for as a doctor in the NHS, you will never get it from me.

Everyone has the right to petition for higher pay, but no one has a right to sacrifice the lives of other human beings to make this point to the government. It’s no different imho from taking people hostage and threatening to blow them up if you aren’t delivered suitcases of cash.

God the ignorance

Orangepolentacake · 01/02/2023 07:12

Orangepolentacake · 01/02/2023 07:12

@Jazz12 did you miss the bit about the figures tax bill?

bet when it’s not someone in the nhs you don’t give a tosh about what they earn while still complaining the waiting lists for treatment are 18 months long

it’s what the tories wanted.

5 figures*

Orangepolentacake · 01/02/2023 07:12

Jazz12 · 31/01/2023 16:51

Afford basics!?? With £100k+ salaries !?? How are other mortals living then!??

@Jazz12 did you miss the bit about the figures tax bill?

bet when it’s not someone in the nhs you don’t give a tosh about what they earn while still complaining the waiting lists for treatment are 18 months long

it’s what the tories wanted.

monitor1 · 01/02/2023 07:11

MushMonster · 01/02/2023 07:10

This one is taking a nasty turn! Overly focused on wages here! And, hold on.. now is the patient fault somehow... what a surprise!
To get out of the cost of living crisis hole we find ourselves in, we need to develop a sense of community and caring for the whole of the UK population. We need to demand equity. Not unreasonable figures that will magically sort all issues for me, but crash the system. Fairness for all, equity for all.

So what is reasonable? I would say that keeping up with inflation as a bare minimum is reasonable. And as we've had 10 years of austerity and sub-inflationary pay rises everywhere in the public sector, a big hike is needed to do that.

Lapland123 · 01/02/2023 07:11

A few hear with fixed incorrect ideas, bees in bonnets and chips on shoulders.

Consultants are not worth 35% less than they were 12 years ago.

Enough nonsense about gold plated pensions when the actual details of that have been explained repeatedly and clearly to you. The great pension theft has many consultants needing to reduce hours, leave nhs and move across to private. Because they CANNOT AFFORD A YEARLY TAX BILL OF 6 MONTHS NET PAY

If that doesn’t get it into your head, nothing ever will. You will only feel this when you need medical care and the consultants have left the building.

OP posts:
MushMonster · 01/02/2023 07:10

This one is taking a nasty turn! Overly focused on wages here! And, hold on.. now is the patient fault somehow... what a surprise!
To get out of the cost of living crisis hole we find ourselves in, we need to develop a sense of community and caring for the whole of the UK population. We need to demand equity. Not unreasonable figures that will magically sort all issues for me, but crash the system. Fairness for all, equity for all.

nolongersurprised · 01/02/2023 07:02

There are countries that pay doctors less. Doctors in those countries work in much more stressful environments. Would you take a pay cut to match them?

Which countries, out of interest? And do they also, like the NHS, have little to no scope for supplementary private work?