Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it silly to avoid commuting?

42 replies

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 12:19

I'm a confident driver, driven all over the country, in central London etc. Yet I have managed to avoid ever having a job with a long commute. I always move jobs so I can walk to work or get the bus. I just cannot stand being stuck in traffic. The rare times where I have to drive in peak traffic, e.g. to get DC's to holiday camps or to pick up relatives, I have become very aware that I would do anything to avoid waiting in traffic with my engine running. It feels like such a waste of time and bad for the planet.

I've taken a job which is necessary for my career progression and excellent in all other ways but is an hours drive away, travelling in peak times.
I'm wondering about driving up early on Monday morning, when dp can take the DC's to school and leaving my car there (I will need a car to do the job) and then getting the train back home. Then I have to cycle half an hour (flat, easy route, no roads) and then get the train daily. I will then drive back on Friday.
People think I'm crazy as I drive and have a car but I'm really worried that it will be harder to start the new job stressed from a horrid commute in a sweaty car (it will be summer) and then start a new job.
Thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Xiaoxiong · 31/01/2023 16:54

Do you need the car during your working day? I wouldn't even bother driving on the Mondays and Fridays, just cycle and train every day surely.

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 16:07

This is the problem.
The crossed parts are really heavy traffic.

Is it silly to avoid commuting?
OP posts:
PaperwhiteTheGhost · 31/01/2023 15:40

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 15:21

Might have to draw a diagram of what the problem is. Essentially I live on the outskirts of a huge city. The job is on the other side of the city and in the countryside. No matter which direction I go I will hit traffic which is going into the city. The only way around it will be a ten mile detour which will also be congested with people trying to get onto the motorway. The cycle path goes past my kids school and leads beautifully to the train station. The train station at the other end is opposite my place of work. If I get a taxi or bus to the train station I will get stuck in all the traffic going into the city

Ah. So for example you live in the Croydon suburbs and the job is in an Essex or Herts village?

Ok. In that case unless you start work at 6am ive changed my mind and would get the train. Fuck the stop start city driving.

Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 15:21

Might have to draw a diagram of what the problem is. Essentially I live on the outskirts of a huge city. The job is on the other side of the city and in the countryside. No matter which direction I go I will hit traffic which is going into the city. The only way around it will be a ten mile detour which will also be congested with people trying to get onto the motorway. The cycle path goes past my kids school and leads beautifully to the train station. The train station at the other end is opposite my place of work. If I get a taxi or bus to the train station I will get stuck in all the traffic going into the city

OP posts:
Ivyleaguestoner · 31/01/2023 15:10

My bike is worth about ten pence

OP posts:
FlySwimmer · 31/01/2023 14:35

Where will you leave your bike each day, and at the weekend? Sorry if I misunderstood that part. Worth remembering that some train companies don’t allow you to bring a full-size, non-folding bike onto peak-time trains, if that factors into the plan. I’d be wary of leaving it for extended periods at, for example, a station bike rack.

Oysterbabe · 31/01/2023 14:20

Also, will you leave your bike at the station all weekend? Risk of being stolen surely.
Otherwise I guess drop it off at the station on your way in on Monday and pick it up on a Friday. Sounds like a whole lot of faff to me.

Oysterbabe · 31/01/2023 14:18

Cycle and train is way more stressful than driving. Trains are so unreliable and car drivers try to kill you.

I cycle to work, because it's 2 miles, but would drive in your shoes.

Always4Brenner · 31/01/2023 14:08

Commuting is hell on earth however you do it, it finished me off if I hadn’t have gone on medical grounds I was wishing I could put my head through a window to stop it.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 31/01/2023 14:07

People think I'm crazy as I drive and have a car but I'm really worried that it will be harder to start the new job stressed from a horrid commute in a sweaty car (it will be summer) and then start a new job.

I don't really understand your logic here. You'll get much more sweaty on a crowded train and cycling than you ever would sitting in a nice, air-conditioned car.

VanCleefArpels · 31/01/2023 13:57

Relying on public transport and/or nice cycling weather is madness compared to an easy door to door drive, listening to improving podcasts or music allowing you to arrive at work unruffled and not potentially having had your head in someone else’s armpit. Seriously your plan is batshit, will cost you so much more money and likely to fall down at the first train strike or winter storm. Just get in your car and make it a positive experience

housemaus · 31/01/2023 13:51

It's up to you, but I'd find relying on the train more stressful (plus not having the car in case I felt ill/didn't feel up to cycling/it was mega windy or too hot or snowing etc etc etc).

I guess you can mix and match as you go to suit you!

I actually miss my 1 hour, 50 mile commute now I've moved - that hour in my car listening to a podcast was often my favourite bit of the days I worked from the office. Time to ease into the day on the way to work, time to decompress before I got home, listened to stuff I liked, called my parents to catch up talked out loud to myself. It was down a not-very-busy bit of motorway, though, so I very rarely got stuck in traffic.

PaperwhiteTheGhost · 31/01/2023 13:41

Each to their own- I drive between 30mins and 1 hour to/from work depending on start and finish times and I love it. Audio book or music on, cup of tea, nice and comfy, no one else there. I see it as me time! I did a 5 month secondment where I had to commute by train and it was horrible. I hated every second on the meat wagon!! I do have excellent air con in my car though, so no sweaty factor.

Also- is going by train not gonna be way more expensive?

KittyCatChat · 31/01/2023 13:38

I can work flexible hours (in a 9 to 5 job) and will leave for work at 06.30 to avoid the traffic. Work is about 6 miles away.

I hate traffic.

Oblomov22 · 31/01/2023 13:36

Not unreasonable at all. I've never had a job that wasn't in walking distance, bike, nice car journey for 20 minutes. I just refuse to consider it. Always find loads of suitable jobs near to home.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 31/01/2023 13:33

Ugh, commutes drive me batty. It's what has kept me in my current job for donkeys years - well, that and the salary!

Georgyporky · 31/01/2023 13:28

Any flexibility in working hours ? I've done 10.00 to 18.30 to avoid the worst of the rush hour, & built up time for a flex day off.

Wakeywake · 31/01/2023 13:20

It's quite obvious you dislike driving and you can choose whatever commuting options you like, but your reasons are disingenuous. Driving in hot weather is way more comfortable than cycling and taking the train. I say this as someone who used to commute 1h each way, which often turned into 2h on jam packed commuter trains. It's not fun.

Muu · 31/01/2023 13:10

The main problem I see with this is whether it will leave your DP doing all the school runs/nursery drop offs and whether or not that’d be fair? Which only you know the answer to.

other than that I don’t blame you. My long commute is crap, even with audiobooks and podcasts.

HeddaGarbled · 31/01/2023 13:04

You could try both ways and see which you like best. You might find the train is crowded or frequently late or cancelled, or it might be fine. You can change your mind every week based on the weather, your work commitments that week, or just how you are feeling.

Me, I’d get a car with air-con and listen to radio 4 during the journey.

But we’re all allowed to make our own choices.

IamwhoIsayIam · 31/01/2023 12:57

I don't think you are crazy to do this. It makes a lot of sense. May be if more people found ways to cycle and use the train instead of commuting by car would be less stressful for those with no choice!

In my experience it would also take little or no longer than driving a similar distance with the benefit of daily exercise as part of your routine so no need to take extra time for exercise.

Some people are so car fixated they will never get why you would want to do this.

CrazyCorgi · 31/01/2023 12:57

Not crazy at all. I’ve loved the last (almost) three years working from home and can barely believe DH and I used to travel a minimum of 90 mins a day (round trip) to work. I’ve just applied for voluntary redundancy as the payout will be huge and I’m only going to be applying for home working jobs if it’s approved 🤞

You should do what’s right for you @Ivyleaguestoner Don’t worry about what other people think.

LIZS · 31/01/2023 12:56

Can you not go by train anyway? Lift or taxi to station.

Slowingdownagain · 31/01/2023 12:55

Well I think commuting is one thing to take into account when choosing a job. It's a lot of wasted time and takes its toll.

That said you seem to be going to quite some extremes to try avoid it. I question whether your dislike for commuting (by car) is clouding your judgement for what is a reasonable arrangement. It seems odd to make much more complicated travel plans just to avoid going by car.

CousinKrispy · 31/01/2023 12:55

I don't see avoiding a bad commute as silly. It can have a big effect on your quality of life.

It is an individual choice and for some people it won't be a big deal and the other opportunities from a particular job outweigh the commute. It will depend on your own tastes and circumstances.

Other people wouldn't enjoy the bike/train option, but if you find it less stressful than driving daily, that's up to you.

I love the sound of your bike/train option as it should be better for the environment overall, plus you get the exercise of the bike ride on a regular basis. However, you may find that the train is also stressful (often late or cancelled, standing room only, expensive). I guess you could try it and see?

Is it possible there would be any effect on your car insurance if you're leaving it parked up near your workplace, rather than at home, during the week?

Swipe left for the next trending thread