Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If I don’t want HRT then I basically have to deal with it

61 replies

Merryoldgoat · 31/01/2023 10:06

I am pretty sure I’m peri menopausal. I’m ‘ok’ but not amazing.

People keep telling me to see the doctor, however since I don’t want HRT then surely I just have to lump it? Or are there non-hormonal treatments I can have?

YABU - plenty can be done without hormones

YANBU - hormones or nothing. Just put up with it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KangarooKenny · 01/02/2023 21:43

Can you tell us your individual problems so that we can offer suggestions for them ?
I’m taking magnesium as Epsom salt baths and L-Threonate tablets. These massively help my word recall and sleep. These tablets are said to cross the blood brain barrier so can also help anxiety.

AgathaMystery · 01/02/2023 21:39

OP I hope you find some relief.

I too have absolutely mad hypotension - most recent hypertensive crisis was in September so you have my sympathy.

I take antihypertensives with limited effect & also take HRT. I had premature ovarian failure aged 40. I started with Estrogel & now use patches. I have always had a mirena coil because who really wants a period? Not me.

not every treatment is right for everyone but perhaps an endocrine Gynae would be better than a GP.

PragmaticWench · 31/01/2023 14:43

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 31/01/2023 14:21

Fabulous - if your only symptom is hot flushes. There are about 34 potential symptoms of menopause and hypnotherapy isn't going to do anything about insomnia, joint aches and brain fog.

I agree @Merryoldgoat that going back to the Gp is the way to go. Some GPs are amazing. Other GPs are completely crap. The problem is that the crap ones often don't have the self-awareness to realise they have gaps in their knowledge and when to refer to a colleague/specialist, so fob women off. I have known so many friends who have been given a flat NO to HRT because of some medical issue and then when they've pressed and seen a specialist, the specialist has recommended the patches but not tablets, or a lower dose, or some other combination of treatment.

I also think there is still a strong underlying attitude that women who "manage" without HRT are in some way morally superior, stronger, better. Complete rubbish, just in the same way that nobody goes round the postnatal wards giving gold stars to the mothers who "managed" labour without pain relief.

I used to think that menopause was this time in your life where your hormones went a bit haywire for a few years, your periods stopped, and then all back to normal. But it's not that at all - once your ovaries stop producing oestrogen they stop for good. At the age of 50 I have 30 years or more of life ahead of me and I don't want those years filled with repeated UTIs because of vaginal atrophy, nauseating anxiety, insomnia and brain fog. I have been on HRT a year and happy to remain on it for life. Modern HRT gel/patches are body identical, the same as you produce yourself. How can replacing something your own body makes be "artificial hormones"?

I completely agree, and am going down the HRT route myself, but the OP has clearly wanted info on alternative options. This is one and has been shown to be very effective, so worth mentioning.

AcrossthePond55 · 31/01/2023 14:41

I don't know if it's available in the UK, but the women in my family (including me) swear by Lydia E Pinkham for menstrual and menopausal issues. I sailed through menopause with just very minor hot flashes and no real 'mood swings' or 'emotionality', as have most of the women in our family.

It's basically an herbal tonic with 10% alcohol. But do check with your doctor to be sure none of the ingredients are contraindicated for hypertension or will adversely affect the meds you're taking.

JinglingSpringbells · 31/01/2023 14:31

SelinaKant · 31/01/2023 13:19

I was very fit and well before the menopause. I had decided decades ago I would never have hrt because at that time, a lot of HRT came from pregnant horses and I was very aware of that disgusting business. (Premarin still does) Google it if you doubt me.

Menopause was a hard time, but I got tips from kind women along the way. Sweats and flushes day and night - take sage tablets. No man-made fibres - linen, cotton, wool and silk everything. Stop alcohol completely - I know this one is hard because menopause drives a lot of women to drink even more - wine every night etc- best not as it makes everything worse. I didn't sleep much at all for two years but I used that time to do online courses and work. I took Menopace.

I have many friends who took HRT, and when they stopped, some of them suddenly had all the symptoms I had and got over, but they were older. I could not have put that off and dealt with it in my late fifties or sisties - no way.

My GP said if you can come out of it with your marriage intact and keep hold of your job, you are doing well. I agree with this. I remember at a health conference at long time being told that HRT is a "workhorse drug" to keep women in the workplace as economic units until retirement and get them over that line to pension age.

I hope you have an easy one. Try and eat well and look after yourself - you might breeze through it!

@SelinaKant There is a lot of misunderstanding about HRT. One is something you have posted, that is just 'delays' the menopause and the symptoms come back when it's stopped.

That's not correct. HRT controls the symptoms for as long as it's taken and the women who find they have symptoms when they stop would have have those symptoms anyway whether on HRT or not. For them, using HRT gave them a break from the symptoms, it didn't delay them.

There is also a misunderstanding over how long symptoms can last.

Some women- about 15%- have symptoms for life and they may choose to take HRT for ever. There is no limit on how long to use it.

Also- you mention your friends having symptoms in their late 50s-60s. That is normal. Many women don't even start HRT till they are in their mid 50s.

The types of HRT that aren't made from mares' urine have been used for a long time- certainly the last 15-20 years. So I assume you could have had that type if you are still under 70?

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 31/01/2023 14:21

PragmaticWench · 31/01/2023 13:37

I read a paper recently that showed hypnotherapy was as effective at helping with hot flushes as HRT. Discussed it with my GP.

Fabulous - if your only symptom is hot flushes. There are about 34 potential symptoms of menopause and hypnotherapy isn't going to do anything about insomnia, joint aches and brain fog.

I agree @Merryoldgoat that going back to the Gp is the way to go. Some GPs are amazing. Other GPs are completely crap. The problem is that the crap ones often don't have the self-awareness to realise they have gaps in their knowledge and when to refer to a colleague/specialist, so fob women off. I have known so many friends who have been given a flat NO to HRT because of some medical issue and then when they've pressed and seen a specialist, the specialist has recommended the patches but not tablets, or a lower dose, or some other combination of treatment.

I also think there is still a strong underlying attitude that women who "manage" without HRT are in some way morally superior, stronger, better. Complete rubbish, just in the same way that nobody goes round the postnatal wards giving gold stars to the mothers who "managed" labour without pain relief.

I used to think that menopause was this time in your life where your hormones went a bit haywire for a few years, your periods stopped, and then all back to normal. But it's not that at all - once your ovaries stop producing oestrogen they stop for good. At the age of 50 I have 30 years or more of life ahead of me and I don't want those years filled with repeated UTIs because of vaginal atrophy, nauseating anxiety, insomnia and brain fog. I have been on HRT a year and happy to remain on it for life. Modern HRT gel/patches are body identical, the same as you produce yourself. How can replacing something your own body makes be "artificial hormones"?

PragmaticWench · 31/01/2023 13:37

I read a paper recently that showed hypnotherapy was as effective at helping with hot flushes as HRT. Discussed it with my GP.

crosspusscrossstitcher · 31/01/2023 13:32

@Merryoldgoat In a similar boat with hypertension and strokes in the family (also breast cancer).
I know I need to cut out alcohol completely, my BP is not great at the mo, trying to lose weight and exercise more.
Not going to take HRT.
I'm on menopace and some multi vits.
The exercise is helping, and smalled sized jeans Grin I just need to put the 🍺down. 🤞

I have been told menopause takes 7yrs to complete 😱😱😱
which leaves me about 2 more...

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 31/01/2023 13:31

Merryoldgoat · 31/01/2023 10:57

@monitor1

I thought poorly controlled hypertension was a contraindication? That’s what my GP told me.

My mum takes HRT and blood pressure tablets. Might be worth having another conversation.

(She also takes a variety of other tabs that I have no idea what they're for!)

Hankunamatata · 31/01/2023 13:27

I take hrt. I find anti depressant, exercise daily and losing weight helped but only hrt stopped the sweats

Hankunamatata · 31/01/2023 13:26

www.bloodpressureuk.org/news/news/blood-pressure-the-menopause-and-hrt-.html

Hrt preps through the skin like patch or gel doesn't affect bp and can actually lower it

Mariposista · 31/01/2023 13:23

My mum couldn’t take HRT and really struggled (MP went on over 7 years and she had the whole catalogue of symptoms). She did find a good diet and exercise helped (although not completely). Good luck!

SelinaKant · 31/01/2023 13:19

I was very fit and well before the menopause. I had decided decades ago I would never have hrt because at that time, a lot of HRT came from pregnant horses and I was very aware of that disgusting business. (Premarin still does) Google it if you doubt me.

Menopause was a hard time, but I got tips from kind women along the way. Sweats and flushes day and night - take sage tablets. No man-made fibres - linen, cotton, wool and silk everything. Stop alcohol completely - I know this one is hard because menopause drives a lot of women to drink even more - wine every night etc- best not as it makes everything worse. I didn't sleep much at all for two years but I used that time to do online courses and work. I took Menopace.

I have many friends who took HRT, and when they stopped, some of them suddenly had all the symptoms I had and got over, but they were older. I could not have put that off and dealt with it in my late fifties or sisties - no way.

My GP said if you can come out of it with your marriage intact and keep hold of your job, you are doing well. I agree with this. I remember at a health conference at long time being told that HRT is a "workhorse drug" to keep women in the workplace as economic units until retirement and get them over that line to pension age.

I hope you have an easy one. Try and eat well and look after yourself - you might breeze through it!

Waitymatey · 31/01/2023 13:18

folk- thanks OP

Sunriseinwonderland · 31/01/2023 13:16

I tried all the non hormonal ones. They did bugger all.

adjsavedmylife · 31/01/2023 13:00

Maisie Hill’s Perimenopause Power is a good read and has tons of practical suggestions.

Merryoldgoat · 31/01/2023 12:41

I think this thread has been really helpful so thank you.

Just a few points.

  1. GP told me HRT not possible with my BP issues but that needs to be challenged which I will do.
  2. I’m nervous of hormones as I’ve had terrible experiences with hormonal birth control - I appreciate this is not necessarily the case but after significant mental health issues it’s still concerning.
  3. I wanted to understand if there were other options as I’m very early in my menopause journey - just starting to get the beginnings of symptoms
  4. I need to tighten up my diet and exercise a LOT.

Thank you everyone - eye opening and I’m very appreciative of you all taking the time.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 31/01/2023 12:35

There's lots you can do without HRT.

I had a history of cancer which led to early hysterectomy (36) followed by HRT

(wonderful) then within a year, I got breast cancer. Not necessarily related to HRT but "just in case", (word of my breast specialist), I gave up HRT and menopause ensued.

By then (because of cancer) I was also following a very healthy diet; avoiding stress, practiced yoga, meditation, excercised gently, swam a lot, got more sleep, aromatherapy, reiki, reflexology. All of those can benefit menopause symptoms too. For hot flushes/sweats, I took evening primrose oil capsules. (used to be available on prescription but no longer; get it in Health food shops). 30 years later DH had prostate cancer, treatment produced the manopause. (like the menopause, only much much worse in men, like manflu).
He took EPO and sage for the hotflushes ; also a homeopathic treatment (from NHS) all of which helped.

   In hindsight, I realise that the lifestyle changes forced on me 40 years ago  (and by extension, DH)  were a blessing and  longterm benefit.  We are 76,  fit, robust, active. I'd recommend anyone approaching midlife, to step back, reassess, and  make the changes NOW .
JinglingSpringbells · 31/01/2023 12:32

With a family history of heart disease, you should definitely be considering HRT.

It helps stop the arteries clogging up.

Any menopause specialist will tell you this.

To reduce your BP, are you getting at least 30 minutes of brisk exercise a day? Walking fast, jog-walks? Reducing salt in your food? eating more than the suggested 5 a day or fruit and veg? Getting lots of fibre in your diet?

BIWI · 31/01/2023 12:31

A low carb diet will definitely help - may also help with the hypertension too.

Cut down/out caffeine and alcohol too although I never managed either of those!

Boots Menolieve really helped me too.

I couldn't take HRT because of breast cancer risk. (My mother died from it).

I'm 63 now, and haven't had any hot flushes for around a decade.

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 31/01/2023 12:30

There is loads that can be done. I tried HRT for 6 months and it did nothing apart from make me put on weight. I react very badly to any form of hormonal intervention. Hated the pill, suicidal on depo etc. There are loads of lifestyle things and diet etc that helps. I work with a brilliant peri and menopause specialist nutritionist. The right diet and supplements has really helped, plus exercise and meditation etc.

pizzaHeart · 31/01/2023 12:28

I haven’t investigated or tried it myself yet but was told by my physio that acupuncture might help with some symptoms, you do need a practitioner qualified for women issues/ menopause for this.

JinglingSpringbells · 31/01/2023 12:27

Merryoldgoat · 31/01/2023 12:19

@monitor1

I don’t want to divulge masses but my family history puts me at a higher stroke risk which might be why.

There is no stroke risk with most types of HRT. It doesn't raise your risk higher than not taking it.

HRT actually protects against heart disease, which is why it's prescribed for those women with an early menopause.

I think from your posts, you're not aware of a lot of this perhaps?

Andsoforth · 31/01/2023 12:26

What symptoms are you experiencing? There is nothing that acts as broadly as HRT but different things can be effective in managing individual symptoms, and there are lots of things to try that aren’t ingested (like weighted blankets for sleep or wicking sheets for sweats etc)

I’m not sure about this but I think you can take oestrogen vaginally for dryness and other issues (recurring cystitis possibly) even when it’s contraindicated because it works differently. I’m fuzzy on that though but it’s one to discuss with a doctor.

I wonder would it be worth an appointment with a specialist? Presumably they have patients who don’t respond well to HRT and have to be taken off it, so they must have other options to recommend too. They might also have more insight into your previous reactions to hormones (the pill triggered terrible depressions for me but HRT has been fine)

JinglingSpringbells · 31/01/2023 12:25

Merryoldgoat · 31/01/2023 10:30

Sorry - I should’ve been clearer - I can’t take HRT - I have hypertension which is somewhat hard to control so it’s contra indicated.

I’m not keen because every time I’ve taken hormones during my life it’s ended with me being in a very poor state mentally or physically or both.

You absolutely can have HRT with high blood pressure.

As long as the high BP is being controlled with diet/ lifestyle or meds.

The newest types- transdermal- do not affect BP like the old tablet forms, or The Pill.