Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My father and inheritance.

127 replies

DadDilema · 31/01/2023 09:43

To make this short my dad has had some health issues recently and it’s brought up talks about his will and inheritance.
I have 2 siblings, my DB has 2 children, and we have two children. So there are 4 grandchildren.

My dad has said that in the event one of us (his children) dies before his, he will not leave our share of inheritance to our children (his grandchildren) he said he’s not leaving anything to the grandchildren, and if one of us dies then it will be split between the remaining siblings.

We are all quite close and have good relationships, and he seemingly loves his grandchildren, but it’s really hurt me that if in the event that I die.. my children/family aren’t thought about.

obviously, it’s his money/estate and he can do as he pleases.. but it’s left me quite confused about why he wouldn’t want to leave anything to his grandkids.
DB feels the same, quite hurt and confused as to why he would go out of his way to exclude our children if one of us dies.

I don’t really know what my AIBU is, should I try and discuss it with him, to compromise - or am I expecting too much for my kids, since it’s his money?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
familyissues12345 · 01/02/2023 09:15

I can't imagine leaving out grandchildren in the event their parent had already died

Surely part of someone's inheritance includes money inherited before (so when DH and I die, the money our children will inherit is made of a chunk of the inheritance we've gained from our parents) so leaving out those grandchildren means they will be financially worse off?

Ultimately though I would hate the feeling that anyone felt we didn't care for them, and that's how Wills are thought of IMO. I wouldn't want I'll feeling after I've gone.

Different scenario, but I had a friend who met someone with 3 teenagers. They went on to have a child together. She was very open that their will favoured their child far far more - and I don't mean that he got half and his Dad shared his half 4 ways, it was much more than that. I just can't get my head around someone doing that without thinking of how the 3 older ones are going to feel? Are they going to still want a relationship with their sibling who has benefitted like this? As far as im aware, there's no money on their mums side either so that's not even the justification. My (ex) friend was very open of her dislike of her step children, and convinced her husband that they need to protect their DS more.

I just don't understand why people don't consider the impact of their will?

daisychain01 · 01/02/2023 08:24

obviously, it’s his money/estate and he can do as he pleases.. but it’s left me quite confused about why he wouldn’t want to leave anything to his grandkids.

theres no "obviously" about this. Despite what some of the MN collective often say, there is a good way of doing this inheritance stuff and there's a shabby, divisive way.

unless there's some huge backstory on this eg some siblings not being his actual children, your father should ensure his will doesn't create a dilemma, but quite frankly he sounds clueless. It will create bad feeling, it will create a dilemma at a time of loss. What he isn't allowing for is that, in the event of one of his children dying prematurely (ie before him), your family will all be grieving (including any children of the deceased parent) and having to process the loss of that sibling/parent, and meanwhile knowing they've been excluded from the will.

If you and your siblings are on good terms, the only thing you can all resolve to do is to ensure the children of the "potentially" deceased sibling are included by dividing the will as if the parent were alive and then ensuring the children receive the money. And don't tell him that's what you plan to do.

Doing the right thing is the only way of right-ing that wrong.

Cocochat · 01/02/2023 08:19

@rubberduckiee I see.
I have a family member who has to apply for funds every few months. It's quite strict.
It's for a vulnerable adult, not sure if that makes a difference.

rubberduckiee · 01/02/2023 08:15

I'm very, very (professionally) familiar with how trusts work! That's why I mentioned them in the first place. There's still a limit to how much you can reasonably control especially when parental decisions come into it.

Cocochat · 01/02/2023 08:14

My df had two dc in his will who were not fsmily but sc. One has predeceased him and his dc will not inherit as my df doesn’t know them at all.
Df specifically had the will altered to reflect this.
However if I died my dc would inherit my share.

I assume that my df will end up in a home as he’s struggling and none of us will get any money. Best way to think imo.
I give dc dribs and drabs of money as I can. Why leave it all to chance?

Slowingdownagain · 01/02/2023 08:13

Have you asked your dad why he is doing it like this?

AlmondBake · 01/02/2023 08:10

I think it's odd too but one aspect is that any money would essentially be left to your partner, not quite your kids.

The money wouldn't be left to op's partner, it would go to her surviving siblings.

Cocochat · 01/02/2023 08:09

rubberduckiee · 01/02/2023 07:59

I think it's odd too but one aspect is that any money would essentially be left to your partner, not quite your kids. It could be left in trust for the kids after they become adults, but you mentioned the main need would be as they were growing up. Before dying he could set conditions for its use by your partner but realistically will have to give your partner free rein to decide what is best for "family welfare" (even including holidays) etc. Not everyone wants their own money to go to a stranger, even if it will have a trickle down benefit for their own gc along the way. So he may have just decided to prioritise his own kids over external partners.

Trusts can be independently run with the dp having to ask for funds from a solicitor for instance.

rubberduckiee · 01/02/2023 07:59

I think it's odd too but one aspect is that any money would essentially be left to your partner, not quite your kids. It could be left in trust for the kids after they become adults, but you mentioned the main need would be as they were growing up. Before dying he could set conditions for its use by your partner but realistically will have to give your partner free rein to decide what is best for "family welfare" (even including holidays) etc. Not everyone wants their own money to go to a stranger, even if it will have a trickle down benefit for their own gc along the way. So he may have just decided to prioritise his own kids over external partners.

ArcticSkewer · 01/02/2023 07:54

Slowingdownagain · 31/01/2023 10:07

This is normal in wills. If a person dies before the person who wrote the will it doesn't pass to their children, rather they just disappear from the calculation.

A lot of people saying this

No, it isn't the norm in wills. Normally it passes down that family line

Foxywood · 01/02/2023 07:23

Rather have

Foxywood · 01/02/2023 07:23

My DM gave money to DGCs - which meant it was split in twice as many ways - they were of an age when it went on cars mainly. I’d rather of put it to long term savings/ pension.

Confusednewmum1 · 31/01/2023 22:36

Strangely I have heard this before from my own grandmother. She doesn’t feel us as grandchildren should inherit. It came up recently - my grandfather has recently passed. She updated her will, like your father that only living children should inherit.

it’s raised a few eyebrows as my aunt died years ago and at Xmas my grandmother always gives £2k per child and always ensures my aunts 2K is split between her 2 kids. So up until now she has always acted fairly between siblings living or dead.

It’s too soon after my granddad passing to challenge as she’s fairly set in her ways. But your post has made me question if there has been lawyer advice given or a legal issue as it’s out of character and doesn’t align with things done in the past.

AlmondBake · 31/01/2023 22:00

But that won't happen because you've already discussed it and decided between yourselves that the children will be fine. So maybe just enjoy your father while he's still here....

But money does strange things to people. An informal verbal agreement now is not as robust as a properly written will.

burnoutbabe · 31/01/2023 21:59

But it may happen. The op's brother and sister may change their mind.

The op could die now and the father in 15 years time with the op's husband now (say) married again with more kids.

No guarantee the siblings will give up their inheritance to the current op's kids many years down the line.

Rosei · 31/01/2023 21:38

DadDilema · 31/01/2023 20:45

Im not saying I’m entitled to his money, he wants to leave me a share of the money and that’s what he’s intending to do. My issue is that the share he intends for me, will be written out and away from my children should I die before him.

if he left all his money to his wife, or a charity.. or spent it all before he died I wouldn’t feel entitled to anything. But if he’s leaving the money to me anyway, why is he excluding my children if I die, so they’ll see their cousins likely benefit from their parents share, but my children will be without.

But that won't happen because you've already discussed it and decided between yourselves that the children will be fine. So maybe just enjoy your father while he's still here....

DadDilema · 31/01/2023 20:45

Im not saying I’m entitled to his money, he wants to leave me a share of the money and that’s what he’s intending to do. My issue is that the share he intends for me, will be written out and away from my children should I die before him.

if he left all his money to his wife, or a charity.. or spent it all before he died I wouldn’t feel entitled to anything. But if he’s leaving the money to me anyway, why is he excluding my children if I die, so they’ll see their cousins likely benefit from their parents share, but my children will be without.

OP posts:
TheDofS · 31/01/2023 20:05

Genevieva · 31/01/2023 16:51

It is normal for a will to have a cascading clause whereby the beneficiaries dependents would inherit if the beneficiary predeceases the testator.

Exactly!

Rosei · 31/01/2023 18:06

plumduck · 31/01/2023 17:32

Yeah I see what you mean. I don't think it is unfair though. The family as a whole grew. It's not all about branches.

Yes true. When the time comes, I will discuss with my brother. Don't want to have that conversation with my Mum as its all about her wishes, not mine x

ChristmasCurry · 31/01/2023 17:44

Just agree a deed of variation with your siblings that if one of you dies then your share will be passed on to your children.

Of course this will have to be based on trust between you all to do so in the event one of you dies.

plumduck · 31/01/2023 17:32

Rosei · 31/01/2023 16:55

Yes I understand that. But she has equally gone between me, my brother and my kids and my opinion is that's not fair on my brother. But that's an opinion I've kept to myself because it's not my money or my decision. No one is "entitled" to anything.

Yeah I see what you mean. I don't think it is unfair though. The family as a whole grew. It's not all about branches.

Cosyblankets · 31/01/2023 17:29

The only beneficiary I've discussed my will with is my husband.

Rosei · 31/01/2023 16:55

plumduck · 31/01/2023 16:44

Because your mum wants to provide for her grandchildren. Maybe she could reduce your share accordingly or something but your children are individuals she cares about too.

Yes I understand that. But she has equally gone between me, my brother and my kids and my opinion is that's not fair on my brother. But that's an opinion I've kept to myself because it's not my money or my decision. No one is "entitled" to anything.

cptartapp · 31/01/2023 16:51

slowingdownagain apologies

Genevieva · 31/01/2023 16:51

It is normal for a will to have a cascading clause whereby the beneficiaries dependents would inherit if the beneficiary predeceases the testator.