Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate splitting bills at restaurants?

446 replies

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 16:21

We socialise a fair bit but do not have a high income. We do this by being careful about how we spend our money. So I absolutely hate it if in a restaurant at the end of the night someone says forcefully we should just split the bill.
No! I know it is easier. But myself and DH have chosen cheaper options so we can afford this. And it always people who have spent loads who say this.

OP posts:
BiasedBinding · 31/01/2023 22:42

WFHbore2023 · 31/01/2023 21:39

I think it's a fair interpretation. Why else behave like that? Unless it's to cover up their numerical illiteracy, if they're unable to work out how much their bill comes to.

I guess I just run in very different circles to some posters, as I have never been out for dinner with anyone that seems to be trying to get out of the experience what they can.

It baffles me.

It's meant to be an enjoyable experience, not 'how can I get Margaret to pay for my starter?'

Me too, but now if anyone I don’t know well ever does state upfront at the start of the meal that we will pay for what we consume, instead of just thinking they like to be clear about things, I’m going to wonder whether they think i look like someone who’s out to fleece them with my “steak and red wine guzzling” Grin

Pipsquiggle · 31/01/2023 22:39

God this thread is so tiresome. It's like no one has any agency nowadays.

If you just want to pay for the food you eat, say something BEFORE the meal.

Easy with friends. With colleagues /acquaintances have a word with the organiser & /or the waiter.

JFM27 · 31/01/2023 22:18

I run a social group with two friends and when we have a meal out with our group we have one bill but everyone pays for what they have had, That seems to work out mostly quite well. Just have to make sure have removed service charge as that is often added on.

NorthbyNorthwest22 · 31/01/2023 22:03

I always make it clear I don’t split the bill at the start.
About 15 years ago we went out with a group of friends, 8 of us in total. When the bill came it was suggested we split. While I didn’t mind so much for the food, we were expected to split a bar bill of £390. I don’t drink and my husband was on antibiotics. We had also paid for our soft drinks as we went.
Apparently we ruined a great night with our stinginess!

No longer our friends…

xsquared · 31/01/2023 21:58

I can't imagine going out with friends and ordering 3 courses whilst they have 1.

It happens though, at least in my experience anyway.

For example, in our last meal, only a couple of us had starters, and the rest of us chatted away as we have been since we sat down.

One or two people may have dessert but I have coffee at that point of the evening.

People should feel free to have what they fancy that evening without feeling embarrassed. If they want 3 courses and drinks, that's fine. If they only want a main course and tap water, then that is also fine. Nobody should feel restricted on what is meant to be an enjoyable night out.

Nanof8 · 31/01/2023 21:56

We usually ask for separate bills when we first order, then we don't have to worry about splitting after. Makes it easier all round. The servers prefer to know ahead of time.

NinjaPig · 31/01/2023 21:52

We went out for a work do a few years ago, I say with my friend and we were the lowest paid people out of the 20 of us. I had a bottle of wine with my meal, as did several others on our table, but Sam wasn't driving a didn't have a pudding.

At the end of the meal, it was suggested that we split the bill and Sam was worried as she didn't have enough, so I spoke up (being slightly pissed) stating it wasn't fair and detailed why.

She was really grateful and although some people moaned (those who had consumed loads), when they'd moved to the bar, at least 4 others came over to say thank you, that they felt the same and would have been out of pocket.

NHS band 2 and 3 can't compete with band 6-8

RampantIvy · 31/01/2023 21:47

TBH round here food portions are pretty substantial so I never eat a three course meal either.

WFHbore2023 · 31/01/2023 21:45

DH can't eat three courses after his cancer surgery, so it does happen.

And so, if I went for dinner with him, I'd also stick with one course.

Not because there's no chance to do it out of a few quid, but because that's the polite thing to do IMO

Persephoned · 31/01/2023 21:39

If you think a bill is unfair or just want to pay for literally what you’ve eaten then you need to say. I don’t keep tabs on what everyone drinks and eats on a group night out - I generally go along with splitting the bill and certainly wouldn’t think oh hang on, x or y didn’t have a starter. Sometimes I don’t drink alcohol (as a pp said I’ll have an AF beer maybe so it’s not far off if others aren’t going mad) or I have a small salad but I shrug and count it as a meal out

WFHbore2023 · 31/01/2023 21:39

I think it's a fair interpretation. Why else behave like that? Unless it's to cover up their numerical illiteracy, if they're unable to work out how much their bill comes to.

I guess I just run in very different circles to some posters, as I have never been out for dinner with anyone that seems to be trying to get out of the experience what they can.

It baffles me.

It's meant to be an enjoyable experience, not 'how can I get Margaret to pay for my starter?'

Spiderplantation · 31/01/2023 21:36

WFHbore2023 · 30/01/2023 21:23

Actually, that's a bluff, as they rely on poorer/more moderate diners for their big bargain meal. I wonder if some of them even deliberately seek out less well-off acquaintances to eat with, safe in the knowledge that they will thus cut their cloth and so be a perfect mark for subbing theirs, when they demand to split, with a side-order of shaming if you protest. If you also can/will push the boat out as much as they do, there's no saving for them to make.

That's the wildest thing I've read in a while.

I think it's a fair interpretation. Why else behave like that? Unless it's to cover up their numerical illiteracy, if they're unable to work out how much their bill comes to.

Spiderplantation · 31/01/2023 21:31

Kazzyhoward · 31/01/2023 07:58

It makes me cringe to think people need calculators for something as simple as adding a few numbers. Even more so a pp suggesting it takes 10 minutes! This is primary school maths!

Yes. This is mental. The usual thing whenever I've been out for a meal is that everyone knows how much theirs will come to and pays it. Without calculators and without suggesting paying equal amounts for disparate orders.

RampantIvy · 31/01/2023 21:26

Posted too soon

In fact, the first words to come out of my mouth once we are seated are generally 'are we doing starters?

Yes, we do this. DH never has a starter.

MichaelFabricantWig · 31/01/2023 21:24

YANBU

I hate the narrative that the bill splitters are “tight” when they are not the ones expecting everyone else to subsidise their food and drink

AllOutofEverything · 31/01/2023 21:24

We always say are we having starters. But if there is nothing I fancy I will happily sit and eat nothing while everyone else has something.

RampantIvy · 31/01/2023 21:22

I can't imagine going out with friends and ordering 3 courses whilst they have 1.

DH can't eat three courses after his cancer surgery, so it does happen.

WFHbore2023 · 31/01/2023 21:05

I also don't understand the huge discrepancy in what people order.
I can't imagine going out with friends and ordering 3 courses whilst they have 1.
The idea of sitting there eating whilst everyone else waits around for me to be done so the main course can come is horrifying.
In fact, the first words to come out of my mouth once we are seated are generally 'are we doing starters?' 🤣

ButterCrackers · 31/01/2023 21:00

Say at the beginning of the meal or when you make plans that you will be paying for what you have and therefore not participating in dividing the bill. The others can still divide the bill once your costs are taken out.

ellyeth · 31/01/2023 20:57

I would be OK with splitting the bill equally if everyone had roughly the same value food and drink, give or take a few pounds.

But if, for instance, someone customarily ordered the most expensive meals, plus a starter, dessert and more than one drink, and I customarily had only a normal priced meal and only one or no drinks, I wouldn't be happy.

I would not feel comfortable insisting that the bill be worked out for each person so I would probably not go out with people who regularly did this.

Slowingdownagain · 31/01/2023 20:53

xsquared · 31/01/2023 20:48

Surprised that people have different dietary requirements and tastes? Really?

I'm one of the vegetarian teetotallers that you're referring to. It's never been an issue in my current circle of friends.

We also have a GF vegetarian in the group who usually drives so no alcohol for her either, and on the other end we have the drinks before, drinks during and drinks after person who will order a fancy dish.

Everyone pays for their own and have always done. Nothing awkward about that.

No, that they dine with people with such different approaches to dining out. I have friends who are vegetarian or gluten free. I don’t drink much myself. It still never creates this huge divide in how we approach the meal with some ordering 8 courses and bottles of spirits whole others sit with their spaghetti and tomato sauce, sipping their tap water. It just never happens. And seems quite a misfit.

xsquared · 31/01/2023 20:48

Slowingdownagain · 31/01/2023 20:01

I am also surprised at how many people go out for dinner with people vastly different to them. So many teetotal vegetarian gastric band people with their steak for starter main and desert and downing bottles of champagne friends. This never happens in my life. Normally there’s a “are people having a starter/ shall we look at the desert menu” conversations but people - very broadly - seem to reflect each other.

Surprised that people have different dietary requirements and tastes? Really?

I'm one of the vegetarian teetotallers that you're referring to. It's never been an issue in my current circle of friends.

We also have a GF vegetarian in the group who usually drives so no alcohol for her either, and on the other end we have the drinks before, drinks during and drinks after person who will order a fancy dish.

Everyone pays for their own and have always done. Nothing awkward about that.

celticprincess · 31/01/2023 20:43

I’ve been called alsorts in the past about this. Recall years ago being totally skint. I ordered the pizza for £4.99 and tap water. Refused to split the bill. Then we found out that the restaurant had applied an automatic 10% to the bill so this had to be split as well. But my share of the bill ended up being £10! I was fuming as 10% on my bill should have literally been 50p. Somehow I ended up with a 100% service charge for my carefully selected food and they couldn’t understand why I kicked off. But no one could be bothered to work out their own bill plus their own service charge.

I don’t drink and rarely have a starter or desert as I usually find I can’t eat that much. I often just have tap water as I can’t drink much juice over an evening. I have some groups of friends who are good about this and often ask me to work out my bill and then they will split the rest between everyone else. Not always though. I paid a hefty price last time I went out for a meal. I did have one juice and one hit drink instead of desert. I opted out of a starter but then someone else ordered a sharing platter on behalf of the table and they couldn’t finish it so I did have a small bit. I deliberately ordered an expensive main though as I knew it would end up getting split. But even with that I paid way more than I had eaten ans drink. And it was a pricier place than I’d usually go to.

neighboursmustliveon · 31/01/2023 20:22

I feel you. I went out with mil, sil and my teenage dd for lunch recently. We all had two courses but mil were both more expensive. The three adults were drinking and we had a cocktail/G&t instead of dessert.

The bill came and mil just said 'let's split it in half' so she paid half for her and her dd (my sil) and I paid half for my and dd. Except our half should have been £15 cheaper than their bill as dd only had two soft drinks!

My sil gave me some money after as she could see I wasn't happy. It was less about the money though and more than mil was treating sil and not us but then wasn't fully treating sil as I was subsidising her!

RampantIvy · 31/01/2023 20:14

I am also surprised at how many people go out for dinner with people vastly different to them.

I'm pleased this thread has enlightened you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread