Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate splitting bills at restaurants?

446 replies

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 16:21

We socialise a fair bit but do not have a high income. We do this by being careful about how we spend our money. So I absolutely hate it if in a restaurant at the end of the night someone says forcefully we should just split the bill.
No! I know it is easier. But myself and DH have chosen cheaper options so we can afford this. And it always people who have spent loads who say this.

OP posts:
AbcXyz123456 · 30/01/2023 20:23

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 30/01/2023 20:16

It’s only swings and roundabouts if it’s not the same people who have the most food/most expensive options each time. Often in my experience it is the same person.

Not in my social circle. As I say if someone didn't drink / didn't have a third course or something then we'd factor that in. In our group the ones who have ordered more expensive stuff would openly say that and offer to pay more (rather than the ones who ordered less having to speak up).

SillySausage81 · 30/01/2023 20:22

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 16:51

It makes me cringe just reading this. Getting your calculators out... 😬

Aren't you lucky not to have to be counting your pennies then. Just be bloody grateful instead of trying to shame people who are in that situation.

RampantIvy · 30/01/2023 20:22

But that’s my point - in my experience, people don’t do this with friends. There’s a discussion- “are we having starters? Are we just doing pizzas or the main menu? Shall we have wine?”.

Yes. We have this discussion when out with other couples. Sometimes we just pay for the drinks separately to avoid resentment.

WimpoleHat · 30/01/2023 20:18

Well if you have soft drinks and a pizza each and they have bottle of red wine, steak, a pudding and coffees….

But that’s my point - in my experience, people don’t do this with friends. There’s a discussion- “are we having starters? Are we just doing pizzas or the main menu? Shall we have wine?”. So, sure, someone might have a coffee which someone else doesn’t, but it’s not worth making a song and dance about. It’s usually a few quod either way.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 30/01/2023 20:16

AbcXyz123456 · 30/01/2023 20:09

My friends and I tend to split equally but we're all mindful if someone didn't drink/ didn't have desert etc so would make adjustments. We'd never knowingly let others pay more but equally not petty enough to work out exactly to the pound who had what. As others have said it's swings and roundabout.

It’s only swings and roundabouts if it’s not the same people who have the most food/most expensive options each time. Often in my experience it is the same person.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 30/01/2023 20:14

WimpoleHat · 30/01/2023 20:01

We can go out as a couple and pay £30 in the exact same place another couple will spend £80.

You see, that seems odd to me. Things are usually in a reasonably tight range on a menu and if you’re sharing wine and water etc, then I’d have thought it generally came out within a few quid of each other. Apart from anything else, when you go with friends, you tend to agree on a restaurant that’s in everyone’s price range, so I can’t see how it’s normal to have such a huge discrepancy when you’re talking about two couples. (Can see how a huge group of colleagues is more difficult.)

All it takes is someone to have a steak, a side, to have a starter and pud when most have one or the other, plus either wine or cocktails and their bill can be a lot more than other people.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 30/01/2023 20:13

AbcXyz123456 · 30/01/2023 20:09

My friends and I tend to split equally but we're all mindful if someone didn't drink/ didn't have desert etc so would make adjustments. We'd never knowingly let others pay more but equally not petty enough to work out exactly to the pound who had what. As others have said it's swings and roundabout.

This

BarrelOfOtters · 30/01/2023 20:12

sjxoxo · 30/01/2023 19:54

But who is going out in a group and ordering extravagantly?? I don’t know anyone that does this. The polite think is for both sides to be reasonable!!! So not ordering oysters when you have lunch with your best friend (unless she is too!) and equally not going out for a meal and having a glass of water and a starter…

My ex boss, who was v well paid, ordered really expensive wine as he didn’t like ‘cheap’ stuff that we’d have all been happy with. We assumed. More fool us he’d put I’m more after making such a fuss…nope.

Nicecow · 30/01/2023 20:11

I think some of you need new friends. If anything I have the opposite problem where people overpay. I have some friends who don't drink, I would never go halves in this situation, I'll always make sure I pay my share or more.

BarrelOfOtters · 30/01/2023 20:10

WimpoleHat · 30/01/2023 20:01

We can go out as a couple and pay £30 in the exact same place another couple will spend £80.

You see, that seems odd to me. Things are usually in a reasonably tight range on a menu and if you’re sharing wine and water etc, then I’d have thought it generally came out within a few quid of each other. Apart from anything else, when you go with friends, you tend to agree on a restaurant that’s in everyone’s price range, so I can’t see how it’s normal to have such a huge discrepancy when you’re talking about two couples. (Can see how a huge group of colleagues is more difficult.)

Well if you have soft drinks and a pizza each and they have bottle of red wine, steak, a pudding and coffees….

AbcXyz123456 · 30/01/2023 20:09

My friends and I tend to split equally but we're all mindful if someone didn't drink/ didn't have desert etc so would make adjustments. We'd never knowingly let others pay more but equally not petty enough to work out exactly to the pound who had what. As others have said it's swings and roundabout.

Tontostitis · 30/01/2023 20:08

I just don't get this if I've had a salad and diet coke and the steak eating red wine guzzler says let's just split it you can just say no sorry that doesn't work for me here's £20. Generally with my friends drinkers offer to pay more. I do think though non drinkers sometimes dont realise how much soft drinks can be. I have one friend who always has 3 courses and two or three soft drinks that will probably be more than my starter salad and one white wine.

BetiYeti · 30/01/2023 20:04

YANBU and this is why I rarely go out for meals with non-family anymore. Too many people have taken the piss in the past.

WimpoleHat · 30/01/2023 20:01

We can go out as a couple and pay £30 in the exact same place another couple will spend £80.

You see, that seems odd to me. Things are usually in a reasonably tight range on a menu and if you’re sharing wine and water etc, then I’d have thought it generally came out within a few quid of each other. Apart from anything else, when you go with friends, you tend to agree on a restaurant that’s in everyone’s price range, so I can’t see how it’s normal to have such a huge discrepancy when you’re talking about two couples. (Can see how a huge group of colleagues is more difficult.)

Brefugee · 30/01/2023 20:01

But who is going out in a group and ordering extravagantly?? I don’t know anyone that does this.

it's more likely to be someone ordering a side and a glass of water because they're on a budget, and everyone else having regular meals. Although a wile ago a lot of people i socialised with were bankers on eye-wateringly high salaries, they ordered the most expensive things, and usually more than they actually wanted/needed just... because they could. And then expected me, a student, to split the bill evenly. Nope. But i never minded putting them right on that score.

sjxoxo · 30/01/2023 19:54

But who is going out in a group and ordering extravagantly?? I don’t know anyone that does this. The polite think is for both sides to be reasonable!!! So not ordering oysters when you have lunch with your best friend (unless she is too!) and equally not going out for a meal and having a glass of water and a starter…

RampantIvy · 30/01/2023 19:54

Years ago DH and I went to an expensive restaurant for a leaving do. There must have been about 20 people there. As I was driving I had a couple of soft drinks. Everyone else was ordering expensive wines and liqueurs. It was decided just to split the bill at the end, and as DH was still quite junior at the workplace he didn't want to challenge it, so we very resentfully paid for our split of the bill and decided that it wouldn't happen again.

If we go out with another couple and we have pretty much the same then we just split the bill down the middle.

LovePoppy · 30/01/2023 19:52

This is so odd to me. The norm for us always was just getting our own meals. No drama, no over spending.

Hollyhocksandtulips · 30/01/2023 19:50

JusteanBiscuits · 30/01/2023 16:52

I happily just split it how ever many ways - but I always lose out as the non-drinker!! Recently went to a meal where I didn't know everyone well. I had a £21 main course and drank tap water. Another person, who I didn't really know, had an £11 salad, so when the bill came insisted in paying less. BUT, she'd had three cocktails and when I said "but I didn't drink if you want to be like that" she told me I should have drunk cocktails. My £21 main course cost me £38!

But if you had drunk cocktails she'd have paid even more? I've told this before but we went out as skint group with wealthier group
Of friends once. They all had £17+ main courses and pints and pints while we had £7 pizza (olden days where it was significantly cheaper than a main course like chicken in an Italian restaurant) and 1 bottle wine between 4. They obviously suggested splitting bill and we ended up with e.g. £15 bill each - in any case, less than their main course alone. They MUST have known this. Obviously I've seethed about this for over 15 years as we subsidised their food 😡

Dramaalpacas · 30/01/2023 19:45

We would always have the discussion at the end ‘we’ve all had pretty much the same, shall we split?’. Then usually someone will say ‘oh but I’ve had a dessert, I need to pay extra’ or someone won’t have had the wine that everyone else had etc.. so we wouldn’t split it exactly but let’s say out of 4 of us if 3 were drinking wine and the wine was approx £30 and the bill was £130 (inc tip) the wine drinkers would pay £35 and the non-wine drinker would pay £25 (assuming they hadn’t had an equally expensive drink). It works out well, nobody has their calculators out and we make sure the whole bill is paid as there is less scope for someone to forget something they had

MrsMikeDrop · 30/01/2023 19:45

Just say at the beginning, tell the person taking your order you want it separate, or go and pay for your bit first. It really doesn't need to be a big deal

Flowers54 · 30/01/2023 19:45

I’ve seen a lot of posts like this and have always found it strange how common it seems to be. I go out with friends, work colleagues, friends of friends and the starting point has always been to split the bill but to point out who didn’t have alcohol / a starter / dessert etc… and insist they pay their lower share then the remainder of the bill is split.

I think pp’s are right, it might feel awkward but if you make reference to paying your own bill when booking or the start of the meal that will be it resolved

Arniesleftleg · 30/01/2023 19:44

Myself and my hubby, then boyfriend went to dinner with his very wealthy friend and his friends. Neither of us were any where near high earners but the friend was wealthy in his own right as well as living from the bank of mum and dad (think 12 bedroom house, private education etc). Anyway, we had all gone out to dinner, about 20 of us and they were all ordering champagne and top notch foods, we just stuck to the basic menu and soft drinks as we knew we'd never be able to afford what the others were eating and drinking. Come the end of the night the cheeky fecker said they were splitting the bill 20 ways! I just stood up in front of everyone and said 'er no!' There was no way we were going to subsidise the bloody bill for all those others that could have afforded to pay for everyone!

Even now when there are more than 3 of us we all pay for what we have. It might be more hassle for the waiting staff but none of us have the money to pay for others. If theres only 2 or 3 we split the bill between us as we all tend to have the same. My friend and I take it in turns to treat each other to breakfast or brunch or a cuppa when we meet every few months, it's our little tradition.

YANBU

Brefugee · 30/01/2023 19:42

also if there is a service charge, you can ask them to remove it ( i usually do) and then each couple/person leaves a tip. The bigger the group the bigger the tip would be the norm, but in general we leave 10-15% (most of our friends are chefs, and it really isn't an issue)

Brefugee · 30/01/2023 19:40

It's completely normal when I eat out with my friends as well.
Why are people so afraid to say up front "if you don't mind I'll just pay my own way. I'm a bit skint this month"?

i think some pp must hang out with absolute arsehole CFs. We go out in groups of 10 or more sometimes, and we don't have people leaving before the waiter has been to everyone and we're clear the bill and a generous tip has been covered. Nobody worries that one person had a bread roll and water and one had filet Rossini and a bottle of champagne. It's not embarassing, it's not awkward and we have been doing this for 30 years or more.