Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So angry at all these threads on useless and selfish men

820 replies

Winterday1991 · 30/01/2023 15:31

Off the back of the thread where the H refuses to care for his sick child so the OP can get some much needed rest as he is on annual leave from work 😡. I am seriously fed up of reading threads like this, why are so many men so selfish?

Why is it always women who have to do the lions share of caring, pulling themselves in all direction whilst their male counterparts glide through life uninterrupted? Why is it always women who carry the mental load for family life and the men just show up. Why is always women responsible for maintaining the household?

Even in the 21st century, why do so many men get such a bloody easy ride, whilst often their poor wives/partners are running around like headless chickens keeping on top of everything.

OP posts:
SamanthaCaine · 04/02/2023 15:19

Anecdotally, when you meet or hear from an impressive young female economist, scientist, mathematician, engineer etc they're often not British.

Definitely not. It's true that other countries have better attitudes towards engineering but there's one fundamental error in your post.

Engineering isn't popular in the UK full stop. More men do it but the UK has such an issue with engineers that it's lowly paid, even for men. There are quite a lot of female British engineers. Lots more elsewhere in the world but we have many talented British women, who are just as badly paid as the men they work with (equally badly I should say).

Sadly in other parts of the world, engineers (in certain industries) are viewed with the same esteem as doctors (quite rightly) but not in the UK where the title has been bastardised and minimised to mean nothing at all.

Stillcountingbeans · 04/02/2023 15:12

A great many women who enter the teaching profession, for example, do so explicitly in the belief that it is more compatible with their ideal of family life

It's not sexist if the choice is genuinely a free one

Where the sexism or patriarchy comes in is that the 'free' choice to become a teacher was made with childcare and school holidays in mind - because the woman had taken on the idea, instilled by society, that the childcare would be her problem to solve.
How many men select their profession based on considerations of childcare, before they even have any children?

It is also a symptom of patriarchy that childcare is an issue - if we had a more equal society then childcare would be far cheaper, far more available, higher-status as a career choice, and far more state subsidised to achieve this.

Stillcountingbeans · 04/02/2023 15:02

@PrincessConstance
You can quantify and manage the physical tasks.
How do you quantify the strategy and thought processes?
You cannot, it's not possible.

You can't easily keep tally of how much work each has done - it is much easier and more straightforward to count how much 'time off' or relaxation each person has. e.g. you will sit down for half an hour when you get in from work, and I will sit down for half an hour later whilst you clean the kitchen. I will have four hours on Saturday morning, and you will have four hours on Sunday afternoon.

If someone continues to take on mental load during their time-off, such as thinking about shopping lists whilst at the gym, that is something only that individual can address.

Stillcountingbeans · 04/02/2023 14:56

@Mark19735
And here I do think there are possibly some evolutionary factors that might explain why men seem to be more able to load-shed and say "this is good enough for today". Their assessments tend to be based more on their capacity to physically continue to do that work - whereas a woman making that assessment is perhaps more likely to be influenced by how they think others ("the village") might feel about them - a worry that doesn't take their capacity to do more work into account.

I broadly agree, except I don't think women these days are that bothered about what "the village" or other people think - they are concerned about the effect on the child if stuff isn't done.
For example, the poster whose DH bought the wrong colour school jumper, and generally didn't do his share of buying uniform - he didn't care about getting it right because he didn't care about the effect on his child.

Likewise a man might think 'this is good enough for today', leaving the children with no clean shirts, or no packed lunch, or leaving the baby to crawl on a dirty floor, with only two nappies in the house. The woman is more likely to keep going at these tasks until late at night, feeling ever more resentful that the man has stopped and put his feet up.

Yes some women make a rod for their own back by being too perfectionist, but equally some men fall woefully short of acceptable standards of childcare, including all the planning and anticipating involved.

PeanutButterSmoothie · 04/02/2023 12:36

Then once you are married (to a wealthier man) with children the “I didn’t make sense for me to work” argument comes into play and any imperative to work harder and get paid more slowly gets eroded. You lose financial power and then you lose agency over own life.

It’s not a “conspiracy” by the patriarchy. No one is plotting to trap women as a class in an economically weaker situation. But the current social structure massively benefits men at the expense of women. I don’t think anyone is asking men to become radical feminists and seek to overthrow the patriarchy but many women just want acknowledgment from men that we are still operating at a considerable structural disadvantage.

The elephant in the room is the fact that a lot of women don't actually seem to want to push the career once the money going into joint account is 'enough'. Many won't admit this but it's pretty obvious.

QueefQueen80s · 04/02/2023 11:53

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:24

@QueefQueen80s

Excelt they don't and most often won't do 50/50

If they haven't don't it pre split they won't do it post

Most women don't even want 50/50 anyway

Most women I know want that and have that, share the load and equal parenting, it works great for us. But thats when the man pulls his finger out and steps up which they have done.

Before that the men know theres a woman round to do it all.

PrincessConstance · 04/02/2023 11:16

Dp believes the only real way of making money is by having a business.
Complete autonomy and control. Flexibility for family and relationships.
He doesn't mind my career but feels I'd make more money and be freer with a business.

SandraCumin · 04/02/2023 11:10

Phineyj · 04/02/2023 11:09

Regarding the different presence of the sexes in various occupations - one thing that drives this is different subject choices at school and therefore different degree choices. The rates at which girls take e.g. Physics and Economics are noticeably higher at girls' schools than at mixed schools (research by Institute of Physics - I have a link if anyone wants it).

There is also significant evidence that women entering professions in large numbers drives down wages (teaching, medicine, nursing). As a poster memorably said earlier in the thread "low value people do low value work". Of course women are over-represented in public sector occupations too where wages are held down by the monopsony (single dominant) employer.

Interestingly, we do not see these trends to the same extent in other developed countries.

Anecdotally, when you meet or hear from an impressive young female economist, scientist, mathematician, engineer etc they're often not British.

That is shocking, this country really is an embarrassment to the world.

Phineyj · 04/02/2023 11:10

Teaching is not all compatible with family life! So much better to be e g. an accountant...

Phineyj · 04/02/2023 11:09

Regarding the different presence of the sexes in various occupations - one thing that drives this is different subject choices at school and therefore different degree choices. The rates at which girls take e.g. Physics and Economics are noticeably higher at girls' schools than at mixed schools (research by Institute of Physics - I have a link if anyone wants it).

There is also significant evidence that women entering professions in large numbers drives down wages (teaching, medicine, nursing). As a poster memorably said earlier in the thread "low value people do low value work". Of course women are over-represented in public sector occupations too where wages are held down by the monopsony (single dominant) employer.

Interestingly, we do not see these trends to the same extent in other developed countries.

Anecdotally, when you meet or hear from an impressive young female economist, scientist, mathematician, engineer etc they're often not British.

SandraCumin · 04/02/2023 10:56

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/02/2023 10:09

@Mark19735

Externalising it and laying the blame for everything at the foot of men is spectacularly missing this point.

I can empathise with that. I do understand the sense of exhaustion and confusion that men must feel and their sense of never being able to do anything right.

But I don’t think women usually are blaming individual men for everything. I don’t. I blame patriarchy. But women do want men who they are intimately involved with to try to put themselves in their shoes and see what it feels like and to understand the effect it has on the household and the relationship when this sort of work is constantly downplayed and undervalued.

Every man is responsible for upholding the patriarchy, even the so called ‘decent’ ones. You cannot start separating them into categories of innocent and problematic when their entire identity is tied to the very system that is oppressing us. You wouldn’t tell a white person that just because they are homeless and destitute that they are no longer a threat to black people.

Wish44 · 04/02/2023 10:26

realsavagelike · 30/01/2023 15:43

@shropshire11 women also procreate with men who are very good at future faking that they will be awesome at stepping up to fatherhood and then the truth reveals itself after the baby is born.

Yes! I waited 6 years before having a baby with my partner so I could be sure he was a good un.I also had numerous conversations pre baby about dividing housework and childcare. 15 months after baby is born he does his share because he has to as it was all planned out before baby, but he resents me so much for it that he now actually hates me and we are going to have to separate if he doesn't stop being nasty to me ( couples therapy fingers crossed) . It is a shock how deeply entrenched patriarchy is.

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:26

What does your dh hoovering twice a day have to do with anything?

How has unpaid labour been resolved?

PrincessConstance · 04/02/2023 10:24

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:15

@PrincessConstance

I didn't write the op

Expecting 2 partners to share the load their joint life creates equally is not scapegoating

It's just common sense

You can quantify and manage the physical tasks.
How do you quantify the strategy and thought processes?
You cannot, it's not possible.

Should Dp insist on me vacuuming the carpet twice a day because it's important to him?
This idea was initially called unpaid labour, but now that is being resolved, women have moved to the invisible mental load.

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:24

@QueefQueen80s

Excelt they don't and most often won't do 50/50

If they haven't don't it pre split they won't do it post

Most women don't even want 50/50 anyway

Youraccountisnolongervalid · 04/02/2023 10:23

QueefQueen80s · 04/02/2023 10:19

Best thing for a man is to seperate and they have to do it all 50/50. Pickups, bedtimes, housework. It makes men of them and makes them appreciate what we do.

Not saying all men!

Still doesn’t always work, DD’s dad has only bought 2 school jumpers in 11 years and they were the wrong colour. (Obviously there are 100s of other examples but that’s one of the ones that makes me laugh rather than pull my hair out)

QueefQueen80s · 04/02/2023 10:19

Best thing for a man is to seperate and they have to do it all 50/50. Pickups, bedtimes, housework. It makes men of them and makes them appreciate what we do.

Not saying all men!

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:15

@PrincessConstance

I didn't write the op

Expecting 2 partners to share the load their joint life creates equally is not scapegoating

It's just common sense

PrincessConstance · 04/02/2023 10:12

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:03

@PrincessConstance

Im not making any wild assertations.

You are. I haven't said any of the things you're talking about. Your whole post is one big strawman

And is still entirely devoid of any point relevant to the actual thread

You actually haven't made any points at all.

The whole op is subjective nonsense-coulda-shoulda-woulda.
Scapegoating.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/02/2023 10:09

@Mark19735

Externalising it and laying the blame for everything at the foot of men is spectacularly missing this point.

I can empathise with that. I do understand the sense of exhaustion and confusion that men must feel and their sense of never being able to do anything right.

But I don’t think women usually are blaming individual men for everything. I don’t. I blame patriarchy. But women do want men who they are intimately involved with to try to put themselves in their shoes and see what it feels like and to understand the effect it has on the household and the relationship when this sort of work is constantly downplayed and undervalued.

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:05

@Mark19735

Claims to be so disappointed that people are focused on how sex impacts the subject

Wanders into blatant sexism and contradicts himself entirely

🤣

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 10:03

@PrincessConstance

Im not making any wild assertations.

You are. I haven't said any of the things you're talking about. Your whole post is one big strawman

And is still entirely devoid of any point relevant to the actual thread

Mark19735 · 04/02/2023 09:59

I find it disappointing that people fight so hard to centre the sex of the partners as not just deterministic, but decisive, in driving these inequalities.

For me it is so clear and obvious that it is the nature of the work, rather than the sex of the person doing it, that is a driver of mental load and it is the capability and mindset of the individual, not their sex, that is a predictor of how much they will labour under that mental load.

And it does link back to the concept of "good enough". Like that article says, some tasks are like projects. They have an obvious, natural, end. Fixing a broken stairgate. Painting a room. Mowing the lawn. There is immense satisfaction to be had in completing them, and a visible and palpable moment when it is ok to crack open a beer and put your feet up. Other tasks never seem to end and require that the person doing it also sets the standard for what is good enough - and I think the stressful part of mental load is because these standards are ones that people feel may be judged by others (as well as themselves). Cleaning and tidying. Helping a child with their homework. Choosing the right outfit for World Book Day. And here I do think there are possibly some evolutionary factors that might explain why men seem to be more able to load-shed and say "this is good enough for today". Their assessments tend to be based more on their capacity to physically continue to do that work - whereas a woman making that assessment is perhaps more likely to be influenced by how they think others ("the village") might feel about them - a worry that doesn't take their capacity to do more work into account. This is also a structural issue, just as much as the economy. And this thread ... and MN in general ... provides ample evidence of just that. Externalising it and laying the blame for everything at the foot of men is spectacularly missing this point.

PrincessConstance · 04/02/2023 09:47

Botw1 · 04/02/2023 09:38

@PrincessConstance

Yes. I've said the same (minus the bullshit about big jobs)

Not sure what that has to do with the thread though

You're making wild assertions that:
Home life issues are a barrier to careers or female advancement.
If only the man weren't around, or if this patriarchy would just disappear my life would be so much better. If Dp shared my mental load then I could be a finance director of insert any top 100 FTSE company.
I call bullshit.
Most people are happy to make choices that suit themselves, everyone isn't suited to careers or big jobs.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/02/2023 09:47

It’s not sexist if the choice is genuinely a free one - regardless of whether it is promoted heavily or not.

Not everything is a conspiracy by the patriarchy. Some women may genuinely prefer to be nursery teachers than account executives. What's wrong with that?

Of course there’s nothing wrong with being a nursery teacher but this choice isn’t made in a vacuum.

The economics of pay in the care professions are In themselves reflective of sex bias. It’s no accident that these vitally important jobs are paid so little. There are many factors behind this and I would be interested to hear @Phineyj’s take but I am sure that in part it’s because historically these jobs were done by women who were not the main household breadwinner.

Theres also the question of what represents a genuinely “free” choice. I’m sure many women do genuinely want to do these jobs but it’s also connected to family expectations: if your family discourages you from pursuing a highly paid career it’s unlikely to be the case that you can imagine yourself doing it. It’s also unlikely that your family would give you the financial support you need or the guidance which would help you exceed.

Then once you are married (to a wealthier man) with children the “I didn’t make sense for me to work” argument comes into play and any imperative to work harder and get paid more slowly gets eroded. You lose financial power and then you lose agency over own life.

It’s not a “conspiracy” by the patriarchy. No one is plotting to trap women as a class in an economically weaker situation. But the current social structure massively benefits men at the expense of women. I don’t think anyone is asking men to become radical feminists and seek to overthrow the patriarchy but many women just want acknowledgment from men that we are still operating at a considerable structural disadvantage.