Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So angry at all these threads on useless and selfish men

820 replies

Winterday1991 · 30/01/2023 15:31

Off the back of the thread where the H refuses to care for his sick child so the OP can get some much needed rest as he is on annual leave from work 😡. I am seriously fed up of reading threads like this, why are so many men so selfish?

Why is it always women who have to do the lions share of caring, pulling themselves in all direction whilst their male counterparts glide through life uninterrupted? Why is it always women who carry the mental load for family life and the men just show up. Why is always women responsible for maintaining the household?

Even in the 21st century, why do so many men get such a bloody easy ride, whilst often their poor wives/partners are running around like headless chickens keeping on top of everything.

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 02/02/2023 21:03

BigFatLiar · 02/02/2023 19:02

I sometimes wonder why women marry them in the first place.

You will see all excuses under the sun on here like he wasn't like this when they married etc, when in reality the guy has always been a coke head scum bag but they wanted to change them.

A load of warning signs are there before but they let their ovaries take over and decide a idiots is an ideal dad.

Spanky123 · 02/02/2023 20:46

Welcome to mumsnet, where feminist hypocrisy thrives and is the man hating capital of the Internet. Imagine if there was a dad's net...

BigFatLiar · 02/02/2023 19:02

I sometimes wonder why women marry them in the first place.

SandraCumin · 02/02/2023 18:51

Spanky123 · 02/02/2023 18:42

This thread has made me realise how horrendous some women and their attitudes are.

Yes the pick me’s really are a lamentable bunch aren’t they?

Spanky123 · 02/02/2023 18:42

This thread has made me realise how horrendous some women and their attitudes are.

Stillcountingbeans · 02/02/2023 18:21

Burgoo · 02/02/2023 17:00

@Winterday1991

I am speaking as a man who has a fairly even relationship with my partner when it comes to splitting chores (though she does the washing up, I do the cooking - I hate washing up!)

I'd politely ask why would men do things unless they have to? Why would ANYONE unless they have to?

The reason is because men can tolerate not doing things much longer than women can (from my experience) and rather than holding them to account, women just do the work. If I know my partner is doing all the work, why would I bother myself and get extra stressed?

Now I am NOT saying that this is morally right. Is it self-centred and showing a lack of respect? Sure. And at the same time the fact remains...people often don't want to do what they can get away with not doing.

For example, I can EASILY live in a dump. Plates piled up in the sink? Not a problem! Grime on the bath? Easy! Dust all over the carpet? Piece of cake! Thankfully my wife is the same so we just end up blitzing the house every so often!

The question I have is, what incentive do some men (or anyone who is lazy) have to do the chores? Being a "good partner" isn't enough. We have to create a situation where men want to do things rather than feel obliged to do things. Otherwise it will never last. From a behaviouralist perspective this is all about reinforcement. Nobody goes to work for the fun of it (we aren't a charity after wall, we go to get paid). It is the same premise here.

BTW I find that there is a tendency to demonise "men" as a collective. We aren't all horrific lay-abouts and I believe it is less about "men" and more about individuals who can get away with it.

The reason we feel we have to do stuff is mostly for the children.
If a couple don't have children, they can be as slobby as they like - or if one has higher standards than the other they can argue over it to their heart's content.

But if children will be affected, it is not fair on them if stuff doesn't get done. The trouble is that the woman often will take on this, and the man doesn't realise, or just doesn't care enough.

NocturnalClocks · 02/02/2023 17:42

We have to create a situation where men want to do things rather than feel obliged to do things. Otherwise it will never last. From a behaviouralist perspective this is all about reinforcement. Nobody goes to work for the fun of it (we aren't a charity after wall, we go to get paid). It is the same premise here.

So turn this on its head. We have to create a situation where women want to do things rather than feel obliged to do things. Otherwise it'll never last.

Hence as I said, an increasing number of women now making the very rational drcision not to be involved with a man.

What kind of "pay" do you think men should be getting for doing their own share of the basic tasks of an adult, and who is it you expect to pay them?

It appears that underlying your comments there is misogyny because inherent in the above statements is that somehow men would be doing women a favour by fulfilling their own basic responsibilities to do half of the work involved in maintaining a clean and functioning home if there are two adults living in it. And that women should somehow feel the need to incentivise them to do this? 🤣 No thanks.

Stillcountingbeans · 02/02/2023 17:24

A poster is now trying to convince everyone booking a holiday is a mental load. I'm genuinely lost for words.

Lucky you.
DH took on the whole mental load for our last holiday: comparing hotels and resorts, finding cheap flights, checking dates, currency, activities, covid passports, checking cabin bag measurements, weighing suitcases, the lot.

He was so stressed out by it all he said that he was never, ever going to organise another holiday again.

If you don't understand that being responsible for organising a holiday is a mental load, then you really don't understand the concept at all.

Or you are pretending not to understand because you are putting on a 'I'm cool, I am so laid back' persona.

NocturnalClocks · 02/02/2023 17:23

I'd politely ask why would men do things unless they have to? Why would ANYONE unless they have to?

The reason is because men can tolerate not doing things much longer than women can (from my experience) and rather than holding them to account, women just do the work. If I know my partner is doing all the work, why would I bother myself and get extra stressed?

Ummmm... on an individual basis presumably because they aren't utterly selfish and actually care about the wellbeing of the other people in their family.

On a wider basis, because an increasing proportion of women are shunning cohabiting win men or marriage/ other financial entanglements to them because of the prevalence of exactly the type of selfish attitudes you've just described.

Why would anybody want to live with or be in a relationship with someone so callous that they view other people in such a way and do not actually care about them?

You've rather proved the point that people have been making.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 17:11

@Burgoo

BTW I find that there is a tendency to demonise "men" as a collective. We aren't all horrific lay-abouts and I believe it is less about "men" and more about individuals who can get away with it.

This is a fair point and actually it does undermine feminist argument to apply this to all men. Try "patriarchy". It's not (all) individual men, its the way (most) men function in a patriarchal society.

But I disagree profoundly with you on the idea that it's a woman's job to incentivise a man to do all this stuff. It all comes back to what do we (women) get out of this?

What is the upside for a woman in being with a man who has to be bullied, nagged, cajoled or otherwise "incentivised" to wash the dishes or do the ironing. I don't want to do all this myself but I'd far rather do it myself than do it on behalf of a healthy adult male who could be doing some of it. There is literally no point to having such a man around.

Botw1 · 02/02/2023 17:05

@Burgoo

Except people do go to work for the fun of it.

Volunteering is a thing

I have zero interest in pretending that men as a species are biologically wired to be able to tolerate mess or that women are responsible for having to coax them into doing their share

Fuck that

Who wants to have kids with a man who has to be persuaded to care for them?!

Burgoo · 02/02/2023 17:03

@SandraCumin

"Well actually studies have shown that women are traditionally inclined towards lesbianism and only with the advent of patriarchal colonialist attitudes did we see a conditioning towards heterosexual monogamy."

That ignores the level of domestic abuse in lesbian (and gay) relationships. There is a fair amount of data on woman on woman domestic abuse - particularly psychological.

I want to see these studies too. Evolutionarily we need to procreate, so this idea that it is conditioning to be in a heterosexual and monogamous relationship is hugely disingenuous. From a biological perspective it is simply untrue. And I say that as a bisexual man.

Burgoo · 02/02/2023 17:00

@Winterday1991

I am speaking as a man who has a fairly even relationship with my partner when it comes to splitting chores (though she does the washing up, I do the cooking - I hate washing up!)

I'd politely ask why would men do things unless they have to? Why would ANYONE unless they have to?

The reason is because men can tolerate not doing things much longer than women can (from my experience) and rather than holding them to account, women just do the work. If I know my partner is doing all the work, why would I bother myself and get extra stressed?

Now I am NOT saying that this is morally right. Is it self-centred and showing a lack of respect? Sure. And at the same time the fact remains...people often don't want to do what they can get away with not doing.

For example, I can EASILY live in a dump. Plates piled up in the sink? Not a problem! Grime on the bath? Easy! Dust all over the carpet? Piece of cake! Thankfully my wife is the same so we just end up blitzing the house every so often!

The question I have is, what incentive do some men (or anyone who is lazy) have to do the chores? Being a "good partner" isn't enough. We have to create a situation where men want to do things rather than feel obliged to do things. Otherwise it will never last. From a behaviouralist perspective this is all about reinforcement. Nobody goes to work for the fun of it (we aren't a charity after wall, we go to get paid). It is the same premise here.

BTW I find that there is a tendency to demonise "men" as a collective. We aren't all horrific lay-abouts and I believe it is less about "men" and more about individuals who can get away with it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 16:59

@SandraCumin

Well actually studies have shown that women are traditionally inclined towards lesbianism and only with the advent of patriarchal colonialist attitudes did we see a conditioning towards heterosexual monogamy.

Would be interested to see those studies...

Even if that were true (and I am very sceptical), I don't think its really the point.

I agree with @DanseAvecLesLoup that it's a myth that women will innately live harmoniously without men. They may not be at risk of sexual violence or exploitation but women can still abuse and neglect other women.

The goal should be for women to be financially self-sufficient and with decent support networks that are not based on sexual or romantic entanglements of any kind. Swapping an onerous financial contract based on heterosexual sex to one based on lesbian sex is a bit out of the frying pan, into the fire, surely?

I agree with your broad point that it's a good idea for women to reduce financial reliance on men as far as possible but in a world where a majority of women identify as heterosexual lesbianism for all isn't a viable end goal for feminism.

NocturnalClocks · 02/02/2023 16:48

Hence my question about how will a 'female only family cluster' organise themselves when one or more of them has different priorities be it career progression or say sporting goals (i.e something that is a time rich commitment)? You also did not answer what you do with a female member of the commune who is lazy or does not pull their weight? Your utopian premise is based on all women in the commune being roughly equal in terms of hours they work and their availability to equally contribute domestically to the household/commune.

I didn't answer your question because I have no idea why you have directed it at me. I have mot suggested women should live in communes or female-only groups. I'm quite happy as a single woman raising my children alone, thanks. So the only person that needs to "pull their weight" is me.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/02/2023 16:29

SandraCumin · 02/02/2023 16:00

Well actually studies have shown that women are traditionally inclined towards lesbianism and only with the advent of patriarchal colonialist attitudes did we see a conditioning towards heterosexual monogamy. Breaking that conditioning would essentially be breaking the stranglehold that men have over our sexuality, which is ultimately the final stage of feminism.

What 'studies' are these?

Botw1 · 02/02/2023 16:01

@SandraCumin

What a load of shit

😂😂

SandraCumin · 02/02/2023 16:00

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 14:43

@DanseAvecLesLoup

in these small female only clusters, what happens when someone is not pulling their weight with the chores and 'mental load', what if one of the women prioritises their super high powered career over others in the 'cluster' by working late or travelling a lot? Are you really assuming that women are incapable of being crap, lazy or prioritising their own self interest over others?

It’s a fair question and I actually disagree with @SandraCumin in that I don’t think women are automatically better able to sort this out because they are women.

But the critical difference is that heterosexual women are not going to be romantically entangled with other heterosexual women and will not be emotionally invested and financially invested to the same degree.

So they can share support and help each other without the weight of expectation and dependence.

Well actually studies have shown that women are traditionally inclined towards lesbianism and only with the advent of patriarchal colonialist attitudes did we see a conditioning towards heterosexual monogamy. Breaking that conditioning would essentially be breaking the stranglehold that men have over our sexuality, which is ultimately the final stage of feminism.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 15:18

@DanseAvecLesLoup

Its an interesting concept but I guess my views are somewhat tainted by what I witnessed in various flatshares in my 20s where the women demonstrated that they could be just as lazy, messy, selfish and entitled as some of my male flatmates when it came to various chores and pulling their weight. And the idea that women by default will just sit down and sensibly sort out any disputes in a calm and respectful manner is laughable.

Yeah I totally agree and to reiterate I don't think women are more likely to create a female-driven utopia just because they don't have male hormones.

Also I don't think we're necessarily talking about living with other women.

But the critical problem with marriage and cohabitation is that they link a financial contract with an emotional/sexual commitment and it's an incredibly blunt instrument. You're basically seeking to yoke two people together in what is theoretically a lifelong financial partnership purely on the basis that they wanted to shag each other and had children as a result (I know in theory there's more to it than that etc but this is the brass tacks).

If you take emotion/romance out of the business of creating a support network for you and your children but create a loose financial and support sharing agreement you are likely to be able to be more dispassionate about any differences of opinion which do arise and if someone isn't their pulling their weight you can part ways reasonably amicably without it involving a huge amount of money and legal fandangle.

If you want to get a joint mortgage with a female friend that's all fine and if you part ways there will be some disruption but without the massive recriminations involved with a divorce. Or not even live together but just have a mutual support/childcare agreement.

It takes a village etc and everyone needs a bit of support but in my personal opinion creating a legally binding contract with someone to share all finances for life based on sex and shared children is a crazy way to run your life. I know most people disagree with this though...

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/02/2023 14:58

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 14:43

@DanseAvecLesLoup

in these small female only clusters, what happens when someone is not pulling their weight with the chores and 'mental load', what if one of the women prioritises their super high powered career over others in the 'cluster' by working late or travelling a lot? Are you really assuming that women are incapable of being crap, lazy or prioritising their own self interest over others?

It’s a fair question and I actually disagree with @SandraCumin in that I don’t think women are automatically better able to sort this out because they are women.

But the critical difference is that heterosexual women are not going to be romantically entangled with other heterosexual women and will not be emotionally invested and financially invested to the same degree.

So they can share support and help each other without the weight of expectation and dependence.

Its an interesting concept but I guess my views are somewhat tainted by what I witnessed in various flatshares in my 20s where the women demonstrated that they could be just as lazy, messy, selfish and entitled as some of my male flatmates when it came to various chores and pulling their weight. And the idea that women by default will just sit down and sensibly sort out any disputes in a calm and respectful manner is laughable. Just because women are not as violent as men it does not automatically mean they will not be complete arses to each other when disputes arise. The Mumsnet forums would collapse overnight if women were all super nice to each other all the time.

Botw1 · 02/02/2023 14:49

I don't find working full time in a hugely stressful job, parenting and doing 'life admin' that difficult.

I don't struggle to fit it in. Im a bit baffled by people who do. (usual caveats aside)

But that is not the point!

It's not my job or responsibility to do it all. Regardless of how easy or hard it is.

Im honestly not sure how we've got stuck on this completely irrelevant point

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 14:43

@DanseAvecLesLoup

in these small female only clusters, what happens when someone is not pulling their weight with the chores and 'mental load', what if one of the women prioritises their super high powered career over others in the 'cluster' by working late or travelling a lot? Are you really assuming that women are incapable of being crap, lazy or prioritising their own self interest over others?

It’s a fair question and I actually disagree with @SandraCumin in that I don’t think women are automatically better able to sort this out because they are women.

But the critical difference is that heterosexual women are not going to be romantically entangled with other heterosexual women and will not be emotionally invested and financially invested to the same degree.

So they can share support and help each other without the weight of expectation and dependence.

MsMarch · 02/02/2023 14:39

No actually, I was pointing out that booking a holiday is just yet another task that has to be done and can be time consuming. Which, if you're already doing a million other tasks including holding down a job, cooking, cleaning etc, can feel completely overwhelming.

And the implication was that if you are doing all of these actual tasks or the extra things while your so-called DP is sitting around watching the football, it can be pretty quick for the resentment to set in.

When I was single, booking a holiday was fun. I could spend days on it. It was part of the enjoyment of the holiday. Now, I'd LIKE to enjoy it, but I have to fit it in between all the other shit I'm doing including running my own, successful business, parenting, cooking, cleaning etc. And I'm not even one of those women who has to do this all alone becuase my DH is very hands on and does his share.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/02/2023 14:33

Mischance · 02/02/2023 14:17

This begs two questions:

  • what sort of men are we bringing up in our society, and how might we do it better?
  • what motivates women to marry these unsatisfactory men, and how might we bring up women with the strength and self-respect to say no to them?

I imagine on your second point it is the same reasons why many men marry unsatisfactory women, low confidence and low self esteem with side helping of societal/peer group pressure to 'settle down'. I am in my late 40s now and have seen too many of my male and female friends, family and work colleagues marry absolute fucking twats. It was clear these people were absolute twats when they first came on scene and continued to demonstrate such twattish behaviour when they moved in together and surprise surprise became even bigger twats post marraige and children.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/02/2023 14:22

NocturnalClocks · 02/02/2023 12:54

So in these small female only clusters, what happens when someone is not pulling their weight with the chores and 'mental load', what if one of the women prioritises their super high powered career over others in the 'cluster' by working late or travelling a lot?

I know it appears to be difficult for you to comprehend, but women are capable of being both present for their children and having very successful careers, as I explained to you earlier in the thread. If men are so pathetic that they think doing both is impossible then they make themselves obsolete.

People generally comment on here that men often only get to these lofty career heights by having a partner at home supporting them by doing the lions share of parenting and managing the household. Generally speaking, those people who are partners at law firms, running hedge funds and managing multibillion pound projects (very successful career people) do not get there by running out the office door at 5pm and working a typical 40 hour week and having free weekends. Not a problem if you are single but trying to wrap the demands of those careers (massive overtime, extra training and qualifications, international travel, being in contention for promotions etc) with a family is extremely difficult without a lot of support (partner, parents, external). Hence my question about how will a 'female only family cluster' organise themselves when one or more of them has different priorities be it career progression or say sporting goals (i.e something that is a time rich commitment)? You also did not answer what you do with a female member of the commune who is lazy or does not pull their weight? Your utopian premise is based on all women in the commune being roughly equal in terms of hours they work and their availability to equally contribute domestically to the household/commune.

Swipe left for the next trending thread