Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So angry at all these threads on useless and selfish men

820 replies

Winterday1991 · 30/01/2023 15:31

Off the back of the thread where the H refuses to care for his sick child so the OP can get some much needed rest as he is on annual leave from work 😡. I am seriously fed up of reading threads like this, why are so many men so selfish?

Why is it always women who have to do the lions share of caring, pulling themselves in all direction whilst their male counterparts glide through life uninterrupted? Why is it always women who carry the mental load for family life and the men just show up. Why is always women responsible for maintaining the household?

Even in the 21st century, why do so many men get such a bloody easy ride, whilst often their poor wives/partners are running around like headless chickens keeping on top of everything.

OP posts:
SandraCumin · 03/02/2023 19:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mark19735 · 03/02/2023 19:01

You are of course entitled to you view, but I'd counter with anyone who gets mad at a dog for not eating with a knife and fork is the crazy one. The dog will just look at you incomprehensibly, then go and lick its balls. And then you'll go and hug it later anyway. Or if you don't, it will sulk for a bit until someone else gives it a hug.

I think I can probably guess what we would think of anyone who advocates kicking the dog (or abandoning it) ...

SandraCumin · 03/02/2023 18:57

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 18:52

Men have low expectations of them, but they shouldn’t. So many household jobs don’t require a vagina to complete them, so why should women be the default parent, the default cleaner?
Men absolutely should be expected to do better.
As much as plenty of us fantasise about life without men, this is only because they are, on the whole, so lacking. We should really aspire to more from them.

So many people rear their sons well, to consider women and girls, but sadly something happens - maybe some hive mind thing - and too many leave these valuable lessons behind them.

Yes men should do better, but they’ll never be able to be on par with us as a class. To expect them to be our equals would be akin to expecting a dog to learn how to use a knife and fork.

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 18:56

BigFatLiar · 03/02/2023 18:44

Surely you'd have a reasonable idea of how things would be before you married.

Not sure if this was aimed at me, but no, no idea. H was an equal in every way. It was after 3 dc that things changed. Maternity leave had changed from 12 weeks (dc1) to 12 months (dc3) and he resented it, called it a holiday (because being home with 3 under 4 was such fun!).
Things went slowly downhill from there. Once disabilities were diagnosed it all collapsed, whilst he felt he was being ultra supportive.

There were no clues, even with hindsight.

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 18:52

SandraCumin · 03/02/2023 18:39

In fairness, we absolutely should be held to higher standards than men because we are better than them in practically every conceivable matter. The only things they excel in over us is matters of violence and depravity.

Men have low expectations of them, but they shouldn’t. So many household jobs don’t require a vagina to complete them, so why should women be the default parent, the default cleaner?
Men absolutely should be expected to do better.
As much as plenty of us fantasise about life without men, this is only because they are, on the whole, so lacking. We should really aspire to more from them.

So many people rear their sons well, to consider women and girls, but sadly something happens - maybe some hive mind thing - and too many leave these valuable lessons behind them.

BigFatLiar · 03/02/2023 18:44

Surely you'd have a reasonable idea of how things would be before you married.

Mark19735 · 03/02/2023 18:41

I'm not gonna disagree that by treating people as individuals, free to go it alone or couple up (or even live communally in social groups of three or more) that the tax system has systemic properties as you described. (Although really, they aren't five different examples, they are variations of the same one, which is that multiple people co-habiting get to pool multiple tax allowances and thresholds. You are wrong on the Council tax, by the way ... the 25% discount is based on an assessment that half the council tax is for costs on a per/household basis regardless of occupancy, and half is based on costs on a per adult occupant basis and assumed two adults per property. Hence a 25% discount for single occupancy is fair.)

But the abolition of the regime that treated households as the single taxable entity was one of the first goals of feminism. Many women consider having their own tax allowances a massive win. It's a cornerstone of financial independence. It's also a benefit that anyone can chose to enjoy - you simply have to chose to co-habit with someone. The sex of that person, or whether you are romantically involved or not, is inconsequential. So it's not a disadvantage if all people could have it, but where some make life choices like eschewing living with a partner that mean they don't ...

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:41

Rubbish. Men are perfectly capable of being decent human beings. We as a society need to make it clear that this is what is expected, and that nobody will be interested in being their friend/ family/ partner unless they do.

SandraCumin · 03/02/2023 18:39

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 18:32

by people becoming as disgusted with a man for leaving his children as they would be for a woman and shunning them

Exactly! Women are held to much higher standards across the board, and some of the worst criticism comes from other women!
Have some solidarity, smash the patriarchy instead of propping it up!

In fairness, we absolutely should be held to higher standards than men because we are better than them in practically every conceivable matter. The only things they excel in over us is matters of violence and depravity.

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:39

Oh and @Badbadbunny then, if there is anything left at the end, can leave their DC only half as much without paying inheritance tax. So it's even compounded on an inter-genenerational level.

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:33

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 18:32

by people becoming as disgusted with a man for leaving his children as they would be for a woman and shunning them

Exactly! Women are held to much higher standards across the board, and some of the worst criticism comes from other women!
Have some solidarity, smash the patriarchy instead of propping it up!

Exactly!

I've made some very practical suggestions in this thread of policies people could lobby their MPs to include in their next manifestos to start that process.

I wonder how many will do so...

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 18:32

by people becoming as disgusted with a man for leaving his children as they would be for a woman and shunning them

Exactly! Women are held to much higher standards across the board, and some of the worst criticism comes from other women!
Have some solidarity, smash the patriarchy instead of propping it up!

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/02/2023 18:31

But easy or hard, it's work that person one never has to think about, and that's the source of the resentment.

This is it in a nutshell.

Mental load applies when one person knows it doesn’t really matter if they drop a ball (or several), because the other person will catch it.

It’s the domestic equivalent of thinking “I can bunk off at 3 and go to the pub because I know someone will cover”.

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:24

soboredtonight · 03/02/2023 18:20

Had a bit of a row this morning over the is. My DH said he has done the washing and drying of the clothes this week twice. I said so fucking what you live here.

🤣🤣🤣 Jesus Christ. What a hero. 🎻

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:22

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 17:41

It's the perception of it being equitable and sustainable for the family.

Yes, this.
My situation was being SAHM to disabled children (ex had been great until after dc were born), where every day including the weekend was like living in a war zone, ex got to spend his days with rational adults who didn’t need constant supervision and who never punched or spat at him. He would then swan in at 6pm and expect our home to be a haven of peace and tranquility, because he worked and I got to stay at home. He felt he had a bum deal, I felt that I had. He would kindly point out that housework hadn’t been done, but apart from cooking for us would do nothing, because he worked.

Amongst families including disabled children this scenario seems very common, and women are very often more trapped and stuck with far more on their plate because you can’t just up your work hours, or outsource parts of childcare or cleaning etc. It’s difficult to separate.

I see most other women living this to some degree or other and most just put up with it, because it’s just what women do.
When I split with my ex so many friends who had apparently happy marriages came and told me how jealous they were that I’d bitten the bullet. So many women are in mediocre marriages, not because they’ve chosen badly, but because having children has upset the balance and women are having to pick ip the slack.

I agree wholeheartedly with those posters who say to keep men out of things. It’s just not worth it.

Yep. And once you're stuck in that cycle, you are trapped.

Fortunately (?) my husband left before we got into that, so I've always had to cope with it all on my own and giving up work was not an option. Hello £3.5k childcare bill per month for specialist childcare for disabled children. Plus the mortgage. And what did he contribute, any childcare or money? Nope. So either way, you cannot win and these useless men do need holding to account, forcing to do their share by the tax and CMS system being fix, by people becoming as disgusted with a man for leaving his children as they would be for a woman and shunning them, by fixing employment policies and childcare so that fewer women ever become financially dependent on men, by us all raising our sons and daughters to know better.

But arguing that the status quo is ok, women's fault, or even desirable (!?) is beyond mind numbingly stupid, and it's sad there have been so many posters doing so.

soboredtonight · 03/02/2023 18:20

Had a bit of a row this morning over the is. My DH said he has done the washing and drying of the clothes this week twice. I said so fucking what you live here.

ConcordeOoter · 03/02/2023 18:16

Botw1 · 03/02/2023 18:12

So in marks world of financial supremacy a nurse who works full time should do all the housework and parenting because they earn less than their oh who is an IT cons who sits on their arse all day?

😂😂

It just doesn't make any sense. Yes if one of the couple earns much more money both partners might choose to prioritise it (would be nuts not to), but past a certain point a difference in wages would lock you at 0% of the housework for life...how convenient.

There's one situation where 0% housework would be justified, that's where there no/adult kids and DP is working 0 hours a week. Other than that, nope

Botw1 · 03/02/2023 18:12

So in marks world of financial supremacy a nurse who works full time should do all the housework and parenting because they earn less than their oh who is an IT cons who sits on their arse all day?

😂😂

ConcordeOoter · 03/02/2023 18:11

Stillcountingbeans · 03/02/2023 16:57

All the angst appears to be emanating from people for whom it is axiomatic that mental load be shared 50:50, and yet it can be proven that this will make any household poorer. Very few people want this.

My position is that all housework, childcare and mental load should be split according to the hours that both partners work outside the home. If one partner is working half as many hours as the other, they get to do 2/3 of the household work. It makes no difference how 'easy' or 'hard' each outside job is perceived to be, or how much each person earns doing it.
This way both partners should find that they have equal amounts of leisure and rest time.
The end goal is not maximising household income, it is equalising leisure/rest hours.

Same here, but it works out at 75% for half the hours worked.

The hours are just treated as hours, because this is fair - although there are some extra allowances made when the job requires it

5128gap · 03/02/2023 18:10

I agree, mental load is only a thing when only one person in a family carries it all.
It refers to partnerships where one party, typically the man, pretty much lives as if he is a child in the parental home. He goes to work, hands over some money for expenses, and maybe (but by no means always) sorts out things directly related to himself, his car, his clothes etc. Meanwhile the other partner organises and implements everything else to keep the home and family running.
Whether this is hard work or not for person two is debatable and variable. Some people have higher standards and/or more complex lives than others, so naturally will find it more challenging than people with more time and smaller lives.
But easy or hard, it's work that person one never has to think about, and that's the source of the resentment.

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:09

Actually no, married couples also get an extra tax break with transferring part of their partner's personal allowance as well if one of them decides not to work/ work very little. So can still pay less tax on the same household income than the single parent is paying. Even thougj they have 48 hours per day to earn money/ care for children instead of 24.

So yes, factually, it is undeniable that at every level through the tax system it is designed to disadvantage single parent households, and does so very effectively.

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:06

Sorry I meant a couple where one person decides not to work at all.

NocturnalClocks · 03/02/2023 18:01

Badbadbunny · 03/02/2023 11:48

@NocturnalClocks

Can you elaborate on what you mean by "tax equalisation". As far as I know, tax is the same whether you're the wife or the husband. Wasn't it in the 80's when independent taxation was brought in?

Sure. What I mean is that single parents (over 90% of them women) are discriminated against throughout the tax system. Much of this applies to single people with no children, too, but it has a far bigger impact on single parents and is one of the main driving factors of our child poverty levels and children from single parent households (and the almost-all women running those households being disadvantaged deliberately by Government policy. Single parent households:

get a 25% discount on Council tax, not 50%;

can earn only half as much income as a two parent houshold can before they are subject to income tax;

can earn only half as much income as a two parent household can before they are subject to higher rate tax;

can earn only half as much income as a two parent household can before they lose child benefit;

can earn only half as much income as a two parent household can before they pay additional rate tax;

can earn only half as much income as a two parent household can before they lose the entitlement to the 15 hours extra funding at nursery for children over 3; and

can earn only half as much income as a two parent houshold can before they lose their eligibility for "tax free childcare".

While single these parents are doing the work of two parents: providing financially and childcare. They have 24 hours per day to split between these tasks whereas a couple has 48 hours per day to do these things and split between them as they see fit. A single parent will likely have higher costs also for this reason, needing additional childcare/ cleaners or whatever because they only have 24 hours. And yet they are taxed more heavily on the same household income.

A couple who decides to not work at all would pay the level of tax a single parent pays on their household income. But they would have no childcare costs at all. So much better off, obviously. A couple where both parents work can share childcare and work between them so have far more free time and lower childcare costs than the single parent AND also pay far less in tax.

This is very deliverate penalisation of single parents through these tax systems which is easily fixed.

Many countries (France, Denmark etc) levy taxes on a households basis for this reason.

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 17:41

It's the perception of it being equitable and sustainable for the family.

Yes, this.
My situation was being SAHM to disabled children (ex had been great until after dc were born), where every day including the weekend was like living in a war zone, ex got to spend his days with rational adults who didn’t need constant supervision and who never punched or spat at him. He would then swan in at 6pm and expect our home to be a haven of peace and tranquility, because he worked and I got to stay at home. He felt he had a bum deal, I felt that I had. He would kindly point out that housework hadn’t been done, but apart from cooking for us would do nothing, because he worked.

Amongst families including disabled children this scenario seems very common, and women are very often more trapped and stuck with far more on their plate because you can’t just up your work hours, or outsource parts of childcare or cleaning etc. It’s difficult to separate.

I see most other women living this to some degree or other and most just put up with it, because it’s just what women do.
When I split with my ex so many friends who had apparently happy marriages came and told me how jealous they were that I’d bitten the bullet. So many women are in mediocre marriages, not because they’ve chosen badly, but because having children has upset the balance and women are having to pick ip the slack.

I agree wholeheartedly with those posters who say to keep men out of things. It’s just not worth it.

MiaMoor · 03/02/2023 17:28

Welcome to mumsnet, where feminist hypocrisy thrives and is the man hating capital of the Internet. Imagine if there was a dad's net...

Imagine if you looked at any number of male centred forums and the misogyny found in them, even ones aimed at dads.

Take Reddit - biggest lesbian sub is a porn sub, actuallesbians has been infiltrated by men and actual lesbians are banned if they’re not happy about it, other women only subs are banned unless they become male inclusive. Incel subs are rife, porn subs disgustingly common.
One sub that actually focuses on teaching women the skills to spot red flags and learn how to choose a male partner well are constantly under attack and has alternative locations ready because the sub can be suspended or blocked at a moments notice.

Mumsnet is a place where women can come and be unapologetically themselves, say it how it is. In many women’s experiences men are useless - there’s nothing hypocritical about this, and a couple of posters disagreeing doesn’t change the fact that in most households it is the woman who does the majority of the work, and that this can be incredibly divisive and causes couples to split up.

Also this assumption that “well I can do xyz easily therefore anyone who can’t is lazy” is such a shitty attitude. We all have different skill sets, the mental load and keeping on top of family necessities is very challenging for some, whilst work is a walk in the park.

Swipe left for the next trending thread