Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So angry at all these threads on useless and selfish men

820 replies

Winterday1991 · 30/01/2023 15:31

Off the back of the thread where the H refuses to care for his sick child so the OP can get some much needed rest as he is on annual leave from work 😡. I am seriously fed up of reading threads like this, why are so many men so selfish?

Why is it always women who have to do the lions share of caring, pulling themselves in all direction whilst their male counterparts glide through life uninterrupted? Why is it always women who carry the mental load for family life and the men just show up. Why is always women responsible for maintaining the household?

Even in the 21st century, why do so many men get such a bloody easy ride, whilst often their poor wives/partners are running around like headless chickens keeping on top of everything.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
aurorauk · 29/01/2024 10:32

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/02/2023 14:50

@ConcordeOoter

Sorry I am not clear why you think I am making a sexist assumption?

I’m not making any assumptions whatsoever about the sex of the non working partner. It could be a man or a woman. But it’s demonstrably true that if you don’t work, you don’t get paid and therefore (unless you have private income) aren’t financially independent. I’m not sure what’s controversial about that?

It happens also to be true that most non working spouses are women.

Hence the comments from other posters about equality. A system which incentivises one partner to become wholly financially dependent on the other and where the dependent partner is almost always a woman, cannot be considered equal.

This isn’t to denigrate the work that non paid partners do. But you can’t duck the fact that the dependent partner has no financial autonomy.

Ooop, no, he's an incel. We're talking about the WELL KNOWN BY EVERYONE issue of men not being adults and doing the stuff they should be doing and this one person has to come and remind us, as if we don't already know, that some women are bad. Thanks, Einstein! But this is about what women should do about the pandemic of lazy, selfish men.

aurorauk · 29/01/2024 10:30

ConcordeOoter · 30/01/2023 16:16

If it's any consolation there are plenty of selfish, disloyal, lazy, manipulative, grasping, cheating, backstabbing, shitstirring and abusive women, too.

If you think about it, if one or two are on MN they will be telling us all a tall tale about their husband and the best MN users can do is take it at face value and try to be supportive.

It's to be expected that we see one side of the story because it's mumsnet. That's how it should be... but don't forget that on any given day the majority of people who are having a perfectly ok or even lovely day with their DH or DW aren't seeking out a forum to tell you about it. Don't let it grind you down.

Found the female misogynist!

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/02/2023 14:50

@ConcordeOoter

Sorry I am not clear why you think I am making a sexist assumption?

I’m not making any assumptions whatsoever about the sex of the non working partner. It could be a man or a woman. But it’s demonstrably true that if you don’t work, you don’t get paid and therefore (unless you have private income) aren’t financially independent. I’m not sure what’s controversial about that?

It happens also to be true that most non working spouses are women.

Hence the comments from other posters about equality. A system which incentivises one partner to become wholly financially dependent on the other and where the dependent partner is almost always a woman, cannot be considered equal.

This isn’t to denigrate the work that non paid partners do. But you can’t duck the fact that the dependent partner has no financial autonomy.

NocturnalClocks · 07/02/2023 14:28

The void that you occupy, hence you heard me.

Mark19735 · 07/02/2023 14:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Stillcountingbeans · 07/02/2023 13:54

SandraCumin · 07/02/2023 13:39

Maybe, or maybe not, but men shouldn’t even be on here anyway so the point is moot.

Mumsnet is open to all - men and women.

I would love for Mellymoon to start a thread explaining their position and reasons - it would be great fun!!

SandraCumin · 07/02/2023 13:39

Mellymoon · 07/02/2023 11:35

theres a lot of useless and selfish women too but if men set up loads of threads on it They would get interpreted as mysogenistic and would probably flag up somewhere.

Maybe, or maybe not, but men shouldn’t even be on here anyway so the point is moot.

ConcordeOoter · 07/02/2023 13:08

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/02/2023 08:15

It is neither here nor there in terms of equality, unless you make a sexist assumption about who is doing it, and demean the sahp role as something lesser.

It clearly does effect equality because the SAHP is removed from the labour market and is unable to function without the working spouse (unless they have independent income). They are therefore completely dependent on the working spouse so by definition not equal.

This isn’t a value judgement on the work a SAHP performs it’s a simple statement of fact. One partner can leave whenever they want, the other can’t without significant impact to theirs and their children’s quality of life.

In replying to my point you quite literally made the type of assumption I specified as "unless".

I'm going to assume you were polite enough to read my comment before replying and are just agreeing with me.

NocturnalClocks · 07/02/2023 13:05

Stillcountingbeans · 07/02/2023 09:54

@Mark19735

You are right that so few people seem to understand the basis of scientific research, what data is, what anecdote and observation are, what information is, what a theory is, and that truth is not synonymous with a published paper.

But your final comment about creationists is just snarky and unpleasant - it doesn't help the discussion.

Snarky and also ridiculous given that he was the one that claimed that men had "evolved over thousands of generations" to have careers and women had "evolved" to do housework. And that horrible feminists had "ruined this equilibirum". 🤣🤣

And yeah, thanks Mark but I think that given my job is mainly driven by data and statistical analysis I have a pretty good grasp of what constitutes evidence and how that differs from your unsubstantiated - and at times absurdly laughable - claims.

5128gap · 07/02/2023 13:00

Mellymoon · 07/02/2023 11:35

theres a lot of useless and selfish women too but if men set up loads of threads on it They would get interpreted as mysogenistic and would probably flag up somewhere.

Well you're also perfectly at liberty to report this thread, so not sure what your point is.

Mellymoon · 07/02/2023 11:35

theres a lot of useless and selfish women too but if men set up loads of threads on it They would get interpreted as mysogenistic and would probably flag up somewhere.

Botw1 · 07/02/2023 10:58

@Stillcountingbeans

Sigh back.

I haven't misunderstood what you're saying.

You stated that you had no difficulty understanding that having a sahp had better outcomes for children, based on your apperent assumption that only sahp talk to or cook for their children and very limited anacdata about some parents who work long hours with no other childcare support

All I'm saying is that your understanding of sahp giving children better outcomes is flawed and wrong. For obvious reasons.

@PrincessConstance

Ive no idea why you keep using your own relationship as some kind of proof. It's completely irrelevant.

The benefits of being able to absolve yourself of all childcare requirements is obvious.

Stillcountingbeans · 07/02/2023 09:54

@Mark19735

You are right that so few people seem to understand the basis of scientific research, what data is, what anecdote and observation are, what information is, what a theory is, and that truth is not synonymous with a published paper.

But your final comment about creationists is just snarky and unpleasant - it doesn't help the discussion.

Stillcountingbeans · 07/02/2023 09:49

Botw1 · 06/02/2023 20:52

@Stillcountingbeans

Even parents who work 60/70 hours a week wouldnt automatically be guilty of neglect

Good quality childcare for working hours plus good quality time spent together on days off.

Wouldn't be my choice but its not neglect

Having a sahp isn't better for children

Sigh.
You have misread what I was saying. I made it clear I was talking about parents of teenagers who put no childcare in place, because the child was supposedly old enough to fend for themselves.

But perhaps this has gone off on a tangent to the main discussion which is about the different roles and workloads that men and women take.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/02/2023 08:15

It is neither here nor there in terms of equality, unless you make a sexist assumption about who is doing it, and demean the sahp role as something lesser.

It clearly does effect equality because the SAHP is removed from the labour market and is unable to function without the working spouse (unless they have independent income). They are therefore completely dependent on the working spouse so by definition not equal.

This isn’t a value judgement on the work a SAHP performs it’s a simple statement of fact. One partner can leave whenever they want, the other can’t without significant impact to theirs and their children’s quality of life.

PrincessConstance · 07/02/2023 07:11

Botw1 · 07/02/2023 06:28

@ConcordeOoter

Given that 98% of sahp are women it's not much of an assumption to be aware of the impacts the role has on equality.

The role is just parenting. No different to any other parenting choice. Not lesser or better but certainly has drawbacks and not something that should be promoted as an ideal.

It's obviously too easily achievable for some men to reap the benefits to their career by having a sahp.

What benefits? Surely the financial benefits are shared by the family.

Considerations on whether work is strictly utilitarian or hedonic or a blend of both. For instance, in our household, Dp's business is purely utilitarian, and my role despite longer hrs is hedonic. I enjoy my job. Dp, not so much, he does it purely for the money.
Plus it enables the family structure to function.
Whatever the choices a couple with children make the distribution of the benefits and burdens needs to be taken into consideration.

Botw1 · 07/02/2023 06:28

@ConcordeOoter

Given that 98% of sahp are women it's not much of an assumption to be aware of the impacts the role has on equality.

The role is just parenting. No different to any other parenting choice. Not lesser or better but certainly has drawbacks and not something that should be promoted as an ideal.

It's obviously too easily achievable for some men to reap the benefits to their career by having a sahp.

ConcordeOoter · 07/02/2023 02:18

Botw1 · 06/02/2023 22:33

@ConcordeOoter

The same is true of both parents working.

🤷

Neither have much impact one way or the other on outcomes for children (when all other factors are removed) with the added bonus of better outcomes for equality

I think a dedicated SAHP is not something everyone is able and willing to achieve, you do what you can.

It is neither here nor there in terms of equality, unless you make a sexist assumption about who is doing it, and demean the sahp role as something lesser.

Botw1 · 06/02/2023 22:33

@ConcordeOoter

The same is true of both parents working.

🤷

Neither have much impact one way or the other on outcomes for children (when all other factors are removed) with the added bonus of better outcomes for equality

ConcordeOoter · 06/02/2023 22:28

Botw1 · 06/02/2023 20:52

@Stillcountingbeans

Even parents who work 60/70 hours a week wouldnt automatically be guilty of neglect

Good quality childcare for working hours plus good quality time spent together on days off.

Wouldn't be my choice but its not neglect

Having a sahp isn't better for children

Not necessarily, but if the person doing the sahp role and the person fulfilling the provider role are effective and well suited to/happy those positions, and there is mutual love and respect, it's something well worth doing.

Mark19735 · 06/02/2023 22:10

There seems to be a complete absence of understanding of the basics of statistics and scientific method. Falsifiability, Representativeness, Generalisability, Correlation v. Causation? Where did anyone post that anyone working long hours is "automatically guilty of neglect"???

An observed phenomenon is just that. There are loads of factors that could cause that phenomenon. I wrote of a small number of single dads that were mainly widowers and far greater number of single mums that were mainly divorcees or never married. That observation is a fact. Not a theory. A fact. It referred to a specific cohort of people whose circumstances are known and whose children's outcomes have been measured. Whether that fact has enough validity to substantiate a theory is quite another matter. Whether that theory can be generalised to the general population is quite another matter. Neither of these claims were actually made - they were inferred.

Now, it is reasonable to wonder whether anything might explain those observations? For example - might differences in wealth have a stronger influence on a child's outcomes than the sex of the parent or their employment status? One might hypothesise that children living in single parent households where that parent is a widow / widower are, on average, wealthier than where that parent is a divorcee or was never married, all other things being equal. Intuitively it seems plausible that life insurance and/or compensation payments, which will have been paid to widows / widowers in at least some cases, will increase the average wealth of that cohort. Likewise it seems plausible that the expense of doubling up on the fixed overheads of maintaining two homes will reduce the average disposable income of parents who divorce, all other things being equal. It would seem like a reasonable basis for a research question. And I'd be staggered if there wasn't at least some influence on outcomes. There are hundreds of alternative hypotheses that could yet be explored, tested, found to have some utility, or discarded. The impact of long covid and lockdowns on learning is another massive topic that demands further research, where deteriorating outcomes are already clearly visible but the theories that explain-predict-control for those outcomes have not yet been developed or tested. We are not at a point yet where all knowledge has already been discovered, written up and published. Oh, hang on - unless you are a creationist. Of course. Makes more sense now.

Mark19735 · 06/02/2023 21:03

Good grief. What does the term latchkey kid refer to? Is it used pejoratively, or is it something parents are proud to call their kids, do you think?

Oh, and for all this chat about everything needing to be published as peer-reviewed research - citations please.

Botw1 · 06/02/2023 20:52

@Stillcountingbeans

Even parents who work 60/70 hours a week wouldnt automatically be guilty of neglect

Good quality childcare for working hours plus good quality time spent together on days off.

Wouldn't be my choice but its not neglect

Having a sahp isn't better for children

NocturnalClocks · 06/02/2023 20:01

Not quite nonsense. Absence of published research doesn't mean the idea is rubbish. Commonsense and your own life experience are also evidence, albeit not research evidence

When a great many large studies have been conducted and not found even a correlation has been found, it's ridiculous to assert that it is anything but unsubstantiated nonsense.

Stillcountingbeans · 06/02/2023 19:59

Botw1 · 06/02/2023 19:21

@Stillcountingbeans

How does common sense come into it?

Of course its nonsense to suggest working that working parents are more likely to neglect their children than a sahp

I am not talking about parents who both work a normal 30-40 hour week - obvs that is no problem. I am talking about parents who both work 60-70+ hours. That should have been clear from my original post about it.