Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alcholism opinions

186 replies

Dedoodedodi · 30/01/2023 15:17

Hi, I'm not new to Mumsnet but have decided to name change, I'm after people's honest opinions on alcholism and wether it is a illness/disease or a self inflicted lifestyle choice, and if that changes somewhere in-between the two, so what may start as bad choices and blows into alcholism and the related Ill health and symptoms that comes from that where is the line drawn between choices and illness? I don't want to say who I am in this equation and why I'm interested in other opinions, as I want to be unbiased as possible. Alcholism does obviously become a life threatening illness in the later stages, if you for example had someone really close to you that you know normally personality and the way they are is lovely and fine but over time slipped more under would you say they had a disease they couldn't fully control? Same as if you got cancer for example, you can't control if you get that or not to best of ability, there's no rules around do or do not do this or that to avoid it, is it the same league or is it different, and if it is, then why please? Can it change someone's personality over time that you knew to be a normal kind quiet person, is it a illness they cant help,the person, combination? I will like opinions to wrap my head around this issue. Thankyou

OP posts:
LawksaMercyMissus · 30/01/2023 17:23

I wish I knew. DH died of cirrhosis three weeks ago, still claiming he didn't have a problem.

I think there's a genetic element to it. I don't understand why he wouldn't have stopped if he could. He lost everything, family, home, job, dignity.

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 17:19

Please don't compare someone with an alcohol problem to somebody battling cancer.

It's offensive.

Addiction is a mental Illness yes, but you're not born addicted to alcohol. (Well some sad cases yes but that's not what I'm on about.)
You have to drink a significant amount over a significant amount of time (which IS a choice) to then become addicted. Which then leads to mental illness / addiction.

But is it in the same league as someone battling cancer, gruelling chemotherapy and surgeries, losing their hair and appearance and their lives probably wont be the same again, that's even if they survive the cancer? No. That's offensive.

Abhannmor · 30/01/2023 17:19

Alcohol definitely changes you both short and long term. I think the expression ' in vino veritas ' is very misused and misinterpreted. It just means you will say things best left unsaid after too much drink.

Not that 'lousy drunk ' you is the real you.

pointythings · 30/01/2023 17:17

@Paperdoll44 your first paragraph contradicts itself - if alcoholism is a symptom of mental ill health then it fits into the illness model. FWIW I agree with you. My late husband had incredibly low self esteem as well as depression. He didn't address those things either, he expected a pill to sort everything.

Alcoholism absolutely is life threatening. Heart disease, liver disease and cancer are all directly related to how much a person drinks. Alcohol related heart disease killed my husband, alcohol induced dementia destroyed my mother. A bottle of wine is one thing and some people can live a long time on that, but my husband and my mother drank a lot more than that. My husband put away 140 units a week that I knew of and it was more than that because I found out after he died that he had been reprimanded multiple times for drinking at work. I'd estimate another 50% on top of what I knew, and that does damage, quickly. My mother would go through a 75 cc bottle of spirits a day in her last 2 years.

Dedodedo · 30/01/2023 17:17

That's the confusing bit beezkneez, you say cancer example no one can choose or change the direction of what happens,we can all agree on that I think, addiction issues/alcholism although did start with choices,if you never ever drunk alcohol then you can't get alcholism, once it goes past a certain line does it not become less of a choice and a illness/disease, physiological changes etc, by the time people get the physical health symptoms or bad affects from the addiction then it's probably not just choice?

IsItJustMePfft · 30/01/2023 17:15

Going thru this with family member and have researched it. When someone keeps drinking it changes their brain, then it becomes a physical need rather than a psychological one. So it is deemed an illness. Its hard not to blame the person for not wanting to give up despite what its doing to them and the people around them. I just live in hope

Paperdoll44 · 30/01/2023 17:10

I don’t believe in the disease model. It is an addiction like any other. It is no more of a disease than addiction to smoking, gambling, porn etc. it is often the result of mental health difficulties, usually anxiety or depression.

To suggest it’s a ‘lifestyle choice’ is preposterous. Nobody would strive to be an alcoholic.

Alcoholism itself isn’t life threatening is it? It’s the knock on effect on internal organs, the risk of suicide or the impact of not eating well, and lack of self care, getting into accidents etc.

I know of a few functioning alcoholics (bottle of wine a night) who have maintained that level of drinking over years. They wax and wane but haven’t spiralled into morning drinking or a bottle of vodka a night. I don’t believe it necessarily gets progressively worse for all individuals.

Im prepared to be told I’m wrong but I have plenty of (albeit anecdotal) experience of alcoholism.

Beezknees · 30/01/2023 17:06

It's an illness. Addiction is a mental health problem, and mental illness is as valid as physical illness.

However, I don't think anyone should feel obligated to a family member or friend with alcoholism if they refuse to do anything to help themselves. It's different to cancer for example, people with cancer have no choice.

Dedodedo · 30/01/2023 16:31

No I understand nobody would want or want anyone they care about to have alcohol dependency or any other drugs too, but what started at very first as normal drinking with friends on weekends etc, to really quite slowly change into day drinking, big personality changes, reliance on alcohol, severe withdrawal symptoms, I do believe it is a illness, I can see signs of the underlying person I know at times,almost back to normal when doing ok, but doesn't last too long, bad stretch again, then a few weeks of good/normal personality again, I know this person to be really kind nice caring person, the differences in personality I see are quite staggering, I know she is still in there, I see the guilt and upset, and then it recycles round and round. I think once a line has been crossed it does become something they didn't ask for, don't want and can't always control? So although I've heard people say and judge it's not a illness, I think in future there will be a lot more understanding around this 'illness'. I honestly believe she's not actively choosing this,no more than I could chose to get something or not, it's mostly something we can't control? Although with this kind of thing, they maybe start with choices,make the wrong choices and by then it really is a real illness that is then as hard as any other illness you might get to influence, ie..not a lot, if I got a cancer next year I can do my best to be healthy as possible but I can't control wether it would go into remission or possibly spread even if I was the healthiest I could be, is this not the same after a certain point?

pointythings · 30/01/2023 16:03

It's an illness or a predisposition, but once the person in question knows they have it, they are just as obliged as anyone else to seek help and work hard towards finding recovery. My late husband was an alcoholic. When I married him, he was a great guy - smart, funny, hard working, caring and yes, a really great dad. Then life events hit him and even though he knew there was alcoholism in his family (his uncle and his brother) he turned to alcohol. And when he realised he was dependent, he simply told me that he was OK with that and that he was not going to do anything about it. He didn't, and ultimately the drink killed him, but not before he did an enormous amount of damage to his DC and to me.

So there's an element of illness to it, but there is also an element of choice.

Addiction does change people - in active addiction, your brain will crave the substance and every choice you make will be driven by that. It means you will lie, deceive, manipulate - anything to make sure you get what you're craving when you're craving it. People in active addiction are awful to be around.

Recovery is possible, but only the alcoholic themselves can make it happen. My sister's partner is also an alcoholic, but he is now 12 years sober. It's incredibly hard work, it means looking inside yourself to work out why you are turning to alcohol, but it can be done.

HelpASisterOut999 · 30/01/2023 15:48

It is an illness that gets progressively worse. It's very hard for someone in active addiction to get out of it but it is possible with a LOT of support and determination. Most people wouldn't choose to develop an alcohol addiction would they?
I see the argument from both sides, my ex drank himself to death in his 40s. I've been angry at him for not trying harder to get better, but services are stretched already and it takes a hell of a light of fight to come out the other side of addiction. I now choose to accept that he was too ill to get better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread