Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alcholism opinions

186 replies

Dedoodedodi · 30/01/2023 15:17

Hi, I'm not new to Mumsnet but have decided to name change, I'm after people's honest opinions on alcholism and wether it is a illness/disease or a self inflicted lifestyle choice, and if that changes somewhere in-between the two, so what may start as bad choices and blows into alcholism and the related Ill health and symptoms that comes from that where is the line drawn between choices and illness? I don't want to say who I am in this equation and why I'm interested in other opinions, as I want to be unbiased as possible. Alcholism does obviously become a life threatening illness in the later stages, if you for example had someone really close to you that you know normally personality and the way they are is lovely and fine but over time slipped more under would you say they had a disease they couldn't fully control? Same as if you got cancer for example, you can't control if you get that or not to best of ability, there's no rules around do or do not do this or that to avoid it, is it the same league or is it different, and if it is, then why please? Can it change someone's personality over time that you knew to be a normal kind quiet person, is it a illness they cant help,the person, combination? I will like opinions to wrap my head around this issue. Thankyou

OP posts:
Paperdoll44 · 30/01/2023 18:08

Regardless of whether some recognise it as a disease, it is speculation.

Describing it as a disease is not helpful in my opinion (as Lindor stated). It implies that it is an affliction and this can make the battle to overcome alcoholism seem even more daunting. It can seem as though you have to battle the forces of nature alongside your own demons.

I think it’s far healthier to recognise alcoholism as a self destructive coping strategy. That way the implication is that it can be overcome (for some).

Janieread · 30/01/2023 18:08

I don't believe it's a disease, unless you class fag addiction or heroin addiction as diseases. Alcohol is poison though, so over time it can damage your brain and internal organs which will make you very sick indeed.

According to a liver transplant surgeon that I sadly have reason to know ‐ personality changes, trouble with authorities due to drinking and drinking in the morning to relieve a hangover are all markers for future liver disease.

Eightypercent · 30/01/2023 18:08

@LindorDoubleChoc I think it is very harmful to tell alcoholics that they have a disease. It reinforces the idea that there is no element of choice or control and people become very frightened and continue to drink to blank out the fearl

Please do less thinking. You have pretty much completely contradicted the entire concept of addiction. Would you tell someone overweight or obese the same thing?

TomatoCultivator · 30/01/2023 18:03

It's incredibly hard work, it means looking inside yourself to work out why you are turning to alcohol, but it can be done.

Pointythings my father blamed everyone and everything for why he turned to alcohol particularly my long-suffering mother. Alanon says about family members ‘you didn’t cause it, you can’t control it, you can’t cure it’.

I agree with that and I certainly don’t think my mother or anyone else in the family was to blame for my father’s drinking.

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 18:00

ComeOnJohn · 30/01/2023 18:00

If people are using alcohol to self medicate an existing mental illness, that's their choosing. They've chosen to do so.

that’s far too simplistic @quarmadreen the mental torment that some people suffer is unbearable and so they reach for alcohol / drugs to turn it off, to get release from the torture, albeit temporarily. Nobody chooses to spiral into alcoholism. It’s very easy to sit in judgement when you have no idea what it feels like to suffer poor mental health.

How do you know I don't know what it feels like to have poor mental health?

ComeOnJohn · 30/01/2023 18:00

If people are using alcohol to self medicate an existing mental illness, that's their choosing. They've chosen to do so.

that’s far too simplistic @quarmadreen the mental torment that some people suffer is unbearable and so they reach for alcohol / drugs to turn it off, to get release from the torture, albeit temporarily. Nobody chooses to spiral into alcoholism. It’s very easy to sit in judgement when you have no idea what it feels like to suffer poor mental health.

ManchesterGirl2 · 30/01/2023 17:59

Dedoodedodi · 30/01/2023 15:17

Hi, I'm not new to Mumsnet but have decided to name change, I'm after people's honest opinions on alcholism and wether it is a illness/disease or a self inflicted lifestyle choice, and if that changes somewhere in-between the two, so what may start as bad choices and blows into alcholism and the related Ill health and symptoms that comes from that where is the line drawn between choices and illness? I don't want to say who I am in this equation and why I'm interested in other opinions, as I want to be unbiased as possible. Alcholism does obviously become a life threatening illness in the later stages, if you for example had someone really close to you that you know normally personality and the way they are is lovely and fine but over time slipped more under would you say they had a disease they couldn't fully control? Same as if you got cancer for example, you can't control if you get that or not to best of ability, there's no rules around do or do not do this or that to avoid it, is it the same league or is it different, and if it is, then why please? Can it change someone's personality over time that you knew to be a normal kind quiet person, is it a illness they cant help,the person, combination? I will like opinions to wrap my head around this issue. Thankyou

Like many things, I'd say it's a mix between the two. There are factors that make it far more likely to happen to some people than others, and its hard to stop once it starts, but there are also choices you can make, and many people do manage to stop. I think it's a bloody hard situation to be in, but doesn't remove all personal agency.

Choice or not, I believe that those around an alcoholic have the right, and responsibility, to set boundaries to protect their own safety and happiness.

OriGanOver · 30/01/2023 17:58

I don't believe it's a disease.

I don't actually believe in addiction although physical dependency is real.

Using substances to that point is a trauma reaction/coping mechanism. No one happy becomes addicted to drugs or alcohol.

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 17:56

pointythings · 30/01/2023 17:42

@quarmadreen your attitude towards mental ill health needs adjusting. The pain is just as real as that of any physical illness, and the stigma that still exists makes seeking help far harder than it is with a physical illness. A little empathy would become you.

I'm not saying mental illness is any less than physical. Where did I say that? And where have I lacked empathy? Bit of a reach there but okay. I said the start of alcohol abuse is a CHOICE. If you CHOOSE to self medicate your mental illness with alcohol, you are choosing to go down a slippery slope. Which then progresses to being an alcoholic. Which, as I said above, is then a mental illness.

Maybe read what I wrote before spouting on about me not being empathetic. I have cancer myself and an alcoholic mother so know both ends of the sword. So maybe stop jumping to conclusions yourself. No need for the defensive attitude.

Dedodedo · 30/01/2023 17:55

I think I just find it quite difficult, I didn't want to say as just wanted opinions with no basis to them, but it is my sibling, she's smart,pretty, kind, I sometimes just don't know how it got so bad,and then things went downhill really quite quick,I not talking a bottle of wine a night, I'm talking about all day pretty much drinking, at times, not always, as I said we will maybe have a good few weeks or months when she doesn't drink and seems to be doing better,and we see her old self we know, but it will change again at some point to a few weeks of heavy drinking again, probably a litre of vodka every 2 days all day topping up, maybe more that is hidden even, we know when she is drinking as the change in personality is so big, I just wish she wouldn't or didn't have this as she has so much going for her and she is now getting serious health consequences and social consequences and I think it's pushing her further in,is this the illness? The denial? I am going to look up al anon, I don't want her to think it's all ok but I don't want her to bury her head and carry on, when on a big bender she will drink around 5 or 6 litres of vodka over a week and that is a lot of units above

WhatdoImean · 30/01/2023 17:53

I have family members dealing with this right now. For those that say it is not a disease and cannot be "caught", I would suggest you research some of the details regarding inherited alcoholism.

Likewise - to the people who suggest it is a "life style choice", then so are SOME forms of cancer - lung cancer from smoking etc.

The physical dependency in alcoholism is frightening. You can go "cold turkey" from many drugs (opiates etc.) - you will feel like a complete and utter hole in the ground, and want to die, but you will not actually die of withdrawal symptoms. In alcoholism there is a literal physical dependency - you stop getting it, you die.

So yes, it is a disease, and like any other potentially fatal disease, physical or mental, it can tear a family apart. And it is.

LindorDoubleChoc · 30/01/2023 17:51

I think it is very harmful to tell alcoholics that they have a disease. It reinforces the idea that there is no element of choice or control and people become very frightened and continue to drink to blank out the fear.

What I find interesting about alcohlism is that some people can overcome it and recover and some can't. I don't know what the reason for the difference is.

Where I think we are lacking as a society is the understanding/sympathy/empathy/whatever we give to the families of alcoholics.

LemonPeonies · 30/01/2023 17:49

A lot of misinformation here. It's not a debate whether it's a disease, it's been recognised as a disease for over 50 years by medical professionals. Secondly the pp saying you have to drink a lot over a significant amount of time etc is wrong. Addiction is absolutely something you can be born with, you don't always need to have trauma in your life either. Plenty of people with healthy upbringing end up in AA, a lot are very young too.

HagridTheGiant · 30/01/2023 17:45

Alcoholism sadly runs in my family. Generations of it.
Looking at the family members who have become alcoholics, there is a strong history of trauma.
I don't think it's as simple as some people are making it out to be. Yes, people choose to drink to begin with. They don't choose for it to get out of control. It creeps up on them and tells them it's not a problem.

pointythings · 30/01/2023 17:42

@quarmadreen your attitude towards mental ill health needs adjusting. The pain is just as real as that of any physical illness, and the stigma that still exists makes seeking help far harder than it is with a physical illness. A little empathy would become you.

Paperdoll44 · 30/01/2023 17:32

Quarmadreen - I’m not sure you know enough about this issue to argue your case.

if you were in intense constant physical pain and only wine relieved it, would you drink the wine?

Emotional pain can be as debilitating.

Dedodedo · 30/01/2023 17:32

Sorry if that was offensive, didn't mean to be, I just wanted opinions on illness or choice which there is a lot of differing opinions on, I don't think anyone would choose either, yet addiction does start with initial choice, most people* are ok and can use responsibily,but not all and where in the pattern does it change, can anyone pinpoint where it changes from normal use, I don't know where the moment was where it crossed the line and things went downhill very quickly, the incline was slow and almost normal but the downcline was very fast. I think there is a lot f judgement and misunderstanding sometimes, and most people in the UK do have times where they will drink socially, maybe use some drugs, a percentage won't be ok but I think it does change at some point and crosses that line into something a lot more serious,and it is a life threatening disease in many ways too.

honeypancake · 30/01/2023 17:30

It is a disease but it starts as a lifestyle choice. It starts with what many see as normal, such as "just one" glass of wine every evening "to unwind". Then it becomes a bottle etc. Sadly, with time, some progress to alcoholism before they even notice it.

Pipsickl · 30/01/2023 17:29

I think the exact definition isn’t that important. There are some facts about alcoholism that are important. No one would choose to be an alcoholic, and those that are really have very little control over it. In my opinion it’s reasonable to be sympathetic to alcoholics (which is what the disease model promotes I think) but also recognise that alcoholism has many many antisocial symptoms that it’s reasonable to protect yourself from in a loved one.

i don’t know anyone who has got better from alcoholism (and I know 2 people who have died from it and know a few others with it) I view it as something that’s not really fully curable I guess, so have (after some horrible family situations) come to the view that your responsibility towards an alcoholic is to recognise the situation, not enable them, provide support where possible, but get away from them to protect yourself. That’s not to say people don’t over come it, but the solution is harder when they are enabled. I think that’s another reason why alcoholism is so destructive - people want to help their loved ones by enabling them, when in reality that won’t resolve the issue and might even worsen it. It goes against every instinct you have.

dormouses · 30/01/2023 17:28

Could it be argued some cancers are self inflicted (through poor diet, lack or exercise, smoking etc) as with alcoholism?

Alcoholism is usually rooted in poor mental health, rather than causing it. And the illness in many ways, as it progresses, is as gruelling as cancer.

I'm not saying I agree or disagree but throwing that in the mix. It's obviously hugely complex and as a country we have a very poor record of dealing with the root causes of alcohol related illnesses, a lot to do with the social acceptance of drinking.

Allytheapple · 30/01/2023 17:27

The running in families component I think is mainly inter generational trauma. I highly highly recommend Gabor Mate on this. He is absolutely excellent.

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 17:27

pointythings · 30/01/2023 17:26

Addiction is a mental Illness yes, but you're not born addicted to alcohol. (Well some sad cases yes but that's not what I'm on about.)
You have to drink a significant amount over a significant amount of time (which IS a choice) to then become addicted. Which then leads to mental illness / addiction.

@quarmadreen you are forgetting that people use alcohol to self-medicate existing mental illness (also drugs of various kinds). So the picture is not as simple as you would have it be.

If people are using alcohol to self medicate an existing mental illness, that's their choosing. They've chosen to do so.

pointythings · 30/01/2023 17:26

Addiction is a mental Illness yes, but you're not born addicted to alcohol. (Well some sad cases yes but that's not what I'm on about.)
You have to drink a significant amount over a significant amount of time (which IS a choice) to then become addicted. Which then leads to mental illness / addiction.

@quarmadreen you are forgetting that people use alcohol to self-medicate existing mental illness (also drugs of various kinds). So the picture is not as simple as you would have it be.

Allytheapple · 30/01/2023 17:25

I believe it is a response to trauma mainly. Same as drug addiction.

Paperdoll44 · 30/01/2023 17:24

Quamadreen. Why on earth are you offended? It’s shit when people get cancer but it’s also shit when people fall into self destructive habits due to poor mental health.

Both are sad. It’s not a competition.

Swipe left for the next trending thread