Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alcholism opinions

186 replies

Dedoodedodi · 30/01/2023 15:17

Hi, I'm not new to Mumsnet but have decided to name change, I'm after people's honest opinions on alcholism and wether it is a illness/disease or a self inflicted lifestyle choice, and if that changes somewhere in-between the two, so what may start as bad choices and blows into alcholism and the related Ill health and symptoms that comes from that where is the line drawn between choices and illness? I don't want to say who I am in this equation and why I'm interested in other opinions, as I want to be unbiased as possible. Alcholism does obviously become a life threatening illness in the later stages, if you for example had someone really close to you that you know normally personality and the way they are is lovely and fine but over time slipped more under would you say they had a disease they couldn't fully control? Same as if you got cancer for example, you can't control if you get that or not to best of ability, there's no rules around do or do not do this or that to avoid it, is it the same league or is it different, and if it is, then why please? Can it change someone's personality over time that you knew to be a normal kind quiet person, is it a illness they cant help,the person, combination? I will like opinions to wrap my head around this issue. Thankyou

OP posts:
Lou670 · 31/01/2023 23:25

@Southwestten It is usually linked to unresolved childhood trauma. This may not come out in a person until later on in life. It is there but the individual may have hidden it as cannot deal with it or may have used other coping mechanisms. When these coping mechanisms no longer work then they will turn to something else. In this case alcohol.

Treatment for the trauma in the form of CBT, DBT and other methods does not always work. Some traumas are so embedded and deep seated that even with years of treatment it is still there. It really is a catch 22 between Mental Health and AUD. You have to be sober in order to be receptive to Mental Health treatment, yet some individuals wait so long that they carry on drinking, then they can't be treated. There is no ideal solution and many individuals fall between the cracks.

JoonT · 31/01/2023 23:19

My gut feeling is that some people have a predisposition to alcoholism. I doubt it’s to do with hedonism or moral weakness or anything like that. The life of a true alcoholic, who drinks a bottle of wine at 10 in the morning, is a wretched, miserable one. It’s not something you drift into.

In general, I’m against telling people they’re victims. Tell someone they’re a victim and they will give up. Much better to be compassionate but firm. People should be encouraged to pull themselves together and face their responsibilities. That said, I have enormous sympathy for alcoholics, especially when it’s rooted in trauma. I feel the same about heroin addicts. Many people go down that route to blot out some horror from their past.

MichaelFabricantWig · 31/01/2023 23:09

a lot of people do turn to numbing or addictive substances to deal with trauma. But not everyone. I’ve had a pretty lovely and cushy life really. Still ended up addicted to alcohol. I started drinking socially or to give myself something to do in the evenings but o got addicted and my tolerance went up.

MichaelFabricantWig · 31/01/2023 23:07

Sorry, I forgot to answer part of the question you were asking in the first place!

I quit for lots of reasons. But one reason I had noticed latterly was because I felt it was changing me as a person. Don’t get me wrong I was just a quiet drunk, I wasn’t nasty or abusive or violent or anything like that. But I felt even when I was sober my personality was changing, I was becoming harder and I didn’t like it.

Southwestten · 31/01/2023 23:04

When treating alcoholism or AUD it is the trauma behind it that needs to be treated.

Lou670 a couple of questions: in practically everyone’s life there will have been some trauma - some more than others, obviously. How does the alcoholic or addict know which incident made them drink? I mean, they may think it’s a recent trauma but it may be something from way back.

Also, is it known how many people got sober from this method of treating it?

MichaelFabricantWig · 31/01/2023 23:01

I use the term alcohol use disorder as opposed to alcoholism.

I consider it not a disease personally but an addiction same as any other drug addiction.

I don’t like the term self inflicted as that seems to me to be loaded with blame and I don’t find it helpful. It is of course caused by people’s own actions but alcohol is addictive and I think people need to stop viewing people becoming addicted to an addictive substance not as some kind of moral failing but that something that is fairly likely to happen, especially with such a socially acceptable drug that is pushed so widely in society.

That said while alcohol addiction may not be an individual’s fault in that no one ever sets out to be an addict it is their responsibility.

for disclosure I was a heavy drinker, bottle of wine a night for years - now nearly 18 months sober. I never started that way but because I was addicted to alcohol it crept up. I was “functioning” in that I had a house, my kids, a good job and nice lifestyle etc but that’s why I don’t like the term alcoholic. It conjures up images of the person who has hit rock bottom or swigging meths on a park bench. It “others” those people and makes people who are knocking back the prosecco and pink gins think that because they are not on the park bench and lost everything they cannot be that bad.

Raffington55 · 31/01/2023 22:58

Dedodedo · 30/01/2023 19:10

I can see how it can spiral quite easily, I don't know how it does for some but not for others, may be more to it, personality traits, genetics etc,not sure. She's 34, she's been drinking heavily we think since about 27, secretly heavily really as had her own social life etc so wasn't that apparent until issues, until about last 18 months, less secretly since then as too hard to hide, things like shot of vodka in a coffee with family etc,things went downhill then, don't know do we intervene if she is actively drinking she will be really angry if we find the stash of empties,but she isn't like this all the time, I do believe this isn't her and if she actually thought she'd realise the seriousness she's really unwell but masking it with vodka, I want to help her but I know from reading it's often not helpful for them in this mindset,if she continues on the units she is she might not see 40 and most definitely not 50, in bad weeks it's near on 200 units,she's not big either I think that would influence the harm on liver but not sure but i guess it probably does, she's eating less,caring less, house and appearance, it's not her

I wonder if your sister would agree to go into rehab? She wouldn't be happy with the idea I'm sure but she will get progressively worse. It's a progressive illness. I've been there. If she needs anyone to talk to I can talk to her (I'm a girl - it's not obvious from my username). Otherwise AA is really helpful. Nothing is expected of you. She can just sit and listen.

Raffington55 · 31/01/2023 22:51

OriGanOver · 30/01/2023 17:58

I don't believe it's a disease.

I don't actually believe in addiction although physical dependency is real.

Using substances to that point is a trauma reaction/coping mechanism. No one happy becomes addicted to drugs or alcohol.

How can you not believe in addiction but believe in physical dépendance?! They are the same thing.

Lou670 · 31/01/2023 22:42

@Vivi0 After wading through all the responses on this subject, your reply is the closest one in accurately answering the original question. When treating alcoholism or AUD it is the trauma behind it that needs to be treated. Mental health resources are severely underfunded and/or understaffed. As for the cancer argument some posters are using. Alcohol is responsible for 15 types of cancer, even in small amounts, not just consuming it at an alcoholic level. There was a study and they listed in reverse order what was the number one killer. Smoking came in at number 9 and number one was alcohol over every other drug. Yet despite this, there are no warnings on the bottles like there are warnings on a cigarette packet. Alcohol is still glorified, yet it causes more crime, more hospital admissions and more deaths than any other drug out there.

BethDuttonsTwin · 31/01/2023 22:22

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Yes, every person I know being the qualifier. No one is claiming this is standard across all addicts.

CeCeDrake · 31/01/2023 22:12

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 17:19

Please don't compare someone with an alcohol problem to somebody battling cancer.

It's offensive.

Addiction is a mental Illness yes, but you're not born addicted to alcohol. (Well some sad cases yes but that's not what I'm on about.)
You have to drink a significant amount over a significant amount of time (which IS a choice) to then become addicted. Which then leads to mental illness / addiction.

But is it in the same league as someone battling cancer, gruelling chemotherapy and surgeries, losing their hair and appearance and their lives probably wont be the same again, that's even if they survive the cancer? No. That's offensive.

Absolutely no comparison between the two. They’re just not similar or comparable much like many different afflictions and health problems.
but what I will point out is, often times, the mental illness leads to alcoholism, not the other way around.
it certainly leads to more mental health issues and deterioration of health, but it does not develop out of thin air, often times, those who become dependant, turn to drink to dampen down the noise of their poor mental health/PTSD/memories/intrusive thoughts and so on, what starts out as a coping mechanism turns into a secondary and horrible Illness.

im not sure of the disease narrative myself, simply because it doesn’t just happen, but it’s not entirely a choice, most people don’t realise they’re in deep until it’s too late.
I have seen the terrifying implications of detoxing first hand which also frightens and discourages them to come off alcohol for fear of that too. It’s a nasty circle of self abuse and harm!

pointythings · 31/01/2023 21:40

@Southwestten I once got given strong opiate painkillers for a muscle injury and only took one dose because I hated the high, loss of control feeling. I preferred the pain. I also hate to be drunk and drink very little. I do think some of it is in the wiring.

Southwestten · 31/01/2023 21:14

it is likely that addiction is a complex issue and that there are many factors at play, including genetic ones.

Pointythings yes it is indeed a complex issue.
I read some of the articles on epigenetics. How terrifying that cocaine can influence the genetic make up of descendants of the cocaine consumers (although I couldn’t understand much of the scientific language).

Re opiate addiction, there was a thread recently about codeine and several people said they hated the effects - some because of a bad physical reaction to it and some because they didn’t like the mental affect - and several said they liked it so people react to it in numerous different ways.

Orangepolentacake · 31/01/2023 20:46

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 17:27

If people are using alcohol to self medicate an existing mental illness, that's their choosing. They've chosen to do so.

I sincerely hope that life never shows you how wrong you are about this

Orangepolentacake · 31/01/2023 20:45

Allytheapple · 30/01/2023 17:27

The running in families component I think is mainly inter generational trauma. I highly highly recommend Gabor Mate on this. He is absolutely excellent.

@Allytheapple in the realm of hungry ghosts is indeed an excellent book

pointythings · 31/01/2023 20:38

@Greatly OK, so I have reread and I owe you a grovelling apology because I got you mixed up with a poster called @GreaterStickle . There's no excuse and I am very sorry to have upset you, especially since you and I have been and in your case still are in the same boat.

Greatly · 31/01/2023 20:37

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Greatly · 31/01/2023 20:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

pointythings · 31/01/2023 20:28

@Greatly all your posts about addicts seem to indicate that you think addiction is a choice people make. People on this thread have pointed out that for the majority of addicts, this is not the case. Many are neurodivergent. Many are mentally unwell. Many are traumatised. Those are not excuses which absolve the addict from working for their recovery, they are explanations for their actions which indicate the areas where the addict needs to focus his/her efforts. Yes, addicts need to take responsibility for their own recovery, acknowledge that they have a problem and put in the work. That does not mean we cannot and should not ever feel compassion for them even as we feel all the other emotions that life with an addict brings about. Al-Anon teaches that we should detach with love, not with judgement.

Greatly · 31/01/2023 20:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Happygone · 31/01/2023 20:16

quarmadreen · 30/01/2023 17:19

Please don't compare someone with an alcohol problem to somebody battling cancer.

It's offensive.

Addiction is a mental Illness yes, but you're not born addicted to alcohol. (Well some sad cases yes but that's not what I'm on about.)
You have to drink a significant amount over a significant amount of time (which IS a choice) to then become addicted. Which then leads to mental illness / addiction.

But is it in the same league as someone battling cancer, gruelling chemotherapy and surgeries, losing their hair and appearance and their lives probably wont be the same again, that's even if they survive the cancer? No. That's offensive.

I couldn't disagree with this more.

Greatly · 31/01/2023 20:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Greatly · 31/01/2023 20:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Coconut212 · 31/01/2023 19:34

Allytheapple · 30/01/2023 19:26

If he has grown up with alcoholism in the family there will be trauma as you are experiencing with your own son.

i should have worded it better mother isn’t an alcoholic, father didn’t start drinking until children moved out so no trauma

lookslikeabombhitit · 31/01/2023 18:51

In my experience it's a choice that develops into a dependency and an illness.

My mother chose to deal with trauma by drinking- we all know there are plenty of other ways to deal with trauma that don't rely on drinking yourself stupid or other destructive choices. She's at the point now where she's totally dependent and it's ruining her health and life. My birth father did the same and he's now severely disabled due to it.

Drink absolutely changes people. Even if they're only mean when they're drunk it undermines everything- even the sober periods. It destroys trust and relationships. I've never met a "good alcoholic". I doubt I ever will.