Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sam Smith's New Music Video

385 replies

Oioicaptain · 30/01/2023 15:03

There's been criticism in the press over the sexualisation/borderline pornography on the video. I've just watched it. It just seems pretty misogynistic to me. He appears to smash a wine glass onto a woman's head and then it looks as though the women are being urinated upon (although it's not clear ...maybe it was meant to be champagne). What are other people's interpretation/views on it. I may well be mistaken.

OP posts:
Greenfairydust · 31/01/2023 09:22

@NotAnotherBathBomb

I am referring to my own previous comment which mentioned his weight as a health concern, you can search for it on the thread.

I am not responsible for what other people posts.

I suggest you read people's comment correctly before jumping on someone who has not said anything remotely ''body shaming''.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 31/01/2023 09:12

As for his appearance: being overweight leads to health issues and it is concerning when someone's appearance changes quickly and radically, because there could be some physical or mental health issues behind the change. It is not ''body shaming'' to be concerned about health and well being.

😂 nice try. I haven’t seen ONE comment expressing concern over his body. Freedom of speech is fine, but own it. Don’t dress it up concern.

Coconut80 · 31/01/2023 09:10

I've had my comment about Sam Smith deleted because I won't call a biological man they them. Welcome to Mumsnet supporters of women and women's rights,not

Greenfairydust · 31/01/2023 08:49

''@CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · Yesterday 17:52
An awful lot of you need to go back and read what you put.
So many have misgendered Sam's self, you ought to be ashamed. Sam Smith is they/them. Do better.''

You assume this was done deliberately.

Not everyone is aware of/follows what specific pronouns celebrities are using.

I used ''he'' in my post because frankly Sam Smith has never really been on my radar as this is not really the type of music I follow. The last time I read anything about him was at the beginning of his career and he was definitely a ''he'' then.

I checked out the video yesterday when I saw the thread out of curiosity and used ''he''' when I commented on it.

I am now aware Sam Smith uses ''They/them''. Fair enough and I am very happy to use the correct pronouns from now on, but don't assume this is common knowledge or that everyone feels that they should use them and that should be respected too.

Intolerance works both ways.

As for his appearance: being overweight leads to health issues and it is concerning when someone's appearance changes quickly and radically, because there could be some physical or mental health issues behind the change. It is not ''body shaming'' to be concerned about health and well being.

And I am not heterosexual by the way before you suggest that I am disrespectful of his queer identity...I simply respect freedom of speech. If you are an artist you have to accept some people won't like what you put out.

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 31/01/2023 08:47

Don’t you think this boils down to the hard fact that some people just have an innate style and sex appeal - and some just haven’t? And it doesn’t matter how many basques, suspenders and raunchy moves are thrown in, it’s really not going to happen. I’m also now stuck with the mental image of Mel Smith doing Vogue by Madonna - complete with conical bra - because of a brilliant post on here!

I find it rather ironic that some of these celebs think that being non binary (it was called androgynous in my day, but still the same btw) is something new and edgy. As a child of the 80s, Prince, David Bowie, Marilyn, Boy George, Annie Lennox, Steve Strange Et Al were far, far better and carried it off with aplomb.

SS just looks desperate.

thisbathiscoldnow · 31/01/2023 08:25

There's absolutely nothing 'raunchy' about a chubby bloke in a sparkly shower cap wearing a nappy with plasters on his nipples.

I do however find the whole thing disturbing and agree that there should be some kind of age restriction on it, as with many music videos where half naked people are groping each other.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 31/01/2023 08:19

LexMitior · 30/01/2023 21:44

I know it's supposed to be effortless sleaze chic but it looks overworked, overdone, and frankly, the kind of thing that makes people say they have work in the morning.

They look like they are seeking an audience. Mr Blobby could have arrived in a jewel encrusted jockstrap - the Noel's house party of eroticism.

Yes, it all feels rather sexless doesn't it? So try hard.

AlisonDonut · 31/01/2023 08:17

Follycastle · 31/01/2023 06:48

I’m a little bit tired of saying this now but for the final time, as I said above, it’s fine to debate their actions and their clothes, but I think nasty comments about their weight and body hair are both inappropriate and also cheapens the arguments people are making about things like fetishising and violence.

I wouldn't get hung up on defending him. He is literally piss fetishing his kink into everyones' kids' timeline. And there is still only one of him.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 31/01/2023 08:15

Follycastle · 31/01/2023 08:13

Funny. So if someone has a different opinion they can’t comment on a thread. Okay then.

Its the undercover thread police.

Follycastle · 31/01/2023 08:13

HaveYouSeenNancy · 31/01/2023 08:07

How odd. Normally messages from MNHQ are a different colour to other messages on my device, but this one is the same as all the other posters.

Funny. So if someone has a different opinion they can’t comment on a thread. Okay then.

HaveYouSeenNancy · 31/01/2023 08:07

Follycastle · 31/01/2023 06:48

I’m a little bit tired of saying this now but for the final time, as I said above, it’s fine to debate their actions and their clothes, but I think nasty comments about their weight and body hair are both inappropriate and also cheapens the arguments people are making about things like fetishising and violence.

How odd. Normally messages from MNHQ are a different colour to other messages on my device, but this one is the same as all the other posters.

Follycastle · 31/01/2023 06:48

AlisonDonut · 30/01/2023 22:20

Well, if he dresses like a complete and utter fetishist and opening up kids to the joys of drinking someone else's piss, then why shouldn't people debate what he is doing?

And there's only one of him. Thankfully.

I’m a little bit tired of saying this now but for the final time, as I said above, it’s fine to debate their actions and their clothes, but I think nasty comments about their weight and body hair are both inappropriate and also cheapens the arguments people are making about things like fetishising and violence.

Inyournewdress · 31/01/2023 00:49

Daisymaker · 30/01/2023 18:49

It's him trying to do the alluring looks that makes me giggle

It was the swinging from the chandelier that got me 😂😂

anonacfr · 30/01/2023 23:43

Greenfairydust · 30/01/2023 19:08

I just watched it to see what all the fuss is about...

  • the song is the most shocking in this, in term how bad it is! truly bland and instantly forgettable
  • the video I found quite tedious as well. I don't find it shocking, just a big mess trying a bit too hard to shock.

There is nothing to be really worked up about I would say.

Frankie Goes to Hollywood and Madonna (Erotica album period) did it all, and better, before.

I actually quite liked ''Unholy'' video and song, found it quite catchy but this one, nope.

His weight gain is rather concerning. I did not even recognise him and I hope he manages to address that. I don't think it is ''body shaming'' to say that this is not healthy.

I'm so with you on those 2 points. The song is sooo bad!
And the video is... yawn.

Worse thing about it is despite all the positivity/sexy new me message Sam Smith looks very uncomfortable throughout.
It's not sexy, it's not edgy, it's just all a little embarrassing.

I rewatched the video with my 16 year old and she couldn't even sit through the whole thing.
Song- terrible. Video-meh.

smileladiesplease · 30/01/2023 23:21

Sam smith is not a plural he's one man

You can't misgender a man with a penis! He's a man.

Honestly it's maddness!

MeinKraft · 30/01/2023 22:25

HRTQueen · 30/01/2023 20:08

Just smacks of desperation

Sam Smith had an unusual voice has recorded popular songs and doesn’t really need to go down this road of being deliberately shocking

Yeah SS was much cooler before he went down the sleazy route. The new video is not very sexy - not because of how SS looks but the whole thing is just way too OTT to actually be sexy.

The Unholy song was problematic too. Who wants to listen to songs about a husband cheating with hookers or whatever it was Confused was it meant to be sexy too?!

AlisonDonut · 30/01/2023 22:20

Follycastle · 30/01/2023 20:49

Yes, but why does that mean we have to rip their appearance to shreds?

Question and debate the video, the clothes, their opinions and actions. But why on earth are we tearing a person’s appearance to shreds? It really isn’t necessary and weakens the other points being made about violence, fetishes etc.

I just think the thread shouldn’t focus on a person’s appearance. Should fat hairy people not be allowed to have careers in entertainment? Should they hide their bodies in case other people are repulsed?

Well, if he dresses like a complete and utter fetishist and opening up kids to the joys of drinking someone else's piss, then why shouldn't people debate what he is doing?

And there's only one of him. Thankfully.

LexMitior · 30/01/2023 21:44

I know it's supposed to be effortless sleaze chic but it looks overworked, overdone, and frankly, the kind of thing that makes people say they have work in the morning.

They look like they are seeking an audience. Mr Blobby could have arrived in a jewel encrusted jockstrap - the Noel's house party of eroticism.

Mirabai · 30/01/2023 21:36

Follycastle · 30/01/2023 20:49

Yes, but why does that mean we have to rip their appearance to shreds?

Question and debate the video, the clothes, their opinions and actions. But why on earth are we tearing a person’s appearance to shreds? It really isn’t necessary and weakens the other points being made about violence, fetishes etc.

I just think the thread shouldn’t focus on a person’s appearance. Should fat hairy people not be allowed to have careers in entertainment? Should they hide their bodies in case other people are repulsed?

It’s not his appearance it’s his womanface.

Eddie Izzard can bugger off too.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 30/01/2023 21:36

Love it or hate it, whatever, but I don't I understand the 'wouldn't show it to/not appropriate for my child'

Um no, why would it be? The majority of mainstream music is aimed at adults, what a weird take Confused

ShakespearesBlister · 30/01/2023 21:30

Hoppinggreen · 30/01/2023 21:21

HER frock you TERF (to paraphrase Ricky Gervaise)

THEIR frock I believe you'll find 😉

Hoppinggreen · 30/01/2023 21:21

ShakespearesBlister · 30/01/2023 20:53

I'm sorry I misgendered a man. It was the frock.

HER frock you TERF (to paraphrase Ricky Gervaise)

SequinsandStilettos · 30/01/2023 21:18

I just watched him on Graham Norton and he came over quite well - able to take a ribbing from Rob Beckett.
I am plus size myself. I loved Dietland and I watched Shrill. Brendan Fraser has just been Oscar nominated wearing a fat suit in The Whale (I shall try to reserve judgement til I have seen it). I am all too aware of the focus on looks but I also agree that the body positivity movement can go too far the other way.
Sam has found a vehicle for dealing with his self-image and esteem. He has been friendzoned a lot allegedly. Given some members of the gay community like hirsute (bears) and bigger blokes (chubby chasing), I am sure he will find someone now he is putting himself out there.
Whether shaking moobs with heart pasties is shocking or not - not really, but nor is it necessary. Like Madge on Jimmy Fallon's desk or when Miley kept sticking her tongue out, it comes over as attention-seeking rather than art.
But I'm not the demographic.
If Madge's antics are calling out ageism and Sam's are calling out sizeist trolls, the message is being lost a little in translation.
I sound like a prude with put 'em away but less is sometimes more. As for body positivity, it is all well and good until you end up with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease which iirc George Michael died from.

ShakespearesBlister · 30/01/2023 21:02

feelingcadoubleledlove · 30/01/2023 20:54

It's satire. I got caught too. Look at the username

Well I just hope they them their are proud of they them their selves!

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 30/01/2023 20:55

ShakespearesBlister · 30/01/2023 20:53

I'm sorry I misgendered a man. It was the frock.

😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread