Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have insinuated my friend’s DS might have ADHD

90 replies

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 15:02

For context- I know this mum (let’s call her Maria) from DC previous school, we continued to see each other after change of schools, ie we go and grab coffee occasionally and we exchange friendly texts every few weeks or so. We also go to each other’s DCs’ birthday parties and sometimes we organise get together with the other parents. We have gone skiing together with our DHs and DCs. Her DH and my DH would go and get beer together on their own. We live in a southern European country (if this makes a difference in attitude). We have known each other for about 3 years. No issues, no arguments before. Our kids are good friends (or were). The issue stemmed from when I had witnessed her only child, DS’ (7) extreme behaviour (let’s call him Pablo) where he gets very emotional about something (yelling and screaming for minor things), attacking my DS physically when DS(6) did not want to play a certain game. Him shouting “I will kill you” to his dad for telling him off for throwing snowballs at my DD. I have over the years witnessed his difficult behaviour and quite extreme. Mind you I have raised two adults (one with severe ADHD) and two minors still at home. I am not a mental health expert by profession however I am a healthcare worker and dealt with many young adults and children with ADHD.
Maria has referred to Pablo being difficult and being very emotional, but she’s adamant that he is just like the boys in his class. I gently asked her if she had had him assessed for ADHD as I see similarities between him and my oldest DS when he was at that age and advised her it could be something to explore to help her DS regulate his emotions. She got very annoyed with me and said there is nothing wrong with him, that he is just boisterous. Every boy in his new class is the same. We left it at that. Then she ghosted me, when I had sent her texts. The latest was a Happy New Year message which she did not even opened. It’s been two months.
I am quite confused as to why she would be so defensive and annoyed. My DH who was not part of the conversation reached out to her DH just “hey what’s going on fancy a beer” and he blocked my DH too. No response. Like they just dropped us as a family.

was I being unreasonable to have mentioned her DS might have ADHD? I did not say for sure, just that it might be worth checking it out.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 30/01/2023 18:21

Tbh lots of people are prejudiced when it comes to all the ND, and believe that their child couldn’t possibly be because of their own ignorance about what it actually means. But ADHD is certainly not the only cause of that sort of behaviour, there are loads of causes including external like trauma. Might have been better to ask whether she thought a dr might be worth a try.
but at the end of the day, you apologised and it wasn’t anything terrible that you suggested, unless her view of ADHD is quite negative..

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 18:16

Brendabigbaps · 30/01/2023 18:00

YBVVVU to say ADHD is a mental health condition, it’s a neurological one.
shameful given your supposed to be a medical professional

Please have a look at how other countries such as the US defines ADHD, American Psychiatric Association define it as a “mental health disorder”.

www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/adhd/what-is-adhd

not all doctors are trained in the UK

OP posts:
Leah5678 · 30/01/2023 18:06

Whether or not he actually has ADHD I don't think you're being unreasonable just to mention it to her, her reaction is very extreme especially her husband blocking your husband over this

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 18:06

In this country, ADHD being assessed by a psychiatrist and it is a mental health condition albeit a neurological one as well, these two are not mutually exclusive. I think you may be too UK centred about how medical terms are being defined especially in other countries.

OP posts:
Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 30/01/2023 18:05

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 16:15

fyi, I am a medical doctor (paediatric doctor) not psychiatrist though. I do the first assessment of ADHD before I send the patients off to a psychiatrist for a full on assessment as we do here in this country. Every country does things slightly differently.

Presumably your friend knew this is your line of work and knew about your older DS. I think if she had wanted your professional opinion she would have asked for it. I'm noy sure her commenting on her DS being difficult is her inviting you to suggest any possible diagnosis.

Miriam101 · 30/01/2023 18:02

So hard with friends as there's a tiny room for manoeuvre before people become very defensive, but I understand you feeling like you were somehow failing her if you didn't mention it, knowing what you know. You did overstep and the wording of your apology text is unfortunate ("I thought my advice might help you get the help you need" is incredibly condescending!) BUT I don't think you were being unreasonable in trying to mention it. I just think you slightly fumbled it. I don't think your family deserve to be dropped as a result esp as it sounds like you were pretty good friends. Hope you find a way through it.

Brendabigbaps · 30/01/2023 18:00

YBVVVU to say ADHD is a mental health condition, it’s a neurological one.
shameful given your supposed to be a medical professional

Viviennemary · 30/01/2023 17:56

No you shouldn't have said this however well meaning you are. It's probably somethingbshe just didnt want to hear

Rinkydinkydoodle · 30/01/2023 17:53

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 15:30

Friend has been struggling and said she didn’t know what to do as he’s so emotional. So should I have kept mum? Just said nothing, although my own son has displayed the exact same behaviour at that age? So I’d just stood on and listened to her moaning about how hard her son is, and just said nothing? Not even a suggestion?

If you really feel it’s fake not to share an opinion, even an informed one, you could say something like ‘yeah, this age can be rough but look how lively and confident Pablo is. He’d be a great team captain (or whatever). Thinking back, and I know it’s not the same situation, when DS was Pablo’s age (insert relevant anecdote.’

Then you leave her to put two and two together. If you absolutely must. Which is a big if.

Basically, it’s not done to ‘help’ people raise their children. I had a similar thing once, a very old friend didn’t take well to me saying something about her child; all I said was that I agreed with something she had previously said on way more than one occasion (he was showing indications of ASD). I back-pedalled like an Olympian when I saw her facial expression change and said something like ‘or actually, he might just be frustrated. He is so much cleverer than his peers, imagine how it must feel to be doing what he’s doing when everyone else barely knows how to count.’ She was mollified and we moved on. Sometimes people just don’t want advice or ‘help’ from their friends, they want reassurance and a bit of sympathy. She didn’t fall out with me but it was a near-miss. Didn’t do it again. I now only make encouraging comments about friends’ children, even if I think I do have a valid point to make or they say they’re struggling a bit. If they really want to know my views on what they ought to do, they can ask, no? Funnily enough, though, they don’t…

On the flipside, you clearly haven’t lost much because the friendship was pretty fragile if the whole family sacked you. Or maybe you hit a nerve. I’d leave it now, just be pleasant if you see her again and don’t mention it.

TenTenEleven · 30/01/2023 17:45

Blort · 30/01/2023 15:23

Your friend is horrible. Your son has ADHD , by going on as if you invoked the devil himself to suggest her son is showing traits of ADHD she's being pretty cruel to your family.

I agree. It's awful that she's so mortal offended at the suggestion that her DS might have ADHD that she has to ghost you and block you. Even though she KNOWS your DS has ADHD.

Like it's fine for your DS to have ADHD but it's the worst thing in the world for you to even suggest that hers might have it.

At least you now know her real thoughts about your DS. Sounds like you're well rid of the friendship.

Ladybug14 · 30/01/2023 17:23

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 15:30

Friend has been struggling and said she didn’t know what to do as he’s so emotional. So should I have kept mum? Just said nothing, although my own son has displayed the exact same behaviour at that age? So I’d just stood on and listened to her moaning about how hard her son is, and just said nothing? Not even a suggestion?

Well yes. As it transpires that is exactly what you should have done if you wanted to keep the friendship

But you had no idea that your words would create such upset

You know now and perhaps with another friend you'll remember the possibility that people get upset when you don't expect them to, and say nothing

I find many people just want to vent. They don't actually want solutions

You now know this too.

Galadriel90 · 30/01/2023 17:10

I don't think you've done anything wrong. Hopefully she may come round and see that.

winepleasenotwhine · 30/01/2023 17:04

I've not RTFT sorry. I live in a southern European country. I have a child with asd & adhd. I have a good Spanish friend with a child who has adhd (and some other issues). The school has been pointing out the need for extra help for the many years I've known them. The friend has shouted very loudly for most of this time how horrible the school is as the child is completely normal and it's all just bad teaching. At 9 the child was finally given an opportunity to be diagnosed. I bit my tongue for a long time. They are now getting help. Some people really don't want to know. Pushing them (like your follow up message) is your agenda not theirs. Sorry you've had to learn this way. Perhaps it is in the culture of the family. Certainly where I live there is a different culture than mine around certain health issues

ShakespearesBlister · 30/01/2023 17:03

Maybe she knows her child's behaviour isn't normal but is in denial. Perhaps she ghosted you because she knows she can't pretend around you anymore because you've spotted signs that all was not perfect. Or perhaps she's so in denial she still doesn't accept it and thinks you were attacking her parenting instead.

ittakes2 · 30/01/2023 17:01

I have ADHD - you have ADHD in your family so you must know society does not fully understand or accept ADHD. Personally I think considering she knows you have ADHD in your family she is the daft friend for treating you rudely as if suggesting her child might have ADHD is an insult. I think it should be you ditching her!

TheCatch · 30/01/2023 16:48

Ghostedbyfriend · 30/01/2023 15:08

Would really appreciate some perspective here.

For clarification I did send a text some week later to say “ I am sorry if I offended you as you seemed so upset, hope you’re okay, I did not mean to make you feel bad, I thought my advice might help you get the help you needed” no reply still…

I was sort of on your side until I read your last sentence, I thought my advice might help you get the help you needed” no reply still…

Seriously? my first thought would've been, 'Who the hell do you think you are?'. You don't know for a fact her DS has adhd, even professionals have to do an assessment that involves both school and home before they can arrive at a conclusion. You went from gently asking a question which was quite fair in the circumstances to being quite condescending telling your friend, that she actually needs help and you hope your advice would help her towards it. That was very rude of you and rather than mending things ended up being the last straw. Definitely do not make any more contact with them. Leave them alone and hopefully next time you will choose your words more carefully.

WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 30/01/2023 16:40

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 30/01/2023 16:06

Some pps are reacting as if you suggested her son might be a dangerous criminal. What’s so offensive about you daring to mention ADHD as a possible thing to check out, when your own child has it? You shouldn’t have to grovel for that. Children with ADHD aren’t any less wonderful or loveable.

I agree with the pp who said she’s just not ready to hear realistic suggestions. Your only crime was to misjudge how much honesty she wanted, and I think that’s an understandable mistake in these specific circumstances.

Totally agree with this. Don't know why you're being pilloried (except it's a sport for some on AIBU) as I see it you tried to help when she was talking about his behaviour.

ffsnotagainandagain · 30/01/2023 16:34

I don't think you did anything wrong. You gave her advice based on your experience. Friends should be able to do this without being ghosted. It didn't sound like you were rude. Sounds more like you hit a nerve with a subject they are not ready to address but I don't see that as your problem.

Movingsoon21 · 30/01/2023 16:31

OP some people are looking for help and grateful to receive advice, others just want to offload. Unfortunately she was the latter your well-meaning advice hit a nerve as she clearly wasn’t expecting you to suggest something like that.

ultimately you didn’t do anything definitely wrong but she’s allowed to take it how she likes and unfortunately she’s decided to end the friendship. I think you just have to accept that - people can end any relationship for any reason they want to.

time to focus on other friends

Andsoforth · 30/01/2023 16:30

I don’t think you did anything wrong. Her attitude is the problem - between normalising her ds’ violence, and calling adhd “something wrong” she’s clearly very ignorant.

when you’ve been through the heartbreak of fighting tooth and nail for timely diagnosis and services, it’s natural to want to reach out to other parents.

It’s always roundly condemned on MN, yet irl there are no shortage of people, practically queued up to give their tuppence worth, even after being informed of a diagnosis.

You were doing a kind thing.

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 30/01/2023 16:29

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 30/01/2023 16:06

Some pps are reacting as if you suggested her son might be a dangerous criminal. What’s so offensive about you daring to mention ADHD as a possible thing to check out, when your own child has it? You shouldn’t have to grovel for that. Children with ADHD aren’t any less wonderful or loveable.

I agree with the pp who said she’s just not ready to hear realistic suggestions. Your only crime was to misjudge how much honesty she wanted, and I think that’s an understandable mistake in these specific circumstances.

This. Enough with the ableism. Having a disability shouldn't have such a stigma attached to it.

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 30/01/2023 16:27

Sadly there's still a lot of ableism in the world and a lot of stigma, and sounds like she is offended by the idea that her child might be disabled, even though you have a child with a disability and are coming from a place of support.

I just hope the kid eventually gets the support he needs, whatever that may be.

Living with undiagnosed ADHD is incredibly hard and I would hope that parents listen and get their kids tested if they even just suspect something like that, to rule it out.

plumduck · 30/01/2023 16:23

Sarahcoggles · 30/01/2023 16:20

@plumduck no there aren't. There are rules about treating people who aren't your registered patients, but no rules about giving advice. I wish there were, then I wouldn't get pestered all the time by non medical friends!

Ah yeah that would get annoying!

zingally · 30/01/2023 16:20

You over-stepped the mark.

People don't like to be told, especially by people they see as "just another mum" (your expertise/qualifications are irrelevant to her), that their child maybe has a disability that would explain their bad behaviour. In one swoop you've implied that their child has bad behaviour AND that maybe he's got a disability that causes it. People simply don't want to hear it. Especially from their peers.

You've apologised - whilst still insinuating that you were right - and she's chosen to ignore you. I think you need to let this one go. You've lost a friendship because you mis-read the room. Let it go until/unless she contacts you again.

Sarahcoggles · 30/01/2023 16:20

@plumduck no there aren't. There are rules about treating people who aren't your registered patients, but no rules about giving advice. I wish there were, then I wouldn't get pestered all the time by non medical friends!