Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

33k and struggling

190 replies

farmanimals · 30/01/2023 14:56

I don’t understand what I’m doing wrong. I’m earning just shy of 33k which is a really respectable salary. Yet I’ve just budgeted for the month and I’m really struggling to save anything or even have anything to spend.

My total for rent, all bills, food, car, phone bill, subscriptions I need for work is £1400. My bills have skyrocketed. I am earning £1900 a month.
This does give me £500 but this has to go towards all outgoings including petrol, all my toiletries and make up, I have to get my hair done because it’s really damaged as well. So if I want to socialise it’s basically out of the question.

Also I’m putting a lot of pressure on myself to save a deposit for a house. I’m putting lile £100 away at the moment a month if that, and only have £2k in a LISA. Makes me think I’m never ever ever going to buy a house.

Am I wrong in wondering how this is possible?

OP posts:
AIBUYesSometimes · 30/01/2023 16:11

The OP could be paying back a student loan. That could be taking a few £100 each month.

Overthebow · 30/01/2023 16:11

You have £500 per month after rent, bill and food. That's actually quite a lot. Toiletries, make up and hair are discretionary spends and not essentials, so it's your choice really if you want to spend a chunk of your £500 on those. It would be more sensible to spend for example, £250 on house deposit saving, £100 petrol (if you need this much), and £150 spending money, until you have enough saved for a deposit. Do your own hair or get just a cheap wet cut, essential cheap toiletries only and you really don't need to buy make-up every month. It's your own choice if you decide to prioritise your hair and make-up over buying a house.

Legotiger · 30/01/2023 16:10

I think you’re doing ok, OP. I did a financial well-being course through work recently and they didn’t really have an answer for what to do when you’ve cut back on everything and still can’t survive. 3 years ago, we paid £75/month for gas and electric. Now it’s £250! Food and petrol cost way more. We used to have a good contingency element for fun and extras. Got paid today, £300 for food for the month for a family after all bills paid. It’s tough.

Thomasina79 · 30/01/2023 16:09

I did a small Lidl shop today, mainly vegetables and some meat. It came to around £23. I have always been a loyal sainsbury shopper, but have found lately their prices have become astronomical so I am buying more and more from said Lilly, especially meat and fish. I did a price comparison item by item on todays shop comparing the two shops and Lidl came out at around £6 cheaper and that was just a smallish shop. The only meat was a big pack,of minced lamb which I can turn into four meals by splitting it up and freezing. We are a two person household, both recently retired.

lowclouds · 30/01/2023 16:09

When you say "all your toiletries and make up and getting your hair done", how much are you spending on these?

I bet you could cut quite a lot there tbh. Those things do not need to cost the earth.

£500 a month disposable income after bills, food etc for one person isn't bad (depending how much of that is going on petrol).

FlimFlamBam · 30/01/2023 16:09

The personal grooming budget is huge, I have severe allergies to most products so can only use Clinique, it’s £45 for a pot of my moisturiser but I only use two a year. How much are you using?

RoseslnTheHospital · 30/01/2023 16:09

I wouldn't describe it as "struggling", but I can see that you have less disposable cash each month than you would have had prior to the CoL increases.

I would look carefully at all your discretionary spending each month and decide if there is anything you can cut back on or swap to a cheaper alternative. When supermarket own brand shampoo is less than £1 per 500ml bottle, it seems crazy to spend > £5 for a branded version.

AIBUYesSometimes · 30/01/2023 16:08

rothbury · 30/01/2023 16:05

If OP is in London, she could easily be spending that as a sharer renting. My DC both rent in shared flats and spend £800 - £950 each. That’s before council tax, energy, water, broadband etc.

And no, they’re not in Knightsbridge or Hampstead Grin

where does she say london?

AIBUYesSometimes · 30/01/2023 16:07

My total for rent, all bills, food, car, phone bill, subscriptions I need for work is £1400

How would you feel about posting the actual amounts?

Most people can cut back on food, phone and subs. Phone- haggle for cheaper deal?
Obviously if you are leasing a car or on credit you budgeted for that? If it's a huge amount you could always end the lease and get a cheaper car (if there was no penalty.)

Beauty products- can you cut back or go for cheaper? I buy high end make up (eg Bobbi Brown) but I don't buy often. Most products last me for months and I tend to stock up when they have 20% off. Most cleansers and moisturisers are the same thing but you will pay for a big name brand.

Tanyaaah · 30/01/2023 16:07

I'm on 29k and I have 2 kids half of the time. It's pretty rubbish these days, used to be fine (ish).

moksorineouimoksori · 30/01/2023 16:07

first of all, you're doing a great job with 2k saved and budgeting enough to have 500 leftover each month!
everyone is feeling a pinch right now and hopefully it will blow over gradually (as they usually do) - in the meantime it will be hard but there are some things you can do.
how much are you spending on food? how much do you spend on makeup per month? and getting your hair done is a one time expense right?

rothbury · 30/01/2023 16:05

If OP is in London, she could easily be spending that as a sharer renting. My DC both rent in shared flats and spend £800 - £950 each. That’s before council tax, energy, water, broadband etc.

And no, they’re not in Knightsbridge or Hampstead Grin

snowlolo · 30/01/2023 16:05

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 15:40

I meant I earn about the same as OP and take home £2300 a month.

This is worth thinking about OP.

£33k is a reasonable salary, but how much of that is going into things like your pension, any work based healthcare plans, student loan etc?

As you can see, some people on your salary are taking home a lot more than you. Your actual take home salary might be more like someone on £25-26k if you have a lot of (necessary) extras you are paying for.

Have you looked at opportunities for career progression or maybe negotiating a better salary as well (I know it's not always straightforward but could be worth thinking about?)

TheDailyCarbunkle · 30/01/2023 16:03

It is possible to save more but only if you're ridiculously strict with money and that really isn't easy.

Brawsome · 30/01/2023 16:01

Subscriptions for work - like professional memberships? You could be eligible for tax relief on these, would be worth checking.

Dreamstate · 30/01/2023 16:01

Think a bit of a detailed list on your expenditure might help to identify where your spending more than you really need to.

For example is your phone costing you £10 or £40 a month? etc.

peachgreen · 30/01/2023 15:58

I absolutely get it OP. My take home is similar but I get a small pension from my late husband on top and I still struggle every month. I'm pretty financially savvy but the truth is, everything has got so much more expensive and what was doable even six months ago is a struggle now. For me the rise in groceries and bills has pushed me over the edge from "fairly comfortable" to "struggling".

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 15:56

Of course it is enough to cover more than bare essentials in most of the country. Everyone I know single is earning this or less.

needthiswilderness · 30/01/2023 15:46

I suspect the depressing truth is that 33k as a single person is just not enough any more to cover much more than the bare essentials. This is a shocking and awful state of affairs and should make us all very angry - but what I mean is, it's not like you're doing anything wrong with your budget, or should be able to save more money. Just keep on keeping on and don't be hard on yourself, that would be my only advice.

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 15:43

@Nw22 Okay. Your employer must have an amazing pension plan.

Nw22 · 30/01/2023 15:41

@AtticusFrost it wasn’t a large pension contribution. It was the minimum allowed by my employer

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 15:40

I meant I earn about the same as OP and take home £2300 a month.

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 30/01/2023 15:39

Are you local government? I'm in the LGPS and take home £1900 after tax and pension on a salary of £33k.

To be honest, I couldn't live alone. Wouldn't be able to afford it.

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 15:39

@Nw22 Large pension contributions are a choice though.
I earn about the same as you and take home about £2300 a month. I pay statutory minimum into a pension as that is all my employer will match.

If you are paying up to £400 a month extra into a pension above the statutory minimum then you will be short of money.

Nw22 · 30/01/2023 15:36

@yoyo1234 when’s I earnt 40k my take home was only 2300 due to pension and student loan