Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should give notice of strike closure!

246 replies

Geeds · 30/01/2023 12:12

I know teachers need to strike, I know they don’t need to give advanced notices, I know the whole idea is to ‘cause disruption’ but surely they also understand that normal working families need notice if they can’t go to work on a certain date?

The school is emailing saying they will ‘let us know by 8am on Wednesday’ about if school will be open or closed on Wednesday. I get 5 weeks annual leave to cover 13 weeks of school holiday, I don’t want to book a day if they then end up open as this will then eventually cost me money when I have to pay childcare in the holidays as I’m out of annual leave. I also can’t really afford the unpaid leave that I’ll have to take it as, if I don’t book annual leave.

I’m not slating teachers for striking, I understand and support the reasons. But AIBU to think they should give us a bit of notice? The strikes will ‘disrupt’ either way, but not giving notice to families is only going to affect the 30 odd parents in your class who also have their own stresses and money worries.

OP posts:
thebellagio · 30/01/2023 14:27

LividNC · 30/01/2023 14:22

Dear @LucySaddler

Why don’t you write your article about the current untenable conditions in schools and what the “government” have done (and not done) to mean that teachers are leaving in droves and that many schools are unsafely staffed?

Why don’t you write about how one day of childcare is nothing compared to the situation we’re sleepwalking in to, where masses of children will have no qualified teacher for many of their GCSE subjects, and the ones they do have will be so utterly demoralised and overwhelmed that they can’t do the job they would love to do?

Why don’t you write about the massive and terrifying epidemic of emotional and mental health problems that schools are facing in their young people, with virtually no external support and certainly no funding?

All of these stories are more vital than “shit negligent teachers shitting on kids on Wednesday, the leftie bastards” which is, I’m sure, going to be an easier narrative.

@LucySaddler added to that list, is the terrifying notion that children needing speech and language therapy in early years has risen dramatically because they've spent their whole lives seeing people wearing masks. SLT and dyslexia are inextricably linked, but schools receive no funding to address the interventions required to identify and support dyslexia. These children will be unable to cope with the curriculum if changes aren't made and funding isn't increased.

The teachers aren't just striking because of pay. But because the government has decimated education to the point where schools literally cannot afford to provide printed homework. They can't afford books. They can't afford pencils. They can't even afford to heat the bloody buildings. This government has annihilated education.

AnotherAppleThief · 30/01/2023 14:27

Create10 · 30/01/2023 13:12

Are no teachers also parents?

Teachers are employed to educate children, not to provide childcare.

Well, when they feel like it they do. They don't give a rats arse about the children's education on Wednesday.

harrassedmumto3 · 30/01/2023 14:27

That's out of order ... and I say that as someone who works in the profession! In my neck of the woods, strike dates are publicised well in advance. Last minute isn't exactly going to curry favour, as it's a massive inconvenience to working families in particular Confused
YANBU.

saraclara · 30/01/2023 14:25

That's a meeting between the Education minister and the unions this afternoon, to try to avoid Wednesday's strike. So no-one knows for certain whether it will happen. Which means parents can't be given sa definite answer. Any heads who've said they're closing are just playing it safe.

SheilaFentiman · 30/01/2023 14:24

WestBridgewater · 30/01/2023 14:22

I’ve only read the first page so this might have been asked. I’m prepared to be told I’m wrong but I thought unions had to give a weeks notice of any official industrial action.

The strike is happening, and notice has been given.

No one is obliged to tell their employer if they personally are in a union, though.

3ormorecharacters · 30/01/2023 14:24

roarfeckingroarr · 30/01/2023 12:35

I mean, they categorically are trying to be obstructive. So long as the teachers are happy though, bugger us parents.

What about the teachers who are parents, who struggle to support their family on their massively eroded wages while also trying to manage an enormous and stressful workload?

Striking is an incredibly difficult decision for most teachers who feel a deep sense of duty and obligation towards their students. But striking is ultimately for the benefit of future generations of teachers and, believe it or not, students. Informing HTs and parents ahead of time negates the whole point of that difficult and distressing decision.

SheilaFentiman · 30/01/2023 14:23

Geeds · 30/01/2023 14:15

Why is it meant to be disruptive to parents though? Do the unions want parents to suffer? It’s not going to make a difference to the govt whether we get a weeks notice or 20 minutes, so why make working parents lives more difficult.
We don’t all have hoards of adults available and ready to watch our kids at the last minute.
And the ‘school isn’t childcare’ line is really ridiculous, our kids are expected to be there 30 hours a week, so of course we plan our childcare around that.

Strikes are meant to be disruptive to the country in general. Parents are the "customers" of schools just as commuters are the "customers" of trains. Parents (and thereby workers) suffering is exactly the point.

Train companies have some idea from past strikes as to what proportion of staff are in unions/will strike, and also, I believe, do some reassigning of staff who do come in.

As others have said, heads can ask but there is no obligation for teachers to answer - some will and some won't. Those schools that have already said what they are doing will have had a sufficient proportion of definite answers to make plans.

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 30/01/2023 14:23

@itsnote my backup plan is a day off work unpaid emergency dependent leave. Which I may or may not actually need but if I don't find out till the morning it's too late for me to cancel and I lose my pay for the day anyway (which by the way is a lot less than the teachers get) they get a choice whether to go in and get paid or strike and lose pay. Why shouldnt parents have the same?

WestBridgewater · 30/01/2023 14:22

I’ve only read the first page so this might have been asked. I’m prepared to be told I’m wrong but I thought unions had to give a weeks notice of any official industrial action.

LividNC · 30/01/2023 14:22

Dear @LucySaddler

Why don’t you write your article about the current untenable conditions in schools and what the “government” have done (and not done) to mean that teachers are leaving in droves and that many schools are unsafely staffed?

Why don’t you write about how one day of childcare is nothing compared to the situation we’re sleepwalking in to, where masses of children will have no qualified teacher for many of their GCSE subjects, and the ones they do have will be so utterly demoralised and overwhelmed that they can’t do the job they would love to do?

Why don’t you write about the massive and terrifying epidemic of emotional and mental health problems that schools are facing in their young people, with virtually no external support and certainly no funding?

All of these stories are more vital than “shit negligent teachers shitting on kids on Wednesday, the leftie bastards” which is, I’m sure, going to be an easier narrative.

JammiDodgers · 30/01/2023 14:21

WelcomedHome · 30/01/2023 14:12

The school I work in gave parents notice last week of which classes would be in and which not. The school was able to do that because the head is supportive of both the strike and the staff.

It is meant to cause disruption. It is not a child care service.

Keep your hair on.

Our head gave notice but she is very supportive in general unlike my daughter’s school. No notice there at all.

itsnote · 30/01/2023 14:19

"We don’t all have hoards of adults available and ready to watch our kids at the last minute."

Ffs, no. So why leave it until the last minute to make a back up plan? You've known the strike dates for a while now.

SheilaFentiman · 30/01/2023 14:18

Overandunderit · 30/01/2023 13:53

That's not how union action works.

There is no requirement to even confirm if you're a union member, let alone if you're striking. Schools will have requested that staff volunteer the info but cannot and should not compel them.

Perhaps you'd have better than 5 weeks annual leave if you had a strong union?

This.

confusedofengland · 30/01/2023 14:17

Ds3's Junior school has informed us this morning that they will be open, so that's fine.

DS1 & 2's senior school has told us they will not be open. Also fine. DH can wfh that day as there are rail strikes too so he cannot go into work (DS2 has SEN & cannot be left in the house without an adult for any extended period of time). However, they are not able to tell us until the day whether work will be set, or whether there will be live lessons. DH cannot supervise work (which DS2 needs) so he pretty much won't do any work until I get home at just after 1pm. I'm hoping he won't get penalised.

itsnote · 30/01/2023 14:17

"It's just a joke. It's not that hard to organise surely?!"

It's simpler for you to presume they're closed. If the staff go on strike then who do you want to supervise your child?

MarshaBradyo · 30/01/2023 14:17

I know which dc are going in to school. I’m very appreciative of state sixth form making sure they can attend, plus private dc there’s no strike.

Geeds · 30/01/2023 14:15

Why is it meant to be disruptive to parents though? Do the unions want parents to suffer? It’s not going to make a difference to the govt whether we get a weeks notice or 20 minutes, so why make working parents lives more difficult.
We don’t all have hoards of adults available and ready to watch our kids at the last minute.
And the ‘school isn’t childcare’ line is really ridiculous, our kids are expected to be there 30 hours a week, so of course we plan our childcare around that.

OP posts:
AlwaysAuntie · 30/01/2023 14:15

The headteacher at DC's school sent a newsletter last week detailing the dates of strikes and letting us know what days they will be closed due to the strikes. It is a village primary though so maybe the larger schools are more difficult to workout whether they will have enough teacher's to open safely.

WelcomedHome · 30/01/2023 14:12

The school I work in gave parents notice last week of which classes would be in and which not. The school was able to do that because the head is supportive of both the strike and the staff.

It is meant to cause disruption. It is not a child care service.

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 30/01/2023 14:11

I agree. My sons SEN school gave us a week & a half's notice which is fine, gives them and us parents time to prepare the kids about the distribution in their routine.

My NT kids school is "oh we should be open, but we won't be doing normal lessons but we also might close if we don't have enough staff we will let you know on the morning." Like Wtf. AngryConfused

It's just a joke. It's not that hard to organise surely?!

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 30/01/2023 14:09

It's bloody shameful for parents to be informed at 8am on the day, I agree. The rules should be that they need to inform the head before hand. Even a day or 2 would be better than nothing.
I 100% support the teachers striking but I don't support the fact that we don't bloody know. Why should we all have to lose a day's pay on the off chance that the teachers are striking? And it is on the off-chance since if the school is open and the kids don't go in then it goes down as unauthorised absence. Primary kids can't be left home alone though so parents have no choice. Teachers can decide whether to strike and lose pay or not, but parents have to lose a day's pay either way

larchforest · 30/01/2023 14:09

Don't blame teachers, it will be the head or the LEA who decides whether an individual school has to close or not.

BogRollBOGOF · 30/01/2023 14:08

I can't see the government suddenly having a change of heart on their attitudes to education because some schools/ union members maximised last minute inconvenience to their community by not giving an indication of what arrangements need to be made.

It's hard enough getting an autistic child to school and convincing them that education is important without multiple school years of phases where school is open to x but not open to y.

itsnote · 30/01/2023 14:07

@Laiste do I? To you maybe.

I'm seeing lots of comments about how striking is supposed to be disruptive. Or that pps would just assume school is closed and make arrangements based on that. Sensible.

TheOrigRights · 30/01/2023 14:06

I think the whole point of strikes is that they are unreasonable (in a MN AIBU sense I mean).
YANBU to want to know and plan, but it's a strike and there are procedures to be followed, so YABU to want the strike to work around your needs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread