Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gaging opinion £400 pw

358 replies

Toomuchtrouble4me · 30/01/2023 11:01

Simply that. Family of 4. Is £400 a week reasonable to live in? This is without any bills so includes:
food for 4
household shopping (detergent etc)
clothing
treats (coffees etc)
household essentials (lightbulbs, batteries etc)
medicines and beauty products
Basically mortgage, bills, large expenses are separate, but thus includes all bits and bobs that are bought weekly plus funds for kids outings and buying gifts if they are going to a party etc.
Is it enough?
we’re trialing how much we need to spend on these things in a week and I don’t seem to be able to manage in £400.

OP posts:
worstusernameeverx2 · 31/01/2023 14:15

@Sunsetintheeast no I'm talking about your average body wash- not antibacterial soap

Lordofthebutterfloofs · 31/01/2023 13:49

Try harder

ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 13:18

Beezknees · 31/01/2023 12:50

You do have to pay council tax. Council tax exemption is only for unemployed.

Either way, it's equivalent to at least £55k on PAYE and hardly the breadline.

Beezknees · 31/01/2023 12:54

ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 08:59

This is based upon a London postcode and maximum rent claim for the borough (£340 p/w, but you'd struggle to find a rent that cheap outside of social housing)

That's based on cheapest rent though. The maximum LHA hardly ever covers the cost of rent. For example in my area the maximum LHA is about £550pm for a 1 bedroom place, but private rentals for 1 beds start at £650 for a flat and £700+ for a house, so you're having to make up the shortfall.

Beezknees · 31/01/2023 12:50

ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 08:20

Just plugged minimum wage into a benefits calculator and a family of four would receive £469.83 / weekly.

Wages after tax = £335.55

Total post tax income = £805.38 p/w

That equates to £41,880 p/a

That's equivalent to £55k pre tax and you don't have to pay council tax. You also straight for various cost of living payments.

Even with rent at £400 p/w and bills at £100 p/w, you'd have £305 p/w.

So an extra £100 a week above the spending power of a family living on a single minimum wage doesn't seem excessive.

You do have to pay council tax. Council tax exemption is only for unemployed.

Sennelier1 · 31/01/2023 12:25

Seems plenty to me, can even include take-away some evenings 🤷🏼‍♀️

ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 11:50

I know the rents at the postcode I used in the calculator, because that's where I rent out a two bedroom flat. The flat is high quality with Bosch appliances, solid oak flooring, etc.

The rent is currently £413 p/w, so there would be a £73 p/w shortfall in rent, but I think that would be easily affordable given the total post tax income of £805 a week and no need to pay council tax, etc.

Given the quality of the flat I've used as an example, you'd probably be able to find something a bit more basic at a lower monthly cost.

Iwantabloodypizza · 31/01/2023 11:37

ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 08:59

This is based upon a London postcode and maximum rent claim for the borough (£340 p/w, but you'd struggle to find a rent that cheap outside of social housing)

Yes, when I lived in London, the social housing lists were 15+ years long.

We were working but claiming top up benefits as rents were so high.

The amount the LA will pay for rent is laughable. Where we were, if you needed a three bed house, the full HB amount was 1,200 a month. There was no where that was 3 bedroom that was under 1,700 a month (it’s more like 2k a month now, I hope the LA has upped it in line with that, but I doubt it).

People don’t understand that. They insist that people claiming benefits are either all in social housing or they are getting all their rent covered, which isn’t the case. You have to pay that shortfall yourself.

And it’s not the case of “well, you’ll have to rent a one bedroom place and all squeeze in then!” because even if you find a landlord who is willing to rent to you on benefits (even top up ones when you are working full time, it was a nightmare), no one will rent a one bedroom flat to a family.

And homelessness doesn’t mean you will get social housing either. How many thousands of families are living in one travelogde room for years at a time? A friend of mine, her husband and dd are entering their second year in one. And yes, they work. They just can’t find anyone who will private rent to them while they need benefits to top up the rent costs.

(And “just move where you can afford to live them!” - ha! Yeah, that’s what we did. It’s not always the easy or good option for many reasons and the only reason we could move hundreds of miles away to a cheap place was that dh London job went fully remote. Not everyone has that luxury. Cheap places are usually cheap because of deprivation and no jobs, so moving to one and leaving your job in a more expensive place makes no sense).

Sorry, I’ll get off my soapbox now, but it’s something that really winds me up.

AIBUYesSometimes · 31/01/2023 11:01

Hmmmm.!

@Toomuchtrouble4me Not sure if you are reading but in your other posts you said you were a teacher and wouldn't ever go back.

That was 2 days ago.

Now, you are saying in another post ( very recent) that you are working as a teacher.

Which is it?

And this does cast some doubt on your figures here if you are giving a different story in all your posts.

Bexblue · 31/01/2023 09:29

No it's not at all .you poor thing how on earth will you cope

Notimeforstupid · 31/01/2023 09:03

Ok so either this is a ‘look how much money I’ve got’ post in which case it’s further evidence that wealth doesn’t buy class or it’s genuine, if the latter is true then you need to take some of that income and pay for some education in budgeting, running a house and general life skills!!

ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 08:59

This is based upon a London postcode and maximum rent claim for the borough (£340 p/w, but you'd struggle to find a rent that cheap outside of social housing)

Gaging opinion £400 pw
PuttingDownRoots · 31/01/2023 08:41

@ThisGirlNever are you sure... it gave me £233

Gaging opinion £400 pw
ThisGirlNever · 31/01/2023 08:20

Just plugged minimum wage into a benefits calculator and a family of four would receive £469.83 / weekly.

Wages after tax = £335.55

Total post tax income = £805.38 p/w

That equates to £41,880 p/a

That's equivalent to £55k pre tax and you don't have to pay council tax. You also straight for various cost of living payments.

Even with rent at £400 p/w and bills at £100 p/w, you'd have £305 p/w.

So an extra £100 a week above the spending power of a family living on a single minimum wage doesn't seem excessive.

Ffariee · 31/01/2023 08:16

YABU
Im not sure if you’ve got your bills worked out right if you’re spending more than £400 a week.
Perhaps you should try to write down everything you are spending for a couple of weeks and see where it’s all going because that does sound excessive.
I think that perhaps you are including necessary expenses that I would class as bills like petrol and have to travel a lot. Otherwise are you having nails, eyebrows and hair done on a regular basis?
it would be good to understand where you are spending the money to be able to help

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 31/01/2023 07:40

£400 a week for food fuel and any extras goes very quickly

Just had a week where one dd needed new school shoes and shin pads and subs for a club,oh and lunch card topped up. That came to £120

A new tyre as blew out on me. £98

That sort of thing I don't dip into savings for so it comes out of the disposable so nearly £220 gone in one day. Obviously I don't get thru £400 every week so there's an over spill but it still doesn't go far anymore

Ginmonkeyagain · 31/01/2023 07:38

Anyway we are lucky that we can more than afford what we do spend on food and are happy to do so, I was just idly wondering how people fed a family of 4 on £50 a week.

Ginmonkeyagain · 31/01/2023 07:36

We keep a well stocked kitchen and freezer too. I suppose I could get it down to £50 a week but the meals would be pretty repetitive and carb based. Also I think part of the issue is Mr Monkey is constantly marathon training and eats like a horse.

ReneBumsWombats · 31/01/2023 07:32

Ginmonkeyagain · 31/01/2023 07:28

Slight derail but how are people feeding families of 4 on £50 pw? I spend about £70 - £90 pw for 2 people and on top of that we usually eat out at least once or twice a week (often one lunch and one dinner). I pretty much cook from scratch and I don't waste much at all. TBF we do eat meat and fish but I am good at making it stretch and often buy yellow sticker things for more expensive items (beef etc..)

That does include household cleaning stuff and toilet roll though.

It helps to be veggie, already have a well stocked pantry/cupboard and a breadmaker/slow cooker. The latter two are of course a privilege and further example of how expensive it is to be poor and how much easier it is to economise when you don't actually have to.

Ginmonkeyagain · 31/01/2023 07:28

Slight derail but how are people feeding families of 4 on £50 pw? I spend about £70 - £90 pw for 2 people and on top of that we usually eat out at least once or twice a week (often one lunch and one dinner). I pretty much cook from scratch and I don't waste much at all. TBF we do eat meat and fish but I am good at making it stretch and often buy yellow sticker things for more expensive items (beef etc..)

That does include household cleaning stuff and toilet roll though.

Beezknees · 31/01/2023 05:32

ThisGirlNever · 30/01/2023 21:37

My earnings history.

£2.20 p/h Saturday job 1991-1994
£3.20 p/h McDonald's 1994-1996
£4.50 p/h security guard 1996
£4.50 p/h meat factory 1997
£4.50 p/h warehouse 1998
£6 p/h insurance admin 2000-2004
£8.50 temping in London 2004-2006
£40k p/a first IT job in London

£47k 2nd IT job in London

£56k 3rd IT job in London
£85k 4th IT job in London

I've earned crap money and struggled to get by. I know what it's like, but I don't feel guilty for now earning more money and having a more comfortable life. I've worked really hard and made sacrifices to study professional qualifications and increase my earning potential.

I very much doubt there are many (any) people supporting a family of four on minimum wage. They'd certainly qualify for in work benefits and probably have access to very cheap social housing - something we can only dream of with our £2,200 p/m mortgage for a pretty crap 3 bed semi.

I stand by my previous comment that it isn't really that much money for a family of four (in London), when you factor in all costs - food, clothes, shoes, kids activities, petrol, lunches, trips to the cafe/nandos/pizza/etc.

Again, more ignorance if you think that everyone raising families on minumum wage are in social housing. I can't believe people have so little understanding sometimes. Most low earning families are in private rented accommodation, social housing is very hard to come by and usually only goes to people who are seriously hard up - you have to basically be homeless to be considered nowadays.

Nobody is asking you to feel guilty, but it's just silly to say £400pw is not much money. It's plenty. Trips out to restaurants/cafes aren't a weekly occurence for most people, nor do they have to be. Shoes/clothes - who buys new shoes every week? I think I bought myself 3 pairs of shoes last year for the entire year, and my disposable income is around £300pw for just two of us so it's not for lack of money, I just don't think we need so much "stuff."

Changingmynameyetagain · 31/01/2023 00:03

We’re a family of 5, we spend £150 a week on groceries, £40 on fuel and travel costs, £15 on karate lessons for ds2, £20 on 2 gym memberships (£40 each pm) and probably £50 a week on clothes or shoes for one of the DC.
We are comfortable and I don’t particularly budget but still, £400 is loads!

icecreamcrackers · 30/01/2023 23:19

I'd manage on that with plenty to spare as a family of 5 with a expensive competitive figure skater thrown in.

Mammyloveswine · 30/01/2023 23:16

Christ I have £400 a month?!!

Thirtyandflailing · 30/01/2023 23:14

£400pw?! We’re a family of 4 spend about £100pw on fuel for Range Rover and a5, £50-£70pw on food, £20-£30 for toiletries etc. I never buy bits and bobs of clothes I prefer to bulk buy at beginning of new season. I think £200-£250pw is more than enough