Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gaging opinion £400 pw

358 replies

Toomuchtrouble4me · 30/01/2023 11:01

Simply that. Family of 4. Is £400 a week reasonable to live in? This is without any bills so includes:
food for 4
household shopping (detergent etc)
clothing
treats (coffees etc)
household essentials (lightbulbs, batteries etc)
medicines and beauty products
Basically mortgage, bills, large expenses are separate, but thus includes all bits and bobs that are bought weekly plus funds for kids outings and buying gifts if they are going to a party etc.
Is it enough?
we’re trialing how much we need to spend on these things in a week and I don’t seem to be able to manage in £400.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bunnycat101 · 04/02/2023 18:46

I think it’s really easy if you’re comfortable to rack up a lot of mindless spending on food. Prior to lockdown I was quite good at bringing in lunches and controlling my work-related expenses. Post lock-down the office became a treat and suddenly I was getting breakfast and lunch out as well as a coffee as I was only in a couple of times a week. Some days I was spending £20 a day so could easily spend more in 2 days than I used to in 5. We also got into really bad habits re takeaways and were spending a fortune. We didn’t have a single one in January and didn’t miss it. There will be stuff that you’re doing that if you really thought about it, would feel like a waste if you totted up your annual spend for that item eg coffees.

howmanybicycles · 04/02/2023 15:19

To cut down to £400, you need to shave £164 off the excessive costs which you helpfully shared. It's easily done without making too much of a compromise to your easy lifestyle. My guess is that you've grown up in significant financial privilege and just need to get your head round living more like normal folk (though 400 is still masses). I'm assuming that after buying all that, surely you are set for the weekend?

So - lose £50 by buying a cake for a tenner or making one.
Lose 15 by buying an eyeliner for no more than £7 (blind tests on some shows I've watched suggest that beyond the packaging, people can't tell).
Things like skating trip, which I think was £58 because I think the food was related to that - make that sort of trip bi-weekly, that saves £26 a week.
Food, you can easily shave £40 off just with more savvy shopping, don't waste and realising that the simpler choices are often fine. So that's £131 already and still allows you lunch out every week and coffee multiple times (which is a massive luxury, lets be honest. I have lunch out maybe once every 6 weeks and so lucky to be able to do that).

The idea that you need your hair blow dried that often is ridiculous. Learn how to do it yourself. I doubt you buy £80 petrol every week given the life style you describe.

Your DH is right. Keep records of what you actually spend and challenge your assumptions. You'll easily cut back when you do that I think.

WisherWood · 03/02/2023 08:29

DH thinks anything over £400 PW is excessive

I'm team DH on this one, especially if he's the one earning the money. 400pw is a very generous allowance - as has been pointed out, some people pay for everything from that kind of money, not just nice things that they want.

So I would talk to him about why he wants to cut back - it may be that he wants to save more for a rainy day, or for a pension pot so he can retire earlier. It may just be that he's scared of where the money is going, even if you can currently afford it. I don't think it would do you any harm to budget. It's a good practice to get into in case you do need it in future. One day you may start regretting the weekly blow dries and £60 cakes, if you realise you could have had a better holiday or earlier retirement, or if he gets made redundant and suddenly you really do have to cut back.

Sunsetintheeast · 03/02/2023 06:44

I just feel like there are ways to spend that kind of money that have more of a benefit

Exactly, but we pays our money and makes the choice.

We are off to the theatre tomorrow - £600, but I don’t care. We also went in January at the same cost. It’s much less than OP spends all the time. My rimmel eyeliner didn’t get me kicked out of our great seats.

Unless I had untold wealth, coffee and work lunches are lower down my order than a myriad of items.

GinClassHeroes · 02/02/2023 22:30

Sunsetintheeast · 02/02/2023 21:59

I think you’re conflating personal optional spending with necessary expenditure.

If you spent £20k on the holiday of a lifetime, would you value it more than the unrestrained spending?

What about paying of your mortgage - if you have one?

What about retiring early?

What about a house deposit for the kids?

All these alternatives are being frittered away IMO, but perhaps you value the freedom.

Personally I’d look at curly girl
method, buy a flask or travel mug, bake a cake, and meal plan… then research a 3 week trip to Indonesia (or somewhere else)

As would I.

We aren’t rolling in it right now - not by a long shot, since we both work part time - but previously, we had a more than comfortable income on two full-time wages, and we are slowly transitioning back to that.

Our lifestyle won’t necessarily improve any - we might eat out a little more, but we are naturally quite sensible, both financially and environmentally - most of our clothes come from Vinted, we pay the maximum to our mortgage possible, we don’t go out often and we don’t do extravagant holidays.

That being said, life is short and you can’t take money with you. But I find it absolutely crazy if someone with enough disposable income to spend £100/day has a mortgage, for example - and a lot of my wealthier friends do this.

It seems crazy to me - I’d personally hammer that money into my mortgage rather than chucking money away in interest. Or I’d invest it.

Obviously OP might have no mortgage in which case fair enough. I just feel like there are ways to spend that kind of money that have more of a benefit.

Sunsetintheeast · 02/02/2023 21:59

I think you’re conflating personal optional spending with necessary expenditure.

If you spent £20k on the holiday of a lifetime, would you value it more than the unrestrained spending?

What about paying of your mortgage - if you have one?

What about retiring early?

What about a house deposit for the kids?

All these alternatives are being frittered away IMO, but perhaps you value the freedom.

Personally I’d look at curly girl
method, buy a flask or travel mug, bake a cake, and meal plan… then research a 3 week trip to Indonesia (or somewhere else)

ThisGirlNever · 02/02/2023 21:41

If you've got the money and you're enjoying life, there isn't really a problem.

I presume DH is earning decent money and his comments aren't based upon you slowly bankrupting the family?

You've received a lot of stick, but there's nothing in your weekly spending that is completely crazy.

Trips to coffee shops.
Top-up grocery shops.
Kids jumpers.
Cake.

I'm on maternity leave and don't really have a social life at the moment, but we certainly spent at those sorts of levels when we were DINKs.

Weekly travel cards = £50 each
Coffees, breakfasts and lunches = £10 a day minimum.
Supermarket shop = £80
Meal out during the week = £40-80
Takeaway or two at £40 a pop.
Day/Night out with friends = £100+ easily in London.
Ubers.
Maybe a nice meal out at the weekend = £120 with wine.

London is an expensive place and a lot of fun if you have the cash.

Fizbosshoes · 02/02/2023 19:41

I think there are possibly 2 issues here.
My DH once told someone we spent £50 each on the kids at Christmas. This was way off the mark but because he has no input he has no idea how much I spend. He would also not have the faintest idea what school uniform costs, or how much to put on their lunch account because I do that....so some (not all) of the issue might be that your DH doesn't know how much is reasonable to allocate for certain things that are essential.

However maybe if he wanted, or needed to reduce weekly spending then you could talk together about what you agree is a reasonable amount for "extras" and define what is necessary to include every week (food, diesel, toiletries etc) and what could be tweaked on a week by week basis . Even when you don't need to strictly budget its good to assess regularly, where money is going and whether savings could be made. (We recently changed a sky package to one that included Netflix, to save the £7.99/month - the 7.99 obviously isn't life changing but it was an unnecessary expense)

Toomuchtrouble4me · 02/02/2023 19:30

Ffs - I didn’t say I needed it! I said I spend over £400 and DH thinks it’s excessive and wondered if anybody else spent around the same on just day to stuff, albeit nice (ish) stuff but hardly high end.

OP posts:
Toomuchtrouble4me · 02/02/2023 19:27

I like the cake from Paul’s bakery. I wasn’t really trying to budget, just live my normal life including normal nice things, DH thinks anything over £400 PW is excessive, it does include drum lessons at the weekend. No bills. I suppose what I mean is that it’s not as though I’m blowing money in designer handbags every week - it’s just day to day ‘stuff’ albeit some nice stuff like bd cake that’s from my preferred bakers and to do that I need more than £400 PW and I wondered if others found the same. I know I’m not living in a budget, I wasn’t attempting to.

OP posts:
Wiluli · 02/02/2023 12:17

Toomuchtrouble4me · 01/02/2023 20:45

That’s what DH says…
last week rounded up figures:
MON 2x school jumpers £72.00
coffee shop 3.60
supetmarket £26.00
TUES: curtain rings and hooks £14.00
Birthday cake £60
WEDS: Supermarket 44.00
Gym £12.00
book £15.00
eyeliner £22.00
other chemist stuff £20.00
coffee £7.00
THURS
lunch £12.00
tape measure £4.00
Petrol £80.00
FRI
skating trip 40.00
supper £18.00
drinks £12.00
supermarket £70.00
wine and nibbles £23.00
…Over budget by Friday on just ‘stuff’
ok there’s not always mums bd cake but there will be some other event or essential purchase - this week both boys need a haircut…
it must just be me but I can’t do it on £400.

If my diesel costs are on the budjet then just like you I will go above often . People here are being rude . You did not ask if you could survive with £400 you asked if you could do a normal week for £400 and I’m assuming you mean comfortably .

vodkaredbullgirl · 02/02/2023 12:02

CalloohCallayFrabjousDay · 02/02/2023 11:50

Bloody hell how many batteries and lightbulbs are you getting through???

Too many by the sounds of it lol

CalloohCallayFrabjousDay · 02/02/2023 11:50

Bloody hell how many batteries and lightbulbs are you getting through???

tattygrl · 02/02/2023 11:47

I'm sorry... I'm oscillating between my mouth hanging open aghast, and helplessly giggling.

Are you serious?

Are you for real?

I can go literally days not spending anything other than pure essentials (travel for work, contribution to petrol for family car). I'm not on the poverty line or anything, just aware that I don't need to spend money every day.

I cannot believe this is real.

You didn't know whether people think to themselves "got a cake to buy this week, so I'll leave my nails for next week"????

I'm sorry I'm really not deliberately trying to be rude but I'm flabbergasted.

PuttingDownRoots · 02/02/2023 08:57

I think the problem OP has is mindless spending rather than particular items.

Take your £1600 "budget" and put it into separate categories.

Fir example subscriptions (classes, gym etc)... if those all come out at the beginning of the month, accept the first week will be more expensive.

Birthdays... put aside a bit each month into the birthday/Christmas "pot". So again it might seem more expensive that week but its actually shared over the year. Assess what you really need to spend on these... was the cake the only thing you bought?

Uniform... if its compulsory logo item its complicated. But (state) schools are supposed to be minimising cost to parents.

But most of all... you need to want to change your habits.

£100 per week saving is £5200 a year. Thats a holiday. Or over 10 years (52k) a house deposit for a child.

WisherWood · 02/02/2023 08:27

A weekly blow dry isn't essential.

No, it isn't. I have very frizzy hair and somehow manage without it. In fact, I find blow drying damaging to frizzy hair, since the hair is frizzy because it is dry, the heat from blow drying just damages it. Better to leave it to dry naturally. Good products for dry hair don't have to be expensive either.

I mean, at this stage I'm not sure why I'm saying this stuff, although I suppose it might benefit someone other than the OP.

Pipsquiggle · 02/02/2023 08:04

Stop:
Eyeliner
Cake
Frequent shop bought Coffees
Book
Top up shopping
Wine and nibbles should be part of bigger shop and planned
Weekly Nails
Weekly blow drys.

Just saved you circa £150

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/02/2023 07:23

Regular top up shopping is blowing a hole in your budget. Do a properly planned big shop.

You can also cut down on some things. I do my own nails and only go to a manicurist for special occasions (weddings, holidays etc..).

Unless it is a very special ocasion you don't need to spend £60 on a cake, Colin the Caterpillar or homemade cake will be just as appreciated.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 02/02/2023 04:51

What? I'm quite spendy and even I think that's crazy.

ChildcareIsBroken · 02/02/2023 04:42

If you want to cut down I'd start with weekly food shopping, plan your meals in advance and order what's needed. Then during the week only buy things that go off quickly like bread.
Then I'd limit some of your luxuries - maybe coffee every other day and have coffee at home rest of the time? Blow dry every other week instead of weekly? And so on...

The best motivation I find is to save in the beginning of the month and then the rest is your limit. Try to plan what you need to buy that month and leave some money for unexpected spending.

Badgerandfox227 · 02/02/2023 03:52

It’s important to budget even if you have expendable income. We have a bank account with spaces for certain things, and withdraw from the space when we spend. So for example we have spaces for groceries, petrol, kids (clothes, clubs etc), take out & treats, house improvements (we’re gradually redecorating), plus savings. Then we each have our own spends. Anything left over in each space at the end of the month goes in savings.

This means we’re being more mindful of our spending, by setting a target at the beginning of the month rather than blowing through money and then wondering where it all went.

Bemyclementine · 02/02/2023 03:25

OP you know you're in a really privileged position to be spending like this and not need to cut down. Your idea of essential is quite different to mine and many peoples though. A weekly blow dry isn't essential. Nor is coffee shop coffee every day. My car needs to go in next week, costing around £360. That is essential. I'm going to struggle but will manage.

I cut out coffee shop coffee a few years ago now. It wasn't sustainable for me any more , it's nice to have though and if you can afford it and want it... maybe have it when you're out fir the day rather than as a matter of course?

There are so many ways you could cut down but if you don't need or want to, you won't. Maybe if you were working for the money it would have more value to you.

Rebel2023 · 01/02/2023 23:58

Definitely look at the supermarket, you don't need to go that often

Write a list, with everything you need and stick to it. I do a shop that lasts 7-10 days, yes day 10 might be using up random stuff and freezer but it all helps. I keep the list on my phone and add to it as I see I need something, the freezer always has some kind of bread in and I keep UHT milk as a back up I need my cups of tea

Look at alternative beauty products, I often google "dupe for X" to see what people recommend, or watch "drugstore new makeup" on YouTube
If you can't cope without it then use Quidco for cash back, google for a discount code and always buy in the sales. I love tarte mascara so I get the Christmas set which is 3 mascaras for about the price of 1

Work out what's negotiable with hair/skin etc. example being I am perfectly happy with dove shower gel (on offer!) but caudalie hand cream I won't give up (again I get it in a cracker set they do for Christmas)

It's just being a bit more clever sometimes with money. Make sure to buy stuff at the lowest price too. So if you eat say Ben and jerrys ice cream. Don't buy it at full price, it always goes on offer. When it's half price, get 2 and stick it in the freezer and you've got 2 for the price of 1 Do that for anything - not perishable, beauty, hair, food. I have a full back up stash of stuff!

Twillow · 01/02/2023 23:44

CLOTHING:
2x school jumpers £72.00

DIY: curtain rings and hooks £14.00
tape measure £4.00
=£18

PERSONAL
Gym £12.00
book £15.00
eyeliner £22.00
other chemist stuff £20.00
=£71

CAR
Petrol £80.00

GOING OUT
coffee shop 3.60
coffee £7.00
lunch £12.00
supper £18.00
drinks £12.00
skating trip 40.00
=£92.60

FOOD
Birthday cake £60
Supermarket 44.00
supetmarket £26.00
supermarket £70.00
wine and nibbles £23.00
= £223

Your biggest spend area, food for consumption at home, is exceeding £30 a day. I imagine you're popping out for bits without much of a meal plan. This is a mistake if you are trying to stick to any kind of budget.

GinClassHeroes · 01/02/2023 23:35

Suzi888 · 01/02/2023 22:36

You’re a teacher ‘gaging’ opinion on a £400 a week spend… 🤔 I’ll just leave this here.

I did question whether she was gagging on £400 or gauging - though to be fair, I think gagging is maybe more accurate.