Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To irrationally resent SUVs ?

408 replies

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 09:09

For those who have impossibly avoided the term, I’m talking about “fake 4x4s.”

A car that would have been a hatchback a dozen years ago, but is now wider, higher up, with fake 4x4 styling (flared wheel arches, roof rails, big plastic moulding).

I can’t stand them.

As someone who has owned two generations of Range Rovers when we lived off a track a mile or so from the main road, I realise people are free to lob back at me. but those cars had a purpose. We wanted to be comfortable; but we absolutely needed the traction and clearance that vehicle gave us.

Does anyone need what a Grandland X offers? A Mokka? (Jesus save me from that awful car. Worst on sale today - just buy a Corsa and stop being previous). Who needs a Sportage or a Qashqai? (the hallmarks of the aspiring, when years ago a Focus or a Golf would have done just fine).

The worst offenders for me are actually the so called luxury ones. BMW X5 is an abomination - can’t do anything off road, is massively wide on road, and two mums at our school park terribly with them and block the road for the other direction.

And that’s the thing - a large segment of folk who own them, can’t drive them properly. I go to the hospital car park twice weekly with my DD. If someone is careless (often are) and parks close to or on the white line… renders the next space completely useless. Which when hunting for the one or two spaces available for my vulnerable DD, can be infuriating.

We don’t need these things, but I get people love them for

• being “high up” (still doesn’t make the drivers any better at driving)

• Being “high up” to load DCs and allow elderly parents to get in and out without bending back

• some of them have a big boot

Ok, but my answer to all these three is..

an MPV. Cars like the Ford Galaxy, S Max, Touran, Alhambra - all high up seating, easy to get in and out of, massive boots.

But no.. the truth is fashion. Why buy a Corsa when you have a jacked up version. Why buy a 5 series when you can have an X5 and dominate the school run.

Meanwhile the greater fuel consumption, the materials cost to make the thing …

AIBU to irrationally hate these stupid wide massive things?

OP posts:
Yarrawonga · 30/01/2023 09:52

But I don't understand all the hybrid mini SUVs. Most seem to be bought for the school run and never see a single bit of mud.

They aren’t very capable in the mud, so that shouldn’t be surprising.

I started with a small hatchback and ended up wrecking it because it didn’t have a enough ground clearance for what I used it for, then bought an SUV/crossover because it had better ground clearance but then got stuck in the mud. So, now I have a 4x4.

Incidentally, I have passed the IAM advanced driving test and can reverse park with a trailer attached.

QuertyGirl · 30/01/2023 09:50

WestwardHo1 · 30/01/2023 09:45

People get unbelievably precious and defensive about their car choices. It's pathetic.

Definitely!

Cars do something to people's brains if they're not careful.

Eternally grateful I don't need one

Ahenrybyanyothername · 30/01/2023 09:49

I agree with you and we have a qashqai 😂. I'd choose my tiny go-kart of a hatchback any day... parking is a nightmare (not because I can't drive, just having enough space to get in/out without inconveniencing anyone else), harder to manouver in confined spaces. Just all round why bother.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 30/01/2023 09:49

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 09:30

They are loads safr for the driver/ passengers too I would think. Strudy builds so if you did have an accident (espeically with a bigger vehicle) you'd be much better off than in a fiat 500. We've all seen the big pile ups on the motorway and we know which cars crimple like paper and which don't.

For me, my SUV (it's not a 4x4 and is chargeable hybrid) is about safety most of all, I find it easier to drive as I am up higher, and it's convenient for space the kids, dogs, etc. My FIL with a bad knee finds it much easier to get in and out of than a lower car too, so that's a bonus. I am not a good parker (and never was - even with my little clio), but the huge armery of cameras and my "parking assistant" software makes me able to park perfectly in one go almost every time. Vs about 300 moves when I had a small car that only had mirrors to guide me.

I think your views on SUV are pretty outdated.

I always find the 'safety' argument for driving SUVs interesting insofar as your improved safety comes at the expense of everyone else, be it pedestrians, cyclists and other motorists. That raised vehicle profile means that the collision height against many other vehicles is such that crumple zones are avoided and other drivers/passengers are more vulnerable to impacts. Certainly from my somewhat anecdotal observations is that an awful lot of people just cant maneuver very well these large cars despite all the sensors and parking aids and expect all other motorists to get out of the way. I have seen on more then a few occasions some lone fat SUV in the middle of the road or in a carpark expecting several cars to back down because the moron behind the wheel 'cant reverse'.

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 09:49

OP, I wonder if you realise how hypocritical you are coming across. Turning your nose up at other people's justifications when you admit to having the type of car you apparently hate, but that's ok becuase you had a bit of land and "wanted to be comfortable".

So essentially your take seems to be that if you are a landowner you are fine to drive these big car -even just to be comfortable, or to deal with the occassional snow on all your acres, but all the peasants living in their semis are just idiots with no acceptable reason for chosing them.

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 09:48

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 09:41

Obviously that was exaggeration. But I am nervous about parking, I think it's mainly because I am quite short so my view isn't the best, and early on driving a scrapped a car parking it which has given me a bit of a hang up about it. Plus, presumably my spacial awareness could be better. Either way, now I have good visbility (and things that beep if I get too close), and I'm a pretty great parker!

I'm 5ft nothing and would not have passed my driving test if I'd not been able to park! The only car I've ever struggled to drive properly was an Audi Estate, even with the seat pulled as far forward as it could go and the seat raised as high as it would go I could not reach the pedals.

I don't think people who are too nervous to drive properly should be on the road personally. What happens when all your fancy sensors and cameras stop working one day while your out on the road somewhere?

Strawberrypicnic · 30/01/2023 09:47

I live in London and feel the same. There are so many of them cluttering up the pavements. If you want a huge car for fashion purposes you shouldn't live somewhere where public space is at a premium. It's selfish.

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 09:47

DoorstoManual · 30/01/2023 09:44

I spent a year in bed my muscles wasted they have never been the same again, when I was finally well again I struggled to get in and out of standard cars, I now have a CRV, my next car will be a Volvo XC60.

Here are some pearls to clutch, whilst you judge people you know nothing about.😡

Good on you hope your car choice alleviates pain @DoorstoManual

but you bloody well know you’re an exception here, so don’t get angry at me when I speak about a rapidly growing , most popular sector of car where most people don’t have muscle wastage but choose it for image.

OP posts:
bloodywhitecat · 30/01/2023 09:46

You are welcome to load my little one with his dystonia which often makes him as rigid as a board and his wheelchair and all of his equipment into a Corsa but until his WAV is delivered I will continue to drive my SUV type car (and yes, I am perfectly capable of driving it thanks).

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 09:45

GCAcademic · 30/01/2023 09:40

I will probably get one when I next replace my car. I really don't want to (not least because of fuel efficiency) but I have elderly parents who are increasingly finding it difficult to get in and out of my car.

I could name you 10-15 cars you could get, that aren’t SUVs.

I mentioned this fallacy in my OP. Everyone is buying these things for their “elderly parents”. It’s the classic justification. 😃

OP posts:
WestwardHo1 · 30/01/2023 09:45

People get unbelievably precious and defensive about their car choices. It's pathetic.

sarahh96 · 30/01/2023 09:45

I have one and find it very useful for traversing the north side of Waitrose car park. 🤣

JenniferSlopez · 30/01/2023 09:45

As someone who owns a stonking great L200 with body lift and mahoosive wheels (which I do actually use off road and on building sites etc) I'm inclined to agree.

I do like X5s though as a big, spacious, car that drives well, bit like a RR Sport (which nobody buys to actually take off road). But I don't understand all the hybrid mini SUVs. Most seem to be bought for the school run and never see a single bit of mud.

DoorstoManual · 30/01/2023 09:44

I spent a year in bed my muscles wasted they have never been the same again, when I was finally well again I struggled to get in and out of standard cars, I now have a CRV, my next car will be a Volvo XC60.

Here are some pearls to clutch, whilst you judge people you know nothing about.😡

Beecham · 30/01/2023 09:44

Blame the manufacturers. It is very very difficult now to buy a low priced 7-seater 'people carrier'. They've nearly all been discontinued and replaced with SUVs

Vauxhall Zafira? Gone
Citroen Grand picasso? Gone
Renault grand scenic? Gone

There are some expensive ones left but the trend is definitely towards SUVs

DixonD · 30/01/2023 09:43

Joyfuljolly · 30/01/2023 09:11

Can’t imagine spending my time so focused on this that I delveloped a phobia and had to start a thread about it.

This. It’s weird.

Not all SUVs are “fake 4x4s”. Mine is described as an SUV, but it’s a very real 4x4. We have it because we have a smallholding.

loveisanopensore · 30/01/2023 09:43

It's not irrational at all.
I live in a 1950s housing estate. There's not enough room for them. Their owners act like they're hauling around building supplies but mostly they're driving 1km to the shop.
The higher bonnet means they're more likely to kill pedestrians.
www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-suvs-are-more-lethal-to-pedestrians-than-cars

PuttingDownRoots · 30/01/2023 09:43

We have a LR discovery sport. Yes it's to go to asda and has been used on the school run.

It also takes our canoe on the roof, pulls our trailer and has been used to rescue smaller cars in snow. It has been up mountains. I've had five kids in it or its been filled with scout camp equipment. Its been a changing room for sports.

Its a bit oversized when I visit my parents in London. But suits our life in Yorkshire.

EyesOnThePies · 30/01/2023 09:42

Our London residential streets are in permanent gridlock because while ‘normal’ cars can pass each other, these bloated monstrosities can’t.

Utterly stupid. Great big plasticky accessorised vehicles with dashboards like a jumbo jet, never driven beyond Lidl, never mind the M25.

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 09:41

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 09:35

How on earth did you manage to blag a Driving License if you can't park a Clio in less than 300 moves?

Obviously that was exaggeration. But I am nervous about parking, I think it's mainly because I am quite short so my view isn't the best, and early on driving a scrapped a car parking it which has given me a bit of a hang up about it. Plus, presumably my spacial awareness could be better. Either way, now I have good visbility (and things that beep if I get too close), and I'm a pretty great parker!

xogossipgirlxo · 30/01/2023 09:41

Resenting them is bit weird to me, but I don't understand crossovers too, especially those with small engines. They're not fit for purpose. Too big for such small engine (like 1L that rather fits Fiesta or Corsa), don't really understand the point of them.

SweetSakura · 30/01/2023 09:40

JassyRadlett · 30/01/2023 09:35

Do you feel the same about estates? They often have a larger footprint.

Yes, anyone who has an unnecessarily large car. But around here it's definitely SUV drivers who have a propensity for parking across two spaces / taking up far more road space than they even need to etc

GCAcademic · 30/01/2023 09:40

I will probably get one when I next replace my car. I really don't want to (not least because of fuel efficiency) but I have elderly parents who are increasingly finding it difficult to get in and out of my car.

Oakbeam · 30/01/2023 09:40

They are loads safety for the driver/ passengers too I would think

Their secondary safety might be better but the primary safety probably isn’t because they tend to be less stable than lower, more nimble, vehicles.

Secondary safety is level of protection in an accident.

Primary safety is the ability to avoid having an accident in the first place.

7Worfs · 30/01/2023 09:40

You are not wrong, OP.

On the school run there’s this incompetent twat in a giant VW she can’t park unless there’s 3x space, so she always parks on the dropped curb outside the nursery.

It pisses me off to no end as I need the dropped curb for the pram.

Car financing for these monstrosities needs to fucking end.

I hate the engine idlers more though. No thought to what they are inflicting on young developing lungs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread