Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To irrationally resent SUVs ?

408 replies

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 09:09

For those who have impossibly avoided the term, I’m talking about “fake 4x4s.”

A car that would have been a hatchback a dozen years ago, but is now wider, higher up, with fake 4x4 styling (flared wheel arches, roof rails, big plastic moulding).

I can’t stand them.

As someone who has owned two generations of Range Rovers when we lived off a track a mile or so from the main road, I realise people are free to lob back at me. but those cars had a purpose. We wanted to be comfortable; but we absolutely needed the traction and clearance that vehicle gave us.

Does anyone need what a Grandland X offers? A Mokka? (Jesus save me from that awful car. Worst on sale today - just buy a Corsa and stop being previous). Who needs a Sportage or a Qashqai? (the hallmarks of the aspiring, when years ago a Focus or a Golf would have done just fine).

The worst offenders for me are actually the so called luxury ones. BMW X5 is an abomination - can’t do anything off road, is massively wide on road, and two mums at our school park terribly with them and block the road for the other direction.

And that’s the thing - a large segment of folk who own them, can’t drive them properly. I go to the hospital car park twice weekly with my DD. If someone is careless (often are) and parks close to or on the white line… renders the next space completely useless. Which when hunting for the one or two spaces available for my vulnerable DD, can be infuriating.

We don’t need these things, but I get people love them for

• being “high up” (still doesn’t make the drivers any better at driving)

• Being “high up” to load DCs and allow elderly parents to get in and out without bending back

• some of them have a big boot

Ok, but my answer to all these three is..

an MPV. Cars like the Ford Galaxy, S Max, Touran, Alhambra - all high up seating, easy to get in and out of, massive boots.

But no.. the truth is fashion. Why buy a Corsa when you have a jacked up version. Why buy a 5 series when you can have an X5 and dominate the school run.

Meanwhile the greater fuel consumption, the materials cost to make the thing …

AIBU to irrationally hate these stupid wide massive things?

OP posts:
Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 10:37

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 10:26

Thanks for telling me how I need to feel 🙄You may think it silly, however I know - factually - that I cannot see as well out the car as I could if I was a ft taller. I don't NEED a higher vehicle for that reason, I could manage it without it. I can also manage without the cameras. But given I have a choice to purchase a car that can increase my visbility (making my maneouvering easier and safer) why wouldn't I?

And re the height of the car, yes and no. Obviously a higher view point makes it easier to see better. But it also depends on seat position, some cars have low set more sporty seats which makes it really impossible if you are short.

Maybe its glasses you need then if you are struggling with visibility? Yes, there are some cars with seats that make them impossible to drive when you're short I know, I used to drive a lot of pool cars at an old job and struggled with the Audi, but I also drove a Scenic and being high up did not increase my visibilty in any useful way. All of my own cars have been little hatchbacks, easy to park and maneouvre and no problems with visibility, so I guess I just don't understand the excuse that people NEED great big high up cars in order to be able to drive to an acceptable standard. From what I've seen as well, so many of these big cars don't even have much more space in them then a smaller car, maybe in the boot! My brother has a qashqai and it has the same amount of seating space as my Yaris does!

Coffeeandcrocs · 30/01/2023 10:33

Because I have three children I'm car seats and a dog which all need transporting multiple times a day as we live in the countryside with no pavements?

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 30/01/2023 10:28

I can't stand Range Rovers/ Land Rovers. But that is directly from the misfortune of dealing with their owners at work.
I have a Ford Kuga. Shoot me. Its high up, has decent tyres to deal with shite East Sussex road. It has all the bells and whistles.

JustFrustrated · 30/01/2023 10:27

I do hate these threads.

Probably cause I take it personally.

I drove X2 qashqais for 5 years and then an estate. None were actually my choice, company cars.

Hated the Qashqai, but did like the viewing from being higher up.

LOVED the estate...so much space.

And actually going from an estate to my hatchback now....took me forever to learn to park a small car.

Personally, I just hate most other road users. Seems to me that most can't park and don't make good judgement e.g. leave it too long/pull out too early at roundabouts.

I also think the quality of driving in London is absolutely appalling. Some of the worst in the country.

xogossipgirlxo · 30/01/2023 10:27

"Because of their size, they are more difficult to drive, so people make a hash of it. And they don't care, because they feel safe because of the size."

IMO, they're easier to drive, because you sit high. You can see end of your bonnet, unlike in hatchbacks etc. It's poor drivers who make others' life miserable. They should hand their licence to the nearest police station and never drive again. If you can't see properly in SUV, there's no hope for you.

bravelittletiger · 30/01/2023 10:27

"The hallmarks of the aspiring"

You sound like a horrible snob in everything you've written. Not sure any of it has much to do with the cars tbh.

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 10:27

I had a Clio for years, went everywhere in it and I can't understand how anybody could struggle to park one?! It's tiny, you can see every inch of the outside of it from the inside! I'm not the worlds best driver either, I'm just average!

GCAcademic · 30/01/2023 10:26

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 09:45

I could name you 10-15 cars you could get, that aren’t SUVs.

I mentioned this fallacy in my OP. Everyone is buying these things for their “elderly parents”. It’s the classic justification. 😃

The alternatives you've mentioned are MPVs. I don't want an MPV, they're too big. Why would that be better? What I want is height to make things easier for my elderly parents (no scare quotes required).

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 10:26

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 10:20

I didn't mean your height is silly!! Being short is awesome, I meant using your height as an excuse for your nervousness around parking is silly! People saying that they NEED a tall car because of their height is silly and its not true. I've driven higher up cars too, I honestly can't say that being higher up made any real difference to anything except I could see over the hedges and look at some sheep in the field!

Thanks for telling me how I need to feel 🙄You may think it silly, however I know - factually - that I cannot see as well out the car as I could if I was a ft taller. I don't NEED a higher vehicle for that reason, I could manage it without it. I can also manage without the cameras. But given I have a choice to purchase a car that can increase my visbility (making my maneouvering easier and safer) why wouldn't I?

And re the height of the car, yes and no. Obviously a higher view point makes it easier to see better. But it also depends on seat position, some cars have low set more sporty seats which makes it really impossible if you are short.

GasPanic · 30/01/2023 10:25

Have a big problem with SUVs - they should be taxed off the road.

Fake SUV's ? Less so. The big issue with real SUVs is that you are lugging round a huge amount of extra metalwork (4WD, beefed up suspension) that you don't actually need for UK driving, making them extremely environmentally unfriendly.

Fake SUVs don't have any of that extra metalwork. Sure they are a bit more chunky than normal cars (probably not much more so than an audi or BMW), but the lack of beefed up suspension and 4WD drivetrain means they are not hauling around loads of extra capability that is never used.

So to me, tax SUVs off the road. Fake SUVs can stay.

mrsbrownhat · 30/01/2023 10:24

As an 'old person' I had to swap my beloved fiesta for one so I can get in and out. It has a TINY boot but apart from that I love it, it's a hybrid not a diesel and I could afford it. And I am perfectly capable of driving it thank you very much. Find something really important to stress over apart from why I chose my car?

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 30/01/2023 10:23

I have an SUV, a pretty old one.

It’s high enough to get in and out of easily for me and relatives who also have long term conditions. The boot size is OK most of the time (although for camping it could be bigger). It’s a decent compromise for the activities we use it for for leisure and driving about day to day.

It’s easy to park and doesn’t take up extra room because as others have said footprint wise it’s probably no bigger than an estate. Having lived very rurally - there’s no link between SUVs and people who can’t / won’t reverse in my experience. It’s far more likely to be executive type cars who won’t / can’t drive properly.

My main disappointment with it is that it’s not hybrid but there is no way we could afford one.

It’s easy to make sweeping statements about owners of a type of car but the reality is that they tick lots of boxes, otherwise no one would buy one.

SmartHome · 30/01/2023 10:23

I cant believe a multiple Range Rover owner has the nerve to castigate other for wanting to drive larger cars - the only cars that bully people round here and take up ALL the space on teh school run are those massive Range Rovers. There is a woman at one of my kids schools who has one that is so large it wont actually fit in a space and it takes her about 20 mins too park it. Everyone runs when they see her comng.

Also my X5 is way easier to park them my Clio ....

Mitfordian · 30/01/2023 10:23

YANBU, they are a scourge on narrow streets in most British towns. Sure they're fine on the purpose built drives of their horrible new build though. 😆

lieselotte · 30/01/2023 10:22

Resenting SUVs is not irrational.

They are oversized and take up too much space on the roads and in car parks.

Because of their size, they are more difficult to drive, so people make a hash of it. And they don't care, because they feel safe because of the size.

They are polluting - even the electric ones because they take up too much room on the roads, and therefore slow down other traffic and create more emissions.

And most of all, they are far more dangerous for pedestrians and cyclists if there is a collision, which is more likely to happen due to point 2.

AMALDO · 30/01/2023 10:22

Our family car is a Ford Galaxy and I love it. Its huge inside and perfect for our family. We recently were involved in a crash and have a courtesy car, a Citroen aircross. Same length same width but so small inside, it's awful trying to fit us all in. Big small cars I call them.... Horrific!

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 30/01/2023 10:22

YANBU, and they are also the ones that one go "off road" down a narrow lane and expect me to go in the ditch in my hatchback. Usually driven by mums dropping their kids off at school at 100 mph.

FuckabethFuckor · 30/01/2023 10:20

One of the genius bits of design on the original Range Rover is the 'crenellations' on the ends of the bonnet. (On the outer edges.) These are terrific in helping the driver see the edges of the car. It gives it a very defined endpoint, and makes it very easy to place on the road (or in a parking space).

There have always been bigger cars and smaller cars. And the knack to driving anything, of any size, is understanding where the edges are. People have accidents and make misjudgements in Clios and Corsas as well as Kodiaqs and Q7s, so bad driving isn't necessarily a car size issue.

To irrationally resent SUVs ?
Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 10:20

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 10:14

Well, I park perfectly well. And great now with the sensors. I dont' tear past anyone, and am a careful and good driver, and haven't clipped any mirrors or similar. Plus, as I already said, my car (although an SUV/ crossover) is no bigger than the equivalent estate version, just higher. I also walk my kids to school, so my car is not on the school run.

And no, we didn't have them then. So clearly I can park without them (and my heigh isn't "silly2, of course it impacts visibility! increased visibility though being up higher and the cameras is a great thing for me), and do (if eg in a hire car).

I didn't mean your height is silly!! Being short is awesome, I meant using your height as an excuse for your nervousness around parking is silly! People saying that they NEED a tall car because of their height is silly and its not true. I've driven higher up cars too, I honestly can't say that being higher up made any real difference to anything except I could see over the hedges and look at some sheep in the field!

LLMS2022 · 30/01/2023 10:19

Can I ask why you feel so superior to all these silly drivers driving around in their silly 'pretend' 4x4's? It's none of your business what anyone chooses to drive or why!! Get a fucking life! And I love how you are trying to drill home that you are such a good driver, and know soooo much about cars.... congratulations, do an awful lot of other people, and they don't feel the need to start pointless threads about it🙄🤔

Snugglemonkey · 30/01/2023 10:18

parietal · 30/01/2023 09:58

It is entirely rational to hate SUVs. they are too big and too heavy and too wide for London streets. My brother drives a horrible great big thing, and his boot space is no bigger than my little VW Golf.

Cars should be taxed by weight (a big factor in pedestrian safety) and footprint (parking spaces) as well as CO2 emissions to make it less attractive for people to buy these ridiculous vehicles.

Perhaps in London, but plenty of us live rurally, somewhere it floods and snow is to be expected. I do the school run in my 4x4, but it is not for show. Looks it too sadly, as it is often filthy, despite a weekly wash 😔

JenniferSlopez · 30/01/2023 10:17

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 10:04

They are fine cars - I read the review where they compared the X7’s ride as similar to that of a Rolls Royce for lack of noise, vibration and harshness.

However is it a car that can “fit” the UK? I look sometimes at our side roads in this country and I think, how can two cars of similar width (X7 and new Range Rover for example) ever conceivably pass each other? Ever?

how do you find it to drive in that aspect?

You'd have to use passing places I guess. I go to a lot of rural building sites in a concrete mixer truck and rarely have too much difficulty. Often someone has to reverse but not far in most cases.

Sometimes I see the look of sheer terror in Mrs Range Rover's eyes when she meets me head on and reverse out of sympathy, although really anybody on the road should be competent enough to reverse their vehicle for 20 seconds in a straight line.

ethermint · 30/01/2023 10:17

agree OP. We live in a small country with small roads, not the USA. And the pollution is terrible.

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 10:14

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 10:09

I've also been driving for more than 20 years, and we didn't have all those parking sensors and cameras back then did we! I picked up on your point about not being able to park a Clio because I though that that was quite concerning yes, also your excuse of being short is silly.

I see people every day in my village who can't park sensibly and it is a real pet hate of mine, trying to walk my children 3 minutes down the road to school is like running the gauntlet every day with cars parked sideways across the pavements so we can't use them and have to walk in the road with all the idiots in their massive cars and no spatial awareness tearing past us. On 2 occasions my partner and I have actually been hit by their wing mirrors. I have to wonder just how useful the sensors really are in these big flash cars if the drivers are still hitting people and struggling to park.

Well, I park perfectly well. And great now with the sensors. I dont' tear past anyone, and am a careful and good driver, and haven't clipped any mirrors or similar. Plus, as I already said, my car (although an SUV/ crossover) is no bigger than the equivalent estate version, just higher. I also walk my kids to school, so my car is not on the school run.

And no, we didn't have them then. So clearly I can park without them (and my heigh isn't "silly2, of course it impacts visibility! increased visibility though being up higher and the cameras is a great thing for me), and do (if eg in a hire car).

ShimmeringShirts · 30/01/2023 10:14

Hating anything takes a massive amount of mental energy, if you have that to spare then it’s up to you what you choose to hate I guess.

Swipe left for the next trending thread