Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To irrationally resent SUVs ?

408 replies

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 09:09

For those who have impossibly avoided the term, I’m talking about “fake 4x4s.”

A car that would have been a hatchback a dozen years ago, but is now wider, higher up, with fake 4x4 styling (flared wheel arches, roof rails, big plastic moulding).

I can’t stand them.

As someone who has owned two generations of Range Rovers when we lived off a track a mile or so from the main road, I realise people are free to lob back at me. but those cars had a purpose. We wanted to be comfortable; but we absolutely needed the traction and clearance that vehicle gave us.

Does anyone need what a Grandland X offers? A Mokka? (Jesus save me from that awful car. Worst on sale today - just buy a Corsa and stop being previous). Who needs a Sportage or a Qashqai? (the hallmarks of the aspiring, when years ago a Focus or a Golf would have done just fine).

The worst offenders for me are actually the so called luxury ones. BMW X5 is an abomination - can’t do anything off road, is massively wide on road, and two mums at our school park terribly with them and block the road for the other direction.

And that’s the thing - a large segment of folk who own them, can’t drive them properly. I go to the hospital car park twice weekly with my DD. If someone is careless (often are) and parks close to or on the white line… renders the next space completely useless. Which when hunting for the one or two spaces available for my vulnerable DD, can be infuriating.

We don’t need these things, but I get people love them for

• being “high up” (still doesn’t make the drivers any better at driving)

• Being “high up” to load DCs and allow elderly parents to get in and out without bending back

• some of them have a big boot

Ok, but my answer to all these three is..

an MPV. Cars like the Ford Galaxy, S Max, Touran, Alhambra - all high up seating, easy to get in and out of, massive boots.

But no.. the truth is fashion. Why buy a Corsa when you have a jacked up version. Why buy a 5 series when you can have an X5 and dominate the school run.

Meanwhile the greater fuel consumption, the materials cost to make the thing …

AIBU to irrationally hate these stupid wide massive things?

OP posts:
Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 11:49

GasPanic · 30/01/2023 11:45

It actually does. The more box shaped a car, the more air resistance and the greater the full consumption.

The higher up you are the more fuel you will use, because it is mostly about the front surface area you present to the oncoming air.

This, and the fact that SUVs tend to have more boxy and less streamlined fronts. If you look at modern saloons the windscreens are all aggressively sloped to push air over the top of the car and reduce the air resistance.

So saloons generally have a much lower drag coefficient than SUVs.

Not in all cases I'd say....

To irrationally resent SUVs ?
Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 11:48

Oakbeam · 30/01/2023 11:33

Most of all its the bullying I hate, the self-important expectation that all other road users must make way for their massive cars.

Is it intentional bullying, or just your own sense of insecurity when faced with a bigger vehicle?

Yes it's intentional, when somebody in a landrover sees you coming down the road and then drives straight past a great big passing space and forces their way up the narrow line knowing you wont be able to pass without needing to reverse that is definitely intentional! Something which happens frequently to me, on occasions I've refused to reverse for them some have become very aggressive with me, having children in the car makes me feel that it would be unwise to try to stand my ground with these people any more.

GasPanic · 30/01/2023 11:45

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:21

YABU. The shape of the car doesn't make it more polluting. And you can't get a large dog into a small hatchback.

I hate the big pointless gas guzzlers but not the overall shape, and many can be quite fuel efficient or fully electric. For one thing, my dad couldn't get into a small car after he has reduced mobilty in his hips, as they sit too low on the road. My mum has good mobility but still struggles getting into a small hatchback. SUVs seats are easier to get into for lots of people and sitting higher on the road means you can see what is coming over the hedges of winding country lanes!

It actually does. The more box shaped a car, the more air resistance and the greater the full consumption.

The higher up you are the more fuel you will use, because it is mostly about the front surface area you present to the oncoming air.

This, and the fact that SUVs tend to have more boxy and less streamlined fronts. If you look at modern saloons the windscreens are all aggressively sloped to push air over the top of the car and reduce the air resistance.

So saloons generally have a much lower drag coefficient than SUVs.

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 30/01/2023 11:45

I have a Volvo SUV. I live rurally. It's lovely to drive with a great safety record. It's the best car I've ever owned.

BubziOwl · 30/01/2023 11:42

CupEmpty · 30/01/2023 09:25

I’m not sure you know as much about cars as you think you do…. Modern land rovers are absolutely shite, they break down all the time and the after customer care is appalling. They are full of faults and are the most overpriced ‘status car’ amongst your list!!

Im from a farming family and no one uses land rovers on the farm anymore - it’s all Mitsubishi, Toyota etc

I have a similar experience with farming family and friends' cars, the only people I know who have land rovers these days certainly don't have them for any practical reason

xogossipgirlxo · 30/01/2023 11:37

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:31

And also if you park it next to a Range Rover or Porsche SUV, you realise what a completely reasonable size they are!

Agreed. They're not massive and not blocking the roads. They're not that bigger than Ford Galaxy, for example. I parked near my work colleague's enormous BMW X5, I felt like I was Golf/Seat Leon driver.

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 11:35

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 11:27

I don't have any problem with BMW's! I have a problem with people saying that they need to be high up or they can't see, I find that really worrying, especially as a short person who is often not seen by people driving those high up cars! Your choice of car doesn't have anything to do with me personally no, but every day the choices that other drivers of these kinds of cars make DOES impact me and other road users, that's why I get annoyed and why I don't like the amount of oversized vehicles on the road. The bullying of other road users, the abysmal parking and blocking of roads and pavements and the inability to reverse a few feet in a straight line forcing me to reverse a mile around corners etc! Most of all its the bullying I hate, the self-important expectation that all other road users must make way for their massive cars. I find the excuses people make for needing these types of car are often nonsense, they just don't want to admit that their choice of car is more about status and "keeping up with the Joneses" then it is practicality.

"The bullying of other road users, the abysmal parking and blocking of roads and pavements and the inability to reverse a few feet in a straight line forcing me to reverse a mile around corners etc! Most of all its the bullying I hate, the self-important expectation that all other road users must make way for their massive cars."

But I don't do any of these things. Also, my car isn't bigger that what I might otherwise chose given our requirements (MPV or estate).

I have explained why I chose the car I chose - the reasons, not the excuses. We all make our own decisions. I think it's pretty short sighted and narrowminded to not be able to imagine that people make different choices to yourself (or - per previous exchange - have difference experiences) and therefore that their choices must be due to arrogance and wanting to show up.

Oakbeam · 30/01/2023 11:33

Most of all its the bullying I hate, the self-important expectation that all other road users must make way for their massive cars.

Is it intentional bullying, or just your own sense of insecurity when faced with a bigger vehicle?

LaFemmeDamnee · 30/01/2023 11:32

It's always the drivers of massive SUVs that are far too busy to park in the car park outside of school and walk up, and instead choose to park on the zigzags right outside the gates blocking the whole footpath with the enormous doors while they offload their kids. Not saying it's only SUV drivers (oversized Minis do this a lot too) or all SUV drivers, but they do stand out as being disproportionately inconsiderate.

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:31

xogossipgirlxo · 30/01/2023 11:30

Oh, Tiguans are great for maneuvering. They're very well constructed, much much better than estates which are only longer version of standard cars, where nothing else was adjusted. And they're really comfortable to drive. Actually sensors and camera in our Tiguan are down, and none of us CBA to fix it (my husband MIGHT do it in the Spring 😂), and it's still easy to park, reverse, you will fit everywhere.

And also if you park it next to a Range Rover or Porsche SUV, you realise what a completely reasonable size they are!

xogossipgirlxo · 30/01/2023 11:30

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:27

Actually our Tiguan was easier to reverse park than the Ibiza we have now (swapped to smaller car because of young driver in household) because of all the built in parking aides.

All the people I see faffing about in parking spaces and not knowing the width/length of their car are in Toyota Yaris and the like.

Oh, Tiguans are great for maneuvering. They're very well constructed, much much better than estates which are only longer version of standard cars, where nothing else was adjusted. And they're really comfortable to drive. Actually sensors and camera in our Tiguan are down, and none of us CBA to fix it (my husband MIGHT do it in the Spring 😂), and it's still easy to park, reverse, you will fit everywhere.

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:30

Cars generally are an issue, I accept that. We really all need to be walking, cycling, or pootling about in little 20mph max simple golf buggy type things for short journeys, only using hired pool cars for longer journeys but we aren't at that stage, and the car industry will lobby hard to never allow it. Therefore people buy cars of a shape that suits them.

Picklypickles · 30/01/2023 11:27

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 10:38

Oh for godness sake, can you not just take it at face value that I found it tricky to see out of a car because I was lower? Why do you find it so important to undermine or disprove that particular experience of mine? It's really quite odd and has absolutely nothing to do with you.

I don't have any problem with BMW's! I have a problem with people saying that they need to be high up or they can't see, I find that really worrying, especially as a short person who is often not seen by people driving those high up cars! Your choice of car doesn't have anything to do with me personally no, but every day the choices that other drivers of these kinds of cars make DOES impact me and other road users, that's why I get annoyed and why I don't like the amount of oversized vehicles on the road. The bullying of other road users, the abysmal parking and blocking of roads and pavements and the inability to reverse a few feet in a straight line forcing me to reverse a mile around corners etc! Most of all its the bullying I hate, the self-important expectation that all other road users must make way for their massive cars. I find the excuses people make for needing these types of car are often nonsense, they just don't want to admit that their choice of car is more about status and "keeping up with the Joneses" then it is practicality.

Neededanewuserhandle · 30/01/2023 11:27

cadburyegg · 30/01/2023 10:53

Lol I have a fake SUV. Skoda Karoq. I bought it because it's comfortable to drive and I needed space for the kids. I used to have an Astra and it cost £100 to fill up a tank, the Karoq only costs £70, for the same size tank, so it's much more fuel efficient. A lot of newer cars are more fuel efficient than older ones. I can park it perfectly well, better than my Astra, because I'm sat higher up and it has parking sensors. A good driver will be able to drive any car. I don't get the outrage about cars on MN. Let people drive what they want!

I used to have an Astra and it cost £100 to fill up a tank, the Karoq only costs £70, for the same size tank
Eh? What miracle of fuel discounting have you devised here?

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:27

Actually our Tiguan was easier to reverse park than the Ibiza we have now (swapped to smaller car because of young driver in household) because of all the built in parking aides.

All the people I see faffing about in parking spaces and not knowing the width/length of their car are in Toyota Yaris and the like.

moonbows · 30/01/2023 11:25

As others have said, this is rational not irrational!!

QuertyGirl · 30/01/2023 11:25

Lcb123 · 30/01/2023 11:22

I mean, I just hate cars. Resent that we own something that is such a killing machine (the planet and people).

People can't see beyond them

containsnuts · 30/01/2023 11:25

I do find those huge BMW 'monster trucks' with the wheels about a foot wide a bit excessive for city driving. What's the concept? Private jet meets tractor? Must cost a fortune just to replace a tyre. On the other hand, I'm hoping to get a Mokka. A bit higher up and more spacious but without being too imposing.

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:24

SavoirFlair · 30/01/2023 11:04

Did the market not also offer

• Ford Galaxy (seats 3 kids across)
• Seat Alhambra (again seats 3 comfortably)
• Volkswagen Touran

etc?

What's your probelm with the Honda CR-V? Surely the fuel efficiency is about the same as the other cars you cite? Or maybe better. It's not like they went oh fuck it and bought an 8 litre supercar instead.

JudgeJ · 30/01/2023 11:23

AnonWeeMouse · 30/01/2023 09:14

I think people should stick to cars the size of which they can handle.

Too many idiots go and buy big cars that they can't drive well. You see them in car parks, struggling to get their ridiculous vehicle into a space, making a 17 point turn to reverse into a spot and they still don't get it central leaving their passenger door so close to your door they evidently think Mrs Pencil Thin drives the car next to theirs.

It's not just SUVs though.
Estate drivers and drivers of those Sales Executive cars. They can't judge the size of the vehicle properly so it makes their lives harder just so they can Ponce about in car bigger than they need. TBF, the standard of driving seems to be so awful on the roads that I've given up my car, it isn't the pleasure it was 20 years ago.

Absolutely this, seeing the Chelski Tractors abandoned, not remotely parked, in a certain Waitrose car park in the way to North Norfolk in the summer is a constant source of amusement. I was once asked if I would move to another parking bay so she could pull through and remove the need to reverse out later as she found it difficult to manoeuvre in small areas.

Lcb123 · 30/01/2023 11:22

I mean, I just hate cars. Resent that we own something that is such a killing machine (the planet and people).

Oakbeam · 30/01/2023 11:22

And I would add that they massive BMW wankers drive in the middle of the country lanes here in Cornwall because they don't want their precious car scratched,

Everybody drives in the middle of the road where I live regardless of what car they drive because the edges of the roads are full of potholes.

Catspyjamas17 · 30/01/2023 11:21

YABU. The shape of the car doesn't make it more polluting. And you can't get a large dog into a small hatchback.

I hate the big pointless gas guzzlers but not the overall shape, and many can be quite fuel efficient or fully electric. For one thing, my dad couldn't get into a small car after he has reduced mobilty in his hips, as they sit too low on the road. My mum has good mobility but still struggles getting into a small hatchback. SUVs seats are easier to get into for lots of people and sitting higher on the road means you can see what is coming over the hedges of winding country lanes!

Frabbits · 30/01/2023 11:20

xogossipgirlxo · 30/01/2023 11:14

Also, they're ugly.

Most MPVS are fucking awful to drive too. I had a Renault Grand scenic as a hire car and it drove like an oil tanker on wheels. Shit fuel economy as well.

Slowingdownagain · 30/01/2023 11:17

I can't help but think that a lot of this SUV hate is just jumping on a bandwagon for chelsea tractor hate, and grouping all SUVs/ crossovers etc in one big group, without actually looking at the reality of the market and what it offers.

OP hates SUVs because they are big, inefficient and bad for the enviroment, but recommends MPVs which are often bigger and less efficient than SUVs (espeically newer ones). OP hates SUVs becuase people can't drive them despite lots of people saying they find them easier to drive than smaller, lower cars (and the fact there are shit drivers in all types of cars).

Not all SUVs are huge big range rovers (although the OP likes those for herself because they are comfortable), and many are increasingly efficient.