Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your parent had an affair

133 replies

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 21:24

Name changed for this post. If your parent had an affair and left to be with the OW/OM (and went on to have a long and happy relationship/marriage) did you have a choice in meeting the new partner? Were you old enough to have a say? Did your betrayed parent prevent you from meeting them? Did your betrayed parent make you choose an allegiance? As an older teen/adult did your feelings change? I'm interested to know how other families navigated this and whether I'm being unrealistic in my expectations.

And if you care to vote....

YANBU= DCs should be able/encouraged to form a relationship with the new partner if they wish.

YABU= The betrayed parent has every right to prevent DCs from meeting the new partner.

OP posts:
MixedBag873 · 29/01/2023 23:44

I already knew the OW well because she was a long time family friend - Dad left when I was 14 to be with her. Next couple of years were a messy divorce. At the time I had issues with dad but never felt badly towards OW because she'd always been nice to me and continued to make an effort and be genuine after. Eventually I realised they made a lot more sense together than my own parents ever did. As only child the experience was pretty tough though and my Mum handled the whole thing pretty badly when it came to me - openly vented frustrations with divorce process and Dad to me, didn't want me to show support of their marriage a few years after that (by which time I was over 18 so could make own decisions). She went ballistic when she found out I'd gone to OW hen do (I'd wanted to make an effort as part of rebuilding relationship with Dad following the divorce) and wanted me to promise I wouldn't send them wedding anniversary cards (I didn't agree to that). I still avoid mentioning Dad to her whenever possible and it's nearly 20 years later, though at least they can all be in a room together if necessary without fireworks. I feel that now my relationship with my Dad and step mum is really strong because we've worked at it. But I still have a lot of unpacked resentment with Mum about how she handled situations back then, badmouthing Dad and was actively discouraging me from accepting OW and burdening me with her own struggles rather than taking them to a counsellor. If she'd presented a more mature front to me at the time I might have found the divorce easier to deal with emotionally and not had such feelings of guilt after enjoying time spent with Dad and step mum.

On the other side though step mum still has a very fractured relationship with her own kids who are only a few years older than me. I don't understand it because of how good our relationship is and how genuinely lovely she is - I can't understand how I've accepted and moved on but they clearly haven't and won't even acknowledge my Dad at all even after all this time. So there's no telling how things will pan out - the most important thing I think is just for both sides to keep making the effort if they want to maintain and grow the parent-child relationship.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:37

@Cheerfulcharlie If it's any consolation at all, and I obviously can't speak for everyone, but I don't think it's a natural conclusion to think your Dad must have thought little of you and your sibling if he was able to conduct an affair. The affair is such fantasy that it's impossible to see it having any impact on real life, the ability to compartmentalise is unreal.

OP posts:
Cheerfulcharlie · 29/01/2023 23:29

As a young teenager my mum did not hide her hurt or dislike towards my Dad’s OW. She didn’t try to stop me seeing her or anything but made her own feelings quite clear & I think it would have been confusing (and possibly unhealthy?) for my mum to have pretended she felt the OW was a nice or ok lady. It’s surely natural not to like someone who has knowingly had an affair with someone with a wife & kids.

I was indifferent to my Dad’s OW and continued to have a good relationship with my dad while I was a teen & young adult but since having children I feel more sad -and a bit angry too -about how little my dad must have thought of me & my sibling to have an affair & treat my mum so terribly. When I was younger, I just felt bad for his behaviour towards my mum, but now I look at it as a parent myself and think how could he have done that to me & my sibling. I also look back at the ‘Disney Dad’ / throwing money & treats at us behaviour which I didn’t see for what it really was at the time & can’t help feel more disrespect for him
& my stepmum (been his wife for many years) the more I think about it.

I now can’t be bothered with her at all and have an increasingly distant relationship with my dad. My sibling dislikes our stepmother (she is a cold personality ) but gets on v well with our dad & does not understand why I feel the way I do now.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:28

Thankyou all for sharing your experiences. My situation, as is only fair to explain, is that I was the one to leave my marriage for OM. I acknowledge it was the absolute worst way to end a marriage, especially when children are involved. However, OM and I have been together almost three years now and whilst my younger two children spend half the week with us and have a good relationship with him, my exh has told my two teens that if they choose to meet him it will be at the expense of maintaining a good relationship with him, their father.
They are 16 and 18 years old and I will respect their decisions but exh is, I feel, putting them in an impossible position. They will not 'betray' their Dad. Badmouthing me/OM at every opportunity, I feel he is using them to maintain some control over me still and I face a future of difficult decisions at every birthday, Christmas, wedding etc....Obviously a potential consequence of having an affair but I can't help but feel he is not putting the children first here. But I wonder if I am being unreasonable. After all I obviously caused a lot of hurt.

OP posts:
larkstar · 29/01/2023 23:23

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:05

@larkstar Interesting, thankyou. I agree that coercion isn't acceptable. But actively preventing DCs from meeting the new partner after a couple of years?

No... You shouldn't interfere - they have the right to make their own decisions. In my family, there are 3 siblings, all of us went NC with our father in 2007. My eldest child accepted friend requests from my father and his new wife but respond only with 1 line replies - I'm almost certain they have never met or phoned.They never discuss or raise the topic of communication with them with me and I don't ask. My children are adults now and they are not daft - they understand the many reasons we don't want any contact or a relationship with him.

OngoingCrisis · 29/01/2023 23:09

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:07

@OngoingCrisis Thats awful!

I feel a lot of resentment tbh. Will be receiving therapy soon as it's affected my ability to set boundaries, especially when it comes to guys and dating. I'm quite insecure and anxious (always anticipating people leaving me)

SequinsandStilettos · 29/01/2023 23:08

Father left to be with OW. They married and have been together decades.
Not old enough to have a say about meeting them and nor did my poor Mum - came as a complete shock to her, her daughters returning from a visit talking about Daddy's new gf, her dog and her (later turned out to be their) child.
She never made us choose, ever, but she spoke disparagingly of her for years.
It turns out in a surprise twist that my Mum had had an affair too (do not blame her, my father had many) but this was only disclosed when I was an adult.
I got on well with the OW. In fairness, she was always kind.
I didn't get on well with my stepfather. He was toxic and prevented me seeing my Dad once, which led to a legal threat.
I am screwed up as a result of my parents' divorce and, whilst I feel for my Mum, she did a terrible job of badmouthing my Dad. He has never criticised her once, not ever but nor has he ever apologised to her (or me) for treating her like shit/leaving.
If you do not want screwed up kids, you learn to co-parent effectively and swallow the bitterness you feel. You are allowed the vitriol but on your time. Do not use your kids to vent at and do not use them as weapons. The counselling won't undo the damage.
If it looks like the new relationship is going to be long term, an introduction is needed. If the kids are teens of course and don't want to know - entirely separate from any input from their Mum - that is, of course, their choice.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:07

@OngoingCrisis Thats awful!

OP posts:
ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:06

@NaatQ968 At 14 what did your Mum say to you about it? If you don't mind me asking.

OP posts:
Lucyccfc68 · 29/01/2023 23:05

My Dad had an affair and he left my Mum for her when I was 10. My Mum never, ever bad mouthed my Dad and was very civil. My Dad on the other hand moved out and within 3 weeks was living with the OW, so not only did I have to get used to the fact that my parents had separated, but was forced into meeting the OW way before I was ready, just so I could see my Dad. Over time, she made it very clear that we were an inconvenience and would have preferred to have just had my Dad to herself without us being around.

Despite me moaning to my Mum and being very unhappy with the situation, she still didn’t bad mouth him. It was only when I got to about 15, that she stopped sticking him for him and making excuses for him. I was old enough by that point to stand up for myself and tell him (and OW) what I thought of them.

I loved him, but he was a shit father. Put his OW above his own kids, got married to her and didn’t tell us, paid my Mum a pittance in maintenance whilst swanning off on expensive holidays with his new wife.

He passed away when I was in my late 20’s and despite hating her, I tried my best to support his wife. In return, she just shat on us all and I am now glad I don’t have to have anything to do with her.

Where as my Mum went on to meet someone, got married and we had a pretty good step-dad. She took her time over introducing us to him.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 23:05

@larkstar Interesting, thankyou. I agree that coercion isn't acceptable. But actively preventing DCs from meeting the new partner after a couple of years?

OP posts:
OngoingCrisis · 29/01/2023 23:02

My dad left when I was 8, OW was 8 months pregnant when he left. Before he went to live with her, he had me speak to her on the phone. I told my mom and she said I, an 8 year old, was a traitor. He lived with the OW for a year or so before ditching them too. I have a sibling that I don't really have a relationship with because of the distance and age gap

NaatQ968 · 29/01/2023 23:02

Interesting..,
My dad had an affair when I was 14.
She was 20. My dad was 32.

It ripped my family apart, they are still together and almost 16 years later after significant life events (positive ones) my parents have finally been able to be in the same room.

On the subject of being forced into a relationship with the other woman... she wasn't forced on me, I think they just wanted to be accepted. I was young, felt betrayed etc etc, so I made their lives difficult in the first few years, I was a right little shit to them.

Now everyone's kinda having to get on with it.
I want a relationship with mum and dad, I have new sisters out of this "affair"

Life is too short.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 22:52

@ThisMustBeMyDream Gosh that sounds incredibly difficult for you.

OP posts:
ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 22:51

@IrritableVowel It sounds like it was a very gradual journey in your case. Do you think your Mum could have stopped you if she'd wanted to?

OP posts:
ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 22:48

@Relaxd This is how I feel too.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 29/01/2023 22:47

FizzyStream · 29/01/2023 21:45

This is an interesting one. My parents split when I was 2 as my mum found out my Dad had been having an affair with a mutual friend since before I was born.

My mum was amazingly selfless about it and although my Dad left the family home and mum had custody of me, she was perfectly civil with him when I saw him at weekends.

He is still with my stepmum (the OW) now 40 years later! I met her when I was 6 and they married when I was 9. I didn't like her at first but I was a child and didn't understand. Now she's known as Nana by my kids and is as much of a grandparent as the blood related ones.

Now we all get on, my mum remarried 11 years ago and I have them all over for big birthdays and Christmas etc. it baffles my in laws as they can't fathom why or how they can stand to be in the same room but I put it mainly down to my mum thinking of me before anyone else and making sure they got on for my sake. Sorry for waffling and hope it makes sense!!

What a wise and loving mum. Always love your children more than you hate your ex

larkstar · 29/01/2023 22:44

I don't like the way you have worded the first options - to me YABU is not acceptable but with the first option I don't think children should be encouraged, coerced or put under and pressure to build a relationship with the new partner: fine of they decide that's what they want to do.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 22:43

@FizzyStream Thankyou for that. I wonder how your Mum managed to shelve her own feelings on the matter. But I'm glad she put you first.

OP posts:
Iam4eels · 29/01/2023 22:14

One of my parents had multiple affairs but they stayed in the marriage. I met a few of the OW but it was usually via whatever the cover-up for the affair was, for example DF would take us along to "jobs" while DM was at work (he was a contractor) and we'd play in the garden with the "customer's" DC while he "worked". At the time we genuinely thought that's what he was doing and that we were such good helpers, keeping the other DC out of the way and playing nicely so he could get on with his work. One of the more long term ones, we actually became friends with the DC so went there most weekends when DM was at work to play with our friends, we went on day trips together, shopping, the cinema, and all sorts. It never occurred to us that he was really playing happy families with the OW and that us being friends with her DC provided yet another cover story - "I took the DC to play with their friends, what a good dad I am..."

For parents who do split up, I don't think either should be telling the other what they can and can't do when it's their time with the DC. Obviously in an ideal world both sides would be 100% on board with co-parenting, would cooperate fully with the wishes of the other, and each would share the same values/morals/rules. However we don't live in an ideal world and sometimes the other parent will want to do things like introduce the DC to a new partner even when the other parent doesn't want them to but that's their choice during their contact time and the other parent can't stop them from doing so. It's a situation that cuts both ways, you wouldn't stand for your XH telling you that you couldn't introduce your new partner to the DC so why would it be acceptable for you to say they can't introduce their partner.

PleaseCleanTheWholeToilet · 29/01/2023 22:14

Yep

Father left us, Got a new woman pregnant before he left
Still with her 30 odd years later

Sometimes saw her after Christmas and very occasional days out but we didnt really see him so no real contact with her

lookluv · 29/01/2023 22:11

Fizzy - thank you. I have tried to do the same- no judgement, no bad words, refuse to argue infront of the DCs. EX did not stay with OW and now has much better partner but same principles.
People make out that it is easy, the one left behind has to go with what ever the other has decided, accept the situation is better for all etc etc. There is an immense burden on the "injured" party to be "better and accepting". One side has to give, give again and then give some more and it is never the one who did wrong in the first place.

No one gets how hard it is. The pain of being the better person in the sorry mess for your children is unbelievable. I used to sit on my own whilst the 2DCS went off to have a "fun" weekend with the "new better happy family" and it physically hurt.

People say the most thoughtless things about how great it is etc etc - believe me it is not and never will be. There is a part of you that is always damaged by the affair. I have now moved on and am very happy, but it was and still is one of the hardest things I have had to deal with and still deal with - my DCS are now old enough to ask questions and have opinions - they want and need to understand but it is not easy to talk about how it felt even now.

One day - say thank you to your Mum, I know you knwo she was amazing but from another mother in her position, I truly understand how hard what she has done was and what you re saying makes me know I am doing the right thing.

Divebar2021 · 29/01/2023 22:09

Well it was my mum who had the affair and I knew him before I was aware of what was going on. He would visit and take me and my brother to do a sport on a Sunday ( without my mother). I was told my parents were divorcing and I then learned we were moving in with the AP - which we did. This is what it’s like being raised by a boomer parent ( actually she’s older than boomer probably). No fannying about with them you’re just expected to get on with it. I was ok with it because me dad worked away and I was used to him being away. My step-dad had dogs and I was very excited about that because we had not been allowed a pet. My mum married the AP and they remained married for way longer than she was married to my dad. he died a few years ago but he was a fabulous step-dad. ( example he paid for my wedding) My dad remarried and moved a long way away and I eventually only saw him once or twice a year.

lottiegarbanzo · 29/01/2023 22:00

But more practically and immediately, yes you can ask to delay until it's clear their relationship is established and lasting. That is very reasonable and normal. No child needs to meet or know about Daddy's series of girlfriends.

But, if Daddy had re-married and it's lasted a year or two, then insisting on his seeing the child alone would prevent them from becoming a real part of his life, which would be isolating and weird for the child.

And somewhere in there lies my experience. I guess it would be different with teenagers, who would have far more choice.

ThisMustBeMyDream · 29/01/2023 22:00

If your parent had an affair and left to be with the OW/OM (and went on to have a long and happy relationship/marriage) did you have a choice in meeting the new partner? No. Not really. He was a student teacher at my mums school so she took me along when I wasn't aware what was going on. I liked him. He played games, took me to football matches, encouraged me in extra curricular stuff.
Were you old enough to have a say? 9, so probably yes.
Did your betrayed parent prevent you from meeting them? He didn't know at first, then my mum took me with her when she left.
Did your betrayed parent make you choose an allegiance? As above, I was kept away for a while and he had to go through court to see me. Took some years. Then I refused to see him for a while too. So no.
As an older teen/adult did your feelings change? Yes, but in lots of ways. My dad had affairs before my mum. Then my mum had an affair with her student teacher. I was a pupil at mums school. When dad found out mum left and took me. He then started shagging another teacher at school which mum made sure I knew about. Mum got a new job, which meant I had to leave the school too as we moved to a new town. Both my parents behaved badly in the break up and I was very much a pawn although neither would admit to it today. It hasn't been easy over the years to come to terms with it all. Relationships are somewhat fractured. I was an only child and bore the brunt of it all.