Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your parent had an affair

133 replies

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 29/01/2023 21:24

Name changed for this post. If your parent had an affair and left to be with the OW/OM (and went on to have a long and happy relationship/marriage) did you have a choice in meeting the new partner? Were you old enough to have a say? Did your betrayed parent prevent you from meeting them? Did your betrayed parent make you choose an allegiance? As an older teen/adult did your feelings change? I'm interested to know how other families navigated this and whether I'm being unrealistic in my expectations.

And if you care to vote....

YANBU= DCs should be able/encouraged to form a relationship with the new partner if they wish.

YABU= The betrayed parent has every right to prevent DCs from meeting the new partner.

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 30/01/2023 12:53

My mum had an affair - it was with someone we knew (small town). She left and stayed married to him, I was a teen and had no choice but to accept him if I wanted to see my mum - I knew she would always put him first. He was an utter prick but was part of our family for years (thankfully he is dead now).

My dad was a saint and never bad mouthed my mum. The happy ending is that he ended up marrying a truly lovely women who made him very very happy, which he richly deserved (sadly he is now dead).

In the end I think children you have very limited choices when their parents fuck around and will usually end up learning to live with it to maintain a relationship with their parents. It is still a crap position to put them in.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 12:46

@Alarae I think my teens could have this sort of relationship with my partner if they were allowed. He is engaged and kind to my youngest two who both like him. We all know he could never replace their Dad, he wouldn't want to. I don't think my ex feels threatened, it's like he just wants to punish us and this is literally the only way he can.

OP posts:
ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 12:41

@Catsandzcocktails It is difficult to hear somebody (other than exh) say that ending my relationship with the affair partner is the only way to proceed. My teens are virtually at the point of leaving home/having their own families, sacrificing my relationship would result in little gain for them and enormous loss to me. Nor do they want me to be alone/unhappy. They want their Dad to back down because ultimately they will never betray him.
@SnackSizeRaisin **In my view the ex is now behaving worse than the op ever did by having the affair. His behaviour is going to be what causes lifelong trauma to the children. We have heard from several people on this thread whose parents managed to keep a neutral front, and from others whose parents were bitter. It's clear that the betrayed parent's behaviour is a huge factor in how children are affected by the split. In fact I think that the parents' ability to be civil to and about one another is a much bigger factor in the effect on children than the cause of relationship breakdown.

The ex in this case is being selfish in putting his own feelings before the teenagers' best interests. That is really bad and damaging parenting.**
This is my take on it but exh states he is more than entitled to feel bitter and the way he behaves now is a direct consequence of my actions, something I should have thought about before. I think though that he has to take some responsibility for how he speaks to/behaves in front of the dcs and acknowledge he is putting his ego ahead of what is actually best for them. This is where I am not sure if IABU.

OP posts:
Alarae · 30/01/2023 11:57

My parents split when I was 10/11, it was my mum who had the affair.

My dad initially left the family home and rented a flat nearby. I went to see him every weekend and my mum never tried to stop me.

When I was around 12, my mum introduced us to her new partner. We moved in with him not long after- I don't really remember being given a choice but it was almost like it was a given I would move with my mum. To be honest, my dad wouldn't have been a great primary parent anyway as he wasn't the most involved and worked long hours. I have two sisters and they split- oldest stayed with my dad (and despised my mum for years, went off the rails a bit) while middle came to stay with mum and me.

My stepdad is a great man and while he will never take over the role of my dad, I know he did a lot to help take care of me. Certainly a lot of lifts during my teenage years! Looking back I appreciate a lot more how he helped out with taking me and my sister on, and what he did to help us feel welcomed in his home.

ethelredonagoodday · 30/01/2023 11:35

My Dad left for the OW when I was about 9. He seemingly had several affairs before her, but she was the one that stuck. My mum was incredibly bitter and remained so until he died the year before last. We met the OW maybe about 6 months after he left, and without my mum's knowledge. When she found out (I think my little brother let it slip) she went absolutely bananas.

She detested the OW and made no effort at all to hide it. All through my life really until my dad died, she was hugely critical of him and suggested we didn't have to have any relationship with him. Over the years, this led to several really difficult conversations, and sometimes falling out. My Mum and I don't have a brilliant relationship now, but I think that's partly because my step dad is very controlling and she basically follows his lead on everything...

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/01/2023 11:31

Catsandzcocktails · 30/01/2023 08:11

You're wrong, people like to convince themselves otherwise, but it does take a certain type of person to do that. No integrity, trustworthiness/honesty, respect or discipline. I don't respect that, I can't. Those values are important to me. If you want to leave, leave. Don't have an affair. Yes the affair is the primary reason. Both the actions of doing it and realising how much it affected my mother.

Ultimately perhaps that is true. However that's almost beside the point. We accept that the OP was very wrong to have an affair, whatever the justification for ending the relationship in terms of her husband's financial control etc.

In my view the ex is now behaving worse than the op ever did by having the affair. His behaviour is going to be what causes lifelong trauma to the children. We have heard from several people on this thread whose parents managed to keep a neutral front, and from others whose parents were bitter. It's clear that the betrayed parent's behaviour is a huge factor in how children are affected by the split. In fact I think that the parents' ability to be civil to and about one another is a much bigger factor in the effect on children than the cause of relationship breakdown.

The ex in this case is being selfish in putting his own feelings before the teenagers' best interests. That is really bad and damaging parenting.

Catsandzcocktails · 30/01/2023 10:57

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 10:46

@Catsandzcocktails I appreciate your point of view, this is how my ex feels also. I suppose what I'm finding difficult to accept is that my exh can blame everything on the affair and has no qualms in telling our children that. What I would never do is tell them all the, in my opinion, inexcusable things he did in our marriage that caused me to justify the affair to myself. Obviously I should have just left but it's too late for that now. I just want to salvage my relationship with my teenagers but feel I'm fighting a fair fight.

Your teenagers will reach their own conclusions, my sister and I did. My husband did. Maybe it'll be this week, maybe in their 20s, but they will eventually do they want.
I think if your children are priority, the best thing to do is leave the affair relationship, not reconcile with husband. That will show them you have some integrity. Actions speak louder than words at this point. Say you're very sorry about it, you are leaving all parts of the affair in the past but not minimising it was wrong and you're storey, now you should have just left, it is about your husband, not them.
I really think that's the best course if you want to salvage as much as you can with your teenagers. Get them some counselling about it too, so they can work on their own feelings about it.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 10:46

@Catsandzcocktails I appreciate your point of view, this is how my ex feels also. I suppose what I'm finding difficult to accept is that my exh can blame everything on the affair and has no qualms in telling our children that. What I would never do is tell them all the, in my opinion, inexcusable things he did in our marriage that caused me to justify the affair to myself. Obviously I should have just left but it's too late for that now. I just want to salvage my relationship with my teenagers but feel I'm fighting a fair fight.

OP posts:
Catsandzcocktails · 30/01/2023 10:27

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:15

@Catsandzcocktails No integrity, trustworthiness/honesty, respect or discipline These are all qualities that I possess and demonstrate in every other aspect of my life. They are indeed essential for the line of work I am in. I would probably be the last person you'd think capable of an affair. I expect to be judged for it but I don't think it's fair to define me by it.

The phrase the proof is in the pudding comes to mind. It's true - you never really know what sort of person someone is, on the outside it may seem like not the sort of thing they'd do. Obviously when it suits you, you are very capable of casting aside those qualities. Don't judge a book by its cover and all that.
Well, you having an affair probably doesn't seem very fair to your ex husband and children. Or continuing the relationship built on the sturdy foundations of lies and deceit. Ultimately, if you do something like that, it is possible your sons will eventually decide to go no contact with you. If they stay in touch, I very much doubt your relationship with them will ever be the same. Certainly not in my husbands experience and he was very close to his mum before. That's just something you're going to have to accept as a consequence of your actions. Not really much you can do now.

WaddleAway · 30/01/2023 10:18

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:47

@WaddleAway I wonder why your Dad never said a bad word against him or tried to prevent you from meeting him? And why some men feel so differently. Exh has basically said 'over my dead body'.
I'm sorry you were coerced into meeting OM, I don't want to make my teens feel like this but pretending I don't have a (long-term) partner isn't sustainable either.

The only answer I’ve got to that is that my dad was (and is) a thoroughly decent man. However much he was hurting, whenever I ranted to him about her leaving he’d just say ‘she’s your mum and she loves you’.
I never wanted to pretend my mum wasn’t in a long term relationship with the OM, and I never wanted her to pretend that either. I just didn’t want a relationship with him myself.

WaddleAway · 30/01/2023 09:51

CornishGem1975 · 30/01/2023 09:47

Did she leave her children, or did she leave the marriage?

It amounted to the same thing. She left and didn’t invite us to go with her. She could have left the marriage without having an affair, she could have left the marriage without leaving her children, but she chose the affair and no children route 🤷🏻‍♀️.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:50

CornishGem1975 · Today 09:47
WaddleAway · Today 09:45
And sadly, although I have a good relationship with my mum now, I lost all respect for her when she had an affair and left her children. If she wasn’t happy in the marriage she should have done the decent thing and told my dad, so that they could split properly.
Did she leave her children, or did she leave the marriage?

See my exh presents it to my teens that I left them when in reality I had no choice if I was to leave the marriage, whichever way it ended. He made sure I was financially trapped/screwed in marriage or divorce.

OP posts:
ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:47

@WaddleAway I wonder why your Dad never said a bad word against him or tried to prevent you from meeting him? And why some men feel so differently. Exh has basically said 'over my dead body'.
I'm sorry you were coerced into meeting OM, I don't want to make my teens feel like this but pretending I don't have a (long-term) partner isn't sustainable either.

OP posts:
CornishGem1975 · 30/01/2023 09:47

WaddleAway · 30/01/2023 09:45

And sadly, although I have a good relationship with my mum now, I lost all respect for her when she had an affair and left her children. If she wasn’t happy in the marriage she should have done the decent thing and told my dad, so that they could split properly.

Did she leave her children, or did she leave the marriage?

WaddleAway · 30/01/2023 09:45

And sadly, although I have a good relationship with my mum now, I lost all respect for her when she had an affair and left her children. If she wasn’t happy in the marriage she should have done the decent thing and told my dad, so that they could split properly.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:41

@CornishGem1975 See this is how feel too.

OP posts:
WaddleAway · 30/01/2023 09:39

I was 15 when my mum had an affair and moved in with the OM. I stayed with my dad. My dad didn’t try and prevent me from meeting the OM, but I didn’t want to. Had no interest in meeting him whatsoever. My mum then coerced me into meeting him by guilt tripping me and telling me I needed to make an effort for her sake, so I did, against my will. My dad never said a bad word against him, but I figured out he was an arsehole all by myself 😏.

CornishGem1975 · 30/01/2023 09:37

It shouldn't be up to the betrayed parent to decide. Let the DC meet their parent's partner and let them decide for themselves how they want their relationship to be. Of course, this doesn't often get 'allowed' because too many parents like to influence their children's feelings and behaviours. Which is truly unhealthy.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:35

@riotlady Gosh that sounds difficult. I'm glad your own family is a lot less complicated!

OP posts:
riotlady · 30/01/2023 09:30

My parents divorced when I was 4, because my dad had an affair. It was objectively probably a good thing as he was abusive to my mum, and I’m not sure how long it would have taken her to leave. His AP was very young at the time- about 21, I think- and they moved in together and later got married. I saw them every other weekend.

My mum honestly gave me a lot of mixed messages about my dad- she never tried to stop me seeing him (even though I didn’t want to a lot of the time) and would tell me how much he loved me and that I should maintain a relationship with him, but she also would tell me lots of details of the abuse when I was too young to hear it. Nobody really said anything bad about my stepmum, I think honestly most of the family felt a bit sorry for her because she was young and they all knew my dad wasn’t very nice. I used to hear her crying a lot when I went round there.

Dad and stepmum are still married, two kids. I don’t really have a relationship with them any more but that’s because of my dad- I don’t harbour any ill will towards my stepmum or blame her for anything. My mum STILL insists I will have regrets if I cut my dad off completely- she has a lot of her own issues about being abandoned by HER dad. Am hoping to break the cycle with my DD and DH who have a lovely relationship xD

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 09:15

@Catsandzcocktails No integrity, trustworthiness/honesty, respect or discipline These are all qualities that I possess and demonstrate in every other aspect of my life. They are indeed essential for the line of work I am in. I would probably be the last person you'd think capable of an affair. I expect to be judged for it but I don't think it's fair to define me by it.

OP posts:
Catsandzcocktails · 30/01/2023 08:11

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 07:52

@Catsandzcocktails I couldn't respect them for being the type to have an affair
Whilst I do understand this, I'm not convinced there is 'a type'. Affairs happen for different reasons and the people involved aren't always bad people on the whole. Ultimately there is always deceit, granted. Do you think your Dad and SM were just 'assholes' anyway or was their affair the biggest factor?

You're wrong, people like to convince themselves otherwise, but it does take a certain type of person to do that. No integrity, trustworthiness/honesty, respect or discipline. I don't respect that, I can't. Those values are important to me. If you want to leave, leave. Don't have an affair. Yes the affair is the primary reason. Both the actions of doing it and realising how much it affected my mother.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 07:52

@Catsandzcocktails I couldn't respect them for being the type to have an affair
Whilst I do understand this, I'm not convinced there is 'a type'. Affairs happen for different reasons and the people involved aren't always bad people on the whole. Ultimately there is always deceit, granted. Do you think your Dad and SM were just 'assholes' anyway or was their affair the biggest factor?

OP posts:
TeeBee · 30/01/2023 07:45

Thanks. That was just the starter for ten. They got much, much worse. NC now but we're the baddies for doing that, obviously.

ForThePurposeOfThisPost · 30/01/2023 07:42

@TeeBee I'm sorry, that sounds really tough.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread