Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset and annoyed that ds's gf of 6 years has chucked him, leaving him devastated and not giving any real honest reason?

234 replies

McWoman · 29/01/2023 13:50

Hi
My son (22yrs) has been chucked by his gf after a 6yr relationship. They didnt live together, and for the last year it was a long distance relationship as he took up a great new job in London, but they had plans for a future together. Now she has changed her mind, with no reasons given, and he has come home, totally devastated and extremely depressed. I would never get involved, but feel totally helpless, out of my depth, and unsure of how to get him out of his current mindset. I have suggested he seeks counselling through his work. Any other suggestions?

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 29/01/2023 14:53

I've had a lot of counselling over the years and I feel it does have it's place. But I don't think it would be appropriate for someone experiencing a relationship break up this soon, he's just going through natural reactions.
If he's still feeling the same a few months down the line maybe.

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 14:51

not giving any real honest reason

She doesn't owe anybody anything.

TIme should heal.

ViridissimaVirga · 29/01/2023 14:51

Oh, and as PP have said - absolutely tell him to go back to London and back to his job. He needs the distraction, and while a weekend at home with Mum might be what he needs, he needs even more to focus on his job and on making new friends and having new experiences. My heartbroken child came home from university for a weekend and was clearly keen to stay at home and have no reminders of the ex, but I said no!

Emmamoo89 · 29/01/2023 14:51

Don't need an explanation. They've obviously grown apart. Just be there for him

diddl · 29/01/2023 14:50

"I don't want to see you any more"-that's a reason isn't it?

So he's 22 & has a great job in London-life is surely just beginning!

W0tnow · 29/01/2023 14:50

She doesn’t need a reason. You’re not supposed to meet your life partner at 16. She probably grew out of him. It’s not a reflection on him, or her. It must be difficult to feel pressured for a ‘good ‘ reason, when in reality it’s probably just I don’t love you anymore.

RoseThornside · 29/01/2023 14:49

I remember trying to break up with someone - it was because I just didn't fancy him anymore - but didn't want to hurt him by saying that. I ended up waffling, saying the classic "it's not you, it's me", how I thought maybe we wanted different things from life, but everything I said, he would home in on and question, trying to show me why that reason was irrelevant. In the end I said something like "I think of you as more like a brother" and he looked totally wounded, but then suggested a romantic weekend away! It was awful and I felt awful about it but should I have stayed with him, got married, forced myself to have sex with him for another 50 years?

I'm really sorry this has happened; but no point forcing her to come out with a reason that you will find acceptable. Time is the best healer here.

PSNonsense · 29/01/2023 14:49

She doesn't want to be in a relationship with him anymore.

That's her reason.

Gwenhwyfar · 29/01/2023 14:49

"counselling isn't the answer, he needs to learn to grieve and be an adult about it"

Oh dear. This is very much "we never had any counselling in our day, just got on with it"...

ViridissimaVirga · 29/01/2023 14:47

I wouldn't worry about why she ended it, OP. I think it's very unusual for people to end up long-term with someone they started dating at 16.

It's horrible for your son if he thought they'd stay together, but all you can do is offer a sympathetic ear if he wants to offload, and time will do the rest. I can understand you feeling helpless (I felt that way when my oldest child's first proper relationship ended - I just wanted to be able to take all the unhappiness away from them and give it to myself instead), but you can just listen, be there, reassure him that it's normal to feel hurt/tearful/lost/unhappy/angry/any combination of those, and that it will take a long time to get over it - but he will get over it. Plus there are all the clichés about "it wasn't meant to be", which are trite but are sometimes helpful all the same. I wouldn't suggest counselling as it feeds into the idea that so many young people have that you can somehow magic away feelings of hurt and loss and sadness. In fact, we need to experience all of those things because that's how we grow up.

WilsonMilson · 29/01/2023 14:47

I had a similar situation when I was young and was in the girl’s position. Got together very young with boyfriend, both still at school and I ended it some years later.

I suppose I didn’t give him a great reason either, but honestly I just felt we had grown apart, had different ideas about what we wanted, and I wanted to experience more of life, date more people, enjoy my freedom and young life.
There’s nothing more to it than that. Didn’t regret it for a moment, it was ultimately better for both is us. I imagine it’s more or less the same for your son. IMHO no one should be settled so young, there is a lot of life to live and he has his whole future ahead of him. It hurts now, but he will move on and maybe even get excited about dating and meeting new people.

honeylulu · 29/01/2023 14:46

He may want a reason. You may want a reason. But from experience even being presented with a reason doesn't help at all because the upset from the relationship ending is still there. There may be a specific reason (someone else) but it's also very common that there is no particular reason- just a realisation that the person doesn't want to be in the relationship any more.

They're both very young and will have changed a lot in 6 years. Distance is often quite testing. I had a boyfriend at uni and all was going well, then I went travelling in the US one summer. Missed him intensely at first but then realised I'd just stopped thinking about him. When I got back we broke up. We did get back together and it was nice but when we graduated and he went back to his home town the same thing happened again. My feelings just faded when I wasn't physically seeing him much. There wasn't anybody else. I think it's quite common.

viques · 29/01/2023 14:45

Whatmarbles · 29/01/2023 14:29

It's one of the life lessons most people go through at some point or another.
He will be sad and upset but he needs to get back to London, brush himself off and carry on with his life.

Has he taken annual leave to wallow for a bit?

Most people have breakups long before reaching the age of 22, and often you learn that :

a) your perceptions of the people you were in love with at 16 change dramatically in the cold hard light of reaching 19 or 22

b) tearful nights crying into your pillow and reading over every card and text they ever sent looking for clues as to why they dumped you is not nearly as much fun as going out with your mates and seeing what life has to offer

c) it is possible to have strong feelings for more than one person, (just do it one person at a time and not concurrently)

I think your son is late to the party, and needs to build up his rejection immunity defences as fast as he can. Moping around the parental home with you being sympathetic and making him cups of tea and sandwiches isn’t actually going to help him to move on.

LimeCheesecake · 29/01/2023 14:43

OP - your reaction seems strange to me, but then perhaps you settled down with your first serious partner so wasn’t expecting this.

sadly, she doesn’t want to be with him and that’s a good enough and real reason. He might not have done anything wrong, she might not have met someone new, it could well just be she doesn’t want to be with him anymore now they are older and grown up. That’s a real reason.

get your ds back to work. He’ll more likely move on if he gets on with life. (Discourage him making any big decisions in the next month or so)

VickyEadieofThigh · 29/01/2023 14:43

NewBootsAndRanty · 29/01/2023 14:29

Well. If there's no real or honest reason, then obviously just have a word with her and make her take him back.

Of course she will have valid reasons.🤦‍♀️

Indeed.

I remember my mother taking the same sort of line as the OP and saying - after my kid brother broke up with a long-term girlfriend (he was in the forces and she used to go round to visit my Mum, who thought, as a result, she was lovely), "I'm going to tell him not to bring anyone else home - you get to know and like a girl and then he breaks up with her!"

I did explain to my Mum that this was not a rational or reasonable view to have and that if the relationship wasn't working for him any more, he was not obliged to continue it.

JudgeRudy · 29/01/2023 14:43

What's you're AIBU? If it's to be annoyed at his ex for finishing the relationship then yes. You say she's given no reason but also say that he moved away (not together) because it suited him, oh and they've been together since they were kids. I think the relationship has just run its course.
'Support' him by all means but ensure that support hinges on him accepting the relationship is over and that that his feelings are transient. Don't make it the topic of conversation and don't ask every detail like 'what exactly did she say'. I think counselling is extreme unless you think his mental health is severely at risk. It's hard to watch someone else suffering but there's really nothing you can do. The majoritybof us have had our hearts broken....and recovered.

Peckhaminn · 29/01/2023 14:40

He's doesn't need counselling OP. counselling isn't the answer, he needs to learn to grieve and be an adult about it. we've all gone though heartbreaks and managed to move on. He will be fine just support him and encourage him to not dwell and enjoy his life in London. X

Slowingdownagain · 29/01/2023 14:39

Heart break is awful but an inevitable part of growing up. Sounds like the probably grew apart on their transition from teenagers to adults. I’m would have been expecting it really.

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/01/2023 14:39

Maybe the reason is she doesn't love him or fancy him anymore, I mean that is everyone's reason when you boil it down

Testina · 29/01/2023 14:39

Mumuser124 · 29/01/2023 14:28

For all of the people saying she doesn’t need to give him a reason, obviously youre correct but it’s very unkind not to. It leaves somebody ruminating over what could be wrong with them, what went wrong, could they have done something better etc. I think it’s just a basic level of human decency to give a reason why you no longer want to be in a relationship.

But OP doesn’t actually say no reason has been given.
In fact, her bleating about “real honest reasons” sounds like the woman has done for than just text, “see ya” to him.

What reasons are there, really?

In my 50+ years (so 35+ of dating) I’ve once dumped someone for a nice neat reason: he fucked a prostitute. Otherwise, every single person I have dumped - and who has dumped me - comes under “just not that into you”.

GabriellaMontez · 29/01/2023 14:36

So she has given a reason?

But not one you think is real or honest!

He must be upset. But I think you could support him better by not inferring he's entitled to a better reason. Quite possible she gave him one and he didn't tell you...

Whinge · 29/01/2023 14:36

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 29/01/2023 14:34

I would bet good money that he knows the reason - he just disagrees with it, or doesn't want to tell his mother as it paints him in bad light.

I agree. There will be a reason, he just doesn't want to share it with his mum. Which isn't surprising give the OPs dramatic post.

butterfliedtwo · 29/01/2023 14:36

MyFlagMeansIceCream · 29/01/2023 13:58

She may well have given him a reason, just not one he wants to accept. She doesn't owe him an explanation that he is happy with, if she doesn't want to be in a relationship any more with him then that IS the reason.

This.

He needs time. Breakups happen, they're part of life. So is learning to deal with rejection.

LIZS · 29/01/2023 14:36

Encourage him to go back to work, moping at home is not going to help especially of she is in same area

Floralnomad · 29/01/2023 14:36

She’s probably found someone else whilst it’s been a long distance relationship and thinks he’d rather not be told that .